"More sinned against than sinning." Is this a more appropriate description of Agamemnon than Clytaemestra?

1020 words - 4 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed
VIEW DOCUMENT
Preview

Clytaemestra's murder of Agamemnon can be seen as one of the main sins in the play. The Chorus of Argive Elders calls the act 'obscene' and since one of the functions of the Chorus is to direct the audience's sympathy and give voice to pious opinions this indicates Clytaemestra is more sinning than sinned against. However when she defends her acts after the murder to The Chorus she tells them it was she who was sinned against, as her husband Agamemnon 'slaughtered' their 'own child' Iphigenia. She suggests that The Chorus are hypocrites as they 'would not cross' Agamemnon for his murder of his daughter but they call her crime 'treacherous' and are 'stunned' by it even though she says it was 'righteous' to kill him.Clytaemestra's justification for Agamemnon's murder suggests it was Agamemnon who was the more sinful of the two and she tells the chorus he 'slaughtered' Iphigenia despite the fact his 'pastures swarmed with... flocks' suggesting he was excessive, killing people when it was unnecessary. This was something the Ancient Greeks thought was a particularly bad sin, as they believed that people should be pious and modest. One of their maxims carved in stone at Delphi was 'nothing to excess'.However it was out of 'necessity' that Agamemnon had to 'sacrifice' his daughter, as Artemis was so upset at the thought of all the young men who would die at Troy the 'winds blew from the Strymon' at her command so the Greeks could not sail and would only let them go in exchange for Iphigenia's 'slaughter'. Although this suggests it was Agamemnon who was 'sinned against' the Chorus of Argive Elders still call him 'sacrilegious' and an 'infidel' because the murder of Iphigenia, a 'sweet', 'innocent' girl was a sin.Revenge for Iphigenia was not Clytaemestra's only motive for 'striking down' Agamemnon however. She had taken a lover, Aegisthus while Agamemnon had been away at 'Illium' and clearly enjoyed Argos being 'my city' and wanted to continue to 'rule' it through Aegisthus. This is a sin as it was considered very wrong especially for a woman to depose a king. Indeed in Pericles' Funeral Oration he says that the greatest woman is the one 'least talked about by men' implying women should be subservient to men and Agamemnon himself remarks that Clytaemestra's 'lust for conflict' and power is 'not womanlike'. At the beginning of The Agamemnon The Watchman comments on Clytaemestra's unwomanly 'male strength of heart' and this is constantly seen as an unnatural quality throughout this play and all of Ancient Greek culture. This suggests it was Agamemnon who was the more sinned against, and Clytaemestra the more sinning.The Chorus back this suggestion as after...

Find Another Essay On "More sinned against than sinning." Is this a more appropriate description of Agamemnon than Clytaemestra?

Could Be The Concept Of Legal Rights A More Appropriate Tool Than Utilitarianism In Determining Morality?

2194 words - 9 pages In order to respond to whether the concepts of rights is more appropriate in determining morality than utilitarianism it is important to firstly define each of the concepts independent of one another before attempting to compare them. Although rights theory is perhaps the most widely applied theory in the Western world this does not necessarily mean that the...

More Than Simply A Creature Essay

1868 words - 7 pages the medical practices because it offers a more realistic and accurate tool of a human to work on though the mannequins are extremely expensive. One author writes, “An animal welfare group is donating $1 million worth of costly training mannequins to medical schools in nine countries to accomplish two goals: giving doctors more modern training, and saving the lives of about 1,000 animals a year” (McNeil). Finally, this issue can influence politics...

More Powerful Than A Stereotype

864 words - 3 pages stereotyped as peculiar and as a nonconformist. The pain of alienation is Alexie’s description of his childhood, “if he’d been anything but an Indian boy living on the reservation, he might have been called a prodigy. But he is an Indian boy living on the reservation and is simply an oddity” (Alexie 5). These labels seem to have had a clearly negative impact on him as he describes that “he grows into a man who often speaks of his childhood in the...

More Than A Bus Driver

2256 words - 9 pages of success even if he/she doesn't accomplish the overall goal. Coaches should be aware and sensitive to the emotional needs of his/her athletes to insure the best possible relationship. "A fundamental component of a positive coach-player relationship is genuine concern or caring for the players" (Stewart 10). Schools districts need educated coaches now more than ever before. "Over 40 million youth up to age 18 participate in various sports at...

Justice Is A Lot More Than The Absence Of Brutality

1654 words - 7 pages Racism: Justice is More than the Absence of Brutality   "Does race still matter?" The question by itself is a strong indication of America's disillusioned attitude towards race. It has been barely forty years since segregation— arbitrary laws that separated white children from everyone else because of the assumed superiority of whites—was abolished, and already Americans, especially white Americans, have begun to complain that we are too...

More Than Just A Place

1016 words - 4 pages merely a building in which a home is to be constructed. Once the contractor has finished, the work of making the house a home has only begun.      The home is a goal. Yes, when we are born we are given a home, but eventually you have to find one for yourself. This can be a painstaking process especially when you have no concept of what your home is. A home can be more than where a person stays. It can involve finding a...

More Than A Noble Perception

618 words - 2 pages By: rocket Frank Caracciolo English Essay 10/4/98 Period 10/11 More Then a Noble Perception Perception is the insight or knowledge gained by perceiving. In The Tragedy of Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, Macbeth the tragic hero of the play is perceived differently by everyone. Macbeth is one of King Duncan's nobleman and soldiers, who as the play goes on murders his...

Islam More Than A Religion

1379 words - 6 pages revealed the Qur'an to his messenger, Muhammad. According to Islamic beliefs, Muhammad is the last of a series of prophets (including Adam, Noah, Jesus, and others). Muhammad's message concurrently perfect and do away with the "revelations" attributed to earlier prophets.Islam More Than A ReligionFrom the very beginning of Islam, Muhammad had indoctrinated a sense of brotherhood and a bond of faith among his followers. The Prophet...

More Than A Radical Revolution

933 words - 4 pages found only in a republic of equal, active, and independent citizens.” America’s radical change also allowed the common people to be voters and help determine their society, also an unheard of change to government and society. Gordon Wood uses this three-phase transition to prove that the American Revolution was more than a conservative rebellion but a true social revolution that perpetually changed America forever. Wood shares his personal...

More Inhuman Than Human

826 words - 3 pages According to Google, the first definition of inhuman is one lacking human qualities of compassion and mercy. The next definition defines inhuman as not human in nature or character. While this can be taken as those being that are less than human it also includes those that are viewed as more than human, making it have both a negative and positive connotation. Through the use of “social norms” the real definition of what is human, accepted...

Money Is More Important Than Education

774 words - 3 pages greater the benefits in terms of salary and other compensations such as health and fringe benefits that have high monetary values. In closing and before I take your question I leave you with this : If you were to check the list of Fortune 500 company bosses, you would find that more than half of them never attended university. In fact, many of them never even finished High School. Even the richest of the rich Bill Gates is a Harvard drop out...

Other "More sinned against than sinning." Is this a more appropriate description of Agamemnon than Clytaemestra? Essays

Think About The Precision Of Lear?S Claim That He's ?A Guy / More Sinned Against Than Sinning?

1466 words - 6 pages tells Kent and the Fool during a storm that he is “a man / More sinned against than sinning”, knowing that he also made mistakes, not only the others. But is King Lear really more of a victim than a guilty one? The most shocking and maybe also the most fatal sin of King Lear is the disinheriting and chasing out of Cordelia by her own father right at the beginning of the play. When Cordelia is asked by Lear to tell him how much she loves him she...

More Than A Homemaker Essay

1366 words - 5 pages for women were always limited and the only thing that women could do was to become housewives. People were very conservative to the idea of the traditional role of a man and a woman. Men are always the provider and women are always the caregiver. Men held more power because of the fact that they earned money. It is hard for people to lose the conservative idea because the idea was around since the beginning of the era. So, rightful place for woman...

More Than A Prize Essay

555 words - 2 pages mention the care this animal requires. It's not his or her fault. They're trained to persuade people to play the game. They are not trained to properly maintain animals.More often than anoles, goldfish are given away as prizes as well. A common goldfish will grow approximately 14 inches or more. It is obvious that a lot of people do not know this. I work at a pet store and so many customers are surprised when they find out their goldfish...

Pertelote Is More Than A Mere Hen

1504 words - 6 pages "Pertelote is much more than a mere hen" how far do you agree with this?I feel that this comment is extremely justified. Chaucer with the use of a beast fable has helped to elevate what would be considered a conventionally boring set of animals, and turn them into portrayals of human beings. As a cock he may have came from the same batch of eggs as his...