National Morality In Hawthorne Essay

1756 words - 7 pages


        Since the beginning of time, man has gathered himself in communities in order to better facilitate the needs and interests of individuals. As institutions developed to govern these communities, the idea of a “collective good” emerged. Central to the idea of a collective good is the responsibility of the community in forming a sense of national morality. Should this morality come from the government or religion? Perhaps, individuals should take responsibility to constitute a morality for themselves. Nathaniel Hawthorne addresses the question of national morality in his work The Scarlet Letter. Through a careful examination of the central characters of the work and an understanding of the underlying ideas of Hawthorne, a view on national morality emerges. Hawthorne criticizes the fundamentalist Puritan characters, particularly Dimmesdale, by showing their hypocrisy and displaying the failures of Puritans and their form of a national morality. The treatment of the outcast Hester
reveals Hawthorne’s desire to form a national morality founded on individual accountability and Transcendentalist beliefs.

        Before disclosing his notions and beliefs on national morality, Hawthorne begins his story, The Scarlet Letter, with a discussion of the Puritan state of Salem set in the 1600's. It is often problematic to discern Hawthorne’s views about Puritanism due to his ambiguity. He reveres the Puritan conviction and their ability to conform to the controls of their faith (Gerber, 34). However, he condemns them for the bigotry and utter intolerance they show for opposing viewpoints and perspectives (Leavitt, 88). This ambiguity causes the reader to question Hawthorne’s attitudes and tone throughout the course of the work. No where in The Scarlet Letter does Hawthorne criticize in particular the doctrines of the Puritan religion. Hawthorne only discusses the Puritanical beliefs such as predestination and the “Doctrine of the Elect” in the context of his narrative. In fact, Nathaniel
Hawthorne himself was a second generation Puritan. Hawthorne’s grandfather was a prominent judge during the Salem Witchcraft trials. Indisputably, Hawthorne’s chief ideological complaint rests in the theocratic Salem where the government is heavily influenced and even dominated by the church. When the authority of the church in state affairs is addressed, Hawthorne’s tone changes to one of disdainful contempt. This becomes evident as Hawthorne portrays the scene of Hester’s punishment upon the scaffold at the very beginning of the story (Hawthorne, 65). Hawthorne regards Puritan Salem as a battleground in the early struggle for political liberty in America (Gerber, 36). Before the battles against the British crown and the ultimate formation of the United States, the rights of privacy and personal liberty were fundamental to the early settlers. The government...


Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay

575 words - 2 pages of his only books which produced a great amount of controversy between the public, readers, and him. Due to the great literature presented in The Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne was appointed by the Democratic administration, but shortly the Whigs won a national election which presented the public the decision to remove anyone appointed by the Democratic Administration. Among those who requested the removal of Nathaniel Hawthorne were his neighbors and

Nathaniel Hawthorne: The Architect of American Literature

1480 words - 6 pages many young girls to death for witchcraft (Whitney). Because of this, Hawthorne changed his name from Nathaniel Hathorne to Nathaniel Hawthorne. Hawthorne found the legacy left by his grandfather and father despicable and changed his name in an effort to distance himself from the name infamous in Salem’s tragic early history (Faculty of European Graduate School). Only four years after Hawthorne’s birth, his father contracted and died of yellow

The Scarlet Letter, by Nathaniel Hawthorne

1358 words - 5 pages In The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne portrays the strong values of the puritans in the 17th century through the townsmen and women. Religion was a way of life for the puritans. Their values interjected in their emotions, attitudes, actions, and speech. Hester Prynne committed adultery, which defies the puritan’s beliefs. By examining the punishments that were given to Hester, Hawthorne is able to continue to emphasize the puritan

The Sin of The Scarlet Letter

652 words - 3 pages Hester Prynne's adulterous affair in The Scarlet Letter has made the book a controversy since its publication. Many conservative critics have challenged its morality and its effects on literature. A year after the book was published, Reverend Arthur Coxe, a church pastor who believes that the book degrades our literature, strongly criticizes how the author depicts sin in a sympathetic, positive light. Although I accept his statements that the

Major character analysis of "The Scarlet Letter"

1329 words - 5 pages individual and the church and the psychological aspects of good and evil. Hawthorne sees the puritan laws as unfair, accordingly in the Scarlet Letter Hawthorne calls in to question the key elements of puritan morality. Puritan laws are based upon sins and crimes committed against god, but in his description of Dimsdale, Hester and ChillingWorth, Hawthorne shifts the emphasis from sin to evil. In Hawthorne view sin is theological and requires a

Brown's Fall

2136 words - 9 pages . Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote “Young Goodman Brown” in 1835. His time period influenced the theme of his work. The theme Hawthorne chose was the weakness of public morality. In “Young Goodman Brown” Hawthorne shows this theme through the perspective of a Puritan man, Goodman Brown. In the story Hawthorne shows that Goodman Brown’s religious convictions are rooted in his belief that those around him are also religious. This kind of faith, which depends so

An Analysis of the Forest Scene

1045 words - 4 pages If one were to possess an imprecise stance on an issue, that person would be suspect to change their perceptions. This theory of ever-changing perception is present in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter; specifically in the forest scene where Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale meet. Hawthorne's irresolute feelings of Puritanism coincide with Hester's changing fortune. When Hawthorne believes in Puritanism, Hester is downhearted, and when

Morality and Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown

1162 words - 5 pages by this Puritan heritage; by Hawthorne's personality which had acquired a skeptical, dual-outlook on life; and by Hawthorne's mental and moral beliefs thathe revealed. Hawthorne struggles with his own morality within his own biographical framework in "Young Goodman Brown." Hawthorne viewed his Puritan ancestors with a mixture of pride and guilt. He felt pride in seeing the history of his own family interwoven with that of Salem (Turner 5). He

A Freudian Reading of Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown

1806 words - 7 pages A Freudian Reading of Young Goodman Brown        Incredibly, Nathaniel Hawthorne, wrote about concepts that Freud clinically proved later on. Much like Freud, Hawthorne analyzes in his tale Young Goodman Brown the same premises for which Freud is the epitome. Thus, one encounters the issues of the opposite effect that social restraint has on society, despite its purpose, as well as the unconsciousness versus consciousness in this text

Young Goodman Brown

1505 words - 7 pages Hawthorne’s father were an attempt to deflect John Hathorne’s, and all those who believed in witches, own evil. The life experiences of Nathaniel Hawthorne were key influences in his literary work as shown in the short story “Young Goodman Brown”. His ancestors involvement in the Salem witch trials, the persecution of Quakers and Puritanism as a whole affected Hawthorne’s morality and concept of good vs. evil. “Young Goodman Brown” demonstrates

Noble Love in The Birthmark

1751 words - 7 pages Noble Love in The Birthmark      Often billed as a story of an unsuccessful attempt to beat Nature at her own game, “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne certainly lends itself to a somewhat deeper interpretation.  Over the years many scholars have noted that the story of Aylmer and Georgiana is riddled with traditional Hawthorne themes such as the evils of selfishness and pride, coupled with an element of solitariness (Arvin xvi

Similar Essays

What Influenced Nathaniel Hawthorne To Write The Scarlet Letter

1683 words - 7 pages morals he grew up learning. In most every story there is a theme. In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novels he used many themes that reflected his personal experiences. Hawthorne used many themes throughout his stories that included: morality, sin, and redemption. (PBS) “Another recurring theme is that of isolation.” (Marks) Throughout Hawthorne’s whole life he moved from place to place always trying to find something better. He always thought he didn’t

The Real War Essay

3568 words - 15 pages is to set an example to the entire world. Slavery is identified as the cause for the South’s barbarity and, as a result, for disunion. The end of slavery will remove the obstacle to national progress and a common civilized, moral nationhood. As with various other aspects, Emerson’s and Hawthorne’s view on the war could not have been more different. In 1863, Hawthorne said about Emerson that he was “as merciless as a steel bayonet” regarding his

Young Goodman Brown: The Evils Of Puritanism

2147 words - 9 pages Puritanism dominated 17th century history and literature. Nathaniel Hawthorne born in 1804 was an American writer who sought to resolve his conflicts with Puritanism through his writing. Hawthorne wrote several stories showing the world the horrors of the Puritan faith and the isolation of individuals who failed to uphold the faith. For Hawthorne, Young Goodman Brown illustrates the difference between Puritan teaching and practicing and reflects

Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay

1507 words - 7 pages The tall and mysterious Nathaniel Hawthorne is a man of little understanding. We know him for being very secluded and alone much of the time. We also know he had many secrets that may have accounted for the gloomy tone in his novels. He was a writer who did not believe in the game of small talk and enjoyed losing himself to a world of this own creation. Many people might have thought that Hawthorne came off as rude and uninteresting, but they