This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Nursing Article Critique: A Quantitative Analysis

1245 words - 5 pages

The CMAI scale attempts to quantify qualitative data which was used to select participants. Results were therefore subjected to observer bias and individual interpretation. This may have been avoided in a randomized and case-controlled study.
Were there many refusals, withdrawals, dropouts, or deaths?
Participation bias 
Research ethics concerns.
Was the informed consent obtained?
Were the participants reasonably able to take part? 
Was the study potentially/actually harmful to participants/others? 
List any ethical issues that are of concern to you as a reader and potential user of the research (e.g., truthfulness, confidentiality, coercion).
Informed consent was acquired from families and proxies, however, it was not obtained from the test subjects.
Setting.
What was the environment in which the data were collected?

Other: Long-term care facility for persons with dementia.
Experiment (if applicable).
What was the special treatment or intervention?
Throughout the sixteen week study, the subject’s CMAI was completed every other day in order to determine agitation levels and a baseline was established after two weeks of behavioural monitoring. Then, two drops of undiluted lavender oil (relaxant) was applied to a fabric sachet every three hours, three times per day, and pinned near the subject’s clavicle. Lavender was replaced with thyme oil (stimulant) for two weeks and was followed by a placebo (unscented grapeseed oil) lasting another two weeks. A second cycle of thyme and lavender was done, and the study concluded after two weeks of post-treatment agitation monitoring.
Did the participants in the study know whether they received the intervention or a placebo?

What methods, if any, were used to “blind” the participants, staff, and data collectors from knowledge about the study that might influence the results?
The residents were most likely unaware as to the effects of the different oils used at different stages of treatment, due to cognitive impairment. It was unclear if the nursing staff were aware of the expected outcomes and whether the same staff were consistently used to monitor and measure agitation levels.
Was there any contamination or mixing of treatments across the study groups?

Were there any other factors related to the intervention/treatment that might have influenced the outcomes?
Performance bias occurred due to the nursing staff’s role in the study. Also, it was unclear whether the subjects were cognizant to the different treatments they were receiving. Thus, the study would have benefited from a double-blind method of testing.
Data collection.
What was the data collection method/tool used?
Were methods used to insure that data were reliably collected (e.g., differences between rater, differences between times of measurement)?
Yes • No • Not reported 
If yes, what were they?
Not applicable.
Were methods used to ensure the validity of the collected data (e.g.,...

Find Another Essay On Nursing Article Critique: A Quantitative Analysis

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

1678 words - 7 pages perceived body satisfaction?" Operationally, the researchers do not define the variables of stress and eating disorders, but they notable considered emphasis that it both a perceived psychological states. The design of the study involved a number of analysis and adjusting the plan, as a quantitative study, they work to make the study unbiased and to maintain the validity of the study. The design of the study focused on creating a survey that

Critique of Johnson’s Quantitative Research Article

4118 words - 16 pages for a school and no company was benefiting from her research conclusions. She was not trying to promote the use of any specific tool to help sleep, like someone working for a drug company might do. Johnson publishing the article in a community nursing journal seems appropriate because many community nursing patients are older adults. The following essay will be a critique of the quality of Johnson’s research process in her study of whether music

Quantitative Article Critique

981 words - 4 pages The purpose of the article I reviewed by Lykeridou, Gourounti, Deltsidou, Lautradis, and& Vaslamatzis (2009) was to examine women’s level of depression, perceived anxiety, and overall stress related to infertility while receiving fertility treatments. It w as hypothesized that the etiology of an infertility diagnoses wouldwill affect female’s psychological vulnerability. The variables that were looked at in the study were infertility diagnoses

Critique on the Nursing Article Critical care patients’ experience of the helmet continuous positive airway pressure

2784 words - 11 pages necessary to ascertain credibility of a piece of research recognising it’ values to nursing practice. For instance, the main elements that need careful scrutiny and analysis are the method, data collection, data analysis, findings and recommendations. Other indications of how dependable the research article may be include where the journal article was published, where the research took place and the background of the authors. However, Conkin Dale

Quantitative Nursing Research Report Analysis

2574 words - 10 pages Family presence during invasive procedures and resuscitationStudy problemWhat problem was the study conducted to resolve?A research problem identifies an area of concern when a gap exists in the knowledge needed for nursing practice (Burns & Grove, 2003, p 55). Family presence (FP) during invasive procedures (IPs) and cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is considered a right, obligation, and natural event by some organizations, notably

Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages article system vary over time? 2. Does accuracy in the use of these features vary according to the type of corrective feedback provided? 3. Does accuracy in the use of these features vary as a result of the interaction of feedback type and time? Seventy five low intermediate level ESL students studying at two language schools in Auckland, New Zealand participated in this study as the subjects. The students had different L1 backgrounds, had

Journal Article Critique - Bougainville Copper: A Case Analysis in International Management

2377 words - 10 pages company operated in Papua New Guinea. (“The case of the Bougainville mine: Success and failure in the management of a multinational corporation.” Journal of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, vol. 8; pp70-85).This essay focuses on the article in terms of the clarity of ideas, adequacy of literature review, specification of research goals, adequacy of data collection and data analysis, assessment of empirical methods, and

A Quantitative Approach to Evaluating Caring in Nursing Simulation

1427 words - 6 pages study is lacking in some areas, such as literature review and a more thorough results discussion, it is evident that these authors have developed an appropriate scale for scoring that has shown through statistical analysis that it is a valid resource in measuring caring. Works Cited Eggenberger, T. L., Keller, K. B., Chase, S. K., & Payne, L. (2012, November/December2012). A Quantitative Approach to Evaluating Caring in Nursing Simulation

"Why We Hate HR": Critique and Recommendations (Article Analysis)

1308 words - 5 pages should not), have at least some input. Throughout the critique and recommendations of the "Why We Hate HR" article, some of the focus will be on the roles and responsibilities of HR as well as the importance of a good HR management philosophy.Article CritiqueIn the article, "Why We Hate HR" one can see that the author points out the flaws in the HR concept repeatedly. They are able to support their assumptions with technical data from reputable

Analysis of a Boxing Article

1271 words - 5 pages Analysis of a Boxing Article The headline does what headlines do. It grabs the readers attention, and suggest what we expect to find when we read on. “NO ONE IS FORECED TO FIGHT” is a sharp phrase that goes straight to the point. The bias of the editorial is clear from the headline, and we expect to read something in favor of the boxers right to box, especially since they are not “FORCED”. As expected it is told with

A nursing report based on a research article 'evaluating a palliative care education project in nursing homes'

1178 words - 5 pages This report is based on a research article, ' Evaluating a palliative care education project in nursing homes', by Froggart (2000). The author of the article Katherine Froggart, who is the head of MacMillan Practice Development Unit, Centre for Cancer and Palliative Care Studies, discusses the establishment of a 2-year palliative education pilot project in nursing homes.The aim of her project was to address the palliative care needs of residents

Similar Essays

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

1627 words - 7 pages Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention

Quantitative Study Article Critique Essay

1436 words - 6 pages Quantitative Study Article Critique This paper is a critique of an article written by McKinney and Jones (1993) entitled: “Effects of a Children’s Book and a Traditional Textbook on Fifth-grade Students’ Achievement and Attitudes toward Social Studies”. In their research the authors examined the effects of a children’s book and a traditional social studies textbook on knowledge acquisition and attitudes toward social studies and the textbook in

Critique Of Quantitative Research Article Essay

790 words - 4 pages Dr. Karrie Hendrickson published an article in 2009 analyzing patterns of hospital resource utilization of children with leukemia and CNS tumors. Dr. Hendrickson used quantitative research as her means of analysis. In her article, Dr. Hendrickson specifies the population as children ages 0 to 19 years diagnosed with cancer at a large north-eastern hospital between fiscal years 2000 and 2004. Specifically, she focused on children diagnosed with

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

993 words - 4 pages value on it subjects (Polit & Beck). In the end the resulting data is neutral and statistical. However, like all things its approach is not perfect, yet, it has the ability to yield valuable data. Summary of Critiqued Article For nursing, research has played a major role in the way clinical practice is done. Research has allowed nurses to provide appropriate care to patients. It allows them to perform their job by providing them the tools and