My Lai Essay

792 words - 3 pages

In the case against William Calley it is said that he ordered his troops to kill civilians at a place in Vietnam called My Lai or was he following orders from his superior Captain Earnest Medina. At the end of the trial after hearing all the evidence against and for Calley I decided that he was not guilty of what they said that he had done. I think that Calley is not guilty of premeditated murder because in war you pretty much premeditate everything except when you are the one being attacked. I guess the question then goes who gave the premeditated order to kill all the people in the town of My Lai, Calley or Medina.

        It was said that 5 out of the 105 troops said that it was Medina that gave the order to kill everyone in the village and the prosecution used those numbers to show that very few heard it come from him, but they never said all of the 105 were there when he gave whatever order he gave so maybe good 20 to 80 were not around to here the order and just heard what Calley told them to do. Killing was also encouraged because a higher body count was better. It was also said that Calley did not always follow the orders that were given to him and the prosecution tried to use that Calley had trouble with authority and because of this he was not that good of a person or something like that.

        The prosecution tried to make Calley look like an evil guy by telling his men to kill all the civilians that they had rounded up in My Lai and a few followed his orders and then tried to get sympathy from us by saying that they cried or by acting disturbed during or after they said that. It was also said that Calley killed a monk and a little kid an that is bad but he was not on trial for killing just those two people which was a bad event and a rash thing for him to have done at the time but the kid could have had bombs on him but a very slim chance at that and after seeing a lot of death during his time their I'm pretty sure he was emotionally messed up...

Find Another Essay On My Lai

My Lai Massacre Essay

708 words - 3 pages My Lai Massacre "My Lai was no accident. It was pure, premeditated murder". The memory of this tragic day is forever etched in the memories of many Vietnamese. The area in which the massacre took place was known as the Quang Ngai Province in the Song My village. This area was many times the scene for the worst fighting to take place between the U.S. and the National Liberation Front. The hamlet of My Lai was said to be the strongest of the NLF

My Lai Massacre Essay

1575 words - 6 pages History EssayHow do you explain what happened at My Lai? What can be done to prevent such tragedies from happening again? What does My Lai teach us about the nature of evil? Was Calley evil, or was he a more-or-less "normal person in abnormal circumstances"? Would Calley have acted differently had he received more training in the rules of warfare? Do all soldiers have this capacity for violence?My Lai is a small village in the Mid-west of

My Lai the Great Massacre

919 words - 4 pages My Lai the Great Massacre The Olson and Roberts book, My Lai is based upon the March 18, 1968, assault on My Lai. By examining the material, an explanation of why this massacre occurred is drawn. The main factors that lead to the My Lai assault were difficulty engaging with the enemy and the problem of distinguishing between the enemy soldiers and civilians, which both led to rage and frustration among soldiers and a misinterpretation of

My lai: the event, the trial,

1535 words - 6 pages colleges, and sometimes towns across the country. Then one day, as the media was delivering their daily recurrences of the horror that was Vietnam, reports of a massacre in a village designated as My Lai 4 came up. Following these reports and some "thorough" investigation came the indictment of Lt. William Calley, the man slated responsible for the event, along with that indictment came charges of murder. The trial and crime helped bring the

My Lai: The Event, the Trial,

1535 words - 6 pages colleges, and sometimes towns across the country. Then one day, as the media was delivering their daily recurrences of the horror that was Vietnam, reports of a massacre in a village designated as My Lai 4 came up. Following these reports and some "thorough" investigation came the indictment of Lt. William Calley, the man slated responsible for the event, along with that indictment came charges of murder. The trial and crime helped bring the

The massacre at My Lai is one of the many

927 words - 4 pages The massacre at My Lai is one of the many results of the negative psychological effects on the men that fought in the Vietnam War. Tim O’Brien’s interpretation of Vietnam in The Things They Carried paints a vivid picture about the horrors of war, how someone could snap, and how easy it is for someone to lose their principles. My Lai is representative of the extreme situations that occurred in war. On March

The My Lai Massacure could have been avoided.

755 words - 3 pages Lieutenant William L. Calley Jr. was guilty in the My Lai killings. Imagine, a family sitting on their front porch peacefully, making breakfast for their themselves. They see hundreds of people rushing at them, pointing guns at their heads. Firing, killing for no reason, just a assumption. Calley ordered his men to kill hundreds of innocent civilians before he knew anything about them. He broke the rules of war killing them. He used his men in

A three page paper covering the massacre at My Lai during the Vietnam war. (Bibliography included)

724 words - 3 pages Company C or Charlie Company, essentially went mad and performed what some have called Nazi acts. It was an incredibly horrible event and was, by far, the worst reality of the Vietnam War.On March 16, 1968 the men of Charlie Company, 11th Brigade, entered the village of My Lai. It wasn't much longer before the killings began. When news of the carnage emerged, it sent tremors through the chain of command in the military, the US political institution

MY LAI MASSACRE AS A RESULT OF OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY. Relates to stanly milgrams experiments and how authority play a part in genocide killings.

1215 words - 5 pages MY LAI MASSACRE AS A RESULT OF OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY The Vietnam controversy made many people feel at distress. It was never considered a "war," although that is exactly what it was. The My Lai Massacre in Vietnam was one of the many atrocities of that war. There is an unquestionable connection between Milgram's "Obedience to Authority" and the My Lai Massacre. According to Kelman & Hamilton, "Unquestioning obedience has been the cause of such

Visitng the Hsi Lai Buddhist Temple.

670 words - 3 pages placed in a particular way. The number of people that visit this temple was countless and its also amazing how tranquil this heavenly temple is even with a room full of people. The Hsi Lai Temple, in my point of view, gave me a glimpse of what they call heaven. The tranquility of this temple brought me confidence, joy and gave me hope for better things in my life.

"Prognosticating the doom of the future" is base on the issues that the author of Salt Fish Girl, Larissa Lai tries to stress out.

919 words - 4 pages Larissa Lai, born in California in 1967 is the author of this astonishing activist fiction- Salt Fish Girl, which brings out issues of guerilla tactics, worker exploitation, sensual relationships, and feminist politics. Although, these issues are happening throughout the world nowadays, they are not the ones that make this novel a powerful intimation. In this novel, the core conflicts are the morals and ethics of cloning and genetic

Similar Essays

My Lai Essay

504 words - 2 pages My Lai is a controversial event in history because there are many different views of what happened. The mission started when captain Ernest Medina instructed Lieutenant William Calley to destroy the village of My Lai. Medina told the 11th Brigade, Charlie Company, that any genuine villagers would have left their homes to go to market. Therefore, Medina and Calley instructed the brigade to kill all of the remaining villagers including the elderly

My Lai Essay

1575 words - 6 pages History EssayHow do you explain what happened at My Lai? What can be done to prevent such tragedies from happening again? What does My Lai teach us about the nature of evil? Was Calley evil, or was he a more-or-less "normal person in abnormal circumstances"? Would Calley have acted differently had he received more training in the rules of warfare? Do all soldiers have this capacity for violence?My Lai is a small village in the Mid-west of

My Lai Massacre. Essay

1057 words - 4 pages . William Calley, stormed into the hamlet, and four hours later more than 500 civilians, mostly unarmed women, children, babies and elderly people, were dead. The objective of the U.S. military mission was clear: search and destroy the My Lai hamlet. What wasn't clear was what should be done with any civilians who might be encountered along the way. Charlie Company had not encountered even one enemy soldier, only three weapons were confiscated from the

The My Lai Massacre Essay

1045 words - 4 pages hard-nosed character of its own. It was getting bloodier," said authors Michael Bilton and Kevin Sim in their book Four Hours In My Lai. Seymour Hersh wrote that by March of 1968, "many in the company had given in to an easy pattern of violence." Soldiers systematically beat unarmed civilians. Some civilians were murdered. Whole villages were burned. Wells were poisoned. Rapes were common. On March 16, 1968, Captain Ernest Medina ordered Charlie