Moral And Legal Lessons From Washington V. Glucksberg

1965 words - 8 pages

Washington v. Glucksberg is a legal/medical case regarding end-of-life issues. A few questions that arose were about autonomy, dignity, legalities, privacy, personal rights versus constitutional rights, morality, and theology. It is about what is moral but not necessarily what is morality in a legal or constitutional sense. Smith (2008), purports in Michigan Law Review, that there is no clear instruction about the relation of law and morality in Washington v. Glucksberg or Vacco v. Quill (Glucksberg-Quill) this coming from the Supreme Court (p. 1574). If the Supreme Court cannot distinguish between what is legal and moral for society, then who would be up to the task? Is it up to healthcare providers, the family, or the patient? Who has the obligation to assert moral courage in end-of-life issues? Do patients not have the right to die without interference from the state and federal governments, physicians, and families? The right to die with dignity is an ethical issue for the individual and institutions. The following examines the difference between legal and moral issues regarding the debate in
Literature Review
Gengo (2011), notes the United States Congress in 1990, passed the Patient Self Determination Act (PSDA). This act provides (1) patients the right to accept or refuse treatment; (2) the opportunity to write advance directives which allows patients to state in advance the kinds of medical care that he or she considers acceptable or not acceptable; (3) does not discriminate; and (4) educates the staff and community about advance directives. This act defines a legal definition of patient rights. It also explains informed consent with risks and benefits, assent, documentation needed, surrogate decision making such as having a medical durable power of attorney or healthcare proxy, and default state specific laws. Given these laws, one wonders if there is a specific federal law for right to die or is this left to the states to debate. According to Chief Justice Rehnquist (1997), the opinion of the court declared that suicide does not offend the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. However, the states have conflicting laws. For instance, in Washington, it is a felony to assist in suicide, “a person is guilty of promoting a suicide attempt when he knowingly causes or aids another person to attempt suicide” Wash. Rev. Code § 9A.36.060(1) (1994). Washington also has the Natural Death Act of 1979, which states, “withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment, shall not, for any purpose, constitute suicide” Wash. Rev. Code § 70.122.070(1).
Lachman (2009), describes that values are personal attributes and are our concepts, ideals, and themes that give meaning to our personal lives. Lachman goes on to describe our professional Codes of Ethics that stem from our values system and our moral character. However, these professional Codes of Ethics...

Find Another Essay On Moral and Legal Lessons from Washington v. Glucksberg

Moral and Legal Dilemmas in the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn

805 words - 3 pages true to his word and helped Jim out the whole way. In the end Jim is freed as Miss. Watson who had passed about two months ago and in her will she stated that she would want Jim to be freed. Huck fights the power of the all-powerful society and in the end, ends up winning. Huck is willing to give up his afterlife for Jim's freedom. To me, there could not be a more compassionate deed. Huck's unselfishness is something we could all stand to follow. Lessons can undoubtedly be learned from The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.

The Ironic Pilgrims of The Canterbury Tales and their Moral Lessons

2403 words - 10 pages constantly need the help of a dictionary, his work truly marks the contemporary ethos, because of the irony, the pilgrims, and the moral lessons presented in his works. Yet critics argue that Chaucer's work should be approached as a collection of distinct pieces. Primarily because of the language he uses. Geoffrey Chaucer writes The Canterbury Tales in what's known as "Middle English" during the 14th century. Chaucer is credited by some scholars as

Mary Anne Warren's On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion

1751 words - 7 pages Mary Anne Warren’s “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion” describes her justification that abortion is not a fundamentally wrong action for a mother to undertake. By forming a distinction between being genetically human and being a fully developed “person” and member of the “moral community” that encompasses humanity, Warren argues that it must be proven that fetuses are human beings in the morally relevant sense in order for their

The Social Economic and Legal Impact Resulting From eBusiness

3193 words - 13 pages IntroductionThis project is to investigate and analyse the social, economic and legal impact resulting from the adoption and growth of eBusiness. The project also investigated the web-based business of Rosenbluth and Dell.eBusiness is not just the buying and selling of goods and services it is also servicing customers, collaborating with business partners and conducting electronic transactions within an organisation. eBusiness is the complex

George Washington, from birth to death. Focuses mainly on battles and predency

1584 words - 6 pages This report is on George Washington. It discusses his life from his birth to his death. It mainly focuses onthe major things that he did while he was alive such as battles and becoming presidentWho Was George Washington? We all know him from the one dollar bill and the quarter, but how did thisman get to be so famous? Well it all started back on February 22, 1732 in Westmoreland County, Virginia. Thisdate marked the birth of George Washington

Well written and descriptive essay/bio on Washington Irving, from a B to an A- paper

947 words - 4 pages History of New York, from the Beginning of theWorld to the End of the Dutch Dynasty, is narrated by the fictitious Diedrich Knickerbocker. This book isa comical, deliberately inaccurate account of New York's Dutch colonization ("Washington Irving" DISC).Knickerbocker History and the almost thirty parts of Irving's next critically acclaimed book, The SketchBook of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent., show that his roots in New York and travels abroad gave him

Ethical and legal analysis of the Ann Hopkins v. Price Waterhouse discrimination law suit. Focuses on case law and ethics.

3145 words - 13 pages to $535,000 plus back pay. Such a powerful organization must be made aware that "the good ole boy" network is just not ethical and that egoism is not appropriate in the workplace.Section 1.01 References:[1] Hishon v. King & Spalding (No. 82-940). Cornell Law Institute. Retrieved May 20, 2006 from[2] FindLaw for legal professionals. (1994).Retrieved May 21, 2006

Differences between: Legal, Moral and Customary Rights Details on various NGO's that protect and define human rights.

1570 words - 6 pages 1. Distinguish betweena) Legal, Moral and Customary Rights.A legal right is one that is enforceable by law. Any citizen and can discover these rights. They can validly be argued in court and generally take preference to other rights.Moral rights are those that particular groups believe are right and just. They are generally derived from religion and reflect the values and attitudes of the group that holds them. Usually the moral rights held by

Analysis of Warren's Book, On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Questions of Life and Death

869 words - 3 pages abortion is dependent on the fetus’s own violation of the mothers’ freedom such that as soon as the fetus is no longer violating the mothers’ rights, the mother herself has no right in violating the fetus/infants existence. Thus Warren’s argument doesn’t support infanticide and she can safely refute the objection that her defense of abortion permits infanticide. Warren, M. (1982). On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Questions of Life and Death, 397-403

How does structure affect the bureaucracy? What lessons can we learn from theory about government and bureaucracy?

931 words - 4 pages concerns (Riley 109-111). The influence of public policy on agency can affect their selection of goals, or create too many goals, that bog down their ability to enact change. This is one reason, in my opinion, that people complain about the way that government agencies function, and also the negative connotation of “bureaucracy” is founded.The lessons to be learned from theories of structure and organization in government and bureaucracy

A letter to President: Lessons from Vietnam War and The Mistakes we should avoid in the future.

638 words - 3 pages we start taking care of it now? "Its never too late - never too late to start over , never too late to be happy." - says a famous quote by Jane Fonda. I found that in American History, Vietnam War is the one we should look the most at , when searching for mistakes to avoic in the present. THere are so many lessons to be learned from that war, but the most significant ones would be " know the battlefield you 'll be fighting on, know your enemy

Similar Essays

The Canterbury Tales: Irony, The Pilgrims And Their Moral Lessons.

2788 words - 11 pages of the doctrines of the time. He passes no moral judgment in Paradise Lost that sex itself may or may not be engaged solely to procreate. For Milton, 'chastity is rather `purity of life', the aggregate of `the duties that touch the purities of ones person'. Her [chastity] proper companions are `modestie and temperance', and if she appears at all as abstinence it is only in the sense of `abstaining from straggling lusts and al

Drone Attacks And It’s Legal And Moral Battle

1428 words - 6 pages military invasions are violating international law that has been in place for over fifty years, and the emotional fear inflicted to communities is immoral and an act of terror; America cannot justify the killing of innocent civilians. 621 words. Works Cited Drone attacks and it’s legal and moral battle It was a beautiful day, blue sky above the Pakistani fields, Mamana Bibi and her two grandkids were in the fields picking okra when the

The Moral, Legal, And Economical Aspects Of Capital Punishment

1552 words - 6 pages renewed movement for this “eye for an eye” method, citing such arguments as “deterrence” and “victims’ rights.” This movement begs a single question – is there any economical, legal, or statistical support for the ultimate punishment? This article will strive to answer that question by evaluating several key issues (be they supporting or otherwise) concerning capital punishment – the legitimacy of ‘deterrence,’ the legality of capital punishment under

The Moral And Legal Obligations Of Battlefield Neutrality

1968 words - 8 pages The Moral and Legal Obligations of Battlefield Neutrality “If a body of enemy troops is repulsed, give to the wounded the same care as you would give your own men; treat them all the forbearance due to the one who is stricken…After the battle, restrain the fury of your troops; spare the vanquished…People should say of you: they fought courageously when they had to, but remained generous and humane throughout.” –General Guillaume Henri Dufour