Nashi: Pro Regime Youth Groups In Russia

2264 words - 9 pages

Type “Nashi” into any search engine and you will come across videos of uniformly clad youth chanting in unison, evoking bygone images of Komsomol or Hitler’s Youth. Indeed, Nashi, a pro-regime, state-supported youth organization, has often been likened to these organizations by the media and scholars alike. Yet, is this simplistic comparison an accurate one? Are state-led youth organizations in Russia merely puppets of the regime, lacking their own will or motivation? In the following pages I trace the origins and purposes behind the organization of pro-regime youth groups in Russia, arguing that while these movements undoubtedly perform many of the same functions as youth groups of the past, they do have some measure of autonomy and agency separate from the regime, if not completely independent of it.
When the Soviet Union collapsed, many Russians hoped for a rebirth of civil society and political participation. While there was a subsequent proliferation of non-governmental and public organizations, civil society in Russia has remained fragmented and divided. It is commonplace to characterize civil society in Russia as perilously weak “owing to the post-Soviet legacy of political cynicism, continuing state ambivalence about the role of society in politics, and a lack of domestic resources to support activism” (Henry 2010: 3).
However, weakness of civil society in Russia cannot be equated to a lack of participatory movements. Indeed, Putin spent much of his second term as president filling the political and civil space with “ersatz social movements” in support of the regime (Robertson 2010). These organizations were formed in response to protests by pensioners and pro-democracy groups and represented an innovative approach to managing dissent in Russia’s hybrid regime. Hybrid regimes, according to Robertson, lack the popular legitimacy of democratic regimes and the extensive societal control of authoritarian regimes; in order to compensate for these weaknesses rulers manipulate and marginalize opposition through a series of diverse mechanisms from control of the media to the development of pro-regime organizations (2010). The pro-regime organizations par excellence in Russia is Nashi, a mass youth movement created by the regime in response to the youth-led electoral revolutions in Serbia, Ukraine, and Georgia in the early 2000s.
Nashi and other state-supported participatory organizations are typically viewed as having no will of their own separate from the regime. Indeed, Nashi was formed with the explicit purpose of limiting the opposition and legitimizing the state; without state support, Nashi may very well be unable to continue its activities. Yet, no state has the power to completely control the rules of the game. A more thorough analysis of the role of state-supported participatory organizations in hybrid regimes must take into account the political and social context as well as the agency of organization leaders and members.

Find Another Essay On Nashi: Pro-regime Youth Groups in Russia

The Political Past, Present, and Future of Russia

4952 words - 20 pages The Political Past, Present, and Future of Russia Russia never associated as a democracy in anyone's mind. It had always been an authoritarian regime of different species and developed a mentality, which creates an almost unsurpassable

Staying out of Syria: inaction risks sectarian warfare and destabilization of neighboring states.

1717 words - 7 pages government to unilaterally disengage and for the President to step down had been criticized. Another explanation is that Moscow has awakened to the fact that the odds are stacked heavily against Assad and his Alawi dominated regime in the long-term. Therefore, Russia could be seeking to appear more even-handed in their dealings with both the Syrian government and the opposition in order to safeguard its considerable economic and strategic

Soviet History

2227 words - 9 pages statue of Hitler be displayed reverentially in downtown Berlin.How Russia Contends with its Soviet Past In Russia, by contrast, no real stigma has been attached to the Soviet regime. Because the Soviet Union collapsed in peacetime rather than in war, no occupying forces have been present to facilitate a reckoning with the Soviet past. The embalmed corpse of Vladimir Lenin, the founder of the Soviet dictatorship who resorted to mass terror and

The Main Features of the Soviet Constitution of Ninteteen-Thirty Six

2053 words - 8 pages the state of all independent lines of thought. Creativity had to serve the immediate needs of the government - 'Partiinost' (Party Spirit). Socialist Realism replaced the abstract experimental work of the 1920s with stereotypical art forms designed to convey immediately obvious pro-Soviet messages. Under Stalin there was some growth in popular culture. By 1940 Russia had 28,000 cinemas and stadiums were built in all

So Why Radicalization?

1558 words - 6 pages -psychological theory, posited by Ted Gurr. In the modernization theory, Huntington states that a “revolution becomes more radical as larger and larger masses of the population are brought into the political scales” (41). Huntington argues this empowers radical groups by spurring their popularity and in turn allows them to create “a new political order” under their rule (41). Yet, as the cases of France and Russia will demonstrate, radical polities do

Opic: Mussolini and Fascist Italy

997 words - 4 pages organisations that were run by the Catholic Church. After much tension the government had finally gained the dissolution of the Catholic Boy Scots in 1928 and restrictions were made on Catholic Action youth groups. As in other aspects of the regime, there was an intensification of indoctrination in the late 1930s, and in 1937, the ONB was incorporated into a new party organisation, GIL. The law establishing this proclaimed that it was the 'unitary and

The Cold War

1427 words - 6 pages War One. The US and her allies pulled out of Russia, and left the Bolsvik-Soviet regime in power. This "intervention" coupled along with the fact that Communists are naturally suspicious and sceptical when dealing with the West, helped create tensions between our two countries. This suspicion may have been created because of their long history of being invaded repeated over and over by the "outside world". But the "intervention"

The First Chechen War and the Four Faces of Power

1208 words - 5 pages from Avturchanov and Khasbultov, partially be- cause Dudajev demanded the recall of all Chechen representatives to Russian Parliament. Russia deployed troops, which approached Chechen borders in late 1992 (1-21). Dudajev utilized a cost- ly signal by arranging his own tanks against Russia, to indicate that if the opposition troops pro- ceeded, they would be punished with shelling. This move made Russia more open to negotia- tions, wherein the

The Nazi Regime

2608 words - 10 pages involving an attempt on Hitler’s life that showed that there was some opposition to the Nazi regime. This opposition involved communist and social democrat parties youth groups, churches and the army. An example of opposition arose when two members of the white rose organization, Hans and Sophie Scholl began distributing a series of anti Nazi pamphlets depicting the negative side of its regime. They were quickly dealt with

'The most important reason why there was little opposition in Germany towards the Nazi regime was its use of propaganda' Explain how far you agree with this statement?

3809 words - 15 pages . Hitler encouraged the youth into the regime with his Hitler youth clubs which included activities for the children and teenagers. The activities were mainly to exercise them and keep them healthy and also to brainwash them to join the Nazi regime. The groups became the only legal options and in 1939 it became compulsory. If a parent refused to send their child there, it showed obvious signs of anti-Nazi views and the parents would be taken away

"Russia in 1894 was a country with many problems" - Discuss this view of Russia

1048 words - 4 pages have more money. Therefore, industry was often discouraged, through poor working conditions and lack of investment, this meant that Russia was very poor, and comparatively undeveloped.In 1894 Russia faced many problems. It had a poor transport and communications system, making industrial growth and control very difficult. There was widespread segregation of ethnic groups and also large divisions in wealth, with the majority of the country, poor and

Similar Essays

Tsarist Rule Vs. Communist Regime In Russia

2612 words - 10 pages Tsarist Rule vs. Communist Regime in Russia From 1856-1917, up until a communist takeover, the USSR had three Tsarist rulers, Alexander II (the Reformer 1855-1881), Alexander III (the reactionary Tsar 1881-1894) and Nicholas (1894-1917). After the February Revolution of 1917, Lenin took control forcibly through the Civil War, but died in 1924. After several years of fighting opposition, Stalin took power in the late

How Far Was Nicolas Ll Personally Responsible For The Problems Of The Tsarist Regime In Russia?

1078 words - 4 pages or was it just that he was politically naïve? Throughout his rule as discontent rose Nicholas still believed that he still had the support of all his people save for a couple of 'undesirables'. In a sense he was living in an alternate political reality. An example of his political naivete was the 1905 revolution that nearly toppled the regime. Before this there had been enormous changes to the composition of the upper-class; the nobles

Describe The Nature Of A Totalitarian Regime, And Compare And Contrast Hitler's Nazi Regime With That Of Stalin In Communist Russia

3998 words - 16 pages In order to accurately compare and contrast Hitler and Nazi Germany with that of Stalinist Russia it is important that we first discuss and fully understand the nature of the totalitarian regime. This will be achieved through an illustration of each separate entity of the totalitarianism system of state bureaucracy; economy management; legislature and the executive. The restriction placed upon civil society achieved through established social

Syrian Crisis Essay

1498 words - 6 pages perpetuating series, with each consecutive funeral and weekly demonstration enlarged in size, sometimes numbering in the thousands and the series of protests and killings continued to rise. Thus, Assad used “Shabiha” who were Alawites as pro-regime militias to kill the unarmed protesters. It became a convenient means for the Assad regime to commit any type of violence and threats against resistance groups and later on refusing responsibility