This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Nostalgia Is Great Essay

2095 words - 9 pages

The current Canadian law concerning anti-hate speech contains two sections. The first section, 319 (2), states that everyone who willfully promotes hatred, other than in private conversation, against any identifiable group (which is defined under 318 (4) as “colour, race, religion, ethnic origin, or sexual orientation”) is entitled to imprisonment or is denied the right to a jury trial. The second section, 319 (3), states defences for (2): no one can be convicted of an offence under 319 (2) if the individual establishes that the statements were true, if they attempted to establish an argument based on a religious opinion, if the statements were for public benefit, or if they intended to point out matters producing feelings of hatred towards an identifiable group in Canada, for the purpose of removal.
The public incitement of hatred law 319 (1) states that everyone who communicates hateful statements against any identifiable group that leads to a breach of the peace is also entitled to imprisonment or is denied the right to a jury trial. This law is different from 319 (2) because the latter is willfully promoting hatred, whereas 319 (1) is simply publicly inciting hatred.
James Keegstra was a high school teacher in Eckville, Alberta whom willfully communicated anti-Semitic statements to his students regarding Jewish people. In 1984 he was charged under 319 (2). However, he applied for an appeal and claimed that said section infringed upon his freedom of expression, as expressed in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. His principal argument was that section 2(b) of the Charter was violated, which states, “Everyone has the following fundamental freedoms: freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication.” Keegstra also debated that various additional freedoms were violated as well, such as 11(d) “Any person charged with an offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal”, 15(l) “Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national and ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability”, and 27 “This Charter shall be interpreted in a manner consistent with the preservation and enhancement of the multicultural heritage of Canadians”. Keegstra’s motion was rejected, however the Supreme Court of Canada had concluded that section 319 (2) violates section 2(b) of the Charter, and that Keegstra’s rights were essentially infringed upon.
B)
It is my personal belief that the anti-hate speech law 319 (2) should mostly remain as it stands, however only one aspect needs altering. Private conversations should be included in section 319 (2), as there is still harm executed even if it is not to the public,...

Find Another Essay On Nostalgia Is Great

Comparison between The Taste of Ashes and Post Communist Nostalgia

2040 words - 8 pages socialist past. It is only when one realises that the return of socialism is impossible, that nostalgia comes into play. One must feel in some way secure in order to begin to remember their socialist past. There are many different factors of nostalgia discussed and explained throughout this book. Tito-Nostalgia for example, where people have developed a great sentimentality towards their former Yugoslav leader, Joseph Broz Tito. Restorative

Great Gatsby analytical essay

839 words - 4 pages In, “The Great Gatsby,” we learn about many different themes and ideas that are presented to us in the book. The themes and ideas are presented to us through the results of the choices and actions that the characters make in the story, ranging from Tom’s adultery to Gatsby’s nostalgia. One theme Fitzgerald teaches to his readers, is that nostalgia (an extreme longing for the past) can cause many problems in a person’s life, through the use of

'Nostalgia' for Sale

1450 words - 6 pages century; advertisers are selling nostalgia as a way of making commercials highly persuasive to their audience.Nabisco, the company that produces Oreo Cookies, has always been known for outstanding commercials. Yet one "Oreo Cookie" commercial is perhaps the most memorable. First, she twists the cookie apart and then, this cute little girl with her hair in pigtails proceeds to dunk the cookie in a tall glass of milk, immersing her entire hand. The

Ian Baucom and Midnight's Children, Wild Thorns, and Reading in the Dark

1190 words - 5 pages people - have a way of leaking into each other...the past has dripped into me...so we can't ignore it..." Perhaps Saleem's nostalgia for his family's past is so great that he is able to bring it into the present and rebuild the ruins of his family history to all their glory. Khalifeh's novel, being set in the West Bank under Israeli occupation, definitely shows how a character's memory is profoundly shaped by the historical identity of the

An Analysis of Tennyson’s The Princess

866 words - 3 pages An Analysis of Tennyson’s The Princess   Alfred, Lord Tennyson is the most influential poet of the Victorian Age. He was named poet laureate of England by the Queen, and the first poet to receive a title Lord. In his lifetime Tennyson has produced many works which are considered great. Such one is The Princess which is a long narrative poem with a number of songs. One of these songs is “ Tears, Idle Tears”, a poem full of sorrow

fakes

2197 words - 9 pages friendship. Its definition can vary from culture to culture or also within Literature. In The Catcher in the Rye, the Caulfield family is an example of the usage of character interaction within the family to build reader empathy trough the uses the emotional topics such as death, sickness, nostalgia, and a place to belong. The three main character interactions within the family group are Holden´s interactions with his siblings and parents

'Boy: Tales of Childhood' Book Review

833 words - 4 pages father created a cutlery tool with both a fork and knife and learned how to tie his shoelaces at the same speed as when he had both hands. After living with the disability for many years, he started a ship broking firm and became a highly successful business man. The second theme, Nostalgia, is frequently expressed by Roald Dahl throughout ‘Boy: Tales of Childhood’. In the novel, Dahl frequently draws in the reader by evoking their sense of

Regionalism

1771 words - 8 pages contact to Antonia for twenty years. Likewise, Antonia has settled for a husband and is in the taxing role of a mother on a farm. There is no fairytale ending to this relationship, as My Antonia has a plausible, Realist plot throughout the novel. Willa Cather paints the picture of Great Plains and European immigrant Regionalism in My Antonia and also portrays Realism in the novel through nostalgia and a Realist, plausible plot. Through “Corn Pone

The hunter or the hunted

999 words - 4 pages maintains his aristocratic lifestyle in his majestic chateau on the bluff here on the remote Island where he now enjoys hunting. He tells Rainsford how he became bored with killing the typical game, and now only hunts the animal that can reason. Rainsford then realizes Zaroff is referring to hunting humans. General Zaroff asks Rainsford to join him on his next hunt, but Rainsford refuses and states,“Great guns, General Zaroff, what you speak of

Nick Carraway from The Great Gatsby

1100 words - 4 pages involves himself into a culture that is selfish. Nick sees this, but he enjoys the lifestyle. However, when Gatsby dies, he cannot enjoy it any longer. The death of Gatsby releases Nick’s hatred for the world that he invests so much time into. I am reminded of my own conflict. I have felt a similar hatred to those who succeeded where I didn’t, and I realize that we must accept our losses and move on towards a greater goal. Works Cited Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. New York, NY: Scribner, 1996. Print

Like Water For Chocolate by Laura Esquivel

1306 words - 5 pages , nostalgia, and tradition in this excerpt, throughout the novel. This accentuates the outcome of the Mexican revolution and its affect on the citizens. The first evidential literary device used in this excerpt is magical realism. Esquivel incorporates imagination and reality in most of her scenes, to lessen the aggravated situation, and somehow turn it into a phenomenon of fantasy and pragmatism. The cake made “everyone flooded with a great wave

Similar Essays

Nostalgia Is Great Essay

1205 words - 5 pages around her. It is evident that everyone in the town talked about her frequently and observed her, “Daily, monthly, yearly, we watched the Negro grow grayer and more stooped” (Faulkner, 379). What is viewed by one person is viewed by everyone in the community. Although she could not control the changing times of the town around her and was reluctant to adapt to new laws (such as paying taxes), she was capable of controlling Homer after she

Nostalgia Is Great Essay

730 words - 3 pages In his book Leviathan, Thomas Hobbes describes the nature of man as functioning solely upon the pursuit of desire for power and of war. Every emotion is a variation of desire, and these desires motivate us to act. He describes the natural condition in which humans are being without political authority. Living in a chaotic and unjust society where every man lives by his own desires, Hobbes argues that humans must use reason and follow the laws of

Nostalgia Is Great Essay

1283 words - 6 pages In Leviathan, Thomas Hobbes describes that human beings living in the natural condition lack freedom. He claims that freedom is merely the absence of an external hindrance, something that prevents one from pursuing their desires. In the natural state of man, each individual is fighting for themselves, living without political authority. Hobbes believes that the only way to attain true freedom is under the power of a sovereign. Alternatively

Nostalgia Is Great Essay

818 words - 4 pages Stephen King’s novel The Shining illustrates the struggles that people face when in isolation. The main character Jack Torrance is challenged with his own personal demons, including alcoholism and his temper. In the given passage, King displays Jack as being confronted with one of his demons, alcoholism. The scrapbook that Jack finds in the cellar of the hotel symbolizes Jack’s secret obsession for the hotel history. The alcoholism in Jack’s