This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

No Oedipal Complex Found In Hamlet

1146 words - 5 pages

No Oedipal Complex Found in Hamlet

 

Some scholars have interpreted Hamlet's actions throughout Hamlet to be the Oedipus complex.  According to the story of Oedipus, Laius, his father, learned from an oracle that Oedipus would kill him.  Laius then left his son to die on a mountain, where he was found and raised by the King of Corinth.  Oedipus was also told that he would someday kill his own father, and fled Corinth because he believed that the King of Corinth was his real father.  On Oedipus's journey, he passes Laius on the road, they argue and Oedipus kills Laius, without even knowing Laius was his true father.  Oedipus eventually marries his mother, Queen Jocasta, unaware of her true identity.

 

Sigmund Freud introduced the Oedipus complex, and his theory states that the individual suffers from a repressed sexual desire for the parent of the opposite sex while having a rivalry with the parent of the same sex.  Many people see a connection between Hamlet and Oedipus.  They insist Hamlet is in love with his mother and this is why he wants to kill Claudius, Hamlet's uncle and Gertrude's new husband.  They contend that Hamlet's "madness" is actually his repressed longing for his mother.  Although Hamlet and Oedipus both kill their fathers, their actions are for different reasons.  Hamlet loves his mother, but he is not in love with her or desire her sexually.  The reason behind his anger towards Claudius is not due to feelings of jealousy, but because Claudius killed Hamlet's father, whom he loved dearly.  Hamlet does not suffer from an Oedipal complex.

 

            Upon closer examination, it is clear that Hamlet and Oedipus do take the same actions in their lives, but for different reasons.  Hamlet does share the characteristic of being overly emotional like Oedipus, however, he is not excessively confident like him.  Hamlet does not act impulsively.  As soon as Oedipus discovers his fate to kill his father, he flees.  In contrast, Hamlet contemplates his actions and does not act hastily.  This is demonstrated in his "O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I" soliloquy in which he asks, "Am I a coward" for not seeking revenge sooner (II.ii.577-634).  Oedipus kills his father in a moment of spontaneous rage, not for revenge.  The parallel to Oedipus's father is King Claudius.  Hamlet's true father is dead.  Only Claudius remains in the way of Hamlet's mother, yet Hamlet does not kill Claudius as a rival.  He follows the instruction of the ghost of King Hamlet, which is to "Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder," (I.v.31).  One trying to prove the Oedipal complex theory could take the angle that the ghost was a figment of Hamlet's imagination, but the ghost is seen by Horatio, Marcellus, and Bernardo, proving it is not.  Oedipus and Hamlet...

Find Another Essay On No Oedipal Complex Found in Hamlet

Hamlet and the Oedipus Complex Essay

1549 words - 6 pages himself to the murder of Claudius, but because he is slow to action, he waits quite a while to strike. To see if Hamlet has the Oedipal complex, a few things need to be determined. How did Hamlet feel about his mother, father, and uncle? Hamlet liked and respected his father. This can be seen in the way Hamlet reacts to his death. Hamlet still wore the black clothing of a mourner a month after the death of King Hamlet. He

Hamlet by WIlliam Shakespeare Essay

2200 words - 9 pages why Hamlet didn't kill Claudius earlier in the play. Many people argue that he’s religious and is a man of inaction, but while looking through the psychoanalytic lens it is evident that Hamlet can’t kill Claudius until Gertrude is dead. Kendra Cherry is a psychosocial rehabilitation specialist who holds a Bachelor of Science in Psychology and is the author of What is an Oedipal Complex. Cherry gives a simple understanding of the Oedipal Complex

Analysis of Hamlet

2249 words - 9 pages hindered by the fact that the Oedipal Complex is by definition part of the subconscious, and therefore will not be overtly expressed by the afflicted individual, which means that the observer is forced to rely upon the observable actions of the individual. However, since there are no known stage cues for Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, in which there are more than simple perfunctory stage directions, the observer is limited to interpreting the words

Inaccessible Oedipus: Comparing Olivier's and Branagh's Women (an contrast between Gertrude and Ophelia in Lawrence Olivier's Hamlet and Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet)

1153 words - 5 pages Branagh and Olivier created film versions of Hamlet that were critically acclaimed, but only one has resonated with the contemporary viewer. Branagh’s rejection of the oedipal themes seen throughout Olivier’s film makes Branagh’s women more accessible to a modern audience than the women in Olivier’s film.Freud first introduced the idea of an Oedipus complex; he described it as a part of normal psychosexual development where a

The Many Identities of Hamlet in Hamlet by William Shakespeare

829 words - 3 pages . Furthermore, his need for vengeance for his father's death causes Hamlet to experience great anger towards his Uncle; Hamlet incorporates the Oedipus Complex in his revenge against his father's murderer, who is presently his mother's husband. At the same time, Hamlet experiences an inner conflict. He is torn between his duty to avenge his father's death and his inability to kill his uncle; which can be seen in relation to his Oedipal Complex as well

Psychoanalyzing Hamlet’s Hesitation

1089 words - 5 pages In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, the main character, Hamlet, has a disinclination to kill his father’s murderer, who is also his uncle, Claudius. Two reasons Hamlet has such a hesitation is because he suffers from guilt and the Oedipus Complex. The Oedipus Complex, in short, is the “sexual desire towards the mother,” from a boy (Seitenlicht). The Oedipus Complex, in psychoanalytic theory, is a desire for sexual involvement with the parent of the

The Oedipus Complex

2208 words - 9 pages hesitations" (Freud 282). He concludes that, because of his Oedipus complex, Hamlet has feelings of remorse and disgust against killing his uncle. He identifies with Claudius, who has fulfilled Hamlet’s oedipal desires; he has killed his father and married his mother. According to Freud, Hamlet wavers mainly because of his suppressed sexual desire for Gertrude, which is being tested by Claudius (Complex in Hamlet). Captivated by the tragedy

The Many Faces of Hamlet

1605 words - 6 pages The Many Faces of Hamlet        Of all the characters in the play, Hamlet by William Shakespeare, the character of Hamlet is without a doubt the most complex. His emotions are never stable, his feelings are constantly changing, and his behavior is confusing and inconsistent. Hamlet is described as "a half a dozen characters rolled into one" (Shaw 344) and with as many adjectives in one sentence as "cruel, angry, tender, depressed

The Superego and Hamlet

1846 words - 8 pages different; and Oediupus had no clue that his wife was his mother or that the man he killed was his father. It was all just a horrible twist of fate; not as though he had this secret desire to sleep with his mother and murder his father. And to make the generalization that all men subconsciously have an oedipal complex is just ridiculous; I in no way see a connection to how this could have affected Hamlet. In Joanna Montgomery Byles’ article

Shakespeare Psychology

1458 words - 6 pages young male, the Oedipus conflict stems from his natural love for his mother, which progressively may become sexual. Unfortunately for the boy, his father stands in the way of this love therefore, the boy feels aggression and envy towards this rival, his father” (Stevenson). The critical applications of the famous theory of the Oedipus complex to the tragedy of William Shakespeare’s Hamlet are innumerable yet the exact root of Hamlet’s obsessive

Freudian Outlook on Hamlet

1423 words - 6 pages special is that he demonstrates “unresolved oedipal complexes”, normally, this physiological state ends when the child reaches the age of six; however, Hamlet still displays it as a young adult (Murfin 314). Furthermore, what makes Hamlet different is that he loved his true father, it is his step father who is really his uncle that he feels his animosity for. One sees Oedipus complex in Hamlet when he seeks murder of his step father/uncle

Similar Essays

The Oedipal Complex In Hamlet Essay

1035 words - 4 pages The Oedipal complex in Hamlet In Shakespeare's play Hamlet, Hamlet is "burdened with his own mind" (Chute), leading the nineteenth century psychoanalysts to diagnose the poor boy post mortem. Sigmund Freud theorized that Hamlet suffered from the Oedipus complex. Others, such as T. S. Eliot, see Hamlet's relationship with his mother in a totally different light. Eliot thinks that Hamlet is just disgusted with his mother. Neither of these men is

Lady Macbeth Is The Most Interesting And Complex Character In The Play. She Is, In Fact, The Point On Which The Action Pivots: Without Her There Is No Play

990 words - 4 pages Lady Macbeth is the most interesting and complex character in the play. She is, in fact, the point on which the action pivots: without her there is no play.Macbeth's most interesting and complex character is most certainly, as the question states, Lady Macbeth. The purpose of this essay is to describe Lady Macbeth's role in the play and discuss why this makes her the most fascinating character. Her evil doings are the main reasons why she

The Oedipal Relationship Between Hamlet And Gertrude

1160 words - 5 pages Throughout William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Shakespeare portrays Hamlet with the same types of behaviors and frustrations in humans that Sigmund Freud saw at a much later date. When the relationship between Hamlet and his mother is analyzed Freud's oedipal complex theory comes to mind. The oedipal complex is a theory created by Freud that states that "The child takes both of its parents, and more particularly one of them, as the object of its

Hamlet Theories Essay

793 words - 3 pages chooses to dispose of the traitorous King Claudius. Hamlet was in love with his mother and when she died, it was as though he didn't have much left to live for. He lost his sanity much the way William Wallace did in Braveheart. After Wallace's wife died, a peace loving man was turned into a vicious warrior. It was as if Hamlet's Oedipal complex came to an abrupt halt. No mother; no secret passion. He delayed in killing Claudius because he could