Multicultural Literature Reflection Essay

2398 words - 10 pages

As a young teacher, I aimed to have my students read multicultural literature because I wanted to open my students’ eyes to the differences between people on this planet we share. I wanted them to see the differences as a beautiful, natural thing. However, looking back at those early years, I did little to enhance what my students were reading other than handing them a book and helping them read through it with some discussions that were not about controversial topics, only about character actions. That left my students to struggle on their own to understand the different perspectives and rich lives in which they were presented. With good intentions, I failed to get my purpose across, and I only left students with more questions. Reflecting on my teaching, and working to enhance the reading of multicultural literature, I found that I had to begin at the beginning-how I would define multicultural literature and what purpose it would serve.
What is multicultural literature? According to Mingshui Cai in his article, “Multiple Definitions of Multicultural Literature: Is the Debate Really Just “Ivory Tower” Bickering?”, the answer to this question is very complex. Cai brings to light the fact that this question is a debate with many possible answers depending on who you ask. He says, “It seems obvious that the focal point of the controversy is on how many cultures are included in multicultural literature” (pg. 1). In my own opinion, in which Cai supports, cultures that should be included are those who are not readily given a voice in society. I do not feel that multicultural literature means that all cultures are represented. I can find many, many books written from the dominant, Eurocentric society. However, there are fewer books represented from those outside of that group. When I use multicultural literature in my teachings, I will focus on groups whose voices are not represented as widely. I will be careful though, not to call this group minorities, as Harris Violet in “Continuing Dilemmas, Debates, and Delights in Multicultural Literature” states that the word minority suggests inferiority, and that is not the message I intend to send (pg. 109).
Multicultural literature is also debated as to who may write the stories. Does it need to be those who are part of the culture? Or can it be written by anyone willing to bring the story to life? For the remainder of my essay, I will focus Native American literature. In exploring the work of Native American fiction and nonfiction, this is one topic that is a hot topic. Native Americans have a rich history with many stories told from generation to generation about life and origins. They also have many stories about an unfortunate history filled with sadness inflicted upon by those with whom they were made to share the land. These are sensitive topics. These stories, as Violet says, can be written by outsiders, but it depends on their approach.
Take The Darkness Under the Water by Beth Kanell...

Find Another Essay On Multicultural Literature Reflection

Nursing: Reflection: Non-English Speaking Patients Essay

1235 words - 5 pages the nurse about other resources available to them preferably in their first language, besides an interpreter. Throughout this reflection and literature review I have often wondered why Canada, such a culturally diverse country is so limited in their ESL resources for patients. Health teaching is one of the most important concepts in health care and with Canada being so multicultural I was surprised as a nursing student I was not aware of

National Culture of Managers: Understanding People´s Value

2046 words - 9 pages themselves with them rather than the country. Personal Reflection of working in a multicultural team During the course of this module, I have been involved in and taken part in a multicultural team activity that requires us to learn and work together as a team despite our obvious cultural differences. I was able to integrate with individuals who share different cultural values and believes to myself. I was able to learn from the different

The Sun Will Come Out Amara A study of the language development of a Cambodian girl in the United States

2341 words - 9 pages -A-Double-Half-Caffe-Mocha-Frappe-Iced-Vanilla-Latte-But-Don't-Spill-It-On-The-Beamer-Novato, Calif.According to language acquisition theorist John Schumann, second language acquisition only occurs to the extent that the individual can become acculturated (1978), and from very early in her reflection we can see how language and cultural shock drastically impeded Amara's adoption into United States (and, more specifically, Novato) culture . As she

The At Home At School and Thristy Thinkers Programs

767 words - 3 pages art into helping students develop as writers. The intent of Thirsty Thinkers was to offer students an initial model of what an elaborate story looks and sounds like through oral reading of stories by teachers, to discuss the features of the story as a group, and to encourage students to develop their own individual text as a reflection of the initial story using the strategy. (Dunn & Finley, p. 36, 2010) Also, they focus on the Ask

Double Consciousness and Its Present State

984 words - 4 pages classrooms must integrate texts that examine the psychological state of double identity. Turning to Luis Valdez’ play “Zoot Suit”, Chester Himes’s protest novel If He Hollers Let Him Go, and Al Young’s prose poem “Coastal Nights and Inland Afternoons”, we encounter literature and characters with double identities that assist in navigating marginalized adolescents with their own struggles in understanding their multicultural, multiethnic, and multiracial

The Theme of Racism in To Kill a Mockingbird

2567 words - 10 pages One of the widely recognized controversies in American history is the 1930s, which housed the Great Depression and the post-civil war, the ruling of Plessy versus Ferguson and the Jim Crow Laws, and segregation. While textbooks detail the factual aspect of the time there is only one other literature that can exhibit the emotion experienced in the era. To Kill a Mockingbird is the acclaimed novel that displays the experiences of the South

Torn Between Two Cultures: Double Consciousness and the Protest Novel

2287 words - 9 pages classrooms must integrate texts that examine the psychological state of double identity. Turning to Luis Valdez’ play “Zoot Suit”, Chester Himes’s protest novel If He Hollers Let Him Go, and Al Young’s prose poem “Coastal Nights and Inland Afternoons”, we encounter literature and characters with double identities that assist in navigating marginalized adolescents with their own struggles in understanding their multicultural, multiethnic, and

A critical analysis of the work edited by Elizabeth Hatton called Understanding TEACHING: Curriculum and the social context of schooling

3801 words - 15 pages Collection.Garcia, R. (1984) Countering Classroom Discrimination. Theory into Practice, (23)2 Multicultural Education. pp. 104-109. Retrieved 24 April, 2008 from JSTOR.Gay, G & Kirkland, K (2003). Developing Cultural Critical Consciousness and Self-Reflection in Preservice Teacher Education. Theory Into Practice, 42 (3), 181-187. Retrieved May 24, 2008, from informaworld.Hatton, E. (1994). Understanding Teaching: Curriculum and the social context of

Identities and Individualism: Youth cultures

1920 words - 8 pages learning process. A single outcome will highlight one process but does not exclude other processes (QSCC2 2001:35). That is, while investigation and reflection may be emphasized in a particular phase, creating and participating may occur as a matter of course. In this module, the syllabus outcomes are met, but at the same time remain flexible enough so that the teaching program can be customised to meet the specific needs, interests and abilities of

Critical analysis of how and why controversial issues could be /has been included in your teaching, with specific reference made to curriculum req

1316 words - 6 pages objective is not to find the best solution but to find the best solution appropriate to the students. Once students have defined the nature of the controversy and supported it with their own various positions, I encourage further research to be developed at home or during the next lesson as reflection tool. The key reason for this task is to determine what is being said in class and whether there is some adequate literature that support or contrast their

Poverty, education and the curriculum

6914 words - 28 pages Home of Integrated Curriculum. Educational Leadership. 49(2). Academic Research Library. Retrieved. 20 June 2008 from ProQuest.Bieger, E. (1995). Promoting multicultural education through a literature-based approach. The Reading Teacher. 49(4); pg. 308. Retrieved 28 June 2008 from ProQuest.Bracey, G. (1999). Poverty and achievement. Phi Delta Kappan, 81(4); pg. 330. Retrieved 30 June 2008 from ProQuest.Brady, L. & Kennedy, K. (2007

Similar Essays

Rejecting The Myth Of Colorblindness In Education

1723 words - 7 pages part of any larger group or culture. As if this philosophy will enable us to bridge any gaps between races, this thought attempts to focus on how we are all the same, rather than how we differ. Teachers and administrators are required to complete coursework pertaining to multicultural education with the purpose of enabling them to better understand the students whom they teach. It is believed that when one understands the culture from which a

Closing The Achievement Gap Of Multicultural Education

1940 words - 8 pages else does and as much reason to play the game with the expectation that if they work hard they will be successful (Ferguson, 2004). Reflection on Literature Content This assignment required research into the achievement gap that still exists between majority cultures and students of culturally diverse backgrounds. The reading and videos within the assignment reflect ways to progressively approach multicultural education programs that promote a

Devlopment Of Children's Lit Essay

2277 words - 10 pages in children’s literature, a time of increased acceptance, activism, and critical thought. Contemporary children’s literature is a direct descendant from the environment of social change of the 1960s, and it is evident that the current trend of multicultural literature stems from the values of equality, integrity, and responsibility instilled by the literary works of the authors of that era. We see the trends of acceptance of others in the

Using Fairy Tales To Promote Multiculturalism

978 words - 4 pages There are many fairy tales that are well known to a majority of American youths. Most children are familiar with the basic structure of the fairy tale. They will tell you that there is usually a problem, a villain, a hero and a lesson to be learned in the end. Using the familiar platform of a fairy tale is a great way for teachers to introduce multiculturalism to the classroom. Multicultural literature can positively shape awareness of