No Mandatory Community Service For Students!

690 words - 3 pages

NO Mandatory Community Service for Students!

Community service: What a wonderful opportunity for students! A chance for our younger citizens to learn responsibility, experience the satisfaction that comes with helping others and to acquire new skills.
Right? Well, that depends who you're talking to. Slip the word "mandatory" behind community service, as school districts in Maryland, Washington, D.C., and hundreds of others have done, and "opportunity" takes a new twist. Opportunity for who? For the students, or for the communities that can now capitalize on students' free labor? (Martin, pg. 13)

More than two decades ago, President Nixon ended the military draft. Now a new and more menacing form of enlistment is threatening our school systems. This enlistment I am speaking of is that we are forcing "community service" to be a requirement for high school graduation.

Compulsory service programs, already functioning in many communities, typically giving students four years to complete, say, 60 hours of labor. The students must not receive any payment. They can choose whether to serve the elderly, or the poor, or the disabled, so long as they serve others rather than themselves.

The penalty for dodging this new draft is simple: no diploma. In Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, angry parents and students took the local school board to court, arguing that such a mandatory service program for high school students imposed the kind of "involuntary servitude" forbidden by the United States Constitution. (Bowden 1998)

But a U.S. Court of Appeals approved the Bethlehem program, holding that so long as school boards stop short of putting students in chains for disobeying and so long as the students have some alternative, even an "exceedingly bad" one — there is no involuntary servitude. (Bowden 1998)

As far back as 1943, the Supreme Court made it clear that boards of education may not dictate such fundamental moral choices. In a decision that prohibited a school board from forcing young Jehovah's Witnesses to salute the flag, the...

Find Another Essay On NO Mandatory Community Service for Students!

The Importance of Volunteering: College Students Should Do Community Service Before Graduating

1311 words - 5 pages always spare time to give back. The rapidly growing demand for volunteers in communities all across America is increasing and it is everyone’s duty, especially college students, to pay their dues to the community and give back; it is our civic responsibility to give back to our communities. It is our duty as citizens to give back to our communities through volunteering; by implementing a mandatory year of community service/volunteer work for

Should students be required to perform a certain number of community service hours in order to graduate?

650 words - 3 pages read each and everyone’s statement. I think that staff and the board should make community service mandatory for students to graduate. Suggestions should always be told in this type of matter. It is important for students to give back to the community because a number of years have provided them with a wonderful public education. I have seen many students in school district that were community service is mandated, some were too shy to

America Needs Mandatory Counseling for Students

1433 words - 6 pages level of education and relationship to take place and would be beneficial for students and faculty across the country. This required time would potentially improve GPA and testing scores across the country. Altogether, many feel that mandatory counseling for high school adolescents would be beneficial, if not essential. If mandatory counseling programs were implicated in all of the high schools across America, the standards and quality of life

French Classes Should be Mandatory For Canadian Students

1811 words - 7 pages its nature. Bilinguals are more efficient at attention control; they focus on important tasks and information with ease. French courses should be mandatory for all Canadian students since bilingualism benefits meta-linguistic awareness, mental flexibility, and control of attention. Mental flexibility is superior in bilingual children since learning two language forces their minds to process two language systems at one time. Bilingualism promotes

Community Service Project Report: Voluteering in Engaging Lation Communities for Education (ENLACE) Miami

616 words - 3 pages Giving back to society is a common goal most people target, but not many complete. During the summer of 2013, it was a pleasure to do just that, and give back to the most important members of our community, the children. From June 17, 2013 to July 26, 2013 I committed myself as a volunteer of ENLACE Miami (Engaging Latino Communities for Education), which is a collaborative, community wide partnership for education taking place at Florida

No Child Left Behind Creates More Problems for Students than it does Solutions

2546 words - 10 pages . ?The NCLB Act of 2001, the revised Elementary and Secondary Education Act, is a potent blend of new requirements, incentives and resources and it poses significant challenges for states? (?Education Commission of the States,? 2003). No Child Left Behind laws require that every state must develop and implement an accountability system; ?Holding schools accountable for the performance of all students is the cornerstone of the NCLB Act? (2003

No Rest for the Students: How Rest Should Become a Priority for Students

2046 words - 8 pages How much time do we, as students, spend on the World Wide Web? I mean both studying and “studying.” You know what I am talking about. It is those breaks we take after researching an article for a paper that is due at a fast-approaching date. Of course, that is only one of the many reasons why students stay up late, whether it is doing homework or chatting away with friends and family. Students are racing against time to fulfill their duties as

Community Service Argument

630 words - 3 pages service site when their parents or friends are at work or just to busy to give them a ride. Unless the school offers a means of transportation for the students there really is no solution to this problem. The supporters argue that students can find community service projects close to home or if they live in the country find another student to car pool with. Forcing students to complete 24 hours of community service in high school in order to


2458 words - 10 pages : Recurring debate over mandatory military service has been revived as the U.S. all-voluntary military force is stretched to its limits in a war on terrorism with no clear end in sight. In 2003, Representative Charles Rangel, Democrat from New York, called for “shared sacrifice” as he introduced a bill to reinstate the military draft. The proposal required all citizens and permanent residents between ages 18 and 26 to complete two years of compulsory

Should physical education be mandatory every semester while a student completes a college degree?

984 words - 4 pages expense to any course the college decides to add to the curriculum. Any instructor will have to make accommodations for the students, no matter what the age or ability level. Some restrictions that may have to be accommodated are: brittle bones, frailty, weakened joints, weight limitations, muscle limitation or immobility, and many other potential issues not listed. On a whole, the idea of P.E. classes is a good, but to make them mandatory for

Community Service

890 words - 4 pages in my life. Volunteering and Community Service are my passion. I believe they create and instill a sense of compassion and empathy for others, values I embody in my life and teaching. My passion for volunteering is a the heart of my job at John Paul II. Community Service is worked into the Christian Ethic classes, a component which has the potential to be a meaningful, a real life experience for our students. I am the facilitator for my

Similar Essays

Should Community Service Be Mandatory For Students To Graduate

866 words - 3 pages the fact a person wanted to volunteer or not there is no denying the gratification a person gets from helping others. No one can deny the true value of community service and what it means to those that benefit. Making community service mandatory could possibly get students to get out there and make a difference and perhaps these will be the first steps for a lifetime involvement in their communities and in the constant pursuit of growth and betterment in their lives.

Service Learning Should Not Be Mandatory For College Students

1339 words - 5 pages Service learning is the name for forcing college students to do volunteer work as part of their college careers. The hope is that this volunteer work will give students a better sense of civic duty, and thus, be a worthy addition to college curriculums. However, this idea relies on the faulty premise that if one is forced to volunteer that one will derive the same benefits as someone who does it out of their own desire to help. Mandatory service

Should Community Service Be Mandatory? Essay

700 words - 3 pages time at school, but to take part of 75 hours of community service of a four-year period is a rather small number. Community service could teach teenagers responsibility, respect, and life lessens, and for an extraordinarily small amount of time and effort it helps further the community.Services volunteered by individuals or an organization to benefit a community or its institutions is the definition of community service. Majority of teenager's

"Students Should Not Be Forced To Do Community Service" This Essay Explains The Negative Effects Of Forcing Students To Fulfill A Community Service Requirement In High School.

623 words - 2 pages , and add more pressure to the already hectic life of a high school teenager. Students should not be commanded to do 75 hours of community service!To begin, requiring 75 hours of community service could be a disservice to students because it could hold many back from graduating. A lot of students have a very busy schedule and might not be able to do the required amount of time of community service. It may be mandatory to go somewhere or to do