Morality And Religion Debate Essay

1152 words - 5 pages

Morality and Religion Debate

In an organized religion debate, Alan Dershowitz and Alan Keyes contended many issues on religion and morality. Alan Dershowitz, a Harvard law professor, believed that "morality can be maintained without religion." He also stated that it must be maintained without religion because times have changed. He said that if religion is not separated from state it could have severe damage, such as the Crusades and the Holocaust. Dershowitz believes that there is a difference between morality and religion. When people are moral without religion, they are being virtuous on their own, not because they are afraid of God. He stated that religion should not consist of a Cost-Benefit Analysis. Alan Keyes, a former Republican presidential candidate, stated that religion sets the standard for what's moral. Keyes argued "power only ultimately respects another power," and Martin Luther King Jr. was not a preacher by accident. Dershowitz also stated that not everything in the Bible should be believed word-for-word, even George Washington said "indulge religion with caution." Keyes believed that if state and religion should be separated, then why does the Declaration of Independence contain so much about religion? Alan Dershowitz and Alan Keyes would have argued endlessly about religion's role in society if there were not a moderator to stop them.

Religion and morality exist together in parallel according to Alan Keyes. Alan Dershowitz stated that if religion and morality are not separated, it could have negative discourse. James Fowler followed Piaget, Kohlberg, and Erickson when selecting the stages to his development of faith across the life span. These three men all selected different ways to look at religion and morality. Keyes believed that morality could not exist without religion. He stated that God is the almighty, and he questioned should we rely on the voice of the people above God. Dershowitz said, in return, that people are not moral if the sole reason for them doing it was to get to heaven. Dershowitz stated "doing the right thing because it is the right thing is more powerful than doing it because someone higher than you says so." Fowler's theory emphasises on the form of faith, not on a particular belief system. He believed that faith could be religious or non-religious, such as God, science, or humanity. Throughout his six stages, he links religion (faith) with morality, and how a person becomes increasingly moral as they grow older and learn more about faith. The relationship between religion and morality has existed throughout all time, and it has cost many senseless deaths and wars. The Crusades were a major example of how religion can be viewed negatively in politics. Dershowitz believed that if the Crusades were right, why were there not counter-Crusades? Keyes retorted that everyone has to be responsible and accountable. He believed that the horrible things done in the name of religion were just our...

Find Another Essay On Morality and Religion Debate

Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe. Essay on how morality and religion are the outstanding themes in the novel.

664 words - 3 pages In Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe, there are many themes intertwined in the novel. These themes include religion, morality, and violence. Morality seemed to stand out as the underlying theme of the story. It shapes the characters and helps develop the book into more than just a classic story.Uncle Tom's Cabin was originally written to convince Americansthat slavery was evil. The slaves endure horror such as the separation of husbands

Secular Morality and Religious Morality Inadvertently Influenced One Another

986 words - 4 pages Even in matters of outwardly secular morality, religion plays such a hegemonic role that, in many instances, secular morality is inadvertently influenced by religious morality. It could even be said that religious morality is greatly influenced by secular morals and not the other way around. While it would be difficult to assess the genealogy of morality it would be safe to say that morality has a very strong connection with religious morality

Morality And Power

938 words - 4 pages      Thucydides’ written history of the Mytilenian Debate and the Melian Dialogue reflects the reality of a period where morality is dependent on the exercise of power and those who possess it. The main theme running through the course of these two debates is that those with the power to act as they wish inherently have the power to dictate morality. The arguments that decide the fate of the Mytilene are made not

The Influence of Religion on Scientific Advancement

1776 words - 7 pages that religious movements have occasionally impeded scientific discovery; however, there is also evidence that scientific progression has been aided by religious ideology. By examining both the negative and positive roles religion has played in history, modern times, and the overall area of morality, one can determine the true extent to which faith hinders scientific advancement. The Catholic Inquisitions exemplify one area in which religion


1634 words - 7 pages species that we are today. Another common debate is the argument of where our morality comes from. “A popular claim among religious theists is that atheists have no basis for morality — that religion and gods are needed for moral values.” (Austin Cline. As u read, most theists conclude that morals are given to us by a God, because you need a reason to have morals otherwise there is no basis for right and wrong. Atheists believe that

Should We Legislate Morality?

1264 words - 5 pages it through political change rather than dealing with the spiritual issues first. That is to say that legislating morality is an attempt to control behavior without dealing with the spiritual roots of the problem. This case offers both a secular argument and a religious argument. Having a religion based law is fine, but if that is all you have then you should not vote for it. To become a law, there must be some secular reason as well. The

Christianity and Islamic Religions: A Blessing or a Curse Part 3

1171 words - 5 pages Lenin and Stalin and the Chinese communism. Another well-known argument that is often used by atheist is that religion is against science and that believers are illogical human beings due to their beliefs in the existence of God. However, a case study of the relationship that exists between religion and science will once again prove this argument wrong. Dr. Abdulla Galadari wrote an article named “Science vs. Religion: The Debate Ends” (2011

Religion vs. Morality

2552 words - 10 pages the child has evolved past parenting all together and therefore needs no more guidance. Defining what is considered moral has now become much more complex. Sam Harris presents the same basic argument of morality in his book Letter to a Christian Nation, by applying it not to a child and his parents, but to society and religion. He says that yes, at point society needed God, like a child needs a parent, to tell them what is wrong and right, but he

The Idea of Morality Cannot Work Without the Existence of God

1032 words - 4 pages The Idea of Morality Cannot Work Without the Existence of God Morality is the set of concepts about wha tis good or bad, right or wrong, in human charater or conduct. God demands that moral judgements are universal and based on religion. However, other schools of thought, e.g. the ideology of Anarchy, claim that if this 'morality made by god' is the case, then 'each person is his own god'. We must

The difference between philosophy and religion (reason and faith)

2137 words - 9 pages Morality and ReligionIntroductionThe issue I intend to tackle in this assignment is the relationship between morality and religion. I will basically explain whether morality depend on religion. It is a common belief among many people that morality and religion are inseparable. Others believe that if any distinction between morality and religion is to be made, then morality can be understood only in the context of religion. This thought about

The Literature of Romanticism versus the Victorian

1579 words - 6 pages In the Victorian era poets are inspired to debate among each other in the heat of enlightenment. The literature of Romanticism versus the Victorian era initially becomes a problematic subject to accept. As a Victorian poet, Gerard Manley Hopkins attacks the conception of religion by questioning the existence of God. Hopkins’ sonnets reflect this issue of an oppress religion and educates people towards the conspiracy of a change era through his

Similar Essays

The Relationship Between Religion And Morality

2114 words - 8 pages : If religion teaches love and acceptance, why does Noah’s father feel that his “strong religious” community ostracizes Noah? If religion promotes kindness and altruism, why does Noah’s mother feel isolated and frighten? Mostly, if religion correlates with morality, how can Gwen’s murder happened in a predominantly Christian community? For my research project, I would like to examine if religion correlates with morality and is religion

Exploring The Relationship Between Morality And Religion

1553 words - 6 pages The relationship between religion and morality is one which has been, and continues to be, exhaustively discussed and debated by philosophers. Are the two hopelessly intertwined, or are they able to exist independent of one another? One argument which seeks to provide a solution to this matter of contention is the Divine Command Theory. In this paper, I will argue that the reasoning provided by the Divine Command Theory is an inadequate

Evolution: The Debate Of Science And Religion

843 words - 3 pages The Debate of Science and ReligionFor Decades, scientists have often researched and experimented in an attempt to derive the beginning of the world and all of its natural wonders. However, devout Christians and other religious followers condoned and shunned this scientific way of thought. Science has tried to create answers for many questions that Christians believed were from God. From education our society has received knowledge, which has in

Discussion Of The View That Morality And Religion Are Linked

962 words - 4 pages Discussion of the View that Morality and Religion are Linked The view that morality and religion are linked together implies that it is God who dictates to us humans whatever is moral. Therefore, any action dictated to humans to carry out by God is morally right or acceptable. Looking from this point of view, morality would be based on unchangeable laws and this