Multiculturalism In Australia: Who Needs It?

2183 words - 9 pages

John Howard's draft for the proposed preamble to the Constitution during the 1999 referendum for a republic included this line: "The Australian nation is woven together of people from many ancestries and arrivals". Indeed, all the authors of the other drafts sought to include some mention of an Australia made up of people from different cultures and to have that enshrined in the new preamble to the Constitution. On the face of it, this would appear to be evidence for and recognition of a multicultural society. I beg to differ. The term "multiculturalism" is a farce. It hides the fact that a society could never be truly multicultural. A "multicultural" society, as we understand it, is simply one where individuals and their communities have compromised and submitted to the dominant culture. By adapting their way of life to that of the dominant culture, what we have is in fact individuals and communities that have evolved and embraced the "official" culture. In short, this society fails to be truly multicultural. Having said that, the adaptation to another culture might not be so drastic for some cultures. It could possibly involved learning to speak a new language and getting to understand a new culture. For others however, it could mean abandoning a way of life. What is in place in Australia is not the beginning of a multicultural society, it should simply be called a culturally diverse society. I will go on to show the various problems that a society made up of people from different cultures faces and that the challenges to a truly multicultural society are insurmountable by focusing mainly on the Aboriginal and muslim communities.

THE LAW AND THE ABORIGINALS
Ideological Aspects
The common law system handed down to Australia by the British has proved inadequate in dealing with a "multicultural" society. For instance, an Aborigine is "52 times more likely than a white person to be arrested and 20 times more likely to die in prison" in Western Australia. The underlying differences in the way customary indigenous law and Australian law works has caused much problems for the government. What is the solution to this? Should there be a plural system in place such that "white" men are subjected to "white" law, whereas indigenous people are subjected to their own laws? Such a system undermines the values of which the Australian system is founded on. The concept of equality before the law is a cornerstone in the western legal tradition and as such implementing a plural legal system would severely undermine the Australian legal system.

However,there is a need to consider how fair the Australian system is. There is indeed a formal equality, but does that translate to fairness? That does not seem to be the case. "Pay back spearing", considered barbaric, uncivilised and definitely illegal under Australian law, is viewed in a much different light by the Aboriginal community. The idea of imprisoning one according to Australian law is a punishment that many...

Find Another Essay On Multiculturalism in Australia: who needs it?

Climate change in australia What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?

1343 words - 5 pages Honours Programme Principal's Essay 2007Topic: What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?StudentMentor teacherHonours Programme Principal's Essay 2007What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?World wide, we are facing a severe problem known as climate change, climate change is caused by global warming, this doesn't mean that the whole earth will become hotter, in some areas the climate will become colder

Horse Racing and How it became Popular in Australia

1942 words - 8 pages Running Head: LAW PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 LAW PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 7 Horse Racing and How It Came to Popularity in AustraliaStudent's NameInstitutionHorse Racing in AustraliaThe horse race is a long-held sporting tradition in Australia that attracts both interstate and international tourists. In the early Australian colonial times, horses were used for labor, transport and recreation activities. Thus, it explains why horses have a special place

Biometric identification, can we rely on it in Australia?

827 words - 3 pages your physical identity is stolen it can't be replaced. Two years ago in Malaysia a man got his Mercedes Benz S-Class stolen. The owner of the car also had the finger print scanner (comes standard), on the car, so only he could open the car. But the robber cut off his thumb, got into the car and drove off. Australia currently has one of the largest numbers of Mercedes Benz S-Class in the Asia-Pacific region. If this trend of car-jackers increase

International Students Who Work Part Time while attending School in Australia

727 words - 3 pages International students are significantly increasing in Australia. Obviously, the main purpose of them comes to Australia is to gain a better education atmosphere. Lately, the working issues are rising among international students, especially twenty hours working per week during the semester, some of them argue, is not appropriate. Therefore, a change should be made to these regulations. However, this essay will argue that, based on the main

Those Who Don’t Believe in Magic Will Never Find It

1382 words - 6 pages to raise six children. Dahl’s mother, however, became an inspiration and a role model for him, to which he based the grandmother in his children’s story, The Witches on his mom (Roald Dahl Biography "Childhood"). Dahl’s schooling took place at St. Peter’s prep school in Weston-Super-Mare, UK. School was not one of Dahl’s favorite things to do, but it served as a purpose for him to find some of the characters in his children’s book, such as “Ms

Australia in the Vietnam War (1965-1972) “There was overwhelming support for Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War (1965 to 1972).” Why did Australia become involved in the war? What were the...

1884 words - 8 pages of these supporting parties came a string of those who did not support Australia's involvement in the Vietnam War, and in some cases went to extreme lengths to stop it, including protesting. Since 1962 when the first military advisors were sent to Vietnam, anti-war protests had been commencing and taking place. After Menzies' announcement of Australia advancing in on South Vietnam, protests became far more widespread and large-scale. The

Looking back on hindsight, was it necessary for Australia to be involved in the Vietnam War?

1046 words - 4 pages Menzies Government, it was very anti-communist decade, in the 1950s Menzies promised that he would introduce laws to stop communism coming to Australia. He then introduced the “Communist Party Dissolution Bill” this required anyone who is communists in Australia to prove his or her innocence. Many people thought that this bill was to give Australia no freedom and forcing Australians to “not believe” in something. The Bill was

Why did it take so long for the Vietnamese Veterans to be recognized in Australia?

661 words - 3 pages were the ones who mis-judged the issue in Vietnam, they were the ones who followed America into war and believed that Australia was under threat, and they were the ones who thought it was necessary to introduce conscription. The public had every right to place blame on the government, but not the men themselves.It wasn't until many years after the soldiers retuned home that a 'Welcome Home Parade' was held in Sydney in 1987. It took 15 years for

Prepare a speech discussing the unique needs of the AGED group in a community (australia) and explain how they are unique. Also suggest ways in which their needs can be satisfied

1058 words - 4 pages like.If this policy is embraced by the aged, (who should very well be concerned about their financial futures), it will solve many of other conflicts in our society. One of these is that of elder abuse. Where the elderly are forced to take care of their grandchildren while the parents go out and endeavor careers. If the aged are working, then this issue will simply not arise. Also, due to their job commitments, muggings and violence against the

Harm Minimisation Has Been An Overwhelming Success In Australia. It Would Be Equally So In Other Countries

2032 words - 8 pages "Harm minimisation has been an overwhelming success in Australia. It would be equally so in other countries". Discuss.The aim of Australian drug policy since 1985 has been harm minimisation. Harm minimisation is the overall policies and programs aimed at reducing harm associated with drug use without necessarily eliminating use (Heather et al 1993). Harm minimisation has been a hallmark of Australia's approach to drugs, giving Australia

Capital punishment needs to be abolished for it is manifestly unjust and there is disparity in sentencing

917 words - 4 pages equal justice for all, the Supreme Court declared the death penalty to be constitutional. I resolutely oppose their act, which seems to support injustice. Capital punishment needs to be abolished for it is manifestly unjust and there is disparity in sentencing.Racism is one cause of the unequal treatment. It exists in most sensitive areas of the judicial system. Racism plays an important factor of determining who will be sentenced to death and who

Similar Essays

Passion: Who Really Needs It? Essay

1447 words - 6 pages jealous and evil brother who killed her husband and was about to kill Dido if she hadn't left the kingdom. Her brother wanted the throne so he did what he felt he had to do. Dido fled the kingdom with some of her people and settled in North Africa. It is here were the city of Carthage was founded. Dido never loved another man after that, for she was still loyal to her dead husband. She went years without loving a man. So when Aeneas come, she

"Motherhood: Who Needs It?" An Evaluation

1313 words - 5 pages While motherhood is not the stereotypical home making occupation that it was in the 1970's, it is still one of the most important roles women play in this country. In "Motherhood: Who Needs It?" Betty Rollin openly expresses her negative opinion of motherhood. Throughout the essay Rollin elaborates on many reasons why motherhood is overrated in America. Rollin says that, "The notion that the maternal wish and the activity of mothering are

Who Needs A Telephone?/Discusses Instant Messaging In The Workplace And Whether It Makes The Workplace More Efficient

1209 words - 5 pages Who Needs a Telephone? What most people once considered a teenagers toy is quickly finding its way into the workplace and being used as a valuable tool on ones desktop. Instant Messengers have rapidly replaced other useful office tools such as email and telephones. It has replaced the need to walk down the hall to ask a co-worker a question and has decreased the number of boring meetings employees must sit through on a regular basis. This

"Looking For Alibrandi" By Melina Marchetta: Multiculturalism In Australia, Virginity, Summarization

1024 words - 4 pages a guy before the wedding and the best example clearly was Josie's mum who shows how things could go wrong if a woman loses her innocent before the wedding, and this big sin was fallowed by another sin that the child of Christina was a bastard. Illegitimacy is another big taboo in the Italian society which emerges out of the catholic religion. So the whole Italian community is tattling about her and Josie, it was the social ruin for both (mother