Mourning And Melancholia In Hemingway’s For Whom The Bell Tolls

2945 words - 12 pages

Mourning and Melancholia in Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls

Ernest Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940) begins with a quotation
from John Donne’s “Meditation XVII.” With this epigraph, Hemingway identifies the
source of his title and defines the connections achieved between human beings through
mourning.: Donne’s argument begins, “No man is an island,” and it concludes with an
assertion of our bond to the dead: “never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls
for thee.” Proper mourning acknowledges the losses to our self in the death of another.
Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls depicts such connections to the dead and
examines the emotional effects of incomplete mourning in terms that parallel Freud’s
own comments in “Mourning and Melancholia”(1917. Hogarth Press edition 1937).
Hemingway’s novel about mourning concludes by depicting Robert Jordan, the
American volunteer in Spain, as he prepares for his death. Jordan accepts the inevitability
of this death and he designs a ritual which expresses his commitment to his lover, Maria,
and contributes to the successful retreat of the members the guerrilla band (401-10). He
provides a last effort of participation in their struggle against fascism and affirms his
Page 2
connection to the future of Spain. In a parallel to the argument of Donne’s “Meditation,”
Jordan’s death while fighting as a volunteer in the Spanish Civil War is presented as a
loss to fascism suffered by the people of all the republican nations of the world. In a
report published in 1938 Hemingway wrote of the deaths of such volunteers of the
International Brigades, and said, “They die fighting for you” (Hem on War 293).
The depiction of Jordan’s life and death parallels the expression of mourning in
Hemingway’s eulogy of 1939, “On the American Dead in Spain” (Nelson 36-9). In both
works, Hemingway praises the volunteers who died fighting to protect republican values.
In an introduction to the “Eulogy” written after World War II, Hemingway scolded
America for its failure to support these “premature antifascists” (Nelson 26). At another
point, he explains this failure:
The majority of the career diplomats of England, France, and the United
States , are fascist, and it is they who supply the erroneous information on
which their foreign offices and state departments act (Hem on War, 293).
The ideologies of the diplomats led to the great bloodbath of the Second World War.
Hemingway helps us to mourn the deaths of Jordan and the other volunteers because he
affirms that they are, in fact, unacknowledged instances of our own losses.
Yet, many of the volunteers in the International Corps during the Spanish Civil
War felt betrayed by Hemingway’s depictions of literary and historical characters and
events. Some of the veterans criticized the lack of political ideology in the central
character, the literary self-indulgence of the love relationship between Jordan and Maria,
and the...

Find Another Essay On Mourning and Melancholia in Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls

For Whom The Bell Tolls(term-paper)

1747 words - 7 pages destruction (Frohock 167). Robert Jordan must make a final stand in For Whom the Bell Tolls if for no other reason, to save his manhood. John Wain explains: “…To make a last stand—for if defeat is accepted in Hemingway’s world, humiliation and rout are not. His fictions present moments of violence, crisis and death, yet these become occasions for a stubborn, quixotic resistance through which the human capacity for satisfying its self-defined

Ernest hemingway's For Whom the Bell Tolls

2282 words - 9 pages suicide on July 2, 1961. "A Movable Feast" was published after his death, and has been defined as a notebook he kept in the 1920's, while in Paris, France (Villapiano 1988). Although Hemingway has passed on, he was a remarkable man, and his style and notorious works live on through the writers of today.When reading an Ernest Hemingway novel, one must try very hard to focus on the joy and encouragement found in the work. For Whom the Bell Tolls is

For whom the bell tolls - summ

1198 words - 5 pages Novel Analysis: For Whom the Bell Tolls By Ernest Hemingway Setting: The story first takes place in Guadarrama Mountains, during the Spanish civil war. Robert Jordan, is an American teacher who has volunteered his services to the Loyalists in their fight against the Fascist rebels. He becomes torn between his new found love, Maria, and a life threatening mission. His love of Maria and the realization of his possible death is crucial to the

Thematic Analysis of For Whom the Bell Tolls

670 words - 3 pages Physical injury is the damage that can be seen the most clearly in For Whom the Bell Tolls and in war in general. The novel is set in May of 1937 during the Spanish Civil War in the Guadarrama mountain range in Spain. The protagonist of the novel, Robert Jordan, left his job in America to fight for the Republican side due to his strong aversion to the Fascist Party. During the course of the novel, Jordan is sickened by the violence of war, as he

Historical Analysis of For Whom The Bell Tolls

1347 words - 5 pages For Whom The Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway takes place during the Spanish Civil War, which devastated the nation of Spain from 1936 to 1939. The conflict started after an attempted coup d'état by a group of Spanish generals against the regime of the Second Spanish Republic, under the leadership of Manuel Azaña. The Nationalist coup was supported by the conservative Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right, Carlist monarchists, and the

analysis of Karl Shapiro's "For Whom the Bell Tolls"

1082 words - 4 pages the crash. These first two stanzas really create a background to the final stanza, which takes the reader through a range of emotions along with the speaker. The last stanza entirely is the perfect example of how the imagery and figurative language get these emotions across to the reader. In doing such, the theme is revealed very clearly and the reader can think to himself for whom the bell really tolls.

For Whom The Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway

2107 words - 8 pages place, technological advancements made way for the development of commercial T.V. and microwave, the quantum theory and some timeless classics were written (The Diary of Anne Frank, 1984, and Hemingway’s For Whom The Bell Tolls), and a large-scale of Americans immigrated to the Philippines – the 1940’s – came as well the emergence of these so-called hipsters. During the early part of the decade, jazz, particularly bebop, became popular. It was then

Analysis of "for whom the bell tolls" by ernest hemingway

641 words - 3 pages republic guerillas have been fighting for months. As the book continues, the theme gradually grows along with the stakes of the war. And a reader can connect with the characters in the novel because they have many things at risk including their lives in the civil war.B. The theme of the work is not specifically relevant to the teenage group. War is currently in process, but teens are not the ones on the frontlines so it can be difficult to

The Strengths of the Female Characters in "A Farewell to Arms" and "For Whom the Bell Tolls": Books written by Ernest Hemingway

1390 words - 6 pages Ernest Hemingway wrote two poignant war time love novels, A Farewell to Arms involving Catherine Barkley and Frederic Henry, and For Whom the Bell Tolls featuring Maria and Robert Jordan. Both couples fall in love, yet endure difficult situations such as blowing a bridge, running from calvary, wounded friends, and avoiding war. During this time, Catherine and Maria help transform their partners from sexually selfish males to emotionally healthy

Comparing "For Whom the Bell Tolls" and "A Farewell to Arms" which are both by Ernest Hemingway

2546 words - 10 pages Hemingway and the Struggle of Masculinity in WarMen in A Farewell to Arms and For Whom The Bell TollsThe name of Ernest Hemingway has long been associated with the idea of a strong, stubborn man who is very socially inept. In both A Farewell to Arms and For Whom the Bell Tolls, we are introduced to an extremely cold, unfeeling character and we see how they evolve from one type of man into another. Frederic Henry and Robert Jordan are both

role of women in for whome the bell tolls

1014 words - 4 pages In Hemingway’s novel, For Whom the Bell Tolls, the role of women is something one can not avoid noticing. Although only two women appear in the book, the distinction of their characters, and their influence on the situation are apparent from their introduction.      Pilar, even from the beginning is constantly referred to as being like a man. One of her main features and personality traits is that she has the

Similar Essays

Changes In For Whom The Bell Tolls

1124 words - 4 pages Changes in For Whom The Bell Tolls   The novel For Whom The Bell Tolls was primarily about Hemingway's changes through wartime. Hemingway reveals these ideas about war through the narrator's thoughts and through the interaction between the major characters. Hemingway shows that war brings about a personal change, that reveals much about man's individuality and that time is limited.   Hemingway reveals much about the

For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

1862 words - 7 pages about in connection with his grandfather and father.” (#10 p.278). The setting and connections Hemingway includes in this book exhibit Hemingway’s experiences in his own life. The novel For Whom the Bell Tolls, written by Ernest Hemingway, is a story of passionate love throughout the brutality of the Spanish Civil War. Hemingway’s simplistic language style, war imagery, mountainous setting, and theme of a heroic protagonist all contribute to

For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

663 words - 3 pages There are many themes that can be associated with the novel, For Whom the Bell Tolls. The story has love, hate, rivalry, duty, war, and several more topics of concern. However, war plays the most important role among all of the possible themes. There is war all around the characters, but it is not limited to battles or physical wars. Wars appear between ideologies, guerrilla band members, beliefs, inner emotions, and decisions. In For Whom the

For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

703 words - 3 pages The novel For Whom The Bell Tolls is based on one of Ernest Hemmingway's own experiences in the Spanish Civil War. This novel describes how irony and love gets in the way of a war and how devastating these affects can be. Irony, love and death is developed throughout this novel by a character named Robert Jordan. Jordan has been assigned a mission to blow up a bridge. On his journey he falls in love with a girl named Maria. This is where the