Moral Dilemmas Faced By Jewish Leaders

2143 words - 9 pages

All around the world, every moment of everyday someone encounters a moral dilemma whether it is minuscule or monumental. Going against ones religious or moral beliefs can be problematic; it may in fact be so moving that it causes one to reexamine their entire thought process. Regardless of ones age during the Holocaust, so many were faced with unbelievable ethical dilemmas. Many Jewish leaders faced moral dilemmas and made heroic decisions; many made life or death decisions to save themselves or others from the horrific plans of the Nazis, , denied Nazi orders in order to protect their loved ones, and several helped others survive.
Crisis situations and heavy consciences
Being placed in a crisis moment is difficult, it may in fact cause a person to challenge their own morals, allow a person to see how far they will go. Many people during the Holocaust had to choose between life or death in order to protect their loved ones. No matter the cost people made these decisions with heavy consciences. In September 1942, one particular Jewish med student gave deadly doses of morphine to many Jewish patients to spare them the inhumane death that the Nazis were going to deliver upon them (Nevins). This medical student took action against what the Nazi Party had in store for Jewish patients. He killed many people to protect them, regardless of the consequences that would later be in store. “…the major opened the door to find four Jews and his loyal Polish servant preparing food for the others.
Gut had no choice but to throw herself at the elderly major’s feet and beg for mercy. “They are my friends,” she pleaded with him. “I had to help them. I couldn’t let them die. (Fogelman).” Going against the Nazis was extremely risqué but many did this to keep their friends and loved ones alive for as long as possible.
A difficult decision
Many people denied Nazi orders in order to protect their loved ones. Regardless of the consequences that this ensued these people proved courageous and faced these impossible odds. “Rabbi Efrati ran into a moral dilemma while there was a search on the house that his brother and nineteen other Jews were in hiding. An infant burst out crying in the bunker during the search. He was faced with the choice of murdering the infant to save the others or risk them being found (Nevins).”The ethical plight that Rabbi Efrati encountered is unimaginable, to choose between twenty innocent lives and one infants life. He had a life or death decision to make for himself and twenty others. “Later that evening, the physically repulsive major summoned Gut to his room. He pulled her onto his lap and then took her to his bed. He insisted that she have sex with him; had she resisted, she would have placed the Jews in mortal danger. Eventually, the major promised to let the Jews stay. Gut never told the people whose lives she had saved what she had done to make their safety possible (Fogelman).” Without Irene’s sacrifice the hidden Jews would...

Find Another Essay On Moral Dilemmas Faced by Jewish Leaders

"Who is Man?" by Abraham Heschel

1028 words - 4 pages Germany. Heschel, however, is Polish in origin. Born in 1907 in Warsaw, he received his early education entirely within the world of the intensive Jewish piety of Eastern European Judaism. The son and grandson of Hasidic rabbis, and the more remote descendant of a line of scholars and religious leaders stretching back to the sixteenth century, he was clearly destined for a life of study. In late adolescence, however, he faced the crucial choice of

The Ethics of Assessments in the Classroom

1886 words - 8 pages Examining teacher ethical dilemmas in classroom assessment Pope, N., Green, S., Johnson, R., & Mitchell, M. (2009). Examining teacher ethical dilemmas in classroom assessment. Teaching and Teacher Education , 25 (5), 778-782. Précis Pope, Green, Johnson, & Mitchell (2009) suggest that we need further research and discussion around ethics and assessment in the classroom. Many ethic dilemmas are faced by teachers however little has been

Logic and Moral Dilemmas

3487 words - 14 pages well as logical, then we must restore consistency to our code. This is accomplished by adding exception clauses to current principles, and giving priorities to some principles over others, or by some other device. I argue that we must accept moral dilemmas as an essential part of real-life reality on the grounds that some moral statements concern values. According to Moore's "axiological thesis," whether these statements are true depends on two

Theodor Herzl: Father of Zionism?

2333 words - 9 pages prejudice they faced throughout the European world, he was never truly a believer in the traditions of Judaism and was primarily concerned with the necessity for the “reformation” of the Jewish culture instead of the founding of a prejudice-free environment. European anti-Semitism, a condition that influenced his own views on his culture, dominated the world that Theodor Herzl grew up in. In a world dominated by prejudice, even Herzl, who

An Introspective View of the Cultural Battle in the Zionist Movement

1811 words - 7 pages Ahad Ha'am differed greatly on the topic of a Jewish state, and the solution to restoring a lost identity. In The Jewish Question, an essay written by Herzl, he expresses his concern regarding the anti-Semitism and persecution that the Jews faced, no matter how many there were or the country they inhabited (200). Yet Herzl made his strongest argument quite clear - the lack of a Jewish homeland aroused persecution and anti-Semitism, as it

"Choose One Religion. Describe The Main Beliefs And Practices Of The Religion And Discuss ...."

5403 words - 22 pages these and others beside such as Rosh Chodesh which is aminor festival which falls at the beginning of each month.Challenges faced by Jewish community in BritainIn Grace Davie's book 'Religion in Britain since 1945', she explains some of the social challenges that are facing Jews in Britain."In Britain, the Jewish population peaked in the 1950's at just over 400,000. Subsequently it declined - for a variety of reasons (among them migration to Israel

Gluckel of Hameln’s Memoirs

1236 words - 5 pages difficulties faced everyday life by the Jews at the time. However, the Jewish people preserved their Jewish self-identity. The memoir is a rich source for the understanding of social and cultural history of the 17th century Europe. Using her spirituality, Gluckel used her memoirs to instruct her children on the importance of values, the family and religious ties, and maintaining their Jewish identity. Works Cited Glueckel. The Memoirs of Glückel of Hameln. New York: Schocken, 1977. Print.

ethical leadership

1699 words - 7 pages Definition of Ethical Leadership Ethical leadership simply means the act of leading by knowing and doing what is right (Wise Geek, 2014). A leader that exhibit ethical leadership understands his or her core values, principles, and beliefs and live true to those values. An ethical leader serves as a mirror through which people view and perceive the organization they represent. Moral and ethical leaders serve as role models for others, who sets

Carol Gilligan on Moral Development

1957 words - 8 pages Carol Gilligan on Moral Development *Missing Works Cited* Carol Gilligan (1982) sparked a heated academic debate with her popular book In a different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development. In this book Gilligan departs from the traditional sequential stage modals advocated by luminary psychologists such as Piaget (1925) and Kohlberg (1969) and develops her own moral orientation model. Gilligan criticises these theories as

What’s Written Versus Reality: Ethical Dilemmas In A Hi-Tech Public Relations Firm

1451 words - 6 pages future for its insufficient operational and financial controls (Weiss, 2006). Furthermore, it is clear that PRI’s leaders are not faced with the same ethical tensions and consequences as its lower-level employees. In fact, top managers choose not to lead by example for this reason (Weiss, 2006). They are not responsible for their behavior and thus do not ensure that their behaviors are consistent with the behaviors they desire from their

Ethical Perspectives

1229 words - 5 pages discussion on issues one is likely to encounter dealing with ethical dilemmas at Bank of America.The four ethical perspectives include character/virtue, obligation/deontology, results/utilitarianism, and equity/relativism; thus, making up CORE. These different ethical perspectives help to explain what drives an individual's decision when faced with an ethical dilemma. It is easy for someone to say what they will do when faced with an example of an

Similar Essays

Moral Dilemmas Faced By Jewish Leaders

2408 words - 10 pages is present that the person will most likely go along with what they order. Hitler was this authority figure and people made decisions based on his orders. The Jewish people however followed the suggestions of their religious leaders or beliefs. Many Jewish leaders faced moral dilemmas and made the correct decisions. Several helped others survive, denied Nazi orders in order to protect their loved ones, and made life or death decisions to protect

Ethical Dilemmas Faced By Nurses And Other Healthcare Professionals

2778 words - 11 pages healthcare personnel in identifying, understanding, and quickly resolving ethical issues. Policies, procedures, and ethic codes are formulated around moral principles of beneficence, autonomy, non-maleficence, and justice. Beneficence is the ethical principle of doing good unto others. Healthcare professionals display this principle by: • Practicing good • Preventing harm • Removing harm (Ranches, Morales, Gelpi, Perez, 2005

Moral Dilemmas In Celia, A Slave By Melton Mc Laurin

1408 words - 6 pages different motives that contribute to the way in which many of the events unfold. Now throughout the book the “main characters”, being Celia, her lawyer Jameson, and the judge William Hall, are all faced with moral decisions that affect the lives of two different people. The first of the main characters that are introduced are Celia’s master, Robert Newsom. Mr. Newsom was a wealthy landowner in Callaway County. In 1850, after the death of his wife

Ethical Dilemmas : Examples During The Holocaust

1040 words - 5 pages present that the person will most likely go along with what they order. Hitler was this authority figure and people made decisions based on his orders. The Jewish people however followed the orders of their religious leaders or beliefs. Many Jewish leaders faced moral dilemmas and made the correct decisions. Several helped others survive, denied Nazi orders in order to protect their loved ones, and made life or death decisions to protect