More Than A Boggart In Dumbledore’s Closet

2017 words - 8 pages

When questioned about Albus Dumbledore’s, the fictional headmaster of Hogwarts, sexuality J.K. Rowling stated, “My truthful answer to you... I always thought of Dumbledore as gay.” (qtd. from Edward par 4). Rowling attended Carnegie Hall in New York City on October 19, 2007 to read an excerpt of her seventh book (Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows), sign some autographs, and answer fan’s burning questions. After outing Dumbledore, Rowling received an ovation at the event, but not everyone reacted to the news with the same excitement and support. The news over Dumbledore’s orientation started another controversy over the children series between supporters of the book and those who opposed the series with everyone voicing various responses to Dumbledore’s outing. Many of the popular responses come from people who support the novels believing the series spreads tolerance of homosexuality, and Christians that oppose the series believing the books threaten their religious views.
Devout Christians like Laura Mallory and Linda Harvey claim that Rowling’s confession proves the harm the Harry Potter series can bring to children today (Harvey par 2). David Dale quotes Mallory in his article, “My prayer is that parents would wake up, that the subtle way this is presented as harmless fantasy would be exposed for what it really is: a subtle indoctrination into anti-Christian values,” (Dale par 4) which puts her and Harvey in the same opinion that the series threatens a Christian life style. Other Christians supporting the books and think that Dumbledore’s preference either doesn’t matter or promotes Christian beliefs on homosexuals. One of the supporters, Regina Doman, points out in her article In Defense of Dumbledore that Dumbledore’s relationship with Grindelwald, an evil wizard with past relations to the headmaster, and caused Dumbledore and his family many problems (Doman). Doman’s believes these situations found in the books support the view that homosexuality is an abomination, and that the novels should be supported for this reason.
More Christian support for the novels comes from The Vatican which promotes the series as an excellent teacher of good morals, despite that one of the main characters prefers his own sex (Bronski par 1). Other views in support of Dumbledore and the novels believe that we should praise the books for their inclusion of such a touch subject as homosexuality. Two supporters of the inclusions, Peter Tatchell and Mary Bousted, praise the books teachings of “tolerance and understanding” (Dale par 5), but Tatchell wishes that Rowling had made the homosexuality more prevalent in the books while Bousted rejoiced that Rowling didn’t make it a big plot point (Dale par 5-6). The supporters of Dumbledores homosexuality don’t just disagree with the opposition over the inclusion of a gay character in the book, the controversy also brings up arguments over education.
Education reform arguments have supporters and opposers of...

Find Another Essay On More than a Boggart in Dumbledore’s Closet

Islam More Than A Religion Essay

1379 words - 6 pages Islam More Than A ReligionISLAM MORE THAN A RELIGIONDespite its huge following around the world and the growing Muslim communities in the United States, Islam is foreign to most Americans who are familiar with Christianity or Judaism. Because most Americans know little or nothing about Islam, they have many misconceptions about Muslim beliefs and rituals. The negative image many people in the United States and Europe have of Islam and the Muslim

More Than Just A Place Essay

1016 words - 4 pages More Than Just A Place It takes some people a long time to get there and others no time at all. It is a place where a person should feel relaxed and comfortable, in harmony with their environment. It is a place of refuge and its doors should always be open. It can be where you go to after a long day of work or what you land on to win the game for your team. The Merriam Webster Dictionary defines it as “one’s place of residence, the social unit

More than a Radical Revolution

906 words - 4 pages found only in a republic of equal, active, and independent citizens.” America’s radical change also allowed the common people to be voters and help determine their society, also an unheard of change to government and society. Gordon Wood uses this three-phase transition to prove that the American Revolution was more than a conservative rebellion but a true social revolution that perpetually changed America forever. Wood shares his personal

More Powerful than a Stereotype

847 words - 4 pages dangerous person, widely feared and ridiculed by Indians and non-Indians alike” may have also been a compelling stereotype that Alexie was able to use as a driving force towards both his own development and strength. (Alexie 209) Maybe stereotypes can drive a person more than they would on their own. Alexie was able to not only survive his alien childhood, but to use it with purpose to become an extremely successful individual that still

More than a noble perception

618 words - 2 pages By: rocket Frank Caracciolo English Essay 10/4/98 Period 10/11 More Then a Noble Perception Perception is the insight or knowledge gained by perceiving. In The Tragedy of Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, Macbeth the tragic hero of the play is perceived differently by everyone. Macbeth is one of King Duncan's nobleman and soldiers, who as the play goes on murders his leader when hearing he will one day be King from a trio of witches. Through

Lesser Than A Hero but More Than A Man

706 words - 3 pages Harry was a man of many flaws, He was not perfect, but he tried. Harry was an alcoholic and a heavy smoker which heavily affected his work and judgment. Harry was not addicted to alcohol, but alcohol meant so much more to him, in Harry’s case it was not a refuge, but the ultimate way to punish himself. Harry was hurting, causing pain to himself for the pain he brought upon his ex-partner Ellen by getting her killed. His guilt was so strong harry

Addiction: More Than Just a Word

1767 words - 8 pages alcohol, drugs, and violence. ICARE chooses to start to educate the students about these things in school, before they can become addicted. Unfortunately for some, it is too late. Talking about this with my mentor ignited a series of questions about addiction. “What exactly is an addiction?” “How is it acquired?” “What are the different types of addiction?” “Is it possible to be addicted to more than one thing, or substance?” “Do people with an

A Film With More Than One Connection

2572 words - 11 pages situations throughout history. The film displays how biopolitics is used to control the aliens, which has close ties to the Apartheid but I would like to demonstrate how this film has more meaning and connections than just one and how through historical fiction we are able to make one scenario the display of many. Historical fiction plays a huge role on how biopolitics is portrayed in the film District 9 (2009), because there is a general consensus

Housing Vouchers: More Than a Housing Solution

1736 words - 7 pages Housing Vouchers Vouchers: More Than a Housing Solution Introduction Many advocates and policymakers of housing for the poor believe that to achieve optimal human development of low-income households the location of the housing must be considered as well as the quality of the housing unit (Newman, 2008). According to Newman (2008), housing of the poor has to allow for economic independence and self-care while providing a safe and adequate

More than a Sport: Discovering Parkour

1540 words - 7 pages Most people have never heard of Parkour until they watched an episode of “The Office” where all the employees decide to reenact a YouTube sensation and do some “hardcore Parkour”. This sparked a phenomenon that had everyone wondering, “What is Parkour?” Walking around campus, I have seen more Parkour now more than ever because of this recent interest. What appeals to the public about Parkour is that it is non competitive. Beginners do not feel

More than a spoonful of sugar

1195 words - 5 pages back to the mother. They need the warmth and the touch. A child is constantly held and cuddled. Premature babies receive three massages a day. (Ackerman72) “Massaged babies gain weight as much as 50% faster than unmassaged babies. They’re more active, alert and responsive, more aware of their surroundings, better able to tolerate noise and the orient themselves faster and are emotionally more in control.” (Ackerman 73) Premature babies benefit

Similar Essays

More Than A Boggart In Dumbledore's Closet

1820 words - 7 pages , much like how religion isn’t. This view can be supported in the Potter books by pointing out how Dumbledore’s sexuality wasn’t a factor in how good of a character he was. “Let’s say Dumbledore’s sexual orientation was revealed in the book series. Would that have made him any more or less strong, kind or wise? I think not,” (Johnson par 4) Juan Johnson said in a short writing on the wizards outing. Johnson’s opinion supports the idea that Rowling

More Than A Prize Essay

555 words - 2 pages Carnival games should not reward animals as prizes because information concerning care isn't provided. Frustrated people are stuck with an animal they know nothing about. Because of this lack of knowledge, the animal will more than likely die. The majority of people do not enjoy having their pet die.A successful pitch of a baseball wins you a green anole, a small lizard that requires specific needs. You're handed your prize in nothing more than

More Than A Homemaker Essay

1366 words - 5 pages far from being over. When she got married to my grandfather, she stayed home with her mother-in-law to learn how to be their “perfect” house wife. It was no different than being a slave. She would be always confined like a prisoner in the house and would be scolded every day, nonstop. She never rested from day and night because her chores were far from being done and taking care of her eight children all on her own was a challenge. My

More Than A Bus Driver Essay

2269 words - 10 pages characteristic that educated experienced coaches share with inexperienced coaches is, they both want to see their athletes succeed and achieve their goals. As discussed earlier each athlete has individual needs that require implementing individuality and specificity. Coaches need to understand that more than just accommodating their physical needs, athletes also require mental support. A coaches behavior is a big deciding factor in classifying them