Moral Accountability Of Governments Essay

1634 words - 7 pages

Moral Accountability

Morality depends on the ability of an individual to choose between good and evil, thus, entailing freedom of the will and the moral responsibility of the individual for his actions. It is obvious this is so for the individual, but what about groups and governments? Do they have the ability to choose between good and evil, do they have free will and therefore are they subject to the same paradigms of morality as the individual or does an autonomous morality apply.
What if we relate this concept of morality to a present day moral dilemma? Such as should the United States government fire cruise missiles at Serbian cities in order to force the government of Serbia to comply with NATO demands of withdrawal from Kosovo? What moral questions should be asked? Further yet, as we are members of a representative democracy, do the citizens bear any of the responsibility of the government's actions? Am I responsible for the government I choose?
Being that it is the actions of a governments we wish to question the morality of, we must know what the present justification for or against the launch of cruise missiles at Serbia and what the consequences of that decision would be. It can be conjectured that the "official rational" of the United States government in its decision to use cruise missiles on Serbia is based on cost/benefit analysis of what would be in the best interest of the nation and the world—a utilitarian morality. The Serbian government has invaded and seeks to undermine the sovereignty of Kosovo while using genocidal tactics to control the population. The US is acting on what it believes to be the greatest good for the greatest number. But who is the government to place a market value on human life? Is it moral and does the government have the right to place such a value on human life? And who is responsible for their decision? The official utilitarian rationale of the United States government does place a market value on human life Kant writes: "Now morality is the condition under which alone a rational being can be an end in himself, for only thereby can he be a legislating member in the kingdom of ends", survival of the individual in a group is the end. If we are to treat men otherwise, as a means to an
end, we must make that a categorical imperative and we must treat it as if that action will be a universal law of nature laws to live by). Hence, to do harm to others, to place a market value on man, would be immoral since it would harm humanity. Likewise, it is immoral for the United States to sacrifice ten thousand lives in hope of saving more. It must be asked "what if everyone sacrificed ten thousand lives?". According to Kant's theory of the Universal law, "We must be able to will that a maxim of our action become universal law, this is the canon for morally estimating any of our actions" (Kant).
Perhaps it is a touch ironic that the very document the US was founded on reads: "We hold these...

Find Another Essay On Moral Accountability of Governments

Accountability to the Canadian People Essay

2867 words - 11 pages conventions that in essence protect the government, this accountability is not more than a moral responsibility. The power of the civil servant is increasing becoming broader as Ministerial portfolios are combined with the modern trend of downsizing cabinet. The influential power of the civil servant is increased as ministers are becoming unspecialized in their portfolios.The only effective legislative accountability is done through the office of the

Adolescent Writers in Second Language Situations

1312 words - 5 pages writing behaviours, and nothing statistically significant in the differences found between the ethnic groups. The conclusion has found that fluency does have a positive influence on writing quality. Kerry Anne Enrightstudied the influences of the U.S. governments accountability and their standard-driven context on the writing experiences of multilingual writers in the linguistically diverse high school classrooms. Qualitative data from 12 ninth

The Accountability of the American Government in the Case of Mr.Padilla

1294 words - 6 pages The Government of the United States, going against Mr.Padilla’s Constitutional rights and not providing him an opportunity to contest the legality of his detention, comprises the value of the Government’s accountability as a law-abiding state. In this particular case, it appears that government officers, including the president, believe that they should be able to do what is against pre-existing laws, if it is necessary to the preservation of

pulic accountability

5395 words - 22 pages of accounting to one that is more focused on accountability,output, performance measurement, efficiency, cost savings and productivity (Guthrie, 1995).Across and beyond Commonwealth countries, Parliamentary Public Accounts Committees(PACs) occupy a key position at the apex of legislatures' scrutiny and oversight processes over the use by governments of public sector resources. This role draws upon the traditions of the British "Westminster


824 words - 4 pages confidentiality among Information and data sharing also it has a negative impact on governments, private sectors or businesses and also individuals, there is also a big question of accountability. Right of privacy, right of accountability and confidentiality are some of the rights that you accuire being a citizen of the country and when these rights are violated it is a offence. Certain information like the social security number or ATM pin

Democracy vs Dictatorship: Case studies.

1138 words - 5 pages further analysis the issue continues to remain complex; however, due to the fact that in a democracy power is separated to keep the government accountable and open dissent is allowed as long as it remains peaceful, and dictatorship often has unchecked corruption, limited accountability and demand complete obedience from its citizens in terms of dissent, a moderate democracy is the best way for governments to be involved in peoples

Romeo and Juliet Expository Essay

1247 words - 5 pages piece of evidence that shows that the death penalty is unmoral "Ultimately, the moral question surrounding capital punishment in America has less to do with whether those convicted of violent crime deserve to die than with whether state and federal governments deserve to kill those whom it has imprisoned."(Bryan Stevenson, JD, Professor of Law at New York University School of Law) Another piece of evidence that proves that the death penalty is

An Analysis of Governmental Performance in Australia

896 words - 4 pages are made on the basis of performance data that each department is required to provide as well as parliamentary committee inquiries. Thomas’ article highlights that the publication of performance data is not accountability – rather, there must be consequences following an examination of this data. To assess parliament’s performance in its ability to scrutinise various government departments, the article draws attention to the two houses of

Virtuous and Pure-Hearted Need Not Apply: Can Politians Succeed without Underhanded techniques?

1479 words - 6 pages The political state in Western nation governments is in turmoil. Watergate, illegal wars, sex scandals, wire-tapping, missing money, and the now infamous Sponsorship Scandal here in Canada, are just some of the most popular reasons that citizens trust their leaders less and less. There is a general political apathy in Canada these days. The common feeling is that one crook being elected is more-or-less the same as some other crook being elected

One Half Trillion

1966 words - 8 pages prescription indicating a medical need. The Journal’s general consensus can be summarized as such: if nothing else, there exists room for restructuring drugs laws to save governments ONE AND A HALF TRILLION 4 at levels money, even to such an extent that these governments can turn budget surpluses from these changes. Range of Alternative Solutions Given the stance that the United States currently takes on illegal narcotics, there stand ready a multitude of

What is and what should be the role of government and the bureaucracy?

845 words - 3 pages agencies are in charge of a specialized area of government. As is obvious by the number of services the government provides, and the different types of government, organization is needed to ensure efficiency, accountability, and effectiveness within government.As taken from the U.S. Constitution the role of government is to establish law and order, protect the nation, promote welfare and growth, and ensure liberty. These very vague terms can be

Similar Essays

Performance Management In The Framework Of Public Accountability In Estonian Local Governments

807 words - 4 pages information can be made between performance reporting as an accountability tool and performance management as a steering tool (Greiling 2006). Over two-thirds of OECD countries include non-financial performance information in their budget documents (Curristine et al 2007). According to Estonian legislation Local Governments in Estonia currently have to compile strategic plans, prepare the annual budgets in accordance with the strategic plans

Ausralia Essay

663 words - 3 pages parliamentary process and ensure that the deficiencies in performance of governments are revealed. Critics see prevailing partisan approaches to the enforcement of political accountability as too ritualistic, narrow, negative and theatrical. It is argued that the prevailing adversarial approaches tend to exaggerate, magnify and distort the real challenges of public management and improved performance in modern government. Up to a point

The Classical Model Theory Of Public Administration

2330 words - 10 pages trying to improve the effectiveness of public management through the application of market oriented, with injecting business methods. Where is the need to achieve requiring a market-type mechanism, performance indicators, targets, competitive contracts, and a quasi-market. In this system the system responsibilities or accountability have already started decentralized (spread out), where each person or organization has its own responsibility based


1739 words - 7 pages towards this shown by the governments tends to be less significant, resulting poor delivery of public goods to the people. Tsai (2007) elaborate this issue and says that these issues can be overcome by strengthening the community social institutions, which have high moral acceptance in the community to influence governments and officials through informal rules and norms shaped by them in a situation where formal institutions of accountability are