Nichomachean Ethics By Aristotle: Arguments On Courage, Justice, And Pseudo Courage.

1972 words - 8 pages

In his dissertation Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle discusses his views of an ethically virtuous person. He asserts three conditions exist for the moral agent to attain ethical virtue. First, the moral agent must "have knowledge." Aristotle does not make it clear whether he means such knowledge as either knowledge of the elements of a situation or universal moral knowledge. Most likely, Aristotle means knowledge of both forms, so the moral agent is well-informed on both accounts. What he does make clear, however, is that accidental virtue due to ignorance or error is clearly not allowed. Therefore, a soldier attempting to flee battle but instead runs into the front lines is clearly not displaying courage, but rather stupidity or cowardice.Secondly, the agent must choose to act in a particular way and choose it for its own sake. This maxim illustrates that a moral action must be chosen voluntarily, and for the sake of the end appropriate to that particular virtue, not as a means for the end of another. Subsequently, eating temperately one day (i.e. the day before Thanksgiving) in order to facilitate a gluttonous next day (i.e. Thanksgiving) would not be exercising temperance at all. In fact, this situation would be the exact opposite of exercising virtue - the application of "temperance" is directed at an inappropriate end, only allowing for gluttony - an excess, and the true end of the application of the virtue.Thirdly, and lastly, Aristotle enumerates that the agent's decision to practice the virtue must "proceed from a firm and unchangeable character." By this statement, Aristotle means that a truly virtuous person is virtuous all the time - not simply when it is convenient and easy. Surely, practicing the virtue of generosity only when money is readily available does not possess the virtue of generosity at all. The genuinely virtuous person will be generous at all times, even when he is in a difficult financial situation.In summary, according to the conditions placed on being ethically virtuous by Aristotle, virtue can never be accidental, involuntary, or erratic. By contrast, a genuinely ethically virtuous person will posses the three conditions (have knowledge, choose voluntarily, and derived from a firm character) and execute them always in ethical dilemmas.Another aspect of Aristotle's dissertation is his discussion of when virtuous actions do not possess the ethical virtue associated with that action. A good example of this erroneous state has to do with the virtue of courage. Actual acts of courage may seem like they possess the virtue of courage, when in fact they do not. Since performing an action does not guarantee acquisition of the associated virtue, it is necessary to examine a few situations in which this is the case.Aristotle outlines five types of "pseudo-courage" that display these actions without the ethical virtue of courage that should be motivating them. The first example is that of civil courage. When a civilian is...

Find Another Essay On Nichomachean Ethics by Aristotle: Arguments on Courage, Justice, and Pseudo-Courage.

The Courage and Strength in All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque

2537 words - 10 pages The Courage and Strength in All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque As I enter my last week as a twenty-year-old, I find myself nostalgically looking back on the past two decades while wondering what life has in store for me over the next two. Where will I be in twenty years? What will I have accomplished? Where will I be living? Will I be married? Have chil… wait a minute, no, that one will have to wait a few more years

My Courage and Subpersonalities Essay

528 words - 2 pages I feel extremely afraid to face up to new situations thus the word I am selecting is courage. As in Assagioli‘s article if I keep this word in mind eventually it will become apart of my daily activities. Individual use: When used by an individual, the application may be termed psychagogic or psychosynthetic. It serves the purpose of evoking and enhancing qualities which are insufficiently developed, thereby fostering a harmonious and integral

Justice as Defined by Augustine and Aristotle

1918 words - 8 pages Justice as Defined by Augustine and Aristotle “Justice removed, then, what are kingdoms but great bands of robbers?” (Augustine, The City of God against the Pagans, p. 147[1]). Augustine makes quite a claim here. The presence or absence of “justice,” he implies, can make or break a great kingdom. What is this justice that Augustine speaks of? Is it the philosopher kings that define Plato’s “just city[2],” or perhaps Aristotle’s

Medea And Mother COurage

1283 words - 5 pages society” and the way they think a mother should naturally act by. Realistically, the instinct depends on the mother’s disposition, the way she wants to behave depends on her emotions, which cannot be articulated. Therefore, it is not possible to impose a definite set of values for how a mother should act for it varies from one mother to another. Mother Courage is a mother who fights for a living so that her three children can survive the war

Courage and Henry's Character

912 words - 4 pages simply by going to war. By the end of the book, his opinion on this seems to change dramatically. Reality really sets in at this point, and Henry discovers that battle is not all that is was made out to be. Throughout the story, Henry realizes what true courage is, and what it takes to obtain this. By facing the horrid events that he did in battle, he becomes much more mature and bold. Fleming eventually refers to what he has been through as

Strength, Courage, and Wisdom

798 words - 3 pages There are many times when song lyrics draw inspiration from poems. In many situations song writers get ideas for music through poems seeing as most are written on life experiences or events. It is evident that the poem, “The Ballad of Birmingham” written by Dudley Randall and the song “Strength, Courage, and Wisdom” written by India Arie have numerous similarities. These two works are about people who exemplify strength, courage, and wisdom

Mother Courage and Capitulation

531 words - 2 pages Mother Courage and Capitulation Brecht tells the reader that capitulation is not just an idea but a feeling and the reader's objection to the world is not as strong as it once was. He tells the reader this through Mother Courage's refusal to capitulate through out the entire work. In today's world, people like Mother Courage cannot relate to capitulation as a feeling because of the regulations that today's world has that Mother Courage's

Courage and Sacrifice

1767 words - 8 pages sat at the window sill, looking out into the horizon. A faint, dim, ephemeral tear ran down my cheek, and I lowered my head. Even Gleam, my golden retriever, seemed unusually dull. I tried to succor her by forcing on a smile, but I just couldn’t handle it; I burst out into tears. Gleam was the only true friend—other than my parents—I ever had. She understood me more than anyone. She let out a soft whimper, and for the first time today I

Essay on "Hamlet" and connections to courage, risk, and sacrifice

1103 words - 4 pages indirectly affects Ophelia and Gertrude. This procrastination is due to a lack of courage as seen by Shakespeare.We can see that both Claudius and Hamlet portray courage in how they initially react to situations. They confront the situation with determination, dexterity, and drive. However. They are quickly hindered. Hamlet masks his lack of courage by acting mad. On the other hand, Claudius masks his own cowardliness with lies. Although Hamlet begins

Mother Courage and her Children by Bertolt Brecht

1317 words - 6 pages Practice WiT- Mother Courage and her Children Topic: Analysis of war as a business in the play mother courage and her children In Brecht’s play “Mother Courage and her Children” he makes it clear that he thinks that war is a “continuation of business by other means”. To him war is not an unnatural occurrence or even a mistake made by society however it is one of societies many preconditions and is an unavoidable occurrence. Given that this is

Context in Mother Courage and her Children by Brecht

798 words - 3 pages Context in Mother Courage and her Children by Brecht There are many different contexts to the play and they are all influenced by social, cultural and historical implications. The context of the play itself and how it was written and performed for the first time and now were all influenced by events that occurred in Brecht’s life. The play itself discusses the thirty year war but is a clear reflection of the Second World War. Brecht

Similar Essays

Book Vii Of The Nichomachean Ethics By Aristotle

3234 words - 13 pages will review book VII of the Nichomachean Ethics (EN), and attempt to resolve some of the remaining questions left open by Aristotle’s critique. According to Aristotle, ethika is not an exact (akribes) science, for it only provides “usual” truths (hos epi to polu), or those that are true for most, but not all, cases. Ethics is a practical discipline, which depends on the prudent person to make competent decisions with respect to

"To Kill A Mockingbird, On Courage", Prejudice, And Justice

4045 words - 16 pages In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird, written by Harper Lee, Scout Finch, a six-year-old girl, in which the story is told/seen through the eyes of, goes through many changes, and probably the most dramatic and best-explained changes are in the courage, prejudice, and justice categories; Scout lives with her older brother, Jem, her father, Atticus, and their black maid, Calpurnia. Now, Jem is an out-going bright boy who finds many adventures with

Glaucon's Definition Of Justice From Plato's Republic. Also, Courage Is Examined In A Similar Context

315 words - 2 pages process were involved. Socrates then goes on to say that soldiers well chosen would be unwavering in their beliefs, immune to the temptations of fear or pleasure. Immunity to such outside forces would make the soldiers courageous and thus the city would be courageous. Therefore courage is the ability to hold steadfast to a belief even through adversity.

Courage In "To Kill A Mockingbird" By Harper Lee; This Focuses On True And False Courage And The Natural Characteristics Of Courageous People

794 words - 3 pages courage.Another part to courage is the ability to rise in power as the opposing morals criticize one's actions. The white society of Maycomb had an immoral bias against blacks; whites looked down on blacks and took many privileges away from them. Atticus had enough wisdom and courage to point out that this system was wrong. By defending Tom Robinson, Atticus had fought against the society courageously and righteously. Although he lost the case, he