This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mutiny In The Trenches Essay

1541 words - 7 pages

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, mutiny is “A situation in which a group of people (such as sailors or soldiers) refuse to obey orders and try to take control away from the person who commands them.” During World War 1, also known as the Great War, mutiny was a problem for all sides, and the French especially. To understand the epidemic of mutiny the French faced in the Great War and especially in 1917, it is necessary to understand its causes, which lie with the failed Nivelle Assault and the differences between the ‘rear’ and the ‘front’, and to understand just what kinds of ‘mutiny’ that France faced.
The notorious failed Nivelle Assault was a large part of the motivation for those French soldiers that mutinied and refused to march. In early 1917, General Nivelle was instituted as the new commander-in-chief of the French army, and he formed a plan that he thought would break through German lines in a mere 48 hours and assure victory. “Before him […] were dazzling visions of cracking the German front wide open by a single overwhelming blitzkrieg” (Williams 6). The previous commander in chief, Joffre, had planned a more gradual and tentative attack. When Nivelle took over, he turned the plan on its head. (Williams 6) According to the Constitutional Rights Foundation, “His strategy was to soften the German defenses with artillery and then, with the aid of tanks, hurl large numbers of troops at the enemy. Nivelle predicted that a "break-through" would occur within 48 hours. This would then lead to a crushing defeat of the German Army and an end to the war” ( The assault began on April 16th. Unfortunately, the break-through Nivelle was waiting for never came, and within a week “more than 100,000 French soldiers had been killed or wounded. Incredibly, General Nivelle insisted on continuing his offensive, believing that the big ‘break-through’ would come at any time” ( The assault continued for nearly a month, until the French public, soldiers, and even government had lost faith in Nivelle, and many regiments had mutinied and refused to march into no-man’s land and onto the German’s metaphorical spears. Up until the assault, the French had “still clung to the belief that it would all be over in two or three months. […] After the disastrous April offensive, however, hopes for a quick outcome evaporated and people began to long for peace” (Becker 324). Seeing that something needed to be done to restore order, Nivelle was replaced as commander-in-chief by General Pétain, who then played a major part in bringing the mutinies to a stop with his reforms meant to placate the incensed soldiers (Williams 68).
Nivelle’s failed assault was not the only thing that motivated the poilus (French soldiers) into committing mutiny, though it was certainly the brick that broke the camel’s back. General Pétain himself summed up many contributing factors in a report published after the war:
He criticized the government for permitting...

Find Another Essay On Mutiny in the Trenches

Life in the Trenches - Original Writing

1254 words - 5 pages Life in the Trenches - Original Writing Today, we were once again heavily bombarding the German lines. It was a routine thing nowadays. Some of the more experienced soldiers didn't even notice the heavy German response bombardments that were every second posing a threat to their lives. As we heard a shell landing, we heard attentively just to make sure it wasn't coming direct on us and then, the colossal roar burst

Life in the trenches : Letter home

946 words - 4 pages Dear Michael,It has been quite some time since I have last written, the more I learn about this god forsaken war the less I want to discuss it, however I know you are sixteen now and may see it a duty to follow my footsteps. So I am taking the time to describe the theatrics of my life in the trenches and the daily occurrences. Firstly I must enquire on the home life, how is your brother and mother? Has the grieving process of father slowed, are

Willie Keith in Herman Wouk's "The Caine Mutiny "

752 words - 3 pages Willie Keith: A Life ChangedSometimes it takes an event in one's life to change a person. In Herman Wouk's The Caine Mutiny, it took the navy to change the life of Willie Keith.Before Willie joined the navy he was living the easy life. His mother came from a wealthy family so Willie had no problems financially. He never really took anything seriously. He didn't even take Princeton seriously. 'But his real career at Princeton had consisted of

The Development of the Trenches in Spring 1915

1371 words - 5 pages The Development of the Trenches in Spring 1915 The spring of 1915 saw a new frontier develop: the trenches. Trench warfare was one of the main reasons so many men died. It was a ruthless system of warfare, in which lines and lines of

Commentary on "Suicide in the Trenches" by Siegfried Sassoon

1274 words - 5 pages Siegfried Sassoon, the poet of "Suicide in the Trenches" fought in the 1st World War, and won the Military Cross for 'gallantry in action'. However in July 1917 he was sent to Craiglockhart War Hospital near Edinburgh where he met Wilfred Owen, another famous war poet. He had become destroyed by the trauma of the 1st World War, and disheartened by the generals leading it. His anti-war stance was confirmed on July 30, when his statement demanding

Life in the Trenches of World War I

1945 words - 8 pages From early in the war, in May of 1914, Blunden recalled his experience in the trenches of France. Structured with sandbag walls, the Old British Line in which the men were stationed was only a frail comfort, as the trenches were often only one row deep with no additional protection against debris caused by artillery shells. Communication between the between the front line and the Old British Line was provided some covered by through the Cover

Communication Barriers in Leadership: Tales from the Trenches

2018 words - 9 pages have tried to share the feedback from our employees with my manager in a diplomatic manner, but she always becomes defensive. She accuses me of undermining her as a manager and the department for soliciting employee feedback even though it is part of my job. She creates a culture of distrust that eliminates my drive to add value. A command-and-control approach to leading has no value and is a paralysis to any organization or department. A true

What were the the conditions of trenches in Gallipoli during WW2?

408 words - 2 pages them sick in many cases. Aside from lack of vitamins the monotonous nature of the food didn't give the soldiers much to look forward to.Water was seldom fresh at Gallipoli mostly brought in kerosene tins and put in big tanks. This caused diseases like typhoid to be a commonality at the trenches. But more importantly the lack of water affected the troops at Gallipoli. There was insufficient amount given to the troops made dehydration a big effector

The Disillusionment from Romantic Warfare in the Trenches of World War I

952 words - 4 pages from a serious case of shell shock: “In all my dreams, before my helpless sight/ He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning” (Owen). Despite his efforts to depict the terrifying event to the reader, Owen knows that no one can truly understand the horror of the trenches, of war, unless they have experienced it at firsthand. This is a direct reference to all those who have never fought in an actual battle that/how they should not talk proudly of

Break of Day in the Trenches a Poem by Isaac Rosenberg

965 words - 4 pages Why I chose this poem: I chose Break of day in the trenches because in the title and the first few lines of the poem, it paints a mental image of the beginning of another horrible day at war. The poet compares the war from a seemingly unimportant rat’s perspective. Another reason I chose this poem was that upon reading a biography of the poet, I realised that he had lived in South Africa for nearly two years. Biography of Isaac Rosenberg

Is It True To Say That The Soldiers In The Trenches Of WWI Experienced Boredom, Brutality and Comradeship?

2584 words - 10 pages advanced were the only times he encountered the enemy.Each day began and ended with a 'stand to' in case the enemy decided to initiate a dusk or dawn attack. After this the day was divided into watches, and while not on duty soldiers spent time sleeping and doing 'fatigues' - digging and repairing trenches and fetching rations and stores. Night was when most work was done - barbed wire was repaired and injured soldiers were rescued safely from No

Similar Essays

War In The Trenches Essay

3263 words - 13 pages War in the Trenches The war was fought by men on foot, in a flat open country that gave no shelter from enemy fire. Facing armies dug trences as fortifications from which to defend their position or attack the enemy. When the Germans turned onto the Allies, they dug trenches on the River Aisne, as a line of defence. By mid-October, two lines of trenches faced each other from the Swiss border to the Channel coast

Description Of Life In The Trenches

872 words - 3 pages Description of Life in the Trenches You might be thinking that life in trenches was non-stop death, violence, and pain. But have you ever thought about why? Or what do soldiers do in their trenches when they're not fighting or dying? Do you always trust sources when you read them? Do you always believe what they say on television documentaries? How can you without a source of evidence? I am going to be telling you what

Life And Suffering In The Trenches

2914 words - 12 pages his troops must at all costs maintain the parts of France and Belgium that they had overtaken, ordered his men to dig in and form defensive trench lines (Ellis 10). The Allies could not fracture the enemies lines and were forced to create trenches of their own (Ellis 10). This was only the beginning of trench warfare. A war of movement had quickly come to a standstill on the Western Front. A massive trench line, 475 miles long, swiftly

Suicide In The Trenches Poetry Analysis

1055 words - 5 pages A lighthearted, immature, jovial boy gets thrown into the terrors of war. In the poem “Suicide in the Trenches”, the mood goes from spring to winter, happy to depressed, this solider boy’s life was changed in the war. The solider boy was transformed by the trenches, just like millions of other men who had to deal with these same conditions. Erich Remarque’s novel, All Quiet on the Western Front, echoes many aspects and themes this poem holds