Neo Aristotelian Analysis Of Chief Sagoyewatha’s Speech To Missionaries; 1805

3232 words - 13 pages

Bertsch 1
A Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha's ("Red Jacket") Oration to Christian Missionaries, 1805
By Kevin Bertsch
Prepared for Professor Mary Walch COM 3343; CRN 10617 in Rhetorical Criticism
Spring 2014 Semester

Bertsch 2
A Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha's ("Red Jacket") Oration to Christian Missionaries, 1805
by Kevin Bertsch
Introduction
Sagoyewatha later dubbed "Red Jacket", because he frequently wore an embroidered coat given
to him by the British as a gift, was a Seneca Chief of the Iroquois Confederacy situated primarily in the
North Eastern part of what is now the United States of America. Founded in the 15th century or earlier
the confederacy was originally comprised of the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca
nations. The Five Nations incorporated the Tuscarora tribe in the early 18th century and was thereafter
known as the Six Nations. Extending east to Lake Ontario and Lake Erie and as far north as Quebec,
Canada, the Iroquois Confederacy covered approximately 4/5ths of what is now New York State. At the
time that refugees fleeing religious persecution in Europe landed on the shores of North America, the
Iroquois Confederacy had existed as a socio-political entity for more than 300 years. This democratic
union derived its power from a constitution that bound the individual tribes together for mutual support
and protection. Known as the "Laws of the Great Peace", it was this concept of separate political
entities joined together in a democratic union that became the model for the founders of the fledgling
United States to develop the three-branch system of government comprised of the Legislature, Senate
and House of Representatives. (Murphy)
Description of the Artifact
Having sided with the British during the Revolutionary War, in the years after cessation of
hostilities, Red Jacket was instrumental in facilitating peace talks and establishing diplomatic ties with
the newly formed United States Government and the Six Nations. In 1805, a Christian missionary society
from New England requested permission from Red Jacket to proselytize the Iroquois settlements in
northern New York. Led by Jacob Cram, They traveled to Buffalo Creek, New York to meet with the
elders of the Iroquois Confederacy and discuss the request. Red Jacket's speech was highly logical and

Bertsch 3
utilized terminology intended to foster consubstantiality between him and the missionaries. During the
oration, he argues that it would be preferable to preserve the status quo and respect each groups right
to practice their faith the way it had been passed down to them from their ancestors. Although very
skillfully and persuasively presented, ultimately, the missionaries rebuffed Red Jacket's attempt to reach
a compromise an added insult to injury by refusing to accept his hand in friendship at the conclusion of
his response.
Description of the Analytical Method
Well known as a skilled orator, Sagoyewatha's name, roughly...

Find Another Essay On Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha’s Speech to Missionaries; 1805

Analysis of Othello's Speech

1153 words - 5 pages gone through. Like many women, Desdemona fell in love with dangers and thrill of the chase. It seems like most of us women love the adventures of seeking what we know is wrong. This passage is a soliloquy or speech from Othello to Desdemona’s father. He is telling how she has become his wife. Othello plea’s with Desdemona’s father for his blessing and to be a family. Othello states that her father has treated him well for many years and should

Neo-Aristotelean Criticism of Susan B. Anothony's Speech on Women Rights

2802 words - 11 pages appeal to others emotions through the delivery of her speech? Did Anthony succeed in inspiring other citizens and women above all to be courageous to fight for the right to equality even being given all the limits that were imposed on women at the time? This analysis seeks to contribute to our understanding of how rhetoric, employed in public speeches, may achieve a persuasive purpose. What is unclear is how Anthony was able to achieve her purpose

Dan George:Hollywood's Chief. An Analysis of White Ownership over Native American Imagery in 1970s Hollywood Cinema

3558 words - 14 pages Dan George: Hollywood's Chief.An Analysis of White Ownership over Native American Imagery in 1970s Hollywood.erhaps no other event more ideally encapsulated the ludicrous, almost anarchical, extremes of mainstream Hollywood's politicization during the 1970s then Oscar night 1973. As the evening's festivities approached their inevitable conclusion, time came to announce the winner of one of the film industry's most coveted honours, the Academy

Abraham Lincoln: From an Innocent Child to the Chief of a Bloody War

1216 words - 5 pages speech was the Gettysburg Address. He elaborately explained the purpose of the war and human equality (History.com). He stated, “Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves” (BrainyQuote). Lincoln was simply hinting at the fact that no one, no matter who they are or what they look like, deserves to be bound by the fetters of slavery. Abraham Lincoln encountered enmity because he did not believe the same way as others did when

How did neo-confucianism respond to the changes of late Ming society?

1854 words - 7 pages who replaced him with theirpuppet emperor, Wei Zheng Xian. The eunuchs used their power to persecutethe Dong Lin and other interest groups and impose harsh tax laws, sparkinginsurrection and riots. This was the climate to which neo-confucianism hadto adapt. In it's original form, new-confucianism, as taught by Zhu Xi, wasall about the study of the Classics and history in order to learn the Way.One had to look outside one's self to learn the correct

Rhetorical Analysis of JFK's Inauguration Speech

910 words - 4 pages John Fitzgerald Kennedy delivered one of the most important American speeches after being sworn in as president on January 20, 1961. His inauguration speech was so influential that it seized the nation’s attention, and quotes from it are still clearly remembered by people today. It is considered one of the best speeches ever written and ever delivered. It presents a strong appeal to pathos, ethos, and logos and accomplishes what any speaker

Analysis of the Emancipation Proclamation Speech

1643 words - 7 pages The "Emancipation Proclamation" speech was actually intended for most of the people that would free the slaves, not to the slaves. According to Rollyson the proclamation was not intended for the slave, blacks, or former slaves. The “Emancipation Proclamation” speech was during the Antislavery Movement or what some people call it the Abolitionist Movement, during the 1960's. The main leaders of the abolitionist movement were Abraham Lincoln and

Rhetorical Analysis of President Obama's Inauguration Speech

1398 words - 6 pages On January 20, 2009, President Obama was officially inaugurated and sworn in as the forty-fourth president of the United States of America. The tradition of being inaugurated requires the president to give a speech about the goals they want to reach during their presidency. The president must make a speech that appeals to the audience while being professional. Rhetoric is a useful strategy to utilize in speech making. Obama uses rhetoric to

Rhetorical Analysis of Antony’s Funeral Speech

1129 words - 5 pages believing in Caesar and consequently, the Second Triumvirate. By combining a subtle use of questions and interjections to keep audience engaged, a variety of rhetorical devices devices that dignify Caesar and himself, and an effective use of all three modes of persuasion, Antony is able to convert the audience to his cause while destroying the conspirators’ credibility.   While Mark Antony’s speech is a eulogy Caesar’s funeral, it gradually

Analysis of Brutus and Antony's Speech

642 words - 3 pages assassinating Caesar which is the love for Rome. He compares two kinds of love in his speech, love for Caesar and love for Rome, “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more”. When these two loves contradict each other due to the ambition of Caesar, which in Brutus perspective, will destructs Rome, Brutus chooses to love Rome because a honorable man cares the felicity of his country, a collective of people rather than the benefit of one single

Rhetorical Analysis of Swami Vivekananda’s Speech

853 words - 3 pages the numerous human minds of those times. First, it is important to underline the rhetorical introduction of Swami Vivekananda. Indeed, Hindu monk surprised and quite shocked a lot of attendants on the meeting with non-standard intro: “Sisters and Brothers of America” (1). There was no addressing to Mrs. or Ms., as well as he did not start his speech with standard cliché ‘ladies and gentlemen’. Practically, Swami used powerful metaphoric

Similar Essays

A Neo Aristotelian Essay On Martin Luther King's I Have A Dream Speech

1723 words - 7 pages this speech was everyone present at the March; however, given the speech’s location and occasion of delivery, it is probable that Dr. King might also intend to target the nation’s lawmakers in Washington. In this speech, he seeked to call for changes from both the white and black communities during the Civil Rights era, and ask for peace and harmony from both sides, instead of conflict and violence. By creatively structuring his speech to target

Work Of The Christian Missionaries: Converting China To Christianity

1353 words - 5 pages The Christian missionaries knew it wasn’t going to be easy. Going to China at the time was a one way trip to an unknown land. The task of converting China to Christianity was rife with challenges due to continued resistance to any sort of outside influence that was a tradition of China for many years. Never-the-less the missionaries still went to China and by leveraging what advantages they could find, they were able to find some measure of

Analysis Of George W. Bush's 9/11 Speech To Congress

961 words - 4 pages relaxed. Many of the congressmen, indeed, much of the American people, had the same questions that Bush brought forward, and they clung to his every word in the hopes of shedding light upon the mystery of 9/11. The questions were well chosen, as they allowed the President to steer the speech in a direction that would justify immediate action, as apposed to a more reserved, cautious approach.Bush incriminated bin Laden and his cohorts of Al-Qaeda, and

Analysis Of Patrick Henry's Speech To The Virginia Convention

842 words - 3 pages “Give me liberty or give me death!” This statement from Patrick Henry’s “Speech to the Virginia Convention,” delivered to the House of Burgesses, has been quoted by many, becoming almost cliché. However, the declaration is truly understood by a select few. The unjust Stamp Act passed by the British crown in 1765, brought fame and notoriety to Henry as he spoke out against the unjust taxation without representation. Ten years later on the eve of