Native Underachievement In Canadian Schools Essay

1620 words - 6 pages

Native Underachievement in Canadian Schools

A comparison of native students and their non-native peers quickly brings one to the realization that native students are not experiencing a comparable degree of education success in Canadian schools. It is vital that native Canadians address this issue thoroughly, to insure that the nation is no longer faced with a semi-literate, unemployable population, requiring financial support. In order to fully address native educational underachievement it is important to examine the historical causes of the problem, the issues we are faced with today, as well as, identifying possible viable solutions.
Early European settlers in Canada unfoundedly conceived the white culture to be superior to that of the native population they encountered. This rampant feeling of superiority led the Europeans to desire domination of the native nation, which was to be achieved through assimilation. The [European settlers] believed that "Indian children were best prepared for assimilation into the dominant society if they were removed from the influences of home, family, and community" (Barman, Hebert & McCaskill, 1986). In the opinion of these settlers residential, or boarding schools were a superior means of achieving native assimilation. After a century, native assimilation through education was forsaken as the official goal of the Canadian government. However, Kevin Busswood, speaking on behalf of the Members of the Association of Canadian Community Colleges states, " educational institutions fail to recognize the hidden agenda through which they are presenting the industrial of life as the only way to go". He further stated, "it is not very useful to lament the effects of colonialism when its institutions are still alive and well in Canada" (Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples, 1994). Therefore, it is possible to conclude that through the hidden curriculum the educational system is continuing to promote
the superiority of a non-native lifestyle. Thus, this is the reason many natives stood in strong opposition to early residential schools. Susan Awashish of the council of the Atikamkw of Manawan Nation states, "If one...society imposes its [institutions] on the other, the latter will react with hostility, adopting an adversarial attitude, because it feels restricted where its most fundamental rights are concerned...We believe that a dominant society has the responsibility to protect its minorities from eventual assimilation" (Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples,1993). This is also the reason many natives today view the education required in white schools to be irrelevant with regards to the traditional native lifestyle.
It is apparent that to many degrees, cultural assimilation through education did not work for a variety of reasons. Although early native students were culturally displaced in white schools, they continued to take tremendous pride in their heritage. It was impossible for the...

Find Another Essay On Native Underachievement in Canadian Schools

Myths, Symbols and Images in select poems of Jeannette C. Armstrong

1393 words - 6 pages culture onto the aboriginals who had diverse and varied rituals, customs and traditions. Even the judicial system in Canada had been a biased one and enforced different laws for the natives and the whites. The native cannot enjoy their rituals, cannot drink and spend their time in merry-making; if they are found so, they are subjected to punishment whereas a non-native is not. The Residential schools are another threat to the natives. The children

Discrimination in Canada in the 1920s

1155 words - 5 pages that this act was really applied. The Indian Act had been created earlier, but the Canadian government never seriously implemented it to get rid of the Aboriginal culture once and for all until the 1920s. The government funded Residential schools and they were an extremely effective way to make the Aboriginal children forget their traditions. At first, attendance at these schools was voluntary but in 1920 all aboriginal children between the ages of

The Myriad Dynamics of State Policies Shaping Canadian Aboriginal Society

1769 words - 8 pages will focus on how the larger Aboriginal setting in Canada has intrinsically linked race to all other aspects of their development through: the Haudenosaunee women’s lacrosse team, the 2010 Vancouver Olympic games, the lasting effects of residential schools and the national tragedy of missing women. Sports have long been apart of the construction of Canadian identity, although racial and gender based issues have been a defining factor in league


872 words - 4 pages It was evident that these teachers affirmed their students’ native languages. The teachers focused on the content that the students were learning and allowed students to respond in whatever language they preferred. The teachers’ affirmation of the students’ native languages ended up affirming the students themselves. This maximized student involvement, participation and understanding. The traditional schooling model is not meeting the needs

Argument Against Native Sovereignty in Canda

2131 words - 9 pages This paper supports Thomas Flanagan's argument against Native sovereignty in Canada; through an evaluation of the meanings of sovereignty it is clear that Native sovereignty can not coexist with Canadian sovereignty. Flanagan outlines two main interpretations of sovereignty. Through an analysis of these ideas it is clear that Native Sovereignty in Canada can not coexist with Canadian sovereignty. The first interpretation of sovereignty that

Residential Schools

912 words - 4 pages forward and share their experiences in residential schools. Residential schools were once seen as a common sense solution to what was believed to be a native problem (). Bringing awareness to the issue and recognizing the problems with this policy will help prevent further violations of rights and liberties. Conclusion The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is in place to ensure the citizens of Canada are protected from unreasonable

Residential School Abuse in Canada

3108 words - 12 pages thought of the First Nations people as savages, and the goal of the residential schools was to civilize them and integrate them in to white Canadian society. The first operators of residential schools thought of their forced integration as a benefit to native peoples. One of the overseers of residential schools wrote to the Sisters in charge of St. Joseph's Mission at Williams Lake that “It now remains for you to say whether these girls will be

Aboriginal Human Rights

2390 words - 10 pages true to their agreement. The social, political and economic inequities present in Native communities throughout Canada are a result of the inadequate response of the Canadian government. It is obvious that this Aboriginal versus government battle has been going on for far too long and it is an unfair challenge to the virtually helpless group of minorities.Aboriginal people have a long and proud history that includes rich cultural and spiritual

Fifth Generation of Native People Fallout

1259 words - 5 pages generation of native people in Canada are greatly impacted by efforts made by the Canadian government that forced previous generations to assimilate and give up their culture. Most of the fifth generation of native people are not directly impacted by the atrocities that forced their people to give up their culture for the benefit of others; however, their diminished cultural identity is a result of it. Parents who are raising the fifth generation

religion paper

1279 words - 6 pages still more likely than the native-born to be in low-skilled jobs” (Stats Canada, 2008). Therefore immigrants are willing to give up their home countries and their roots just to maintain a low skilled job in Canada. So yes, the immigrants are providing huge benefits to the Canadian matrix, their multiculturalism provides us with cheap labor. But, perhaps the most interesting thing to point out in the quote by Statistics Canada is the use of native

Aftermath of Residential Schools

936 words - 4 pages residential school on first Nations include the loss of intellectual, spiritual beliefs, and emotional trauma.The Native children were denied legitimate schooling because they did not spend much time learning in the classrooms and did not receive the proper education like the Canadian children (Hare and Barman 336). In Hare and Barman's opinion, life at the schools was often harsh and rules were strict (336). Native children spent most of the day in

Similar Essays

Home Economics In Canadian Schools, 1919 1944

2740 words - 11 pages Separate School at ‘U’,” The Winnipeg Evening Tribune, April 19, 1943, 13. Ted Schrader. “Education for Life,” The Winnipeg Evening Tribune, April 26, 1943, 6. “Urges School Emphasis on Homemaking,” The Globe and Mail, April 4, 1944, 9. Secondary Sources: Linda Peterat and Mary Leah Dezwart, eds., “The Pioneers: 1900-1925; View Points of the Times.” An education for women: the founding of home economics education in Canadian public schools. Charlottetown: the Home Economics Publishing Collective, UPEI, 1995. Print. Mary Leah Dezwart, The Red Book Revealed: British Columbia’s Home Economics Secret 1930-1975. British Columbia History Vol. 40, no.2, 2007.

The Impact Of Sports In Native American Boarding Schools

1978 words - 8 pages wonder that sport is often a reflection of the society that it occupies. One such society that was deeply impacted by the role of sport is that of Native American boarding school students in the 1800’s and 1900’s. These students lived tough lives but just like how it had helped other cultural societies, sport was able to provide these students with basic needs of autonomy and pride. At these boarding schools, Native American children were able

Native American Education Essay

1395 words - 6 pages directly repressed their culture and identity through the Indian boarding schools. There were rules put in place such as cutting the children’s hair, changing their names, diet, dress, and identity. Educators wanted Native American children to speak English, worship God, and assume American gender roles (Davis). Also, many Native American’s strongly believed that abuse of an infant would lead to the death of its soul or some physical abnormality

Assimilation Through Education Essay

1578 words - 6 pages achievement. They were either unable to attend school, or the schools lacked proper infrastructure or culturally appropriate curriculum . On returning to their Native communities, Native children of this education system were expected to encourage and support their Christian teachings and culture . Under the agreement in the Constitution Act of 1867 and ensuing Indian Act of 1876, the Canadian government assumed responsibility for Natives and began