This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Oedipal And Electra Complexes Essay

1180 words - 5 pages

Oedipal and Electra Complexes

In Rebecca female sexuality is explored through the heroine’s symbolic development of a negative Oedipal complex followed by an Electra complex. Although avoidance of incest was believed by Freud to be the impetus for normal sexual development, the film explores the abnormal outcome of a negative Oedipal/Electra complex, i.e. replacement of the mother by the daughter as the father’s heterosexual love interest. The heroine is torn between her desire to merge with Rebecca and to separate from her due to this combination of negative Oedipal and Electra complexes. The key difference between these two complexes underlies the heroine’s development.

The difference between a negative Oedipal and Electra complex is not subtle. A negative Oedipal complex involves love for the mother in the form of Freud’s “bisexual attraction”. The girl will desire and identify with her, wishing to emulate her. An Electra complex is defined by the girl’s imagined rivalry between mother and daughter for the father’s love. For Freud the heterosexual development of little girls is more difficult to explain compared to that of little boys because the girl must change the object of her love from woman to man. Initially the girl has a negative Oedipal complex until some catalytic occurrence shifts her into an Electra complex marked by dislike of the mother and rivalry. In a normal Freudian non-incestuous relationship the girl will transfer love of the father to other men and will not stop loving the mother entirely. In an incestuous relationship the girl will eliminate the threat of the mother, take her place, and engage in a sexual relationship with the father. Avoiding this, Freud believes, drives the female sexual development. Embracing this, Hitchcock displays, drives the unheimlich development of Rebecca.

Symbolically in the film, the main characters take on the roles of key players in Freud’s development strategies. The lovely heroine is clearly the girl, very young relative to Maxim and for the first half of the film innocent, weak, and small. She is made smaller by the overpowering presence of Rebecca, who for her typifies the perfect female. Maxim is clearly the father figure due to his age relative to the heroine and his relationship with her. His comments about her being a child, his desire for her never to grow up or wear black satin and pearls, and the way he touches her and treats her so chastely bring his fatherly qualities to the forefront. Rebecca is the mother figure inasmuch as she tried in life to completely possess Maxim and even seemed to plot her own death in a manner that would allow her to control him and possess him from beyond the grave. Before the plot unravels she is the ideal woman, rich in the feminine qualities of beauty, intelligence, strength and especially power over the father; the heroine sees her as the ultimate object of the father’s desire and love.

This first part of the film...

Find Another Essay On Oedipal and Electra Complexes

The Role of Irony and Fate

1305 words - 5 pages , but it is called the Electra complex. Girls will experience what Freud referred to as penis envy. They will blame the mother for their predicament and have resentment towards the mother. The Electra complex is resolved the same way as with boys and the Oedipal complex. Over the years, Sigmund Freud’s views on the Oedipus complex have been highly criticized. This is due to the fact that little is known as to the psychological and sexual development

Gender Issues within Fairy Tales Essay

1083 words - 4 pages before," which makes "the listener feel how suffering can purify and strengthen" (Luthi 144). Another reason for women playing such a key role in fairy tales is the Oedipal complex. In fairy tales the Oedipal complex manifests itself from the female perspective (or the Electra complex). "[F]airy tales enacting Oedipal conflicts split the mother figure in two: one mother who stands by her child and another (step)mother who stands in the way

The Oedipus Complex

2208 words - 9 pages Inspired by Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex and his analyses of his own and patients’ psychological behavior, Sigmund Freud developed the Oedipus complex. Freud believed that dreams are suppressed oedipal urges, and that these urges are universal to humankind. Opposition to the theory’s name is common, since many believe that Oedipus Rex has a profounder meaning than Freud asserts. Through the content of the play, Sigmund Freud supports his complex by

rear window text

1279 words - 6 pages restored and having the film’s protagonist resolve the conflict within the narrative. While the male protagonist journeys through the narrative, he undergoes through the Oedipal trajectory and must find a female counterpart that aligns with his character. Classical Hollywood Cinema offers various messages that reflect dominant ideology in the film’s conclusion. Such ideologies as; good triumphs over evil, the long arm of the law always finds the

Orestes in Modern Drama: "Mourning Becomes Electra"

2328 words - 9 pages Electra, on the other hand, the crimes are rooted in the characters' subconscious. So, the Mannons shut up inside themselves and, for them, there is no escape from complex or heritage. Orin's suicide, for instance, is the judgment leveled by his Oedipal complex. He cannot face life with the burden of causing his mother's death. Orin commits suicide mainly because of an active madness of bloodguilt for the death of his mother. As for Lavinia, it is

Inside the Head of Sigmund Freud

1588 words - 6 pages complex theories such as the Oedipus complex, and the Electra complex. His fields include neurology, philosophy, psychiatry, psychology, psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. Many question his authenticity since there is no proof or record of Freud holding a degree, more less a doctorate. However, there is proof that he did study at the University of Vienna in 1873. The Interpretation’s of Dreams is one of Freud’s most famous books that gained

Hamlet and the Oedipus Complex

1549 words - 6 pages and dies. Maybe Gertrude also had feelings for her son. If swords weren't flying at the time, and a poisoned cup was the only weapon around, Gertrude would have spared her son's life in a last show of her love by taking the drink and sacrificing her own life for his. Now that Claudius, Gertrude, both Hamlets, and Ophelia are in the afterlife, another important question arises: Are there Oedipal complexes in heaven (or hell)?

Psychoanalytically Analyzing the Poetry of Sylvia Plath

1932 words - 8 pages called the Electra complex. Children resolve this conflict by identifying with their same sex parent. Loss of a parent can prevent the normal resolution of the Oedipal conflict and result in a fixation or obsession with the lost object (object is the term used to define the internal representations of others). The desire to have the lost object back is also the desire for what Freud called primary narcissism. Primary narcissism is a state that all

David Mamet's Oleanna: Father-Daughter Relations

807 words - 3 pages the divine oracle at Delphi. Similarly, the sister of Orestes aided Orestes, himself, in avenging the death of Agamemnon, their father, by killing their mother, Clytemnestra, and her lover, Aegisthus. These two yet to be identified mythological figures, Oedipus and Electra, respectively, have lent their names to modern psychology. Oedipus and Electra complexes are characterised by perverse manifestations in which a child libidinously desires a

Discuss the "Cinderella" fairytale through its appropriation, how it is affected by its culture, a different version and Bettelheim's psychoanalytical reading

646 words - 3 pages make their foot fit into the glass slipper.From a psychoanalytical viewpoint, Bettelheim offers a Freudian analysis on Cinderella as a symbolic vehicle for a young girl's maturation. He discusses the insecurities and aggressions surrounding sibling rivalry, a child's pervasive feeling of worthlessness and masochistic desires to be treated like Cinderella, and a child's oedipal anxieties as she takes steps required to reach self-fulfillment and a

Sigmund Freud

595 words - 2 pages ComplexGroup of largely unconscious ideas and feelings centering round the wish to eliminate the parent of the same sex and possess the parent of the opposite sex.According to classical theory it occurs during the oedipal stage of libidinal and ego development i.e. between three and five.Freud believed that all complexes and neuroses can be traced back to the time Oedipus complex.Resolution of the Oedipus Complex (The Boy)The Oedipus Complex offers

Similar Essays

Incest In "Mourning Becomes Electra" Essay

1302 words - 5 pages in order to care for Orin and make sure he does not tell their secret. As well as Vinnie learning her role through the Electra complex, Orin does nearly the same through the Oedipus complex. On the contrary, Orin is forced into stepping into Mannon’s shoes when he is forced to go to war and fight like a Mannon. Thusly, he actually only learns his role through becoming mentally imperfect from the war. However, O’Neill’s take on both complexes

Beauty And The Beast: The Untold Meaning

1119 words - 5 pages of not having her father. She then eventually realizes that she no longer needs her father to be her dominant male figure. She is then able to identify with the Beast and be able to accept him as a prince. Many children which have been exposed to this story are going through either the electra or oedipal phase which will allow them to identify with the story at a subconscious level. Works Cited Bettelheim, Bruno. "The Animal Groom-Cycle of

Freud Outline

1494 words - 6 pages interaction with others (ego processes)” (Sharf, 2012, pp.47). The Blacky Test is an instrument derived from Freud’s drive theory. (Sharf, 2012, pp. 47-48) 12. Strengths and weaknesses: a. 13. Multicultural concerns: a. Freud’s psychoanalysis can be viewed as insensitive towards other cultures in today’s world. The Oedipal and Electra complexes are vulnerable in situations of a single caretaker, multiple caretakers or in a situation of role reversal

Mourning Becomes Electra Eugene O'neill

543 words - 2 pages Although O'Neill derived Mourning Becomes Electra from the Oresteia, the myth that actually structures the play's action is overwhelmingly that of Oedipus.The Oedipal drama, and Freud's elaboration of it, determines the course of the trilogy. Lavinia, for example, yearns to replace Christine as wife to her father, and mother to her brother. Christine clings to Orin, and Brant is but a substitute for her precious son. Orin also yearns to re