This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

No Prison Time For Juvenile Crime And Violence

879 words - 4 pages

No Prison Time for Juvenile Crime


Students are shooting up schools across the country. Kids as young as twelve and thirteen are being convicted of murdering their peers. Right here in Hanover, two teens have been charged with the murders of Dartmouth professors. Although juvenile crime across the country may not be on the rise, high publicity, headline-grabbing juvenile-perpetrated homicides certainly are.


Prosecutors, attempting to satiate public demand for "justice," have begun trying these juvenile offenders in adult courts and sending them to adult prison. But is it really fair to send children into a penal system like ours, which ignores rehabilitation and is almost exclusively focused upon retribution? Is it right to essentially give up on these children at such a young age? Is this aggressive prosecution tactic in the best interest of the juvenile defendant or the community as a whole? No.


Most studies and statistics suggest that sending juveniles to adult prisons increases recidivism rates among those teens transferred. Jeffrey Fagan, who spearheaded an extensive study of juvenile offenders in New Jersey and New York, reported that not only are children sentenced as adults more likely to commit further crimes, they are more likely to be sexually assaulted while in prison, more likely to be beaten by guards, and more likely to be attacked with a weapon by fellow prisoners. This type of abuse decreases the chances for being rehabilitated, thus making those youths more dangerous to the community if and when they leave the system.


Statistics aside, sentencing a juvenile to adult time is hypocritical and morally objectionable. Recently, Lionel Tate, a 14-year-old Florida teen, was sentenced as an adult to life in prison for a murder he committed when he was 12 years old. Tate, in the eyes of the law, did not have the capacity to vote, to purchase adult products such as cigarettes and alcohol, or even to watch a PG-13 movie alone. Yet that same law claims that Tate had the capacity to fully understand the repercussions of his actions. If Tate had been convicted of shoplifting or another petty crime, prosecutors would have laughed at any suggestion of treating him as an adult. Does the nature of the crime itself, then, dictate the evaluation of a juvenile's mental capacity? Such aggressive and misguided prosecutions are in direct response to public anger toward the defendant, not necessarily motivated by what is in the best interests of justice. The inconsistency and hypocrisy in the treatment of juvenile offenders is unacceptable.


If treating violent juvenile offenders as adults is ineffective and morally objectionable, what can be done to curb this disturbing trend of...

Find Another Essay On No Prison Time for Juvenile Crime and Violence

The Development and Provison of Prison Library for Juvenile

1805 words - 7 pages . Among the criminal cases committed by students such as stealing motorcycles, burglary cases, injuring others and rape. (Nurul Adlina Kamaluddin, 2009). Increased of crime incidence among teenagers has caused many young people have wasted their time in prison. Based on studies of the Research Institute of Malaysia in collaboration with the Youth Development Center for Psychology and Development Malaysia; they have found

juvenile crime paper for school

1510 words - 6 pages . With the juvenile justice systems it is different. By wanting to keep everything in the secret, it is almost like they want to protect kids and teenagers and meet their needs, even if they did commit a crime and about to be send in the prison because of this. Also, the cases and files in the juvenile justice system might be destroyed and deleted later, which will not ever happen with adult justice system. From time to time there might changes in

Solutions for Juvenile School Violence

855 words - 3 pages Center for Education Statistics, 1 in 4 students, (grades 9 – 12), reported that one of their peers had either offered, sold, or freely given them some type of illegal substance on school property; in the 12 months prior to this survey, (Indicators of School Crime and Safety: 2006, National Center for Education Statistics, 2006). As the rates of on campus, school violence and mayhem continue to rise in the United States, we will continue to

Crime, Violence and Masculinity

1523 words - 6 pages and has become a major concern for many nations. Increasingly, much of the violence is committed by male children and teenagers. Crimes by young people are no longer just misdemeanors, but they now include the major felonies of rape, robbery and homicide. The rise in violent crime in the last few decades has been accompanied by a rise in violence in the media, especially television, movies and music. To protect society, the US government must

Developmental Crime Prevention and Juvenile Delinquency

2391 words - 10 pages is juvenile delinquency. There are many behaviors that fall under juvenile delinquency including, but not limited to violence, drug use, and truancy. These behaviors begin to develop as early as infancy due to risk factors such as poor parental supervision, child abuse, neglect, and poor social cognitive skills. Developmental crime prevention is a good strategy to combat juvenile delinquency for many reasons. As mentioned above, this strategy

Essay on Juvenile Crime and Punishment

1049 words - 4 pages well familiar with trouble. Before he was arrested for the killing, Nathaniel was suspected of committing more than 20 crimes, including beating teen-agers with metal pipes. At the time he was taken into custody, police say he was being suspected of a new crime almost daily, a crime spree prosecutors say ended in cold-blooded murder. "He had 22 police contacts, five involving a gun, two involving a student and one involving a bus driver," Oakland

Death Leaves No Time for Goodbye(s)

1024 words - 5 pages in bed, a bed that we moved to the living room, so that we could at least spend some time with him; to say that things were bad would be a gross understatement. The atmosphere at home was just so bad, that I took to going out for long walks alone, utterly disregarding the heat of Abu Dhabi. And yet, completely brushing aside his current predicament, dad insisted that the three of us (mum, dad and I) fly back here to India for the vacations

Poverty and a Lack of Education are Fueling Juvenile Crime

1740 words - 7 pages questions of overcrowding and media violence. These factors undoubtedly contribute to crime, but they do not have as much influence as poverty coupled with poor education. When trying to solve the problem of juvenile crime most people are quick to suggest increasing law enforcement and creating harsher prison sentences. These solutions will help to a certain extent, but they are treating the effects of juvenile crime instead of the causes.Some people

Prison and the Alternatives: Is Incarceration the Answer to Crime?

2143 words - 9 pages strict supervision; but, if the defendant fails to comply with the conditions of the program, he or she will return to Lancaster County Prison. Defendant's with no present or past history of violent behavior who are sentenced to Lancaster County Prison for a period of less than two years are eligible for the Intermediate Punishment Program. Defendants convicted of murder, rape, robbery, kidnapping, and drug trafficking are excluded from

Crime and Violence: Influence of Socioeconomic Status

644 words - 3 pages petty thefts for profits. Many of the people in the town were aware of it and this very much affected their view of them, they began viewing this group as troublemakers. And over time they began to engage in more and more violence. “Al threatened to beat up a teacher.”…. “Each member of the gang had been arrested at least once. (Chambliss 28) After member of the community continued to label the Roughnecks as criminal, they began to accept their

Violence and Crime within new schools

10038 words - 40 pages school year. Another survey discovered that one out of 12 students stayed home from school for fear that someone would hurt or harass them (Kreiner, 1996). Violence also hinders the learning process. Students cannot concentrate on learning and the educator cannot focus on teaching if they have fears for their own safety or have to spend most of their time disciplining.The basis of this thesis is to discuss the causes of violence and crime among

Similar Essays

Juvenile Crime And Violence In Schools

650 words - 3 pages society more callous to human life, and thus more susceptible to violent acts. Another factor influencing violence in schools is the neglect of troubled children. There are so many children crying out for help, and no one notices. Patterns of anger, raging tempers, and aggressive behavior in children should be caught at an early age and dealt with before they become serious problems. Children that exhibit signs of emotional disturbance should be

Television Violence Contributes To Juvenile Crime

623 words - 2 pages Television Violence Contributes To Juvenile Crime In the article, "Television Violence Contributes To Juvenile Crime" written by Mortimer B. Zuckerman, the idea that violence in children comes from watching violent television shows and movies is expressed. This article states that children become violent due to watching too much violence on television. This article merely states a reason why some children may become violent over time but it does

Incarceration In An Adult Prison Increases Juvenile Crime

2259 words - 9 pages because teen brains are not mature and lack understanding towards the situation, incarceration in an adult facility increases juvenile crime, and children that are sentenced to adult prison are vulnerable to abuse and rape. Society has lost touch with our children, and instead of fixing our children we ignore them. No longer are children slapped on the wrist for criminal behavior. The nation's youth is sent to prison confined in cells for hours

Violence In Entertainment Is Not Parallel To Juvenile Crime

709 words - 3 pages a change of -36% over 13 years. Meanwhile, sales of video games in 1996 versus 2008 went from $2.6 billion to $11.7 billion, respectively—effectively showing no correlation between video games and serious juvenile crime. Notwithstanding what people may say about the correlation of video games and other media to violence, people overlook that we as humans have always been violent. Humans have killed other humans a number of times over history and