This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Native Canadians Essay

1838 words - 7 pages

Media Discourse Involving First Nations People written by York University professors Frances Henry and Carol Tator brings up a very serious topic concerning the discrimination of Native People in the Canadian press. The main point of their article is the fact that the majority of “white people’s newspapers” are biased toward Native Canadians. It is not of course as discriminative as it used to be, but the Canadian media in any of its manifestation still use certain stereotypes on the daily basis. The media, according to Tator and Henry, as a very strong manipulative tool, does give wrong ideas about Natives to the rest of the Canadian population. And they seem to have a lot of quit strong evidences for this topic. More particularly, the examples were taken from two major newspapers: The Globe and Mail and The National Post. The first one focuses on the case of sexual assault of a young women by Jack Ramsay, another one have a series of articles and editorials about fishing rights in Canada. “While admitting that Ramsay did behave inappropriately, the writer of these articles was going to great lengths to marginalize the Native victim as untrustworthy, unreliable, forgetful, and alcoholic”(Tator, Henry 210). That was authors’ reaction to one of the passages from a newspaper. And truly, if a reader takes a close look the quotation from The Globe and Mail does sound like if the purpose of the materials posted was to let down the Natives. The other proper usage of information appeared in the second study case, which was analyzed by the National Post in 2000. “It was strongly implied – but not, of course, clearly stated – that Native peoples and their negotiations were there only to “pocket” more concessions, and that they weren’t there to deal with the situation in good faith” (Tator, Henry 221). Here, again, no doubt The National Post shoed some prejudice about Native People, which make Tator and Henry to concentrate on their work. However, like in any good work, there should be another interpretation to those texts, a sort of different side. The argument of the authors seems to be quite strong and relevant, but the question remains: is there anything more about those cases and articles dedicated to them that Tator and Henry “forgot” to mention. That is where the reader really has to break the ground.
The more detailed analysis of this article starts with the conclusion that was made by authors. The point that they were trying to support, as it was mentioned earlier, was the fact that in the English press does not portray a fair picture of Native people and their rights in Canada. So, to support their conclusion they showed some evidences that were meant to prove their ideas about the discrimination, as we also discussed earlier. Despite this, it did not work as well as it was intended. The conclusion itself is okay. But taking into the account the fact that the premises were not always false, but wrong interpreted, the conclusion suffers a lot...

Find Another Essay On Native Canadians

Royal Proclamation Essay

606 words - 3 pages Royal Proclamation of 1763: a Historic Moment Few Canadians acknowledge the Aboriginals and their land rights, and even fewer Canadians study them. The Royal Proclamation of 1763 is considered one of the most important treaties in history to be made with the Native People; yet very few have even a vague idea when they hear the words “Royal Proclamation, 1763”. Even with the grounds that the Royal Proclamation of 1763 provided, Canada has

Native Sovereignty Essay

1313 words - 5 pages Really want an Aboriginal Archipelago?" I will be taking the position against the coexistence of native sovereignty with Canadian sovereignty. These two articles will help me support my position on the issue. Olthius and Townshend are in favour of native sovereignty within Canada based on historical and moral grounds. These authors believe there is a difference in perceptions between native and non-native Canadians regarding the jurisdiction

A Negative Impact

1115 words - 4 pages When Europeans first began to settle in British North America, they had, had a positive impact upon Canadians, but over the years, they had an ultimately negative impact on Canadians in British North America. By bringing over disease, introducing the fur trade, and beginning religious conversion, the Europeans created this ultimately negative impact. When the first wave of European settlers came to British North America, the disease that they

Pierre Elliot Trudeau Speech

700 words - 3 pages reminder that we still got problems to fix in our country. But what the separatists cannot succeed in is taking away the Canadian pride. The pride shared by not only the French and English Canadians, but by Canadians of all cultures, of all religions. The belief that Canada is our home and native land, a nation that is truly strong and free.So long that water still runs in the Canadian river. There will be one nation!So long that the sun still shines

Corporate Executive : Mulroney Politics Among The Public

558 words - 2 pages heresolved there would be no more. He was elected party leader on June 11,1983, after attracting broad support from among the many factions of theparty, especially from representatives of his native Quebec.Mulroney's major initiatives between 1984 and 1988 were the Meech LakeAccord, a package of constitutional changes designed to end Quebec'sboycott of the 1982 constitutional reform, and the negotiation of a free tradeagreement with the United States.In

vimy ridge

622 words - 2 pages held it since 1914, and three French attacks in 1914 and 1915 had failed to dislodge them. Already more than 200,000 men had fallen on the long, gentle slopes leading to the crest. Behind it Germans had been able to move with comparative safety; and from its crest they had watched each Allied move. For the Canadians the battle would prove to be politically, nationally, and emotionally significant during World War 1.April 9, 1917, on Easter Monday

Native Underachievement in Canadian Schools

1620 words - 6 pages Native Underachievement in Canadian Schools A comparison of native students and their non-native peers quickly brings one to the realization that native students are not experiencing a comparable degree of education success in Canadian schools. It is vital that native Canadians address this issue thoroughly, to insure that the nation is no longer faced with a semi-literate, unemployable population, requiring financial support. In order to

Ethnic and Linguistic Canada

1471 words - 6 pages Ethnic and Linguistic CanadaCanada has long struggled with issues of ethnicity and linguistics as the nation's large French-speaking minority struggles to maintain its linguistic and cultural heritage. However, the French-speaking Canadians are not the only political players north of the border, and as Canada becomes increasingly diverse, its politics become increasingly complex. According to a 1991 Canadian census figure, almost one third of

Canadas Brain Drain Issue

1797 words - 7 pages or French as well as the Canadian would. Moreover, their training may be different, and while on paper they are degreed and have experience, but in reality they may not meet our standards. This is why foreign university graduates earn roughly 25% less than Canadian-born University graduates while emigrating Canadians do as well or better than native-born Americans do. Therefore, just by looking at this factor, it’s only logic for us to conclude

Historical Essay

635 words - 3 pages inequality. Numerous groups encountered conflict and had to endure hardships. These comprised of the First Nations, Chinese Immigrants as well as Black Canadians. The First Nations were assimilated and Residential schools were built for children. They were discouraged to speak in their native tongue and follow their native traditions (ethnic nationalism was highly discouraged). They were brutally punished and abused, for disobeying instructions, which

Canada's Multicultural Identity

1426 words - 6 pages Who are Canadians? There’s no clear definition. A thousand years ago, Canadians were Native Americans and 300 years ago, Canadians were French settlers. Today there is not one single definition of who we are. People have moved to Canada from all corners of the globe. No longer are we fur hat wearing court Dubois, or soldiers from the British army. Very few Canadians can say they truly come from North America. Were a hodge podge collage of all

Similar Essays

Native Canadians In Literature Essay

4661 words - 19 pages camps' the people were broken, their culture decimated and their souls eventually converted to the word of God. Literature contributes to this destruction in two ways: 1) by perpetuating and adding to the fallacies that existed about the native Canadian and; 2) by serving as an extensive record of the injustices served the native Canadian by other Canadians. The natives have their own literary record of the indignities they faced at the hands of

Government Negligence Is Relation To First Nation, Inuit, And Metis Health

655 words - 3 pages see that sick individuals are taken care of before these disputes take course. Someone needs to take immediate and full responsibility for Native health. Statistics show that Native people in Canada have lower health rates than non-Native Canadians. On average, Native people live 7 years less than non-Native people, and their infant mortality rate is 2 to 4 times higher. HIV/AIDS deaths are twice as high, and alcohol related deaths range

The Lifeblood Of Canada Essay

653 words - 3 pages When new immigrants arrive in Canada, several native Canadians are disturbed by the act due to the belief that they serve no benefit to the country. There are other assumptions that the lifeblood of Canada is native Canadians. Both statements are false because new immigrants are the lifeblood of Canada and the benefits they convey to Canada are revealed through the workforce, new discoveries, and services. Businesses need workers in

Canadian And American History Of Relations With Aboriginal Peoples Compare Treatment Of First Nations By A Merican And Canadians Consider Whether Either Could Be Considered Humane

919 words - 4 pages Natives. Legal recognition of native people led to a difference in the treatment of native groups in Canada in contrast to the Americans. Some of the differences were due to political, ideological, and economic factors.19th century settlements in Canada differed in one crucial respect from its American counterpart. While Canadians had a political policy of making treaties with the Native people, Americans were by this time rapidly expanding