Nationalism, Gender And The War Discourse

1700 words - 7 pages

The presence of war has been argued as one of the major contextual factors leading to rapid changes in media discourse. During periods of conflicts, the media are characterised by a heightened emphasis on a clear division between “us” – the goodies and “them” – the baddies (Bugarski 1997). In particular, a “polarising logic of war discourse” (Pankov, Mihelj and Bajt 2011, p. 1044) is deliberately formed by conflating various forms of nationalism and other discourses of identity, such as gender and age (ibid), with the intent to create binaries and contrast different entities involved in the war. In doing so, the media serve to sustain power in political systems, for they promote preferred social relations and values of the ruling political structure (Van Dijk 2006, p.15). The mediated representations of the political crisis in Crimea in 2014 have followed this pattern. In this case study, using critical discourse analysis, I shall examine the language and accompanying video of the article “'What If My son doesn’t Come Back at All': Crimean Mothers Wait for Their Sons Drafted in Ukraine”, which was published on Russia Today News’ website on 26th March 2014. I particularly pay attention to how these textual and visual elements transform people into nationalised and gendered subjects in a pro-Russian nationalist narrative so as to legitimise the ideology that the news serves.
The article was tied to the concern over the situation of Crimean soldiers serving in the Ukrainian army after the Crimea’s legal status referendum held on 16th March 2014. As a result of this referendum and a string of events entailed, Crimea, formerly an autonomous republic within Ukraine, became a part of the Russian Federation, and those soldiers who had not returned to Crimea were thus considered as undergoing military service in another country. Although reporting in the “public sphere” (Habermas 1989) an issue concerning citizens and the nation, the article was structured around personal stories shared by the soldiers’ families. This way of framing discredits the sense that deems the referendum as having negative consequences on Crimea’s national interests, which possibly counters its legitimacy. The article also presented the issue as emotion-driven, caused by maternal anxiety and love rather than general national dissatisfaction. Such an interpretation is visible in the constant emphasis on emotion of the people portrayed, in both reporting language (“nightmare”; “fear their loved one won’t be able to come home”, “I tell him, ‘Hello, son, I love you’. That is all I can tell him”; “the anxiety is too much to bear”) and video footage of the interviews with them (mothers crying, mother showing photos of her son, fiancé waiting on phone). This discursive construction serves to ideologically avoid giving this issue the impression of radical political criticism made by citizens, which might threat the representation of a united Crimea during the crisis. Similar ideological...

Find Another Essay On Nationalism, Gender and the War Discourse

Militarism, Nationalism, and the System of Alliances: The Causes of World War One

1481 words - 6 pages seen. We know the story, but when we read the between the pages, what were the underlying causes of the Great War that changed history? Through extensive research among primary and secondary documents, the answer has been found. The hidden causes were militarism, nationalism, and the system of alliances. Militarism led nations to jump at war prematurely. Nationalism causes other nations to become suspicious, and it also leads to a war that could

Nationalism After the War of 1812 and Important Court Cases of the Time.

565 words - 2 pages After the war of 1812, a surge of nationalism spread everywhere throughout America. Having unofficially won the war without even an official army, the people of America became very proud of themselves and how their great country established such a feat. The nationalism grew until John Marshall, an aggressive Chief Justice, further strengthened and expanded it. He was a devout Federalist appointed by John Adams years before his most famous case

The French Revolution and Nationalism

934 words - 4 pages After the conflicts against Napoleon in 1815, the outlook of nationalism permeated throughout entire Germany by middle-class liberals and was influenced by the French revolution. Soon Bismarck unified the German states under Prussia. Nationalism encouraged the German people to stand against conservatives and when Germany was finally unified as the German Empire it was very much an authoritarian and a combatant state as well. This is a

Rousseau's Discourse on the Arts and Sciences

1932 words - 8 pages Rousseau's Discourse on the Arts and Sciences Jean-Jacques Rousseau has been called both the father of the French Revolution and a rascal deserving to hunted down by society (Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson, p. 462). His works, controversial in his lifetime, have lost little of their ability to inspire debate in the seceding two hundred years. Although much of this debate has focused on Rousseau's political theories, his works on

Assess the importance of each of the following factors in causing the First World War: nationalism, alliances and economic factors!

1043 words - 4 pages Dunia MalezaiAssess the importance of each of the following factors in causing the First World War: nationalism, alliances and economic factors! Causes of World War One are complicated. There is no such clarity about which was the main factor in causing the war as all the above mentioned factors are interconnected and equally important. Although Germany has been blamed by many because she invaded Belgium in August 1914 when Britain had promised

The Pros and Cons of Nationalism

721 words - 3 pages about the country. This papers purpose is to illustrate the pros of nationalism as well as its cons. Beginning with America, there is a strong sense of nationalism. Being called patriotic would signify you support America and the ideals the flag stands for. It has many meanings to every individual, either learned through school or something they may have had happen and symbolize it with the flag. For instance, after September 11 happened

Nationalism: background and the big picture.

587 words - 2 pages independently from a centralized point. Still another aspect of nationalism is the willingness to go to extreme measures in achieving autonomous self-rule. Revolutions, wars, ethnic tension, and other conflicts of varying degrees have occurred throughout history because of a love for one's country. The spirit of nationalism has shaped the histories and destinies of many countries. Nationalism can unite people into cohesive, stable nations

The Failure and Rebirth of Burmese Nationalism

2230 words - 9 pages All people in the world strive to find a sense of belonging. This sense is coupled with ethnic identities, cultural customs, and social implications. The groups that inhabit the corner of the world, now known as Myanmar, have had great struggles and upheavals through the last century. They have been stricken with World War, independence struggles, as well as military dictatorship. The Burmese groups have tried with diligence to establish their

What was the main cause of world war I ? The four main causes were imperialism, militarism, alliances, and nationalism. Without these influences the war would have never happened.

848 words - 3 pages Instead of trying to point to one major cause for the First World War, like many historians attempt to argue, there were many causes that evolved around four major ones. Even Benthmann portrayed his frustration with attempting to isolate a major cause when his reply to the question of what started the war was "Oh, if only I knew". The four main causes were imperialism, militarism, alliances, and nationalism. Without these influences the war

The Dominance of Biomedicine and Challenges to its Discourse

3477 words - 14 pages either licensed or unlicensed healers to the legitimization of the medical profession and medicalisation of natural life experiences had occurred (Gabe, et al., 1994). With this, scientific medicine, commonly known as biomedicine, continued to dominate the discourse of health and illness from the end of the 18th century up to the present (Williams, 2003). Despite this perceived supremacy, scientific medicine faces serious challenges from

Nationalism and Racism in the Late 19th and 20th Century

1247 words - 5 pages white lands by imperializing lesser nations. This, he felt would ensure the white man’s dominance over vital life sustaining resources (Perry 158). Pearson’s nationalism was clear through his promotion of imperialism by any means necessary. His message was tinged with Social Darwinism as he advised Europeans of the inevitable survival of the fittest, with the white man remaining on top. He believed that expansionism was a worthy war and

Similar Essays

Gender, Parody And Discourse Essay

669 words - 3 pages compared to one an other these two films show two opposing messages regarding homosocial relationships. It is my opinion that the use of parody and satire of a genre can make such challenges to existing discourse formations appeal to a wide audience of moviegoers. The male relationships in these films are examined through the use of common genres. In these specific films it is primarily the zombie horror genre for Shaun of the Dead and buddy cop

Nationalism And War Essay

1446 words - 6 pages Nationalism and War Does nationalism have a relationship with the causes of the wars between 1792 and 1914? This can be disputed through the events of the French Revolution, the Napoleonic Wars, the unification struggles of Germany and Italy in the late 1800’s, the Alliance systems of the late 1800’s and the assassination of the Austrian archduke before the outbreak of World War 1. During the French Revolution in 1792, an effort was made

The War Of 1812 And Its Effects On American Nationalism

2033 words - 8 pages By any criteria the years following the War of 1812, otherwise known as the “Era of Good Feelings,” must be considered a time of exceptional growth and development in the United States, but above all, it may be considered a time of evolution and ripening of American nationalism, unification, and economic prowess. The war of 1812 was a very problematic war. States did not fulfill their duties, while commanders and leaders were not informed or

Golf And The Sencondary Discourse Essay

2733 words - 11 pages language. Over several years, I have been able to learn the secondary Discourse of golf by learning about the golf swing, learning terminology, principles of the sport, and through my experiences. When I started playing golf around age twelve, I was uncertain about the technicalities of the game or any of the rules that are involved. It took a long time for me to understand the nuances of golf because of the challenges it presents. It started with