This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mutual Assured Destruction And The Ethical Dilemmas That Come With It.

1285 words - 5 pages

Mutual assured destruction or MAD is the doctrine of a situation in which any use of nuclear weapons by either of two opposing sides would result in the destruction of both the attacker and the defender. The doctrine assumes that each side has enough weaponry to destroy the other side and that either side, if attacked for any reason by the other, would retaliate with equal or greater force. The expected result is that the battle would escalate to the point where each side brought about the other total and assured destruction and potentially, those of allies as well. I would like to consider some of the moral questions surrounding mutual assured destruction. I shall try to present the moral dilemmas that arise, although it would be useless to try to conceal my own response to these dilemmas. Nuclear weapons are so uniquely powerful and destructive that the moral issues presented by them must be on the same vast scale.
MAD is a product of the 1950's US doctrine of massive retaliation, and despite attempts to redefine it in contemporary terms like flexible response and nuclear deterrence, it has remained the central theme of American defense planning for well over three decades. But, MAD was developed during a time of unreliable missile technology and was based on a mortal fear of Communism, by ignorance of unknown enemy that lurked behind the iron curtain. Times have changed. The primary application of this doctrine occurred during the cold war which was between the 1950's and 1990's between the United States and the Soviet Union. MAD was seen as a tool that helped to prevent any direct full-scale conflicts between the two nations while they engaged in smaller proxy wars around the world. The credibility of the threat being critical to such assurance, each side has to invest substantial capital in weapons even those not intended for use. Basically the ideology was that if I have nuclear weapons and you have nuclear weapons I will not use them against you and you will not use them against me for fear of retaliation with the same weapons leading to both of us being destroyed. This was appropriately called MAD (Mutual Assured Destruction) and seemed to offer a lot of people comfort in its apparent stability. It depended on the willingness to use nuclear weapons against another state. If we remove the possibility of using nuclear weapons first (which the Western Allies did not, by the way, unequivocally guarantee) then the moral issues boil down to two: first, is it morally justified to destroy the society of another country in retaliation for the destruction of one's own? Second, is it morally justifiable to threaten to do so?
The answer to question one must clearly be no. If my country has been devastated by a nuclear attack then deterrence has failed and there is no point in doing the same to the attacking country and humanity would demand that I simply accept defeat. The point is not much discussed by supporters of nuclear deterrence...

Find Another Essay On Mutual assured destruction and the ethical dilemmas that come with it.

"The Idea Of Mutually Assured Destruction As A Reason For Superpowers Not To Attack Each Other"

655 words - 3 pages scene, because America felt that it needed to respond to these actions taken, in order to protect their safety. These sites were not permanent and did not remain for very long, but were ideal for eliminating lengthy response times due to their proximity. The other method of eliminating response time was by way of detection. With the creation of radar and satellites, missiles could be detected before they reached their targets. This allowed for a

Safe Tanning & the benefits that come from it

1449 words - 6 pages Everyone knows the risks that come with ultra violet light exposure and tanning, but does anyone really know the benefits? Only about a decade ago people were going to the beaches to get burnt. They thought it was the means of a good tan. Today however people now know the risks associated with getting burnt though most do not understand the benefits that sunlight can offer. Tanning salons are teaching the right way to use the ultra violet rays

Reality Television and The destruction It Brings

961 words - 4 pages conflict and excitement. When you place humans in a remote or secluded space with opposing and allying teams in effect, more than likely they will have outbursts or begin to fight for their team. This, for some reason, gives our minds a source of entertainment. It is destructive to our learning processes because it gives us a false sense of reality. Reality shows install certain thoughts about the outside world that usually are not achievable

It is through the understanding of other people and our relationships with them that we come to understand ourselves and our lives. Discuss. "Tirra Lirra By the River" by Jessica Anderson

1944 words - 8 pages , motifs, structure, allusion, juxtaposition, tone and symbolism effectively enhance the exploration of Nora's mind and relationships. The depth and intricacy of the language carefully weave a tapestry of Nora's life, skillfully fabricating the notion that it is through the understanding of other people and our relationships with them that we come to understand ourselves and our lives.

The Feminist Model to Solving Ethical Dilemmas

963 words - 4 pages a choice between equally undesirable alternatives that in turn involve moral values that appear to have equal validity (Banks, 2006). When dealing with such dilemmas it is important to refer to one of the ethical decision-making framework. These frameworks provide step-by-step guidance to help assist practitioners through complex decisions. There are four key models to refer to; The feminist and reflective model, The inclusive model, The ethical

Ethical Dilemmas in the Nursing Field

628 words - 3 pages these dilemmas to address. 1. Empirical Knowledge vs. Personal Beliefs: Empirical knowledge is the type of knowledge that includes empirical research, scientific enquiry, reductionism and positivism, it is often viewed as ‘true’ or ‘valid’ knowledge that can be theoretically explained by scientific traditional ideas like psychology, pharmacology, sociology and biology or by rigorous empirical testing which include knowledge from books, journals and

Ethical Dilemmas : Examples During the Holocaust

1040 words - 5 pages inhumane death that the Nazis were going to deliver upon them (Nevins). This medical student decided to fight back against what the Nazi Party had in store for them. He killed many people to protect them, regardles of the consequences that would later be in store. This was an ethical dilemma with a difficult decision to make, let the Jews be tortured, starved, or shot by the Nazis or end their suffering and risk ones own death. It was a generosity to

"Normative ethical subjectivism" and the four arguments aganist it with examples

1421 words - 6 pages Dictionary)." In the normative ethical subjectivism argument tolerance is good thus making it good for others to respect the actions and beliefs of that other people. The tolerance argument is still not a persuasive argument for normative ethical subjectivism. The problem with tolerance argument is that we all have to be tolerance of people's opinions if they truly believe in them, making their opinion morally right. If a person truly believes in

Iliad’s dilemmas with the definition Piety

1051 words - 5 pages scatter it into the salt sea and pile again the beach deep under the sands and cover it; so let the great wall of the Achaians go down to destruction (p. 56). This quote shows that Zeus is giving Poseidon permission to tear down the wall once the war is finish since the Achaians did not make any sacrifice. This example proves that there is a problem with the chosen definition of piety because it is revealed that the Achaians did not please Zeus

Iliad’s dilemmas with the definition of Piety

1306 words - 6 pages In the Inferno, Dante presented a remarkable view of hell by taking a journey through the nine circles of it with his guide Virgil. Throughout this journey, they met several souls and people who are in charge of each circles of hell. One person in particular that they met throughout the journey was Minos, who is the person that decides which souls should be sent for torment. Upon their encounter, Minos warns Dante to "watch where you go/once you

The Ethical Dilemmas of Collecting Data and the Consequential Revision of Commodities, Culture and the Politics of Representations Definitions

1969 words - 8 pages between companies. However, this has put forward the following primary ethical dilemmas surrounding human rights: the right to informed consent and the right to personal data. In addition to the creation of ethical dilemmas, the collection of human data has brought about a need for a revision of definitions. Commodities are known as a raw material or primary agricultural product that can be bought and sold. Therefore, as a result of human data as an

Similar Essays

Janus Capital Group: History Of The Company, What Are The Ethical Dilemmas That The Management Has Faced?

2805 words - 11 pages JNS (' mission statement has always been to "get investors where they want to go." Tom Bailey began the company with this one simple idea and was able to impart oversized returns for his shareholders over the long run. But investors may not be willing to believe that Janus has their best interests in mind because of some recent scandals that have rocked the mutual fund industry. This once respected fund company has come under

The Moral And Ethical Dilemmas Of Anthropology

1146 words - 5 pages the Code of Ethics of the American Anthropological Association (AAA) is found in Part III, Section A, Number 1: “Anthropological researchers have primary ethical obligations to the people, species, and materials they study and to the people with whom they work.” (American Anthropological Association, 2009) This main principle helps to guide social scientists through a maze of ethical dilemmas such as if and how the research itself may harm or

Ethical Dilemmas And Normative Theories Essay

1618 words - 7 pages ). Ethical dilemmas such as financial management, corporate social management, corporate governance, shareholder relations, insider trading, and discrimination are examined by business ethics. Ethical dilemmas arise in situations where there is no right or wrong answers, usually a complex moral issue that needs to be resolved, a choice needs to be made between ‘right’ and ‘right’; choosing the best of the worst. It is not normally easy to

Ethical Dilemmas In The Workplace Essay

660 words - 3 pages In Module 1, Kindred Todd faced quite a few ethical dilemmas that included her values and technical ineptness. The first predicament was tested her personal morals and ethics. According to, Cumming and Worley, OD practitioners are dealing more and more with value conflicts with powerful outside groups (Cummings & Worley, 2008). Kindred was immediately faced with the issue of knowing what was ethically correct but being told the unethical