This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Nationhood And Nationalities In Pakistan Essay

1994 words - 8 pages

Nationhood and Nationalities in Pakistan

Pakistan is a country inhabited by people belonging to many different nationalities. Hamza Alavi’s article focuses on the rising sub-national demands in the country and how the dominant factions have tried their best to suppress these movements.

Official Nationalism:

Benedict Anderson describes official nationalism as “A national identity that is not spontaneously generated from below, but is imposed from above by those at the heart of the power structure in the country, in reaction to powerful sub-national movements.”

Despite the passing of more than half a century since the inception of Pakistan, we still remain a ‘country’ rather than a ‘nation’. It may not even be wrong to say that we are a collection of nations residing inside a country. Pakistan has become divided on the basis of ethnicity due to the long denial of provincial autonomy and due to the dominance of a particular ethnic group.

Reasons for Installation of ‘Official Nationalism’:

As soon as Pakistan came into being, demands of provincial autonomy began to surface. People belonging to the smaller provinces started to realize that the salariat (which constitutes the military and the bureaucracy) was dominated by Punjabis. Due to the fact that it makes up more than half the population of the country, it was obvious that it would dominate the civil service, military and politics. This led to the feeling of deprivation. People of Sindh, KPK, and Baluchistan felt that they were not being treated equally and nor were they being given equal opportunities. As a result the demands for greater provincial autonomy began to surface and it also triggered the sub-national movements. The privileged and dominating ethnic groups that held key positions in military, bureaucracy and government, saw this as a threat to their control and dominance, because increase in provincial autonomy meant decrease in their power. Apart from this, regional players took special interest in promoting sub-national movements. These were people who knew that they could not score power in the centre, so instead they tried to strengthen their position in their provinces by resorting to ethnic politics. So, the people in control in the centre and in military and bureaucracy felt that if these demands were to be fulfilled, it would mean surrendering their control, which they were naturally reluctant to do. Instead of providing the concept of territorial basis of Pakistani nationhood within which the people belonging to all ethnicities could be accommodated, they sought refuge in religious ideology, which was used to deny the validity of ethnic identities altogether. This obviously had disastrous effects which our power hungry rulers had failed to foresee.

Salariat based National movement:

The heart of Muslim nationalism in India was in UP and Bihar, which were Muslim minority provinces. Muslims constituted almost 13 to 15 per cent of the total population in UP. Due to...

Find Another Essay On Nationhood and Nationalities in Pakistan

Fighting in Kashmir Revives Rancor in Pakistan and India (Summary)

916 words - 4 pages Fighting in India over land has always been an issue dating back to the second millennium and this sometimes has detrimental effects on trading. Today Pakistan is separate from India where as it was part of India many years ago. Pakistan and India often fight over Kashmir today and it is affecting their trade routs because neither country wants to reopen them. Although Pakistan and India were once together that did not affect fighting in that

Capital Punishment in United Arab Emirates and Pakistan

1035 words - 5 pages you’re wearing a skirt or shorts, they need to be at the appropriate length. However rules on the beaches are much more lenient. Swimwear is accepted but should be appropriate. Top-less sun bathing and wearing thongs is inappropriate and unacceptable. Background of the Country and the Laws of Pakistan: Pakistan which is known as the Islamic Republic of Pakistan is country in South Asia. Having a population more than 180 million, it is the

Corporate governance and firm performance in Pharmaceutical industry of Pakistan

3362 words - 13 pages Pakistan, the first Code of Corporate Governance was finalized and issued by SECP in March 2002. Then it was subsequently incorporated in all the listed companies of three stock exchanges in Pakistan. In 2004, SECP took the first step to establish the Pakistan Institute of Corporate Governance in public private partnership.Corporate governance is the set of policies, customs, processes, laws and institutions affecting the way a corporation or company

Investment in Fixed Assets and Firm Profitability in Textile Sector of Pakistan

1457 words - 6 pages Investment in fixed assets and firm profitability in textile sector of Pakistan Muhammad Shahzad Nazar Department of BBA Banking and Finance Government College University Faisalabad Pakistan Email: Literature Review: Investment is the sacrifice of present condition for the future perspective in which risk lies as the factor that can affect the investment decision. So, the investment in the fixed assets can be checked out


2341 words - 9 pages There is widespread poverty in Pakistan and the two main reasons are poor governance and income inequality. Few studies have focused on the theoretical substantiation of impact of bad governance and income inequality on poverty, but we do not find any study carrying empirical work on the impact of bad governance on poverty in Pakistan. This study is an empirical research that attempts to find out the long run and short run impact of poor

Impact of Foreign Remittances on Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction in Pakistan

2476 words - 10 pages INTRODUCTION: Remittances typically refer to transfers of money by foreign workers to their home countries. Remittances are not a new phenomenon in the world, being a normal associated to migration which has always been a part of human history. Remittances are playing an important role in the economies of many developing and low income countries. Pakistan is a labour abundant country; hence, as neoclassical theory shows, if workers are unable

Impact of Poor Governance and Income Inequality on Poverty in Pakistan

1657 words - 7 pages governance in demographic and socio-economic factors and infrastructure. Pasha (2000) determined nine components of “good economic governance” as achieving “fiscal discipline”, “growth with equity”, “institutional capacity”, “protection of public interest”, “credibility and consistency”, “capacity to manage crisis”, “effective delivery of services”, “integrity and sovereignty” and indicated that economic performance of Pakistan on the basis of

SME Development In Pakistan. Do Economic Growth And Government Support Matter?

2801 words - 11 pages economies. It is very important sector in both developed and developing countries. In Pakistan, SMEDA defines Small & Medium Enterprises, as approved in SME Policy 2007, as an enterprise that has up to 250 employees, or a paid up capital of 25 Million PK Rupees, or an annual sale of up to 250 Million PK Rupees. The Federal Government, in line with the economic development of Pakistan may, from time to time modify the eligibility criteria as it

A marketing analysis (international and domestic) regarding a wooden furniture in Pakistan

839 words - 3 pages Unit" set up project situated in Pakistan. The "Wooden Furniture Manufacturing Unit" will cater the needs of the domestic market. The researches have proved a strong competition that lies inside the international and domestic market.Market Analysis OutlineThe demand for wooden furniture is constantly increasing in the domestic market as well as in the international market due to its traditional appeal and durability.Domestic MarketIn Pakistan

Comparison between Half-Caste by John Agard and Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan by Moniza Alvi

1079 words - 4 pages Compare And Contrast Two Poems From Other Cultures And Traditions.I have chosen to compare Presents from my aunts in Pakistan by Moniza Alvi with Half-Caste by John Agard.The authors of these two poems were both born in another country and moved to England at an early age, where as John Agard was born and raised in Guyana and then moved to England during early adulthood. During this essay I will be comparing the imagery, tone, differences and

The Ways in Which Culture and Identity are Presented in Search for My Tongue and Presents From my Aunts in Pakistan

2138 words - 9 pages The Ways in Which Culture and Identity are Presented in Search for My Tongue and Presents From my Aunts in Pakistan In this essay I aim to discuss the ways in which culture and identity are presented in 'search for my tongue' and 'presents from my aunts in Pakistan' The first poem, 'search for my tongue' is written by a woman called Sujata Bhatt who was born in nineteen fifty six, in Ahmedabad, India. She emigrated to

Similar Essays

The Partition Of Indian Subcontinent: Crisis Of Identity And Uprooted Nationalities Resulting In Double Disaster For Pakistan

2127 words - 9 pages Pakistan in 1971, creating third state in the subcontinent, each with roughly 150 million Muslims. Detractors of the two-nation-theory point out that had India not been partitioned there would have been around 450 million Muslims living there, such a large population can hardly be termed a persecuted minority. Though emergence of Pakistan would not eliminate the problem of minorities, it would reduce the area of conflict between Hindus and Muslims

“Nigerian State: In Search Of Common Identity And Nationhood”

3150 words - 13 pages Untitled "Nigerian State: In search of common Identity and Nationhood" I. Introduction This topic shall address the concept of nation's identity (state) vis-�-vis individual identity. In an attempt to find a representative or adequate meaning of nation or individual identity, I stumbled onto ocean of semantic jargons and meanings. For example Identity defined through the lenses prescribed by Socio-Scientists

Stability In India And Pakistan Essay

839 words - 3 pages Today, India’s economic progress and political stability, together with its size, have lifted it to the status of a world power. Pakistan, on the other hand, is dogged by an unhappy past marked by repeated military interventions that prevented democracy from taking root. Both the regions form part of the South Asian sub-continent. South Asia is home to one fourth of the human race and has the largest middle class anywhere in the world. But the

Poverty In Pakistan: Causes And Consequences

1746 words - 7 pages development, societal norms and values. But the contents of the needs are more or less the same everywhere. Hunger, lack of shelter, being sick and unable to see a doctor, no access to school and education, joblessness, fear of the future are all the constituents of the Poverty. It also encompasses lack of opportunities, expression, representation and freedom. Pakistan is a low income developing country. In Pakistan, like other developing countries