This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

No Separation Of Powers In The Uk

1698 words - 7 pages

We live in a very diverse society, observance of the rule of law is the best way that can guarantee that our basic human rights are preserved, successful government at home is operating and a fair progress on the international level is maintained. Basic principles of the rule of law go back to Dicey’s theory, which states that there should be an absolute supremacy of regular law, no one should be above the law and that the Constitution is the result of the ordinary law of land. There is no clear meaning of the rule of law; therefore it is essential that the government maintains the basic principles of the rule of law that were established by the philosophers who feared the concentration of power in one’s hands, on order to prevent tyranny. Rule of Law cannot exist without a transparent legal system, the main components of which are a clear set of laws that are freely and easily accessible to all, strong enforcement structures, and an independent judiciary to protect citizens against the arbitrary use of power by the state, individuals or any other organisation. Only if each branch has influence and retraining functions on each other, can the parliamentary machine function properly and give the effect of the rule of law without imposing any tyrannical or arbitrary power by a specific institution, which would infringe the main principles of the rule of law. The issue would arise if there would be very weak separation of powers with a strong concept of parliamentary sovereignty at the same time. The power of judicial review ensures that officials act within the scope of their legal powers and that individuals have an effective way of obtaining remedies if their rights were violated. Although UK is said to have an efficient system of checks and balances, overlaps do occur. The fact that courts have no power to question the validity of the Acts of Parliament, gives Parliament an ultimate authority, effectively making the system of checks and balances more vulnerable. This, therefore, questions the validity of the doctrine of the separation of powers and the extent to which it efficiently protects the main principles of the rule of law.

‘The separation of power is essential both to the maintenance of democracy but also for the legal system, where an independent judiciary is essential if the rule of law is to have any substance.” Historical developments indicate that separation of powers played a crucial role in order for a governmental mechanism to function fairly and carry out the fundamental principles of the rule of law. This is illustrated in the controversial decision in M v Home Office, which indicated that no power by a political official should be abused, and that Home Secretary has to carry out the decision, which the court and judges agreed upon. In order to preserve Dicey’s principles of the rule of law, it is essential that we don’t simply attack the discretionary powers, but find the way to establish legal and political safeguards, by...

Find Another Essay On No Separation of Powers in the UK

The Separation of Powers in the United States Political System

892 words - 4 pages would have been sympathetic to his famous "New Deal". However, the proposal met firm resistance in Congress seeing it as an attack on the Separation of Powers. However, there are some arguments to claim that the US Constitution is not centred around a Separation of Powers as much as we are led to believe. Richard Neustadt claimed there was no Separation of Powers but merely "separate institutions sharing power

Separation of Powers Essay

709 words - 3 pages Constitution established three separate branches of government. By structuring the government in this fashion, the power to rule and govern would be distributed equally through a “separation of powers” arrangement. This structure prevents any single entity from ruling on its own without any checks or balances in place to protect the citizens. In creating a government with separated powers, three branches were established: the Executive Branch, which

Separation of Powers

844 words - 3 pages      Successful governments in history gained their acclaim by trial and error. The government in the United States is no different. In fact, the structure of the government in the United States has been through many changes: the American government was once feeble and operated with weak alliances between states; however, the present government functions in perfect equilibrium with the separation of powers, the federal

Separation of Powers

760 words - 4 pages If one person handled everything in the United States, there would be so much chaos in this world. Charles-Louis de Secondat, published Spirit of Laws which encouraged the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Constitution of the United States. He stressed that, to promote liberty effectively, the three powers had to be separated and acting independently (Separation of powers, n.d.). To ensure that the governmental power would not be used in

Separation of Powers

1349 words - 5 pages government. Furthermore, no body of government is supposed to abdicate power to another body. The separation of powers ensures the checking and balancing of each arm of government, although this is not always a harmonious relationship and can provide tensions between the arms of government. Nevertheless, the separation of powers ensures that the actions of government are in accordance with the law and the rights of the people are protected.The

separation of powers

629 words - 3 pages In the United States government there are 3 branches of government, the power given to the central government is divided among these 3 branches. Each of these branches are given powers so that they can check the powers of the other 2 branches ensuring that one branch doesn’t become to powerful One of these branches is the legislative branch this is the branch that includes congress, they are responsible for making laws. The second branch of

Separation of Powers under the HK Basic Law

6439 words - 26 pages centralism" where all power, including the power to control the judiciary, is concentrated in a system of peoples' congresses.13 Official Chinese hostility to separation of powers extends as 5 No more than 95 government ministers are allowed to be members of the House of Commons under Section 2 of the House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975. 6 The English courts have repeatedly described the UK system of government as one of separation of

How does the separation of powers in the US constitution both facilitate good government and check tyranny?

1367 words - 5 pages without the separation of the government institutions. James Madison states that 'there can be no liberty where the legislative and executive powers are united in the same person... [or] if the power of judging be not separated from the legislative and executive powers '. If power were vested solely in one person, judgement and legislation would become subjective entities, as opposed to the crucial objectivity that is required for just government

The Power of Presidency: The Separation of Powers that the President has to follow

823 words - 3 pages Dating back to 1690, the Framers created the system we know of today as the System of Checks and balances. This system provided the Separation of Powers for our Federal Government, in which it was created in our Constitution. This meant that there would be three branches of government, the Legislative, made up of the House and Senate, the Executive, which is the President and Vice President, and the Judicial, made up of our federal courts and

Comparing the Position and Powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister

2062 words - 8 pages Comparing the Position and Powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister Political instinct alone seems to dictate to many that the American president - 'the world's most powerful man' - is the most powerful politician in any of the world's democratic nations. He is at the head of the world's most modern military force and the world's largest economy. What the president says is reported around the world and world

Rise in the powers of the Princeps

1021 words - 4 pages If we assume that the position and powers of the Princeps rose and developed subsequent to the Republican Civil Wars ending, following Octavian's return from Egypt (after he had defeated Antony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium in 27 BC), we can see that such wars had created a situation in which a system of rule under the 'Princeps' or ('first among equals') might take root and flourish.The traditional source of political power in Rome, the

Similar Essays

The Separation And Balance Of Powers In The Uk Constitution

1742 words - 7 pages The Separation and Balance of Powers in the UK Constitution “By the latter part of the 20th century the independence of the judges had come under increasing threat from interference by the executive. Recent reforms have, however, served to redress this position and ensure that a proper division of personnel and functions between these two arms of the state is restored. Discuss this statement in the context of the

Separation Of Powers In The Us Government

1014 words - 4 pages order” (Beltz 28). The separation of powers is a basic constitutional principal of modern democracy. “Since the writings of Locke and Montesquieu, the separation of the legislative, executive, and judicial is deemed essential to avoid tyranny from the people who hold these powers” (separation of powers A society where the law is not overseen and the separation of powers of is not ensured has no constitution at all (separation

The Separation Of Powers Doctrine Essay

1605 words - 6 pages The judicial control of administrative agencies is held in check by four principal mechanisms: (1) Structural Constraints imposed under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers; (2) statutory constraints set forth generally in the Administrative Procedure Act and specifically in each agency’s organic legislation; (3) the requirement that individuals be treated fairly in conformity with the standards of procedural due process; and (4

Importance Of The Separation Of Powers In Government

1224 words - 5 pages within parliament is the legislative branch, the executive branch initiates policies, it includes the sovereign, the government (prime minister/ cabinet) and local authorities and the judges are the judicial branch. The UK does follow a modified version of checks and balances however it has been argued that the UK constitution has no separation of powers because of parliamentary sovereignty and the UK’s uncodified constitution. Each branch is not