Nafta And Maquiladoras Essay

2310 words - 9 pages

NAFTA and Maquiladoras

The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which became effective on January 1, 1994, is a comprehensive, rules-based agreement designed to promote “free-trade” among the United States, Mexico and Canada (NAFTA Forum,1998). Although the agreement was made between three countries, it was largely the inclusion of Mexico around which most of the oppositional debate was centered (Mayer, 1998). Canada is a modern, developed nation very similar in culture and economy to the United States. Mexico, however, is considered a developing nation with an economy much weaker than the United States. Still, a prior trade agreement did exist between the United States and Mexico. Therefore, in order to properly evaluate NAFTA, we must also take into account that prior trade agreement, the Border Industrialization Program (BIP) of 1965. The increase in maquiladoras on the U.S.-Mexico border, and its inherent problems, is a direct result of the BIP (Blank & Haar, 1998). The overall impact of the BIP on the U.S.-Mexico border and the maquiladora industry has been manifold, resulting in increases in maquiladoras, border population, environmental pollution and human social and health concerns. It is also important to recognize that prior to ratification of NAFTA, the Clinton Administration demanded, under pressure by environmental and labor groups, the attachment of two side agreements concerning labor and the environment. Although still too early to tell, NAFTA appears to be amending some of the inherent problems which exist along the U.S.-Mexico border.

Opposition to NAFTA must be placed in some historical context. During the 1980’s many American manufacturing jobs were being exported to Mexican maquiladoras. American labor groups originally protested only on the grounds of job loss, but eventually shifted their focus on the plight of the Mexican worker and the environmental degradation around maquiladora’s (Mayer, 1998). In 1989, the AFL-CIO produced a film about toxic dumping at a Mexican maquiladora, and even worked with ABC’s “20/20” program and NBC’s “Dateline” on stories about toxic hazards in Mexican maquiladoras. In 1989, the AFL-CIO joined environmental and citizen rights groups such as The Border Ecology Project and the Quaker American Friends Service Committee in forming the Coalition for Justice in the Maquiladoras. Environmental and human rights abuses were a means for the American public to focus on the loss of American jobs. As one AFL-CIO official stated, regarding the American public, “Nobody cared about a worker losing his job in Illinois. They were much more sensitive to toxic dumping in Mexico” (Mayer, 1998). Environmental opponents saw the Maquiladora Program as being extremely harmful to the environment, and publicized instances of American companies attempting to take advantage of Mexico’s poor environmental record. Once NAFTA became an important political objective, labor and...

Find Another Essay On NAFTA and Maquiladoras

Sweat Shops in Mexico Essay

1131 words - 5 pages Imagine working tirelessly in a factory all day with the constant pressure of trying to support your family. This is the reality for millions of Mexican workers employed in maquiladoras. Maquiladoras are factories of foreign companies, mostly American, that use Mexican natives to build their products. The problem is many believe work for these improvised people is a good thing. However, the conditions of the factories are dangerous and the many

The North American Free Trade Agreement

3714 words - 15 pages constant pressure from the Bush Administration. I will outline several primary concerns about NAFTA, looking at the effects and circumstances surrounding the development of this deal. In June 1990, president Salinas of Mexico met with president George Bush to discuss a proposal to expand Mexico's maquiladoras program (named for the Maquiladoras Act of 1972: a law designed to exempt international companies from certain environmental and labor


986 words - 4 pages , illegal immigration, and loss of national control. When the borders opened for business many American and Canadian companies packed up and moved into Mexico to cut their over-head costs considerably. There is a fear of deindustrialization between the two established countries. But in 2001, NAFTA required the removal of maquiladoras, companies on the border of Mexico and The United States, tariff-free status. This led to the relocation of


1083 words - 4 pages Between the Canada, Mexico, and a Hard PlaceUnderstanding NAFTA and its EffectsTony BerensHonors English 10, Hour 2Kathryn TabkeMarch 21, 2008Introduction:The year of 1994 gave birth to a big screen legend, the Lion King, announced the election of George W. Bush as the governor of Texas, and saw a cancellation of the World Series. In the same year, the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was put into effect, an event in the close past

Has the North American Free Trade Agreement Hurt the American Economy?

1005 words - 4 pages In summarizing theses two opposing views on this issue, it will be difficult if not impossible to keep my blue-collar sensibilities from coloring my views on this contentious debate. That being said, I feel that whatever damages that may have occurred to the U.S. economy primarily in the manufacturing segment due to NAFTA have been largely overshadowed by more recent and more serious threats from other quarters, namely from China’s export

Dora’s Dirty Secrets of the Global Industry

1537 words - 6 pages . There have been a burst of these maquiladoras(factories) popping up all over in less industrialized countries because it’s cheaper to mass produce these toys/products at a fraction of the price after NAFTA was signed in 1992. In many instances inequality is visible in these young women’s lives from when they begin to work as teenagers in what appears to be a booming industry of the maquiladoras(factories). It also gives an excellent view of

The Use of Biopower

1572 words - 7 pages power. Maquiladora workers suffer from slow death as a result of the rules that NAFTA (North Atlantic Trade Agreement) have set up. NAFTA is a trade agreement that was supposed to help regulate free trade and improve the economies of Mexico, Canada and the United States. Instead, it only benefits America while ruining the economy of Mexico. The NAFTA agreement allows American corporations to build Maquiladoras, “A factory in Mexico by run by

Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Free Trade Area of the Americas

1172 words - 5 pages Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Free Trade Area of the Americas In recent years, representatives from 34 countries have been working to expand the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) to Central America, South America and the Caribbean. The Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) is another example of the free-market fundamentalism that has created a global race-to-the-bottom that threatens the environment, families' livelihoods, human


1986 words - 8 pages , companies from other countries such as Korea, Japan, and the United States (Fig.2) embark to build their assembly plants and flourish on the low labor rates. "Maquiladoras" are foreign owned manufacturing plants that rely on cheap Mexican labor.The unemployment rate was high in Mexico in the 1960's. To fix this issue, the plan was to draw in American corporations that would build their companies in Mexico. In order to ascertain new businesses in

Exploration of the Economic/Profitable Dimensions of Illegal Mexican Immigration for U.S. Economy

821 words - 3 pages liability to their already struggling economy. The maquiladoras (The maquiladoras are generally owned by non-Mexican corporations. They take advantage of plentiful low-cost Mexican labor, advantageous tariff regulations (lessened somewhat as a result of the North American Free Trade Agreement), and close proximity to U.S. markets to produce such items as home appliances and automobiles) might provide the Mexican opportunity to make a slightly

NAFTA Regional Integration

1405 words - 6 pages Trade Agreement began to go into effect. In Mexico, the government stipulates that NAFTA produces more foreign investment. The industries that seem to gain the most with NAFTA are the maquiladoras (assembly plants) and the automobile industry. Production is cheaper in Mexico than in many other countries because of the extremely low cost of labor. In the United States, many companies have been benefiting from NAFTA, especially companies that sign

Similar Essays

Maquiladoras & Nafta Essay

2053 words - 8 pages MAQUILADORAS AND THE NAFTA'S IMPACT: Introduction In this paper I will discuss the history and practices of the Maquiladora industry. I will discuss its background, its problems, the benefits it offers to United States companies, and the impact the NAFTA has and will have on the industry. In addition, I will make a suggestion on a possible strategy the Maquiladoras can adopt in order to address the challenges brought on by the NAFTA, to

Maquiladoras Essay

624 words - 2 pages Maquiladoras, foreign owned export assembly plants, have been both beneficial and problematic to men and mainly women working near the U.S.-Mexico border. The maquiladora program is a world wide economic issue affecting many people that must be addressed to the public.Mainly women make up the workforce in maquiladoras. Although the maquiladoras have been able to supply many women with jobs, the women, however, have faced many adversaries in the

North American Free Trade Agreement (Nafta)

2079 words - 9 pages unemployment numbers, and rising trade with the United States. The NAFTA has, possibly, helped Mexico gain the most out of all the other 2 nations. This can mostly be best seen in the fast growth of the Mexican maquiladora business. “A maquiladora is a labor-intensive business that imports inputs, frequently from the United States, and then processes and exports them. Since maquiladoras frequently bond the bordering nations of United States and Mexican

The Problems With Nafta Not Helping Economies

1503 words - 6 pages not the case in Mexico where NAFTA has slammed the middle class back into poverty. Another thing, which NAFTA affects, is the environment. NAFTA supporters promised that the agreement would lead to increased investment in environmental cleanup and less maquiladoras along the U.S.-Mexico border. However, many communities still lack access to both water and sewage systems. "Today, only 10 percent of Mexico's yearly output of 7 million tons of