This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Movie Essays Comparing The Novel And Film Version Of Joy Luck Club

1844 words - 7 pages

Comparing the Novel and Film Version of Joy Luck Club


   Wayne Wang's adaptation of Amy Tan's Joy Luck Club combines literary and cinematic devices by adopting the novel's narrative techniques and strengthening them through image and sound. The adaptation exemplifies not a destruction or abuse of Amy Tan's novel, but the emergence of a new work of art, not hindered but enhanced by the strengths of its literary precursor.

             Incorporating her family's own experiences as Chinese immigrants to the United States, Amy Tan tells the story of four Chinese mothers (Suyuan Woo, An-mei Hsu, Lindo Jong, Ying-ying St. Clair) and their American-born daughters (Jing-mei "June" Woo, Rose Hsu Jordan, Waverly Jong, Lena St. Clair). Having left their homeland in the hope of escaping their traumatic past and securing better opportunities for their daughters, the mothers recount the hardships they endured in adjusting to their new homes in San Francisco's Chinatown. The largest Chinese community outside Asia, the novel's Chinatown - as in reality - blends together elements of the immigrants' ancestral homeland with the American way of life. It illustrates the life of "dualities" many Chinese Americans encounter - "two identities, two voices, two cultures, and even two names" (Huntley 73).

While Amy Tan composes her novel out of distinct narratives, she interweaves the stories by means of recurrent themes and symbols. Having immigrated after the Chinese Exclusion Act was repealed by Congress, all four women lament the alienation from their daughters who have lost rapport with their mothers and their Chinese heritage by embracing the lifestyle and attitude of the American mainstream culture. In addition to the common themes of immigration and generational conflict, Tan interrelates her stories through the themes of food, dream, and language.

            Defenders of high culture, such as Hannah Arendt, George Bluestone, and Virginia Woolf, have contended that, in their search for entertainment, adaptations often demand destructive alterations of literature (Boyum, p.7). Yet the need for entertainment does not threaten Tan's already captivating Joy Luck Club. The novel's easy-flowing, poetic language, along with the explosiveness of the American subject of immigration, account for the enthusiastic response among the international readership and for the excellent book reviews of, among others, the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, and San Francisco Chronicle.

            Though director Wayne Wang slightly alters the novel's plot, the changes occur without detriment to the novel. Like the book, the film clearly conveys the disjunction between both generations, brought about by cultural misunderstanding, language barriers, and differing values. However, the film is more optimistic in that it concludes with an explicit reconciliation between the mothers and their Americanized daughters rather than just the "fragile détente" (Huntley 44)...

Find Another Essay On Movie Essays - Comparing the Novel and Film Version of Joy Luck Club

The Joy Luck Club Essay

2435 words - 10 pages The Joy Luck Club In The Joy Luck Club, Amy Tan’s first novel, short-story-like vignettes alternate back and forth between the lives of four Chinese women in pre-1949 China and lives of their American-born daughters in California. The book is a mediation on the divided nature of this emigrant life. The novel is narrated horizontally as well as vertically; friendships and rivalries develop among the daughters as well as the mothers

The Joy Luck Club Essay

2817 words - 11 pages The Joy Luck Club The Joy Luck Club is a story about four Chinese friends and their daughters. It tells the story of the mother’s struggles in China and their acceptance in America, and the daughter’s struggles of finding themselves as Chinese-Americans. The movie starts off with a story about a swan feather, and how it was brought over with only good intentions. Then the movie goes on, the setting is at a party for June the daughter of

The Joy Luck Club

1055 words - 4 pages Marriage is a really important part of life. The novel The Joy Luck Club, written by Amy Tan, explores the concept of marriage in all of its forms. The daughters' marriages are less successful than the mothers'. The three daughters who are being mentioned in the essay are Waverly Jong, Rose Hsu Jordan and Lena St. Clair. Waverly Jong acts impatiently and does not try hard to maintain her first marriage. Rose Hsu Jordan listens to other people

The Joy Luck CLub

720 words - 3 pages The book, The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan, is a very inspirational book about four Chinese women and their four Chinese-American daughters. One of the stories in the book is called "Feathers from a Thousand Li Away", which talks about the lives of the mothers when they still lived in China during the war between China and Japan. The mothers had to make tremendous sacrifices during this time in their life. For instance, Suyuan Woo was forced

The Joy Luck Club

1089 words - 4 pages Chinese values, beliefs, and traditions have been slowly disregarded by many of the descendants of Chinese immigrants. In the book, The Joy Luck Club, written by Amy Tan, this is portrayed in mother-daughter relationships. Lindo Jong tries to teach Waverly, her daughter, about all the Chinese values, beliefs, and traditions. Waverly is affected greatly by her mother's Chinese culture and finally, at the end of the book, finally realizes what it

The Joy Luck Club

1154 words - 5 pages Home is not exactly a place but it is an understanding of the beliefs of the mothers in the novel and the different but not wrong beliefs of their daughters. The first relationship that will be discussed is the relationship between An-mei Hsu and her brief relationship with her mother in China. An-Mei first describes her mother as a ghost who later returns to her after she had been gone for nearly five years. After leaving her other

Model Minorities and The Joy Luck Club

1019 words - 5 pages promise of the American Dream, children of Chinese immigrants suffer from many problems arising from the many stereotypes and their misrepresentation as a “model minority” by native-born Americans. Amy Tan exemplifies this discrepancy between Chinese and American views on Chinese American children in The Joy Luck Club. The American Dream is not fruitful for immigrants of color because they are misnomered as model minorities, despite the

Barrio Boy and The Joy Luck Club

941 words - 4 pages In both pieces of literature; "Barrio Boy," by Ernesto Galarza and "The Joy Luck Club," by Amy Tan; the authors portray five families and their friends' struggle with language barriers, even within their own families, adapting to the customs and routines of the North American society, and how the younger family members succeeded in school, work, and relationships. In Amy Tan's book "The Joy Luck Club," the theme of the "American Dream

The Joy Luck Club and Its Analysis of Familial Relationships

1528 words - 6 pages Amy Tan wrote her novel The Joy Luck shortly after experiencing a series of events that are similar to Jing-mei, or "June" Woo's experiences through the course of the novel. The original context of the story was to examine her life and the life of her mother in order to forge as stronger bond between them. Instead, Tan's novel takes the mother/daughter dynamic and analyzes it in a way that all women, not just Chinese-Americans, can relate to.Amy

Comparing Novel and Film Version of Snow Falling on Cedars

2293 words - 9 pages Comparing Novel and Film Version of Snow Falling on Cedars It is no easy task to create a work - through writing or film - that has an impact on society. In writing, one must discuss and analyze a relevant topic that will have an impact on the readers. One must also present stunning sensory images through words in order to create a complete understanding for the reader. In filmmaking it is not much different, but there must be

The Joy Luck Club Essay

803 words - 4 pages Many times plot development is thought of as a key detail in keeping a story organized, while others would say that plot structure tends to add too much order to a piece of work and hinder the reader from exploring true creativity. A great example of these two contrasting ideas is illustrated in Amy Tan’s well-known novel “The Joy Luck Club”. Although some could argue that there is no definite plot structure portrayed at all within the book

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting Joy Luck Club Movie And Book

848 words - 3 pages The novel, The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, tells of four Chinese women came together in San Francisco to play Mah-jong and they tell stories of the past while they were in China. These four women and their families all lived in Chinatown and suffered bad childhood while they were in China. They came to America with the belief that their daughters can change their fate. This is how the Woo's, the Hsu's, the Jong's and the St Clair's met in 1949

The Joy Luck Club Essay 782 Words

782 words - 3 pages library Association Award and many more awards. This novel has been very popular ever since. After reading Amy Tan's biography and her novel "The Joy Luck Club", people were fascinated by how her characters in her novel reflex aspect of her life. Some stories were really based on her own family story. Furthermore, the relationships between mothers and daughters that Amy Tan described in the story was reflected with her personal life story about

The Joy Luck C Lub Essay

1344 words - 5 pages JOY LUCK CLUB Amy Tan Published in 1989 Chinese American Major and minor characters: The novel consists of 8 major and minor characters. The Mothers: Suyuan Woo, An-Mei Hsu, Lindo Jong, Ying-ying St.Clair. The Daughters: Jing-mei "June" Woo, Rose Hsu Jordan, Waverly Jong, Lena St. Clair.Suyuan Woo, June's mother is a very uptight woman who rarely has to say anything positive at all. She is however very observant and reflects greatly on the

The Joy Luck Club Essay 766 Words

766 words - 3 pages Essay Writing July 09,2000 The Joy Luck Club The pain of four women led to the joining of The Joy Luck Club. This movie is based on the bestseller written by Amy Tan describing the experiences of four women who emigrated from China to the United States. Each woman's story contains horrendous experiences in China and shows how those experiences affected their relationships with their American born daughters. Each woman had gone