Noble Love In The Birthmark Essay

1751 words - 7 pages

Noble Love in The Birthmark 

    Often billed as a story of an unsuccessful attempt to beat Nature at her own game, “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne certainly lends itself to a somewhat deeper interpretation.  Over the years many scholars have noted that the story of Aylmer and Georgiana is riddled with traditional Hawthorne themes such as the evils of selfishness and pride, coupled with an element of solitariness (Arvin xvi).  However, we are want to consider whether Aylmer’s motives in this story are purely selfish.  Does this man perhaps deserve a touch of human sympathy?  

With blazingly obvious symbolism, clearly defined by the author himself, the reader can choose to take the tale for what it seems to be, a purely selfish experiment gone awry.  Yet, it seems as though Hawthorne was sympathetic to his man of science, leaving open for discussion the idea that love did exist in this sordid world of tiny hands and test tubes.  Although it is at times ambiguous, the tone of the story seems to point to just this idea.  Of it Richard Fogle writes:

“…Hawthorne’s attitude is so removed and imperturbable that nothing in the story can be taken simply; in “The Birthmark” he reaches his furthest rage of disengagement” (Fogle 118).  It is through the intellectual and moral development of Georgiana, not the scientists own actions or words, that the reader comes to understand that although twisted in his methods, Aylmer does possess a kind of “noble” love.

            When the story opens, we are told that “an experience of spiritual affinity more attractive than any chemical one” has caused “a man of science” to take leave of his laboratory and be married.  The narrator also tells the reader it was not unusual, in those days of constant scientific discovery, “for the love of science to rival the love of a woman” (Hawthorne 147).  Immediately we are warned that this love will survive only if it can be “intertwined…with his love of science” (148).  This issue presents itself almost immediately after Georgiana and Aylmer are married, when the former discovers that Nature has left his near-perfect wife with a tiny blemish on her ivory cheek; the small imprint of a hand.  Of this Robert H. Fossum writes: “Like Eve entering the Garden, Georgiana has brought love and human warmth into Aylmer’s cold and lonely laboratory…she has brought the blemish of her birthmark…” (Fossum 78).  When asked about how she herself views her mark, Georgiana replies as one who has not given the subject much thought:

“To tell the truth is has been so often called a charm that I was simple enough to imagine it so.” (148)

In fact, when first love is mentioned it is only a few lines later when Georgiana responds to Aylmer “…you cannot love what shocks you!”  Hurt and surprised, she equates, (quite accurately), Aylmer’s ability to love her with his need to see her sans birthmark. 

            It is after this first confrontation that as the reader...

Find Another Essay On Noble Love in The Birthmark

The Fate of Women in The Birthmark

2464 words - 10 pages myopic Aylmer sees in the birthmark on Georgiana’s cheek. He is unfortunately oblivious to the virtue in her soul and heart, the deep beauty contained in the depth of her love for him. The wife’s virtue leads her onward and upward; the husband’s lack thereof and inability to appreciate virtue in his Georgiana leads him downward and downward.   Even after Aylmer has “persuaded a beautiful woman to become his wife,” he is not capable of loving

Evil in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark”

654 words - 3 pages What seems to be a simple tale of human error at first, Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story “The Birthmark”, implies a much deeper and darker note upon closer inspection. A relatively short story, it details an event in the lives of Aylmer and Georgiana, a recent wedded couple. Georgiana possesses a birthmark on her cheek that repulses Aylmer more and more as time goes on. When he confronts her about it, she voices that it is a part of her charm

Unattainable Beauty in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Birthmark

1077 words - 4 pages that physical perfection long before the era of “America’s Next Top Model” and “Nip/Tuck”. Hawthorne’s classic tale “The Birth-mark” seems to caution against “perfecting” nature’s beauty through the use of science. “The Birthmark” introduces us to a fervent scientist, Aylmer, who marries a beautiful young woman, Georgiana. Try as he might, Aylmer cannot keep his passions for both his wife and his science apart for long: “His love for

Essay on the Woman Protagonist in The Birthmark

1895 words - 8 pages “the visible mark of earthly imperfection,” and that it “shocks” him. Georgiana perceives a lack of love in his overdone negative reaction to the birthmark: ``Then why did you take me from my mother's side? You cannot love what shocks you!''   The narrator includes observations of other women regarding the mark: “Some fastidious persons -- but they were exclusively of her own sex -- affirmed that the bloody hand, as they chose to call it

Relinquishment of Free Will in The Birthmark and Carnal Knowledge

1202 words - 5 pages devotion to Alena was based on lust and momentary excitement, and was therefore fleeting, while Georgiana's adoration of Aylmer was based on a deeper regard and genuine love. Though "The Birthmark" and "Carnal Knowledge" are entirely dissimilar stories, the connections between the characters in them and the situations they find themselves due to their mutual frailty are unmistakable. Jim and Georgiana both allow another person to control them

Aylmer's Struggle for Perfection in Nathaniel Hawthome's, The Birthmark

2052 words - 8 pages Aylmer's Struggle for Perfection in Nathaniel Hawthome's, The Birthmark Aylmer's struggle for scientific perfection transcends human possibility in Nathaniel Hawthome's "The Birthmark." He attempts to perfect that which nature rendered imperfect. When the quest for human achievement opposes divine design it has no chance of succeeding. This key element in Aylmer's twisted love leads to the demise of what he seeks so desperately to perfect

"Femenist View Of Alymer" in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark"

1137 words - 5 pages Feminist View of AylmerBy the end of the eighteenth century, science had found its way into the advancement of humankind in the realm of medicine. Men believed they could cure and save all creatures on earth from their flaws and defects. Aylmer in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark" is one such character. Aylmer is a scientist who strives for perfection, so much so he believes his newly wed wife, Georgiana, would be the "ideal loveliness" if

OEDIPUS: A NOBLE PAWN IN SOPHOCLES "OEDIPUS THE KING"

654 words - 3 pages A man's actions are truly his own. These actions determine his character. In order for a man to be considered noble he must possess outstanding qualities and show these qualities through his actions. In "Oedipus the King," by Sophocles, Oedipus proves that all though his destiny is predetermined, it is his actions that make him the "noblest of men" (Prologue 48). Oedipus, though the gods have kept him tragically blind to the truth remains noble

The Noble Savage in Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

1644 words - 7 pages The Noble Savage in Frankenstein by Mary Shelley [In the following essay, Millhauser considers Frankenstein's monster in relation to the tradition of the noble savage in literature.] The estimate of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein familiar to us from literary handbooks and popular impression emphasizes its macabre and pseudo-scientific sensationalism: properly enough, so far as either its primary conception or realized qualities are

Okonkwo: the Noble Savage in Achebe's "Things Fall Apart"

1762 words - 7 pages Okonkwo was not a cruel man. But his whole life was dominated by fear, the fear of failure and of weakness. It was deeper and more intimate than the fear of evil and capricious gods and of magic, the fear of the forest, and of the forces of nature, malevolent, red in tooth and claw."Khamees, Yasser. The Noble Savage and the Savage Noble in Achebe's Things Fall Apart and Behn's Oroonoko. Minya, Egypt. 2005Spark Notes. 2005.

The Significance of Physical Markings in Moby Dick, The Scarlet Letter and "The Birthmark"

2451 words - 10 pages Hawthorne's "The Birthmark," Georgiana becomes the object of her husband's fear and disgust because of a birthmark on her cheek. In Herman Melville's Moby Dick, Ahab exhibits "the barbaric white leg on which he stood" (Melville, 135) and Queequeg shows "His bald purplish head" and other "parts of him checkered with the same squares as on his face; his back, too . . . still more, his very legs were marked" (Melville, 24). Even the whale, Moby Dick, has

Similar Essays

Women In The Birthmark Essay

2111 words - 8 pages Aylmer sees in the birthmark on Georgiana’s cheek. But he is unfortunately oblivious to  the virtue in her soul, the deep beauty contained in the depth of her love for him. The wife’s virtue leads her onward and upward; the husband’s lack thereof and inability to appreciate virtue in his Georgiana leads him downward and downward.   The concept of women is established in the very opening paragraph of “The Birthmark.” The narrator introduces

Disorders In Hawethornes "The Birthmark" Essay

1024 words - 4 pages In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s story “The Birthmark” you find a couple fairly prevalent disorders. Although psychology was as of yet not existence, Hawthorne describes them quite well. Alymer suffered from an obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, while his actions caused Georgiana to develop a body dysmorphic disorder. Both of which attributed to the eventual demise of Georgiana.      Alymer is an older scientist who

"Disorders In Hawthorne's The Birthmark." Essay

1011 words - 4 pages In Nathaniel Hawthorne's story "The Birthmark" you find a couple fairly prevalent disorders. Although psychology was as of yet not existence, Hawthorne describes them quite well. Alymer suffered from an obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, while his actions caused Georgiana to develop a body dysmorphic disorder. Both of which attributed to the eventual demise of Georgiana.Alymer is an older scientist who marries a beautiful woman much

Obsessing About Perfection In The Birthmark

1121 words - 4 pages Georgiana, can only focus on the one flaw she has, a small birthmark on her check. Seeing himself as god like, he thinks he can remove it and make her perfect. Aylmer is a scientist and possibly a sorcerer whose very name means “noble and famous”. He made many discoveries in his laboratory about the powers of nature and as a young man, earned the “admiration of all the learned societies in Europe.” (Hawthorne 228). I think his god like view of himself