National Academy Of Sciences: Human Cloning

954 words - 4 pages

The National Academy of Sciences (NAS) made headlines when it issued a broadside that would, if followed by Congress, grant an open-ended license for biotech researchers to clone human life. True, the NAS recommended that Congress ban "reproductive" cloning, that is, the use of a cloned embryo to produce a born baby. But it also urged that human cloning for purposes of experimentation--often called "therapeutic" or "research" cloning--remain unimpeded by legal restrictions. Such a public policy would permit virtually unlimited human cloning--so long as all the embryos created thereby were destroyed rather than implanted in a woman's womb.

The recommendation from a well-known scientific organization did not appear at this particular time by coincidence. The Senate will soon consider S. 790, legislation authored by Sam Brownback (R-KS) that would prohibit any creation of human clones--whether for research purposes or for reproduction. The House passed a virtually identical ban in a bipartisan vote last summer, and President Bush strongly supports the bill. Thus the legal future of human cloning--and the potential fortunes to be made by Big Biotech in the United States--hang in the balance in the Brownback bill.

Limiting the ban on human cloning to procedures designed to lead to the birth of a baby would accomplish next to nothing. Figuring out how to clone human life successfully is going to be very difficult. Thus, early research would likely focus on perfecting techniques. Should this be successful, researchers would next attempt to maintain the resulting embryonic clone for a week to two weeks--long enough to harvest their stem cells. (The biotech company Advanced Cell Technology announced it has created human clones and maintained them to the six-cell stage(Advanced), which is not long enough for stem cells to appear.) Should the stem-cell Rubicon be crossed, implantation of the embryonic clone would then be relatively easy. Hence, the next natural (dare I use the word?) step would be the manufacture of human clones not just for research or genetic manipulation but for implantation, gestation, and birth. In any case, the morally serious question is whether human cloning is permissible--not when those cloned should be killed once created.

Much as an original oil painting can be seen only dimly beneath its patina, an agenda to eventually permit unrestricted cloning for all purposes can be discerned between the lines in the NAS report. The NAS panel appears to view human cloning as merely another "reproductive technology." Indeed, the primary reasons cited by the NAS for finding that reproductive cloning "is not now appropriate" are strictly utilitarian: It simply isn't safe at this time.

Moreover, given the NAS's enthusiastic support for unlimited human cloning for purposes of experimentation, its stated opposition to reproductive cloning could easily evaporate. Indeed, the NAS panel urged that any legal ban placed on reproductive...

Find Another Essay On National Academy of Sciences: Human Cloning

Dangers of Human Cloning Essay

1115 words - 4 pages Some may think human cloning is a good thing; however, I believe these individuals are uninformed on the many dangers of cloning. Cloning, none the less, human cloning has yet to be perfected. This has been proven by physicians from the American Medical Association and scientists with the American Association for the Advancement of Science. They have issued public statements strongly advising against human cloning. Currently, the U.S. Congress

Abuse of Human Cloning Essay

1610 words - 6 pages cloning human beings becomes a reality, it will be the process that will slowly deteriorate the diversity of the world, and the ability for people to deal with negative occurrences in their life.Ethically and politically cloning seems to be breaking all the rules, already. Supporters of cloning are pushing for a reform of any law or constitutional right, banning cloning, to be changed. Cloning is currently backing an ethical uproar around

Morality of Human Cloning

1470 words - 6 pages The novel Brave New World presents us with a vision of a future where human beings are no longer born the “natural” way but are rather manufactured in identical batches to certain specifications. Where concepts like “mother” and “father” are scatological and children are taught only to keep the order and complete their predetermined occupations. By the end of the novel Mr. Huxley has us thankful that such a world is beyond our grasp. However

The Benefits of Human Cloning

1129 words - 5 pages Cloning Foundation. “The Benefits of Human Cloning.” 1998. Human Cloning Foundation. 1 October 2001 <>. Robinson, Bruce. “Human Cloning: Comments by political groups, religious authorities, and individuals.” 3 August 2001. Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance. 1 October 2001 <>. Wachbroit, Robert. “Human Cloning Isn’t as Scary as it Sounds.” The Washington Post 2 March 1997. 3 October 2001 <>.

The Ethics of Human Cloning

1307 words - 5 pages Human cloning is separated into two major categories; reproductive cloning, which uses cloning technology to create a human embryo that will produce an entire human, and therapeutic, which adopt cloning into field of medical practices to find a cure for many diseases (Kass). Reproductive cloning requires a somatic cell, a DNA-less egg, and a surrogate mother; as a result, it creates a new individual with the same genome, or genetic coding. The

The Dangers of Human Cloning

2328 words - 9 pages representatives than in the house, “religion is among the more powerful offspring that shape attitudes toward human cloning ” . As science moves forward the challenge to religion increases. “human cloning threats human being as products “ O'Malley said on behalf of the bishops . “manufactured to order to suit other peoples wishes, a technical advanced in human cloning is not progress for humanity but its opposite ”. Many Christian experts

The Debate of Human Cloning

4520 words - 18 pages Missing Appendix The Debate of Human Cloning Human cloning has become a hot topic for debate. As we progressed one step closer to successfully cloning and developing a human being, legislators and the general public have become more concerned about the ethical and moral implications of this procedure. The federal government has been unsuccessful in reaching an agreement as to what policy to pass and enact. Thus, any current legislation on

The Ethics of Human Cloning

1340 words - 5 pages The Ethics of Human Cloning In order to make a fully justified decision on whether human cloning is ethical or not, one must be exposed to the background of the subject. To start, a clone is an exact replica of an organism, cell, or gene. The process itself is done asexually with the use of a cell from the original human. It is then placed inside a female capable of bearing a child and is then born as a clone. Along

The Debate of Human Cloning

2104 words - 8 pages The journey that human cloning has taken has been one of dramatic highs and lows, heated arguments and confusion about the path ahead. When researchers witnessed the birth of the first cloned mammal, they were ecstatic, but this high ended with the tragic early death of this sheep, Dolly, due to abnormalities (Jaenisch 2004: 2787). The initial success and progress in this field fueled scientists to want to do further research into this

The Ethics of Human Cloning

1191 words - 5 pages . If a human's body is incapable of producing enough protein on it's own. There is an alternative where human protein compound that is injected in the bodily fluid of an aniaml such as milk for cows. Thus, human protein could be extracted from the animals body and endossed by those who have a genetic defect. (Yount,49) People might argue that because of cloning there will not be any genetic diversity, but one of a dwindling species argues Ryder. He

The Reality of Human Cloning

668 words - 3 pages The Reality of Human Cloning As aptly put by Rosa Beddington, the word “clone” has become one of the most emotive of all the terms coined by scientists which have entered popular vocabulary. I shall add another, and that will be the phrase “Dolly the sheep”. The conception of Dolly, the “baby” of scientist Ian Wilmut and his team has opened the possibility of cloning humans. The mention of Dolly brings to average the person, haunting

Similar Essays

Benefits Of Human Cloning Essay

1494 words - 6 pages of human cloning still overweigh the benefits; therefore, it is necessary to have an international and national organisation to monitor the development of this technology. Human cloning especially therapeutic cloning is the solution for health problems. It can be used to clone stem cells to cure diabetes patients, help discovering new medicines, and supply organs and tissues to transplant. Scientists use patient’s skin cells to produce new stem

Benefits Of Human Cloning Essay

3194 words - 13 pages . (1998). Clones & clones: Facts and fantasies about human cloning. New York: Norton. Rantala, M.L. & Milgram, A.J. (1999). Cloning: For and against. Chicago: Open Court Publications. Sadler, S.E. (1999). The physical self – a look at biology for women. Departments of Biological Sciences & Women’s Studies, University of Denver. Silver, L.M. (1999a). Remaking eden: Cloning and beyond in a brave new world. New York: Avon Books, Inc

Immorality Of Human Cloning Essay

1541 words - 6 pages unethical and dangerous in its likely consequences. In so doing, we ought to have the backing of the majority of our society and our government. We should do all that we can to prevent cloning, and we should do this by means of a national legal ban. However, it is estimated that conducting experiments in all kinds of human cloning will one day be constitutionally guaranteed. According to the first amendment, such a situation is indeed possible. While

Ethicality Of Human Cloning Essay

2296 words - 10 pages Is Human Cloning Ethical? The idea of human cloning may sound preposterous to a lot of people, but it can actually happen. The thought of human cloning in itself actually happening was introduced when the first sheep ever cloned, “Dolly” was created. On July 5, 1996 the idea of cloning a human was forever changed when Dolly was made, and probably had many doubters about cloning thinking otherwise. Animal cloning was a huge step into the door for