This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Nietzsche And Wagner Essay

5162 words - 21 pages

Nietzsche and Wagner

In terms of artists and their influences, the case of Nietzsche and Wagner has been the focal point of discussion between many great academic minds of the last century. The controversy surrounding the relationship has led many to postulate that the eventual break between the two men may have contributed to the untimely death of Wagner in 1882, and Nietzsche's eight-year writing spurt from 1883 - 1888.
While investigating the details of this peculiar relationship, I was struck by the historical and philosophical depth of several discoveries, the fundamental question being this: Why was Nietzsche's perception of both Wagner's music and his character upset simply because Wagner declared his return to God? I envisioned that this question would provide a rather simple essay, one aimed at declaring the cause of the quarrel as a basic Christian vs. Atheist dispute among oversensitive philosophical minds - but this paper has turned out to be a wealth of thought, knowledge, and chance that I can't possibly express in five to eight pages.
What struck me as odd throughout my research, aside from many eerie coincidences in the progression of their lives, was how many times the subject of Ludwig van Beethoven appeared in my research, as he was Wagner's first real musical inspiration and various references are made to him. I was able to make many parallels between the life of Nietzsche and Beethoven, and it is in my opinion that the similarities between these two men are even more profound than the parallels between Wagner and Neitzsche. As academic interest in the comparison between these two men is buried beneath an overwhelming amount of material relating Nietzsche and more directly related historical characters (i.e. Wagner, Hitler), much of my paper is based purely on my own speculation and inference (I only found one useful website). I have found that the two men's lives are undeniably a subject worthy of comparison; the phases of life of Nietzsche's overman that he prescribes as the camel, the lion, and the child befit the artistic and rhetorical stages of each man's respective life with an uncanny resemblance.
With regards to popular comparison's made between Nietzsche and Wagner, Nietzsche and Hitler, Hitler and Wagner, Napoleon and Hitler, Napoleon and Beethoven, I developed an unprovable, yet intriguing, theory of how these men were all connected through a reincarnation of ideas and personalities. This theory, upon further research, has manifested itself as an integral part of Karmic New Age esoteric philosophy. In short, an ongoing practice and belief in this philosophy predicts the dawning of a new era for mankind, and I believe that the men I will discuss play an integral part in the coming of this alleged era.
"The problem I thus pose is not what shall succeed mankind in the sequence of living beings (man is an end), but what type of man shall be bred, shall be willed, for being higher in value, worthier...

Find Another Essay On Nietzsche and Wagner

Friedrich Nietzche regarding his theory 'God is dead'

1994 words - 8 pages commonly absent from school due to headaches and pains in his eyes. In 1858 through 1864, he attends Schulpforta, a Protestant boarding school where he received a very classical education. It is here that Nietzsche forms an artisticsociety with two friends. In 1867, he joined the military and entered a Calvary company. The next year he suffers a chest injury and returns to Leipzig, where he meets Richard Wagner, a man who greatly influenced him

Nietszche's view on art Essay

872 words - 3 pages himself and his art beneath him-when he knows how to laugh at himself" (Genealogy of Morals 99.) Nietzsche seizes upon the example of Richard Wagner, asking why Wagner embraced chastity in his old age, and why he wrote Parsifal. After a brief discussion of Wagner, Nietzsche concludes that we can learn little about the meaning of ascetic ideals from artists, because they always lean on the authority of some prior philosophy, morality, or

Nietzsche’s Influence on the Nazis: Intended or Misinterpreted?

2406 words - 10 pages continued to write. Many of his well-known works were written during this time such as Daybreak (1881), The Gay Science (1882/1887), Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883-85), Beyond Good and Evil (1886), and On the Genealogy of Morals (1887). Nietzsche's final active year of writing was in 1888. During this year he wrote The Case of Wagner, Twilight of the Idols, The Antichrist, Ecce Homo (although not released until 1908) and Nietzsche Contra Wagner. Concepts

The Essential Nietzsche

1724 words - 7 pages . His friendship with Wagner has undoubtedly left an impression on that man but it is unknown to what extent. It is also fair to say that Wagner himself left a prominent impression of Nietzsche, because in his later years he dedicated two books to the study and criticism of Wagner and his music. Nietzsche's ideas may not be tangible, and some of them might be absolutely incorrect in today's society, but his ideas of Master and Slave morality


4984 words - 20 pages effort to resist it. It could be argued that my views on Wagner have been too strongly influenced by Nietzsche, but I'm not a hundred percent sure of that. I discovered both Wagner and Nietzsche in 1993, but didn't get much into Nietzsche until a couple of years after that‹I started with Zarathustra, of course, but don't recall reading anything else by Nietzsche or exploring him any more deeply for some while afterwards‹by

Essay on Twilight of the Idols by Friedrich Nietzsche

2046 words - 8 pages truth is on its last legs." So the "Twilight of the Idols" serves as a short introduction to the whole of Nietzsche's philosophy. Friedrich Nietzsche's Twilight of the Idols, or How to Philosophize with a Hammer is a statement of many important aspects of his philosophy. The book's title is a satirical reference to the title of Wagner's opera, Twilight of the Gods. The hammer is a metaphor used by Nietzsche to

Friedrich Nietzsche

1744 words - 7 pages University of Bonn to study theology and classical philology. A year later, however, he abandoned theology and transferred to the University of Leipzig to pursue a doctorate in philology. At Leipzig Nietzsche became an ardent admirer of philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer, whose work he accidentally discovered in a secondhand bookstore, and the composer Richard Wagner, whom he met in 1868 and came to regard as a second father. In 1869, at the

What for Nietzsche is the Meaning of the Death of God?

2392 words - 10 pages Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) has born as a philologist and not as a philosopher, even though his innovating way of thinking, influenced remarkably the view on the meaning of life within the whole modern Europe. It is considered one of those great minds, as Marx and Freud, which have been able to create a new ideology to rely on, to create a new perspective both socially and psychologically, to give human kind a chance to open to the true

Analysis of Dostoevsky and Nietzsche's Literature

5368 words - 21 pages . Nietzsche was never one to shy away from criticizing himself (see Nietzsches Ecce Homo), his friends (see Nietzsche contra Wagner), or philosophers in general. The first chapter of beyond good and evil, appropriately named the prejudices of philosophers,” deals with the problems philosophers encounter and the error in the way they deal with these problems. Nietzsche would have delivered a harsh criticism of Rodya in the novel, crime and punishment

Sigumand Freud And Nietzsche: Personalities And The Mind

1646 words - 7 pages Sigumand Freud and Nietzsche: Personalities and The Mind There were two great minds in this century. One such mind was that of Sigmund Freud (1856-1939). In the year 1923 he created a new view of the mind. That view encompassed the idea we have split personalities and that each one have their own realm, their own tastes, their own principles upon which they are guided. He called these different personalities the id, ego, and super ego. Each


1251 words - 5 pages in one period and be rejected by another society or in an-other period" (Kovach, 68).The subjectivist insists that beauty "resides in the feelings of individual men," and if this is true, beauty also varies by culture because "the feelings of individual men are molded by the culture in which those men reside" (Jarrett, 30). However, modern objec-tivist philosopher Pete Wagner believes that "beauty in the subconscious wouldn't be in-consistent

Similar Essays

The Uberman, Friedrich Nietzsche Essay

982 words - 4 pages father"(Bentley, p.86). In 1868 Nietzsche was a student in Leipzig. This is when he met Cosima and Richard Wagner. The latter was a world-renowned musical artist. Both of these individuals were crucial to Nietzsche's development as a philosopher.Theognis was a poet of the sixth century B.C. This man supplied Nietzsche with the idea that an aristocracy "should be scientifically bred like horses"(Bentley, p.85) When Nietzsche was twenty, he had

Friedrich Nietzche Essay

1385 words - 6 pages a most unheroic contribution to mankind, wishing he had pursued a more active and socially valuable career, such as medicine. Nietzsche never was satisfied with his own value. In 1869, composer Richard Wagner invited Nietzsche to spend a winter holiday with him in Tribschen. Wagner was living with another man’s wife and was not known for his conformity. Somehow, Wagner appealed to Nietzsche’s sense of adventure. Nietzsche was so taken by Wagner

Nietszche Essay

1005 words - 4 pages century European literature and philosophy psychology. Nietzsche emphasized the Dionysian cult with its wild frenzy and other aspects of Greek culture that had otherwise been ignored. By the end of the 1870?s Nietzsche became more and more interested in the French enlightenment, which then separated ways with long time child hood friend Richard Wagner a classical composer who despised the French enlightenment. Even thought neither man had changed

Nietzsche : The Father Of Existentialism?

1833 words - 7 pages Schopenhaur. This was extremely significant to Nietzsche because this book had very radical ideas of Atheism and chaos of the world. These thoughts are some of the founding principles of existentialism; which is what Nietzsche is credited with creating. While at the University, in 1868 Nietzsche met the famous composer Richard Wagner. Wagner was one other person that helped to shape Nietzsche's beliefs; "Wagner was mostly Atheistic and believed humans