This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

New Historicist Criticism: Macbeth And Power

1166 words - 5 pages

Stripped of Shakespeare's poetic style and skilful characterization, Macbeth is revealed as little
more than a petty tyrant. Like Machiavelli's Prince, Macbeth seeks power as an end in itself and
sees any means as justified provided it helps him achieve his goal. It is a standard image of power: an individual, or small group, occupying a position of authority from which he (seldom she) attempts to force his will upon others. Today's equivalent of a feudal monarch is the power-hungry politician, the cult leader, or the ruthless business tycoon. But the new historicist conception of power is different; rather than being a top-down affair that originates from a specific place or individual, power comes from all around us, it permeates us, and it influences us in many subtle and different ways. This idea of decentralized power, heavily indebted to post-structuralist philosophy (see Derrida and Foucault), is sometimes difficult to understand because it seems to have an intangible, mystical quality. Power appears to operate and maintain itself on its own, without any identifiable individual actually working the control levers.
This new historicist notion of power is evident in Macbeth in the way in which Macbeth's apparent subversion of authority culminates in the re-establishment of that same type of authority under Malcolm. A ruthless king is replaced with another king, a less ruthless one, perhaps, but that is due to Malcolm's benevolent disposition, not to any reform of the monarchy. Similarly, the subversion of the play's moral order is contained, and the old order reaffirmed, by the righteous response to that subversion. In other words, what we see at the beginning of the play--an established monarch and the strong Christian values that legitimize his sovereignty--is the same as what we see at the end of the play, only now the monarchy and its supporting values are even more firmly entrenched thanks to the temporary disruption.
It is almost as if some outside force carefully orchestrates events in order to strengthen the existing power structures. Consider, for example, a military leader who becomes afraid of the peace that undermines his position in society. In response to his insecurity, he creates in people's minds the fear of an impending enemy--whether real or imaginary, it doesn't matter.
As a consequence of their new feelings of insecurity, people desire that their leader remain in
power and even increase his power so that he can better defend them from their new II enemy. II
The more evil and threatening our enemies are made to appear, the more we believe our own
aggressive response to them is justified, and the more we see our leaders as our valiant protectors
(Zinn,Declarations of Independence 260-61,266). Military or political power is strengthened, not
weakened, when it has some kind of threatening subversion of contain ( Greenblatt 62-65).
The important point about the new historicist notion of power, however, is that it is not...

Find Another Essay On New Historicist Criticism: Macbeth and Power

War and Lust of Power in Macbeth by William Shakespeare

1007 words - 4 pages Considered one of the darkest and most influential of the tragedies, William Shakespeare’s Macbeth tells of the effects one suffers due to war and the lust for power. Macbeth himself is led to believe that he deserving and destined to become the king of Scotland, and allows his thoughts and actions to become corrupted due to his ambition. While Macbeth loses himself in his conspiracies to murder his king and his friends, the character of Macduff

Analysis of Macbeth and His Struggle for Power

1995 words - 8 pages In William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth, there is a constant struggle for power by Macbeth that leads to many problems, not only for himself, but for the very nature of Scotland as well. While examining the play Macbeth, we will prove how Macbeth’s ambition for power will affect the natural order of the world and show how he is an unjust ruler. In the beginning of the play Macbeth, Macbeth was viewed as a righteous and brave man; and had

Ambition and Power as the Dominant Theme in Shakespeare’s Macbeth

1957 words - 8 pages In Macbeth, the dominant theme would be ambition and power. This theme presents itself as a dangerous quality. Ambition is extremely dangerous in this play because this leads to the downfall of both Lady Macbeth and Macbeth and triggers a series of deaths. Therefore ambition and power are the driving forces of this play. Power is also the dominant theme of this play because most of the people that are in the play are power-hungry such as Lady

Abuse of Power by Macbeth and President Obama

907 words - 4 pages Macbeth and President Obama both abuse their power by killing and getting away with it, lying to their followers, and bribing. Macbeth was a great General in battle and a loyal servant to the king until he began to make bad decisions, fall to temptation, and even kill. The first thing that Macbeth did wrong was make bad decisions. His wife, Lady Macbeth, told him that he needed to kill Duncan. His response was just as she

Unchecked Power in Shakespeare's Macbeth and King Lear

1470 words - 6 pages between the tragic heroes in Macbeth and King Lear. However, the differences between the two outline the re-occurring themes in both plays. In Shakespeare's plays the central characters' own weaknesses and lust for power lead to corruption. The unchecked power in Shakespeare's Macbeth and King Lear ultimately leads to corruption, tragedy, and the hero's fall from grace.In Macbeth, Macbeth's power goes unchecked within himself, his wife, and within

Macbeth in William Shakespeare´s Macbeth and Osama Bin Laden: Power Hungry

836 words - 4 pages thinks life is meaningless because every person will pass away and they are all just waiting helplessly. Macbeth drastically transforms throughout the play and it is especially evident in the end. He is now saying that one’s life, the brief candle, is meaningless, pointless, and once one passes away, he or she is not even thought about twice. In conclusion, Macbeth is exceedingly greedy for power, which forces him to enact terrible things out of fear

The "Flip-side" of Power An essay on the conflict of power and safety in Macbeth

935 words - 4 pages other, and a similar phenomenon is found in our everyday lives. This relates to William Shakespeare's Macbeth. The protagonist is lured to murder King Duncan by the desire for power, an appetite whetted by the witches' prophecies and his wife's encouragement. But when he obtains the thrown, he finds himself insecure. He attempts to remove threats that decrease his security. In the play Macbeth, despite appearances of paradox, Shakespeare uses the

Macbeth's Weak Mindset, Lust for Power, and Quest for Blood in Shakespeare's Macbeth

1547 words - 6 pages , proclaiming Malcolm, Duncan's son, as the heir-apparent.”(Garcia 12) At the end of the story things take an unfortunate turn for Macbeth as his quest for blood leads to him being murdered at the hands of MacDuff. After Macbeth is murdered all peace is returned to the city of Glemis. As the play goes on, Macbeth becomes increasingly obsessed with his quest for power. He begins to loose his sense of morale and loyalty, and develops an entire new

Man Versus Self, Man, and World: The Corrupting Power of Ambition in Macbeth

1275 words - 5 pages The vigorous desire to achieve a goal holds the capability of having a great affect in one’s life. William Shakespeare's play Macbeth establishes the immense effect and influence of ambition. After gaining power over his country, Scotland, the protagonist, Macbeth, experiences an internal battle as he fights between his ambition and conscience. He also destroys stable relationships with others as his selfish goals hurt those around him when

Effect of power upon relationships, "Macbeth," "Prometheus Bound," and "Ubu Roi"

1774 words - 7 pages brother's hands. The works of Prometheus Bound, Macbeth, and Ubu Roi all make use of this literary melody, a strong relationship destroyed by one of it's own members as the tumultuous climb into power is undertaken. The first component of this equation is of course the bond that will ultimately be broken. In a work by Aeschylus, entitled Prometheus Bound, this bond is shattered prior to the commencement of the play. Preceding Prometheus being

Macbeth essay plan about ambition , power and roles in their marriage - english lit - Essay

491 words - 2 pages Saturday, 21 January 2017 Essay plan English Ideas : Ambition/Power Macbeth isn't really ambitious as he says he is going to stop because he knows he is going too far - “Vaulting ambition, which o’erleaps itself, And falls on th’other” Falls also foreshadows the big fall of macbeth and his wife further on the play. Vaulting emphasises how far they are going Lady macbeth is more ambitious than Macbeth - Lady macbeth has always wanted more power

Similar Essays

Modernism And New Criticism Essay

3204 words - 13 pages Modernism and New Criticism The ways in which we define the importance of texts is constantly changing. We can look back and see critical theories used, such as Historical Criticism, Reader-Response Criticism and Psychoanalytic Criticism. Each of these theories offers a different way to interpret a text. However, when looking back over the texts of a specific era, shouldn’t the type of criticism we used for a book be based on that time

Powmac Power And Corruption In Macbeth

2098 words - 8 pages Power and Corruption in Macbeth       "Authority poisons everybody who takes authority upon himself" (Vladimir Ilyich Lenin). This could easily be a comment on the story of Macbeth where an apparently respected Scottish couple have the opportunity to seize the highest authority, take it, and in doing so, poison themselves and their country. In Macbeth, the play's theme is the strife created by the wrongful seizure of power and the

Macbeth And Lady Macbeth’s Lust For Power

983 words - 4 pages Macbeth and Lady Macbeth’s lust for power has caused them to make unforgivable decisions the created despair and chaos in Scotland. In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, many characters are driven by not just ambition but the lust for power. But none of the characters in the play Macbeth can compare to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth has to gain power. These characters showed the sin Gluttony. Gluttony is when you consume yourself with

"Macbeth" And "Brave New World" Comparison Essay

1326 words - 5 pages Freedom and individualism are a significant component of contemporary society, however there are many parts of the world where these basic human rights are not granted.The lack of these basic rights are clearly demonstrated in the novel Brave New World by Aldous Huxley and the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare. The leaders of many societies are willing to sacrifice innocent lives in order for society to function according to their visions