Newborns And Infants In Need Of Organ Transplant

1392 words - 6 pages

The situation that B’s parents are faced with is not an easy one. Having the courage to, in a way, harm their own daughter in hopes of helping other babies is commendable to many. In today’s society the demand for organs far outweighs the supply, but for newborns and infants who need transplants the shortage is especially dire. B’s parents have the ability to help several of those babies who need healthy organs. Unfortunately, they are unable to wait until B dies naturally to be able to harvest her organs. Nevertheless, she is only expected to live for a few days until her vital functions fail. There are many strong arguments for both sides, but in my opinion terminating the life of B to harvest her organs is the right thing to do.
Essentially, B is a purely biological life. There is no mental functioning, which also means there is no morality. Even with no functioning brain, B’s brain stem is supporting all of her vital functions that are keeping her alive. This presents the first moral principle in question; is B going to be harmed if they take her life before her body actually succumbs to the anencephaly? B’s parents believed that since she was going to die soon, her organs were doing her no good. Babies with anencephaly never experience any degree of consciousness, so one might argue that they are also free of any pain or suffering. Others might argue the fact that there is no way of knowing if B would be harmed, but it is clear that being alive is not benefitting her in any way. She has no chance of living a life with real relationships and experiences. B might live a few more days, but it would be of no benefit to her. It might be a loss for others, essentially her parents, but not for her.
By allowing such organ donations, the parents would be able to seek solace in the fact that although they lost their child, they were able to help several other children in the process. B’s parents would be able to give meaning to her short life through life-saving organ transplants to others. This concept of looking at how much good would come from the situation relates to the Utilitarian’s Principle of Utility. For Utilitarians, when choosing an action, we should choose the one that would promote the most overall happiness and minimize overall pain. This principle applies to all beings with interests and preferences and who can experience pain and pleasure. Many would argue that since B is not able to have any interests, she should not be considered when weighing the options. Aside from this, the real dilemma is whether B’s life promotes more happiness than the other children’s lives that her organs would help save.
Since B cannot experience pleasure, she is not in the moral sphere of this Utilitarian argument so you would next need to take into account the parents’ happiness. Naturally, they are going to experience grief with the passing of their child, but they were the ones who proposed donating her organs in the first place. Through analyzing...

Find Another Essay On Newborns and Infants in Need of Organ Transplant

Birth Injury and Birth Trauma in Newborns

738 words - 3 pages Birth injuries or birth trauma is the damage of tissues or organs during or shortly after childbirth. This includes any damage that is long term including brain and cranium injuries. Injuries at birth can often times be a result of doctor or nurse error. Trained professionals that are caring for you and the baby during and after the birth must watch out for any signs that could result in a birth injury. Sadly, reports indicate that about 40

Social referencing and Synchrony in infants

554 words - 2 pages act in response to their mother, differently from their father. Most young infants will want to comply with their mothers wishes. In an experiment, with infants and mothers, infants were ordered not to lay a hand on toys, within easy reach. Mostly, the infants complied with this instruction. This result was accomplished by the mothers, giving facial expressions or a tone in their voice. About half of fourteen-month-olds and virtually all twenty

Health and Medical Care of Infants

1355 words - 5 pages Every day, physicians called pediatricians are helping and treating children’s illnesses and making sure they are healthy. Dr. Ananya Mandel describes pediatrics “as the branch of medicine dealing with the health and medical care of infants, children and adolescents from birth up to the age of 18” (Ananya l). Pediatricians work with children and care about their health. Without pediatricians, children wouldn’t receive special treatment, which

A Comparison of Medical Transplants and Organ Donation in Canada and China

1410 words - 6 pages necessary before distributing and high-risk organ (CBC News, 2008). Selling the organs commercially is also prohibited in all provinces in Canada. Statics Organ Donation and Transplant in China Organ Donation and Transplant in Canada Medical transplantation has been seen a rapid increase in the past 20 years. There are more than one million more who need organ transplant every year. According to the Chinese Ministry of Health, there is

Separation Anxiety and Attachment in Infants and Toddlers

2859 words - 11 pages 1937 who was interested in “’maternal overprotection’ – the emotional impact of mothers who are anxious, overly cautious, and generally infantilizing of their young” (Karen, 1998, 16). His study involved several young children who had not had maternal care as infants and seemed unable to connect emotionally with their adoptive parents. He remarked that these children appeared to be suffering from “primary affect hunger,” which Levy defined as

Ethics and the Commercialization of Organ Transplants

1084 words - 4 pages commercialization of organ transplant can be considered ethical. Seeing the wide gap that exists between the availability and the need of organs for transplant, it really seems essential to facilitate sales of organs to meet the demand and to save lives. Consented organ donations till now in our society have remained limited and not all people agree to it. Seeing the demand for cadaveric organs for transplantation, it does not appear possible that the

The process of organ and blood donation

2519 words - 11 pages donation, and blood donations; patients are put on a waiting list. A new person is added to the list every 10 minutes. The factors of being the next one to have a transplant range from how severe the patient is, and how long they’ve been on the waiting list down to their blood type. Up to 1,000,000 people need lifesaving and improving tissues each year, you’re never to old to donate! Some people think that if they become an organ donator they won’t

Cleft Palate and Cleft Lip: Defect in Infants

1484 words - 6 pages Cleft Palate and Cleft Lip is one of the most common facial defects in infants. However, surgery can correct either defect or both. Scientists believe that environmental and genetic factors though don’t have a specific cause in which they can prevent Cleft Palate or Lip to occur. “Cleft Palate is a split or opening in the roof of the mouth, and can involve the hard palate and/or the soft palate… Cleft Lip is the physical split or separation of

The Process of Organ and Blood Donation

2624 words - 10 pages ), are active with intravenous (IV) drugs, or are a male that has been in prison in the past six months. When it comes to organ and blood donations, patients are put on a waiting list. A new person is added to the list every ten minutes. (Unknown) The factors of being the next one to have a transplant range from how severe the patient is, and how long they have been on the waiting list, down to their blood type. Up to 1,000,000 people need

Prognosis for Infants and Children with Tetralogy of Fallow

1847 words - 8 pages the initial assessment after birth, these infants may have a pronounced murmur. They also have hypercyanotic episodes known as “tet spells” because it is seen in infants with Tetralogy of Fallow. This happens when the infants oxygen demands exceeds the blood supply Cyanosis may be present during feeding and these infants need time to learn how to suck, swallow, and breathe simultaneously. Until that happens, the infant remains at risk for

Examples of Genocide. Speaks of The Catholics in Northern Irland, the Armenians, and the extermination of the newly born female infants in China

736 words - 3 pages Young Turk Government were found guilty of carrying out the killing by a secret network (Armenian Genocide). The decision to eradicate the Armenians was not an impulsive decision, but 'the result of extensive and profound deliberations' (Armenian Genocide).In the case with China, genocide resulted in the extermination of the newly born female infants. Since ancient times, the Chinese have regarded the males to be precious and more prestigious than

Similar Essays

Organ Transplant And Donation Essay

1897 words - 8 pages Coronary Artery Disease, or abnormalities and defects such as biliary atresia, can all disrupt the function of human organs (“Transplant Australia”, n.d ). Thankfully, through radical advancements in modern medicine, organ transplants are a safe and highly viable option to restore the human body’s perfect harmony. No matter the reason for organ failure, once it occurs, the patient’s journey to receiving a new organ begins. Through the matching

Commercialization Of Organ Transplant Essay

1132 words - 5 pages   In the era of science and technology organ transplant has become important part of the treatment. Transplantation of organs from one body to other body provides better health and treatment. Transplantation of organs is also important for us because it reduce continuous medicine cost. Besides few disadvantage like matching problem organ transplant holds many advantages. Many people donate their organs in order to help their beloved ones or

Artificial Organ For Transplant And Therapeutic Protein

819 words - 4 pages Artificial organ for transplant The next application of animal biotechnology in pharmaceutical is artificial organ for transplant. Organ transplant can be defined as “a surgical operation where a failing or damaged organ in the human body is removed and replaced with a new one” (Paul, Valapour, Bartele, Abbott-Penny, & Kahn, 2004, p.5). According to Paul, Valapour, Bartele, Abbott-Penny, and Kahn (2004), example of organs that can be

Measuring Mecury Levels In Mothers And Newborns

772 words - 3 pages Our study showed that 203 newborns (13%) and 176 mothers (11.2%) had mercury concentrations greater than the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) reference dose of 5.8 µg/lL (US EPA, 2007). However, there have arguments that this limit should be lowered to account for pharmacokinetic variability in cord: maternal ratio (Stern and Smith, 2003). The German Federal Environmental Agency set newly revised mercury reference values of 2.0μg/l for