This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

My Friend Hamilton Who I Shot

6594 words - 26 pages

A Historiographical Discussion of the Duel Between Aaron Burr and
The duel between Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton holds a significant relevance in
American history and should be examined within the context of early American culture and
politics. The recent historiography of the incident provides us with a complex, evolving web of
conflicting interpretations. Since the day of this tragic duel, contemporaries and historians have
puzzled over why these two prominent American statesmen confronted each other on the Plains
of Weehawken. What circumstances or events could have motivated two of the most brilliant
political minds in America to endanger their lives and reputations by taking aim at each other on
that dismal day?
The recent historiography of the event can be divided into two schools which I shall
denote as the “contextual” school and the “psycho-historical” school. These differing “schools”
demonstrate the complexity of history and the extent to which a variety of factors, including bias
and changing frames of reference can influence interpretive study and conclusions. It is the
object of this discussion, therefore, to examine the heretofore mentioned interpretations, and to
critically analyze the differing ideas concerning the Burr-Hamilton duel.
The most succinct version of the event, as told by Joseph J. Ellis reads
On the morning of July 11, 1804, Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton were rowed across the
Hudson River in separate boats to a secluded spot near Weehawken, New Jersey. There, in
accord with the customs of the code duello, they exchanged pistol shots at ten paces. Hamilton
was struck on his right side and died the following day. Though unhurt, Burr found that his

reputation suffered an equally fatal wound. In this, the most famous duel in American history,
both participants were casualties.1
Almost every American is familiar with this most famous—and deadly—of American
duels. Hamilton was celebrated and hailed as a martyr, and Burr was labeled a murderer and
went on to undertake many strange adventures in the American west, eventually tried for treason
for his purported conspiratorial intentions. Before engaging further in this discussion, one must
first differentiate between what I have denoted as “contextual” history and “psycho-historical”
history. I contend that “contextual” theses are steeped in disciplined research based on
contemporary and secondary sources. Anthony Brundage wrote that “psycho-historical”
arguments “attempt to apply to historical study the methods and insights developed by Sigmund
Freud and other psychological theorists during the past hundred years or so.”2 This idea of
highlighting and differentiating between “contextual” and “psycho-historical” studies provides
this discussion with a centrality that will allow a further understanding the forthcoming analysis.
J. Lee and Conalee Levine-Schneidman argued “it was not Burr who was...

Find Another Essay On My Friend Hamilton -Who I shot

Story I did for my assignment, 900 words, and is about a guy who plays Rugby and goes to War, gets a girl and lives on

895 words - 4 pages brother 3 yrs older then him, and his mum wasn?t a very happy women, she always pressured him and forced him to do things which made Jonobi kind of depressed. But his dad, although they didn?t have a great relationship, his dad supported him and took care of him.Jonobi was a person who kept to himself and was a lonely person, he thought a lot about things due to the fact that he spend a lot of time alone, he always wondered why he was alive and who

The Consequences of the Burr and Hamiton Duel

975 words - 4 pages Burr”. He wrote in the letter that he was “strongly opposed the practice of dueling’ for both religious and practical reasons. He then continued stating “I have resolved, if our interview is conducted in the usual manner, and it pleases God to give me the opportunity, to reserve and throw away my first fire, and I have thoughts even of reserving my second fire.” While Dr. Hosack, the doctor called to help Hamilton after being shot, was told by

Biography of Alexander Hamilton

2376 words - 10 pages many people and once the news came out that young Alexander Hamilton, at the age of fifteen, wrote the article a group of readers, as well as family and friends, decided to sponsor his schooling. Hamilton thought of the idea of the article from a sermon he heard from a Presbyterian minister that compelled him. It is evident from a letter he wrote, which was addressed to his friend, about how he wanted to increase his chances to become something

Make a Wave

924 words - 4 pages severing Bethany’s arm just past the shoulder” (Bender and Sterrett 194). “That’s all it took: a split second. I felt a lot of pressure and a couple of lightning-fast tugs. I couldn’t make out any details, but I knew that the huge jaws of a fifteen-foot tiger shark covered the top of my board and my left arm” (B. Hamilton 15). Bethany and her friend were so far away from the shore “a quarter of a mile” that it took them about fifteen minutes to get

Alexander Hamilton

1392 words - 6 pages . “Alexander Hamilton” is an incredible biography that I, as a reader, would highly recommend. Readers are captivated through every page of incredibly well written history. My only critique is that readers are only given brief descriptions of Hamilton’s appearance, making it hard for the book to play like a film in your mind. Though, when taken into consideration that these events were written over two hundred years after Hamilton lived, Chernow does

Alexander Hamilton's Contributions

1176 words - 5 pages to Hamilton’s plan for the United States and the Constitution of the United States. However, I believe John Steele did a better job with his Yes argument. He made it clear that Hamilton still has an effect on how the United States Constitution and Economy is set up. He has the correct mindset in my opinion, no matter how much the events after Hamilton affected the economy it is still the same blue print Hamilton created. Due to this I believe Appleby supported her argument much better than Steele did, however I believe steele had a more sensible argument.

The Other Half

2451 words - 10 pages coming straight towards him. In that moment, my heart was filled entirely with anger, The man that mentored me, the man that brought me up through the ranks was trying to kill us. I begun paying no attention to either of our bullets, but to the single shell, now about to hit Niall. The shot impacted and some marble dust kicked up. My heart stopped as I saw Niall going down. I sprinted towards Niall, shooting a glance back at the Captain, who was

Alexander Hamilton: Triumph and Tragedies

3954 words - 16 pages it wasn’t the men he killed, but the chances he took in daring other men to kill him that mattered. He had a romantic view on war, one soldier’s written account of Hamilton in the battle for Princeton on January 6, 1776 that wrote “I saw mere boy, with small, delicate and slender frame, cocked hat pulled down upon his eyes… [who] marched behind his cannon, patting it every now and then as if it were a pet horse or plaything.” Hamilton, not

Alexander Hamilton

827 words - 3 pages murder by food poisoning. Hey! Some people just aren't as talented in the kitchen as others. Secondly, if I was going to make my mom cook, I would ask her to cook some Spanish food simply because a little cultural diffusion never hurt nobody. That, and because I like Spanish food. Besides, Hamilton is a lawyer; he would eat anything that is home cooked. 11. What exactly did you enjoy or not about this biography? 	I liked the vocabulary and

Alexander Hamilton Biography-2 pages paragraphs including -introduction -early life -before the Revolution and during the revolution -during and after the revolution -later years

1168 words - 5 pages of having a strong central government, and had said many of the bad points of the Articles of Confederation that had a weak government. Without Hamilton's help in the government, America would go astray.Alexander Hamilton was born on January 11, 1757 on the West Indian island of Nevis. He was the illegitimate son of James Hamilton, a Scottish merchant, and Rachel Faucett Lavien. He had one brother named James who was two years older than


2713 words - 11 pages . In the 1791 Senate race, Aaron Burr was running against Phillip Schuyler, who happened to be Hamilton’s father-in law. Schuyler was a Federalist, whereas Burr was a Republican. Hamilton and Washington wanted Schuyler to win because they had his support. Because of Hamilton’s political and familial relationship with Schuyler, his policies would have most likely been supported. Unfortunately for the Federalists, Burr did win and he

Similar Essays

My Friend Committed Suicide, I Did Not

1442 words - 6 pages My Friend Committed Suicide, I Did Not During Junior High I had many absolutely dire problems that were constantly on my mind. My out-of-date wardrobe continuously embarrassed me. My hair would not acquiesce to any attempted hairstyle. My parents didn't understand me, my teachers were all picking on me, and nobody really liked me for me. These beliefs were all false, of course. At the time, it never occurred to me that all my concerns and

How My Childhood Affected Who I Am Today

582 words - 2 pages thoughts about a person when considering them as a friend. This strong sense of trust could also put me into danger in the future, with strangers or while I am alone.         All in all, I believe my circumstances as a child have helped form my identity today. I would not change who I am, and do not regret growing up where I did. I formed dependable relationships that I will have throughout life and memories that will never perish.

Who Else Can I Blame For My Sickness

1119 words - 5 pages A discussion that has been a big topic of debate is whether tobacco companies should be liable for smoking related illnesses and deaths. Let us take a look back at the history of this and see why the responsibility needs to fall on the person who partakes in tobacco use. Let me first make you aware of my opinion on tobacco use. I am totally against the use of tobacco but with that being said I don’t believe it is their responsibility. I just

“My Way Of Life Has Fallen Into The Sear…And That Which Should Accompany Old Age, As Honour, Love, Troop Of Friends, I Must Not Look To Have…”It Is Not Fate But Macbeth Who Is Responsible For His...

1030 words - 4 pages Ajay Mohanraj"My way of life has fallen into the sear…and that which should accompany old age, as honour, love, troop of friends, I must not look to have…"It is not fate but Macbeth who is responsible for his demise. To what extent do you agree?Set to the backdrop of medieval Scotland, William Shakespeare's "Macbeth" portrays how the protagonist Macbeth is responsible for his own destiny through the deeds he commits and that fate