Nationalism And Democracy Essay

1079 words - 4 pages

Nationalism has played a crucial role in world history over the past centuries. It continues to do so today. For many, nationalism is indelibly associated with some of the worst aspects of modern history, such as the destructive confidence of the Napoleon’s army and the murderous pride of Nazi Germany. Large numbers of people, descent in their hearts, have carried out unbelievable atrocities for no better reason than their nation required them to. Authoritarian and totalitarian regime have crushed dissent, eliminated opposition, and trampled on civil liberties in the name of the nation.
These horrors caused by nationalism seem to be at the opposite end of the spectrum from the promising ideal of democracy. As Ghia Nodia pointed out, many analysts view nationalism as “fundamentally antidemocratic” (3). What these anti-nationalists fail to realize is that nationalism has also called force heroism and even sacrifice throughout history. Numerous people have risked their lives to restore democracy and civil rights in their nations, when they could easily have chosen comfortable exile elsewhere. Indeed, nationalism is the very basis of democratic government because it unites the citizens as “we the people”, supports the common political destiny, and nurtures trust toward the government.
The most important value of nationalism to democracy lies in the fact that it has the capacity to unite individual citizens into a single entity with shared beliefs. Democracy requires a definition of demos or who are included in the game and who are not (Nodia 6). Wherever the boundaries of the playing field are in dispute, democratic institutions (such as participation, representation, or cooperation) simply cannot function. Thus, for democracy to operate effectively, the existence of a united political community is critical. Nationalism is often the main reason why people identify with their respective political community. As the main source of national identity, nationalism “makes [people] feel connected not only to one another but also to the homeland itself” (Jusdanis 28). In the case of the American founding, when the delegates from respective states met to construct a more perfect union, they did not identify themselves as Virginians or New Yorkers. Instead, they defined themselves as “we the people of the United States” as it appears in the Preamble to the US constitution. The shared interest in liberty and freedom as well as the attachment to the land of their fathers made it possible for the vast population of the thirteen states to think of itself as a unified body despite their internal ethnic and cultural divide. By identifying themselves as a member of certain group, people will form a society with certain shared value, which ultimately can become the political units for a democratic government. Nationalism is essential for creating a cohesive political community.
In addition to defining the political units for democratic governance, nationalism can...

Find Another Essay On Nationalism and Democracy

An Argument Against a Presupposition Essay

1740 words - 7 pages democracy. It is this fact that makes the argument against nationalism an erroneous endeavor as the one thing people will be uniting under, the democratic principle, is the source of their unification. Croly believes that the traditional fear of a strong centralized government is unenlightened and antiquated. Clearly, Croly is placing a lot of faith in the “democratic principles” that will guide the unified nation. It is interesting then that

As a Western construct, can nationalism satisfy non-Western movements? Does it then possess good or bad qualities?

1513 words - 6 pages Nationalism cannot be seen as either 'good' 'bad', as the notion of 'good' 'bad' characteristics depends upon the position of the observer. Nationalism is a Western construct which has been variously justified and used for different purposes wherever it is found. It will be argued that nationalism, while possessing neither absolute 'good' nor 'bad' qualities, can never be completely progressive. Even in its anti-colonialist form it derives from

Pro’s and Con’s of Nationalism

1810 words - 7 pages Pro’s and Con’s of Nationalism Nationalism was coined back in the 1770’s it has a major role in the shaping many nations throughout the world. Nationalism has many positive and negative aspects to it. Nationalism has the strength to unify people despite their classes. It also has the ability to united people to lead movements against oppressive governments. There is a downside Nationalism can as method to evoke fear. The biggest negative is

Globalization: An Ideology of Western Elitists?

1228 words - 5 pages its agencies also contribute to: the depolarization of society, the undermining of democracy, and the denationalization of the globe. This paper will assess the various political and economic factors of globalization from a socialist perspective. Globalization creates and amplifies depolarization on a regional, national and global level. First, the main criticism of globalization is its role in creating and increasing the gap between classes

The Role of Nationalism in German Unification: Three Post-Holed examples

2251 words - 9 pages , which included Bismarck, supported militarism and didn't want universal suffrage because it would interfere with their power. The South German states wanted universal suffrage, a liberal constitution, and real democracy instead of the "Bismarckian" democracy that was imposed on the people. This caused a rift between the North and South German states, divided by the Main River, and a crack in the strong German nationalism that was present during the

Soviet Family Code and Women: Marxism and the National Question by Lósif Stalin

1295 words - 5 pages Marxism was originally not designed for a multiethnic state but for nation-states. Thus the underlying assumption that national sense of belonging could take over class sense belonging required party members to elaborate a nationalities policies. Joseph Stalin published in 1913 a seven-chapter article about the position that Marxists should adopt in regard to nationalism. In Marxism and the National Question, Stalin asserted what would be the

Democracy in Iraq

734 words - 3 pages In order to understand the prospects for democracy in Iraq, it is necessary to recall the way that power operates in a nationalist republic and what causes the existing democracies in the region to be flawed.Arab nationalism emphasizes the Arab character of past Islamic empires and pointed to a future in which a single state would unite the region from Morocco to Oman. The nationalist ideology has historically embedded roots in Iraq, and is

Discuss Nationalism in the ERa of Good Feelings

546 words - 2 pages Nationalism, not sectionalism, was the driving force during the era of good feelings. Nationalism became the leading ideology of the American republic. While sectionalism proceeded in bringing the nation into turmoil and constant bickering among the politicians, as in the case with dealings leading to the Missouri compromise, nationalism was able to unite the nation into a headstrong body, led by an ever-increasing, more powerful central

Acccount for th failure of democracy in Germany between 1918 and 1933

1852 words - 7 pages Germany. These included the role of various military factions, nationalism, and the political process in Germany during this time. When all these contributing factors were combined with national and international economic collapse Germany's fragile attempt to introduce democracy was doomed to failure.The crushing defeat of Germany in World War 1 saw the collapse of the monarchy heralding a need for change in how Germany was governed and an allied

A Hald Century of Progress, based on the book The Nation Takes Shape by Marcus Cunliffe

1048 words - 4 pages American government. Part of the nationalism had been brought over by The Revolutionary War, but recent factions between Federalists and Democratic Republicans threatened to destroy the unity of the nation altogether. Nonetheless, the events that resided in America from 1789-1837 were enormous contributions to nationalism. The War of 1812 boosted America's pride and more and more people sought an active role in the government. The war also led to the

Arab Democracy, fiction or Reality?

4961 words - 20 pages occupied Palestine. The people, on the other hand, agreed on forgoing their quests for liberal participatory politics (Ibrahim, 253). This was a form of nationalism that had become the default in the Arab World at that time. And thus whatever promises were given to the people by the revolutionary leaders to live in a free liberal democracy after the revolution, were empty words. It is interesting to note, that under the English colonial rule, Egypt

Similar Essays

Assess The Importance Of Nationalism As Cause Of The Failure Of Democracy In Germany In The Period 1918 1934.

1831 words - 7 pages Nationalism was an important and integral factor in the downfall of the Weimar Republic and in turn, the ensuing failure of democracy in Germany in the period 1918-1934. The sense of loyalty and devotion to one’s nation, which the German citizens had felt in their militaristic past, was ultimately devastated by WWI and its consequences. Although nationalism was a major cause of the failure of democracy in Germany, there were many other

Four Definitions Of Nationalism Essay

1681 words - 7 pages , paternalistic democracy and gave importance to economic emphasis. In addition to these documents, “The Narodna Odbrana” document represents both “Popular Nationalism” and “Bureaucratic nationalism”. Nationalist movements aiming at Austria were done both by nationalists alone and also by the control and influence of the government in order to weaken Austrian rule in Bosnia, and unite all Serbians. By defining four different

Should Nationalism Be Suppressed? Essay

834 words - 3 pages are of the opinion that nationalism should be suppressed. People who believe that nationalism should not be suppressed value human rights, democracy and political freedom. Nationalism should never be suppressed.A case study that supports this view is the storming of the Bastille. Someone who would support this position is Locke because he valued the right to rebel against an unfit leader. By standing up for their rights and not allowing themselves

Rescuing The Public Constraint Essay

1114 words - 4 pages important. Specifically, nationalistic belief in democratic states includes the belief in the supremacy of democracy as a form of government. As a result, it would be in opposition to the nationalism of a democratic nation to engage in a conflict with a democracy unless their national survival was unambiguously and credibly threatened. Critiquing Rosato’s final argument requires that we draw from the preceding discussion of nationalism. Rosato