This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Morality And Abortion Essay

1796 words - 8 pages

In this paper I will explain and examine Judith Jarvis Thomson’s view on abortion as outlined in her essay “A Defense of Abortion”. I will summarize her perspective on the issue, and will then criticize and support her arguments and the analogies she includes.
First, I will address Thomson’s decision to assume that a fetus is a person from the time of conception. I think she makes a wise choice in labeling a fetus as a person throughout pregnancy because this decision eliminates one controversy surrounding the morality of abortion. Were Thomson not to concede the issue regarding personhood, skeptics could focus on their issue with that single point and this disagreement could ...view middle of the document...

The question is, “Is it morally permissible for you to disconnect yourself from the violinist and allow him to die?” This case is meant to seem ridiculous. The answer that most readers will agree upon is that it is completely morally permissible for you to disconnect from the strange man. You owe him nothing, you were kidnapped, and now your body is being used against your will. Thomson’s argument as to why it is morally permissible for you to disconnect from the violinist and allow him to die is similar to the following. The violinist has a right to life. You also have a right to life. However, what you have that changes the situation is a right to autonomy over your own body that is being infringed upon by this violinist. Because you did not willingly give up your autonomy rights by allowing him to be connected to you for nine months, Thomson would argue that the violinist is violating one of your rights and it is therefore morally permissible for you to disconnect from him and allow him to die. This analogy is meant to parallel abortion only in some cases; specifically, cases of rape. Similar to an individual being kidnapped and her body being used against her will in the violinist scenario, a woman’s body is taken without her permission and used against her will by a rapist and the fetus of that rapist. Therefore, a woman’s right to autonomy is violated by a fetus when it is the product of rape. Thomson argues that if we can determine that it is morally permissible for you to disconnect yourself from the violinist then we can also determine that it is morally permissible for you to disconnect yourself from the fetus in cases of rape. However, there are several flaws in this argument. First of all, in the violinist scenario, the woman is performing the action of unplugging herself whereas in the case of abortion after rape, a third party must be involved to perform the action. This calls into question what actions a third party can morally perform. I think Thomson’s analogy about a woman and a rapidly growing baby trapped in a house together addresses this concern very effectively though. In this scenario, a passerby comes upon a house in which a child is growing so rapidly that it will soon crush and kill the woman also trapped in the house. When the woman asks the third party to kill the child and save her, the third party faces a moral dilemma; whose right to life is superior in this case? However, when it is clarified that the woman owns this house and the baby is an intruder, it becomes less of a moral obstacle. At no point is it obvious that a fetus has a right to life that is superior to the mother’s right to autonomy. On the contrary, the woman’s right to life as well as her right to autonomy, according to Thomson, are superior to the child’s right to life. Therefore, it is morally permissible for a third party to choose to act in accordance with the woman’s wishes. This case of the growing baby may only be...

Find Another Essay On morality and abortion

Abortion: Conscience and Morality - Issue Study

962 words - 4 pages What is Abortion?Is abortion murder, or just the right of the mother? That is one of the main questions in the whole abortion conflict. Abortion is when a doctor kills an embryo when it is still inside the mother, and can be summed up as "the knowing destruction of the life of an unborn child." (Mass General Laws Chapter 112 Section 12K). In this age, Australia and society in general has deemed this act to be acceptable.All babies have a right

Morality of Abortion Essay

1452 words - 6 pages Morality of Abortion      For the past couple of decades, the issue of abortion has been the most heated topic debated in the United States. When considering this topic, one must look at three things: ethics, emotions and the law; for all of these are important to this issue. Like any debate, there are two sides to this issue: pro-choice and pro-life. The people who are pro- abortion say that the mother is the ultimate

The morality of abortion

1398 words - 6 pages in the question of the morality of abortion. When parents decide to keep or not keep a baby the issue of adoption does not play into this. The reason for this is that once the baby is born that the parents may change their mind if they want to keep it. Parents must decide at the onset of the pregnancy to decide if they can in good conscience bring a child into the world, if the answer is yes, then people should proceed with the pregnancy and

The Morality of Abortion: Practically Proven

1281 words - 5 pages Abortion. The word alone summons controversy and unrest within normally civil conversation. Society has consistently examined and reexamined, debated and re-debated the morality of abortion until defined and perhaps hostile sides have formed. It is my intention to show that abortion within the first trimester of pregnancy is unequivocally morally justified, regardless of the means or consequences of the pregnancy. It is entirely morally

Morality of abortion in case of rape by Thomson

1212 words - 5 pages People term to accept and reject moral and ethical decisions according to the agreement with the majority of the society. However, there are many debating cases that cannot decide whether those are morally wrong or not because it is hard to draw a clear line of immorality and morality between those cases. Abortion is one of debating cases among them where some people argues that it is impermissible to do abortion and some believe that it is not

An issue of morality. Abortion. Cited with footnotes

2246 words - 9 pages Abortion is and has been one of the most controversial moral issues for centuries. The ongoing debate on whether or not abortion is acceptable has been evident in not only government legislation, but social mediation as well. Pro-life activists insist that killing a baby while inside the mother's womb is immoral and on the same level of manslaughter, and therefor should be outlawed. They say that homicide is illegal in the U.S. while in many

Abortion a Moral Choice or Leg

680 words - 3 pages methods to put an end to unwanted pregnancy (Suzumski 13). Throughout the years abortion has become a very controversial subject. Abortion is a moral dilemma addressed in many court cases; yet moral decisions, such as abortion, may be debated in a court of law, but in these cases the arguments are often moved from legal questions to questions of morality and religious/ethnic beliefs (Milbauer 3). Law has opened many doors for abortion. It has been

Abortion: The Murder of Inconvenient Lives

839 words - 4 pages morality left within the human race. Finally, I would like to mention the association abortion has to everyone. The number of abortions has fluctuated very little since statistics on the matter began being recorded. Its lowest point was in 1992 when the percentage of abortion was 27.5% of pregnancies, and its highest point was in 1983 when it reached 30.4% of pregnancies (“Abortion”). “At current rates, more than one-third of American women will

Exploratory Essay: Abortion

1791 words - 7 pages , called pro-choice. The pro-choice respects and honors a woman on when to conceive on their own time. They condemn protecting the health of women by thinking and acting positively among the woman’s decision to abort their child. An essay called, “The Contradiction of Abortion and Morality” relates to this issue, by suggesting that abortion is “Morally unacceptable (Cite)”, and that the rights of having an abortion are primarily a mother’s

Abortion Should Remain Legal

2323 words - 9 pages : The Solution in Search of a Problem.” The Huffington Post., 12 Aug. 2013. Web. 02 Dec. 2013. Haddad, Lisa B., and Nawal M. Nour. “Unsafe Abortion: Unnecessary Maternal Morality.” National Center for Biotechnology Information. U.S. National Library of Medicine, Spring 2009. Web. 01 Dec. 2013. Harman, Elizabeth. Creation Ethics: The Moral Status of Early Fetuses and the Ethics of Abortion. Vol. 28. N.p.: Philosophy and Public

Perspectives on Abortion

1116 words - 5 pages For many years, the morality of abortion has been questioned by two perspectives: pro-choice and pro-life. While modern culture explains that abortion is a woman’s free choice if she does not want the unborn baby, the Catholic Church teaches the world that from the moment of conception there is a child with a soul within the womb, and to abort it would be to murder an innocent being. In the year March 1970, a woman dubbed Jane Roe took federal

Similar Essays

Morality And Legality Of Abortion Essay

507 words - 2 pages Morality and legality of abortionSomewhere amidst the abortion debates of the last quarter century, the real issuehas been lost. The focus has become too religious for a country that has separated churchand state. Therefore, I won't argue the religious rights and wrongs of abortion. Noanswers can be derived until we focus on what the law and our citizens do value, becausethis is how laws are changed. American laws hold sacred the value of human

The Morality Of Abortion And Surrogacy

1933 words - 8 pages The Morality of Abortion and Surrogacy It is said that, the basic principle of such tradition is that humans communicate through symbols, which are a common currency through which a sense of self is created through interaction with others. Mead's theory neatly avoids the trap of positing a sense of self that is constructed entirely through symbols and society by making a distinction between two different selves: "I" which is the

Philosophy And The Morality Of Abortion

2428 words - 10 pages be inflicted with Spina bifida or other comparable conditions which can be detected during a foetal stage. So importantly, the likely future that awaits a foetus if not aborted, is a vital component when contemplating the morality of abortion. For a woman who desires an abortion, her interests should always (considering a normally developed woman) take precedence over the foetus, as only she is an individual, with plans, goals, and a conscious

Abortion And Morality Essay

1232 words - 5 pages “Any American born after 1973 is a survivor of legalized abortion” (“Abortion”). This quote struck me because of its frankness. After it was legalized, many women had an option to abort their pregnancy against the Catholic Church’s wishes. Any child that was born after that year could have been aborted. This shows that many of the people that are living today could have been killed simply because the mother did not want them and they were