Morality Not Necessary Linked To Religion

834 words - 3 pages

Morality Not Necessary Linked to ReligionThrough human history religion has played a big role to define what is the right and wrong way to act. Even in actual days people relay on what religious texts, such as the Bible or The Quran,and its authorities, God, say in order to find out what is morally right - defined as a system of ideas of right and wrong behavior. The Divine Command Theory defends that in fact God commands what is morally right and forbids what is morally wrong. But is there really a connection between what is moral right and what those authorities command is morally right? Is rape wrong because God commands it or because there is a rational reason why it is wrong? Plato argues that The Command Theory is false whit his Euthyphro Argument, which rises a tiny dilemma: "Is an action morally right because God commands it, or does God command an action because it is right?" (The Ethical Life, Shafer, 2012, pp. 63). I claim that Plato argument is right, that in fact God is not the creator of morality.The Divine Command Theory is a kind of moral relativism: what is right or wrong is what the divine authority, God says is. Even if God commands are complete irrational, if God says that rape is good, then going trough the streets raping people will morally right, even when we know the act causes psychological and physical damage on the victim, in other words we know there are reasons why rape is not morally right. Or if God said that two plus two is equal to eight, which is completely false since two units united with other two are four regardless of what God says. This makes all the commands of God arbitrary and eliminates the logical validity of God commands. Also, The Divine Command Theory assumes first that religious belief is needed for moral motivation, second that God is the creator of morality and third that religion rs an essential source of moral guidance Plato explains with his Euthyphro argument that second assumption is false.The Euthyphro argument is the discussion between Euthyphro and Socrates about the essence of piety. During their dialog Both are waiting outside the Athenian court, Euthryphro to charge of murder against his father, and Socrates because he is being charged with impiety - defined as a lack of proper concern for the obligations owed to public religious observation or cult.-. They begin a discussion of piety - defined as the veneration or reverence of the Supreme Being, and...

Find Another Essay On Morality Not Necessary Linked to Religion

Davie's Concept of Believing but Not Belonging to Religion

1866 words - 7 pages Davie's (1994) concept of ‘believing without belonging’ describes the movement away from organised religion and the increasing numbers of people who are ‘spiritual but not religious’ (Davie, 1994). It describes why people feel they no longer need to take part in religious practises, but still classify themselves as ‘Catholic’. This essay will first discuss what it means to believe, secondly the extent to which Davie's concept is applicable to

Can a definition of “Religion” be academically useful? Pick yes or no, and provide an argument as to why or why not?

763 words - 4 pages A definition of Religion is and can be academically useful. It’s the same as with science as it is with religion, the ability to have a definition, creates academic validity for the subject. One has the ability to point to a certain section or a topic of a book and then support themselves with a fundamental definition. Now the problem that arises in religious studies is that the definition is not always accurate or consistent. Many different

Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not?

724 words - 3 pages Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not? The moral views of a society should be incorporated into the laws of society to a degree that represents the best interest of the people. It is far fetched to say that we should remove entirely moral views from our legal system, while on the other side of the spectrum it wouldn't seem right to

Morality and Religion Debate

1152 words - 5 pages morality, but society also praises religion and morality for its helping in overcoming troubled times. Alan Dershowitz stated that the "burning of witches and execution of homosexuals" should be credited to religion being linked to morality. He also believed that the Bible is not a safe means for judging people, and if it were, then we would not have evolved as people enough to realise that inequality is wrong. Dershowitz stated that people should not

The Idea of Morality Cannot Work Without the Existence of God

1032 words - 4 pages been shaped without religion or the existence of God. Some groups argue that Morality does not come from any institution at all but from instinct- instinct to be be positive and instinct to be constructive and not destructive (much of God's morality as we know it centres upon how to treat others in a positive way but here the argument is that this is inbuilt in us without the existence of a God). We can see from the

Morality and Politics

1971 words - 8 pages Morality and politics have always been closely linked; even in present day politics, morality often has a part to play. Morality within politics has always been a controversial and highly debated topic by many leading political thinkers. There have been many key thinkers on the subject; however, Plato and Augustine have both an interesting and highly debated view on the argument of whether politics should be focused on morality. Both Plato and

Secular Morality and Religious Morality Inadvertently Influenced One Another

986 words - 4 pages Even in matters of outwardly secular morality, religion plays such a hegemonic role that, in many instances, secular morality is inadvertently influenced by religious morality. It could even be said that religious morality is greatly influenced by secular morals and not the other way around. While it would be difficult to assess the genealogy of morality it would be safe to say that morality has a very strong connection with religious morality

Morality And Power

938 words - 4 pages      Thucydides’ written history of the Mytilenian Debate and the Melian Dialogue reflects the reality of a period where morality is dependent on the exercise of power and those who possess it. The main theme running through the course of these two debates is that those with the power to act as they wish inherently have the power to dictate morality. The arguments that decide the fate of the Mytilene are made not

God as purpose of religion

658 words - 3 pages "murder is wrong" are seen as divine laws, requiring a divine lawmaker and judge. Still, many atheists argue that treating morality legalistically involves a false analogy, and that morality does not depend on a lawmaker in the same way that laws do, which either renders God unnecessary or morality arbitrary. In conclusion, God is necessary to develop yourself as a person. You become a person who has many qualities and bad things. You are

Controversy Between the Existence of God

1679 words - 7 pages world can be viewed as prerequisite for the formation of the point under study. While one can believe that God creates morality, and the non-existence of God means that morality does not exist, lots of questions regarding the nature of the link between religious and moral norms arise. The main counterargument to the quotation under study lies in the fact that the religion and morality are not synonymous. Furthermore, many non-religious studies (e.g

Evolution and Moral Truths

1716 words - 7 pages asserts that what is true for one person may not necessarily be true for others. It states that while something may be true now, it might not have been true in the past and may not be true in the future, as well. This type of truth is always subject to change and to the perspective and interpretation of people. In order to related this concept of truth back to the idea of evolution, it is necessary to examine the idea of moral relativism. Moral

Similar Essays

Morality Not Necessary Linked To Religion

834 words - 3 pages Morality Not Necessary Linked to ReligionThrough human history religion has played a big role to define what is the right and wrong way to act. Even in actual days people relay on what religious texts, such as the Bible or The Quran,and its authorities, God, say in order to find out what is morally right - defined as a system of ideas of right and wrong behavior. The Divine Command Theory defends that in fact God commands what is morally right

Discussion Of The View That Morality And Religion Are Linked

962 words - 4 pages view is deontological because it based on golden rules and does not look at present consequences before it is considered moral or right. This view makes morality objective as it lays down certain rules for humans to live by. The Euthyphro dialogue is what the issue of religion and morality is based around. This dialogue by Plato portrays the view that morality and religion are linked. In this dialogue, Plato’s

Do You Agree That "Being Religious In Itself Is Not A Necessary Qualification For A Student Of Religion?"

781 words - 3 pages . Despite this, parents send their children off for religious classes on weekends so that they may attain a certain degree of understanding of their parents' religion. Whether or not these children attain a full understanding of the religion at this age depends on the individual child's own understanding and upbringing. Despite these examples, some do agree that being religious is necessary for one to be a student of religion. They argue that

"Psychology And Religion" How Is Psychology Present In Religion? How Might Some Dangerous Behavior Be Linked With Religious Beliefs? Is Religion Useful Or Detrimental To Society?

1110 words - 4 pages human beings. When taken to extremes any religion can be dangerous."Fred Nojd (http://members.attcanada.ca/~fnojd/wherearethedeists.html)The previous paragraph from Fred Nojd sums my feelings fairly well. I do not object to religion. In fact, I don't believe a society with freedoms such as those we currently enjoy in America would be possible without it. However, I do think that any religious convictions that hinder one's ability to deal with