Oh Who Will Protect Poor Emily?

1320 words - 5 pages

In Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily”, there is a constant theme of protection for Emily Grierson, because she was a woman living in the south after the civil war and the requirements that were placed on women enable to be honorable. That is to say that, women needed to be protected by the men of the community during that time in history and women’s actions were constantly under watch to see if a woman was honorable and worthy of protection or not. Within the story, there are many instances in which this is shown. Faulkner also shows the reader a gender split between the men and women and how they felt towards Emily.
In the book Literature by Edgar V Roberts, Faulkner begins the story “A Rose for Emily” with an extremely long sentence which shows the communities reaction to death and immediately displays a scene through gender differences:
“When Miss Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to her funeral; the men through a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument, the women mostly out of curiosity to see the inside of her house, which no one save an old manservant-a combined gardener and cook-had seen in at least ten years”(76).
This passage displays a tone of the men’s respect and sense of protection toward Emily, which is very different from the other women’s reaction to her death. It also shows the reader that Emily was honorable in the eyes of the men of the town. We have seen this need to protect women throughout history, but in recent years there has been a great decline and it is sad.
In an essay called ‘Miss Leonora When Last Seen’: Why Americans Run Away from Home by Judith Caesar, she describes the situation regarding the way the townspeople felt towards Emily. Caesar says, “To the town, Emily Grierson is first and foremost an upper-class Southern woman with a specific role required of her concerning sexual propriety, a role that enables the town to see her as an image of feminine purity and perhaps, by extension, of Southern honor”(3). This expresses the idea that women had expectations placed upon them from men as well as society, in order to be deserving of protection.
There were restrictions placed upon the ideal behavior of women also in this time in history. In an essay written by Michael L. Lahey titled Narcissa’s Love Letters: Illicit Space and the Writing of Female Identity in ‘There Was a Queen’, Lahey writes
“And the presence of a female erotic gaze in “There Was a Queen” becomes
significant if it signals the inevitable movement towards a female voicing, that absence which Faulkner makes so conspicuous in this story, as he does in his other texts of desire and sexual regulation, of female silence and silences females: Sanctuary, The Hamlet, “A Rose for Emily,” and especially The Sound and the Fury” (6).
For a woman not to behave in an “appropriate” manner was to say she was not a “lady” and therefore was not honorable and not worthy of protection.
In the...

Find Another Essay On Oh Who Will Protect Poor Emily?

Acceptance of Reality: Denying the Facts

1053 words - 5 pages . Emily is a mysterious woman who faces an unceasing battle of letting love over power her to the extent where it is virtually impossible to accept reality. William Faulkner wrote A Rose for Emily in five different parts. The story begins with a description of Emily’s funeral and then moves into the “near-distant past.” Rather than writing this story in a chronological fashion, Faulkner shifts and manipulates time by stretching the story over

The clash between past and present in "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner

880 words - 4 pages town (the new generation), which can be considered a character, is “glad that Miss Emily would have an interest”, while “there [are] still others, the older people, who […] just sa[y], ‘Poor Emily’”. This difference in their attitudes towards the events of life is also seen in Miss Emily and Homer Baron, who for some time thought that that gap of time dividing them both could be bridged, but are then appalled to

The Destruction of Emily in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily

1639 words - 7 pages . "Oh, it’s simply the poor woman had had no life at all" (Comments 190). Emily fails in reconciliation with the world, so she takes the only available thing from the modern world into her way of life. That thing is the man she felt was the true love in her life and of her time. Emily is a victim of circumstance. Her father and her aunt’s way of thinking corrupted her way of life since early childhood. The values and traditions were falsehoods

A rose for Emily

2080 words - 8 pages Colonel is the guy who initially dreamed up the scheme to relieve Emily of her tax obligations when her father died. That was a nice thing to do. But, this same Colonel, the mayor, "who," we ar...Judge StevensJudge Stevens gets one of the best lines in the story: "Dammit, sir, will you accuse a lady to her face of smelling bad?" (2.9) Given everything the town knows at this point, the smell should have...Old Lady WyattOld lady Wyatt is Emily's great


1210 words - 5 pages reality that those in society who we think we can trust, are in fact those who we must be most suspicious of. As a parent, an individual is compelled to protect their child with tiger-like defenses and an ever watchful eye.The fact that this story is not chronological in the way that it is organized is purposeful to illustrate the pattern- the shifting- the passing back and forth of Emily both emotionally (allowing the nursery school teacher, the

The Changing Verbal Portraits of Emily in A Rose for Emily

3019 words - 12 pages dominant front position. His turned back suggests a disregard for her emotional welfare as he wards off potential danger--or violation of her maidenhead--with his horsewhip. The back-flung door invites suitors in, but only those who meet Grierson standards. Unfortunately, those standards are unattainable--"The Griersons held themselves a little too high for what they really were" (CS 123)--and Miss Emily remains a spinster at age thirty. The

"A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner

1091 words - 4 pages In William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," we see how past events affect the life of the main character Miss Emily, especially her inability to accept change. Throughout the story Miss Emily goes to extreme measures to protect her social status. Miss Emily lives in the past to shield herself from a future that holds no promises and no guarantees. William Faulkner illustrates Miss Emily's inability to accept change through the physical, social and

A Rose For Emily - In Memory Of Emily Grierson

1165 words - 5 pages In the short story ¡§A Rose for Emily,¡¨ (1930) William Faulkner presents Miss Emily¡¦s instable state of mind through a missed sequence of events. Faulkner arranges the story in fractured time and then introduces characters who contribute to the development of Miss Emily¡¦s personality. The theme of isolation is also presented by Faulkner¡¦s descriptive words and symbolic images. 	Faulkner uses anachronism to illustrate Miss Emily¡¦s

Expectations in A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner

1710 words - 7 pages bankruptcy would shame her. It is interesting that the mayor creates a story to tell Emily so that her pride will not be damaged (Faulkner 79). The story is so ludicrous that the narrator explains, “Only a man of Colonel Sartoris’ generation and thought could have invented it, and only a woman could have believed it” (Faulkner 79). But as time passes and a new generation steps up in society, the old ways and values of the south begin to

Seeing Eye's Interpretive paper

1078 words - 4 pages to remain unseen to the rest of the world and herself.School was not one of Emily's strong points; she was not quick at a time when quickness was easily confused with ability to learn (75). Her teachers thought she was slow because she was always behind, always trying to catch up. She was just one girl in a large school, just one girl who was thought to be slow. How can anyone learn, when all that you are told is you are slow and stupid? Emily

The Treatment of the Lower Class in Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho

1603 words - 6 pages , like other characters, are flat. The female servants' most dominant trait is their predilection for chattering. Alongside the latter, superstition is a defining characteristic of all lower class characters, continually exhibited by Annette, and even by the kindly peasant La Voisin who houses St Aubert just before the latter's death. The servants and peasants are a clear foil to the sensible, yet rational, upper-class members - Emily, St Aubert

Similar Essays

Emily's Rose Essay

931 words - 4 pages Emily's Rose Emily lives in the small town of Jefferson. Jefferson is a town where her family has lived for generations, and where her family is known to have “held themselves a little to high for what they were;” so they were treated as such. Emily is kept home by her father and almost hidden from the entire town; the gentlemen callers who dared come calling for Miss Emily’s hand were only “vanquished” by her father. They were not of

A Critical Analysis Of "A Rose For Emily" William Faulkner

2322 words - 9 pages Grierson is already dead when the story begins, but we also know the story is about her. I believe this technique is used to create empathy for the character of Emily because you only see her through the eyes of the people of Jefferson, who would often talk about her behind her back; but she’s referred to as “poor Emily”.The order of the story is also used to build up tension and suspense; the story starts and Emily is already dead, she

Tragedy In The Eyes Of The Beholder

993 words - 4 pages smell diapered the town never thought to think twice of it and went on with their lives. Finally When Emily dies unexpectedly the towns people finds a shocking discovery in Emily’s home. Homer had rotted into her bed, and even worse Emily had killed him, and had been lying beside him. Of course, when under the spotlight as Emily is it is inevitable that wherever she goes and whatever she does gossip will follow her. After analyzing the story, I

A Party On Friday The 13th: Short Story

782 words - 4 pages , she darted out of his office. “This meeting will need to be dismissed. I have another meeting in 10 minutes.” The principal said in a deep, raspy voice. Emily went home with her mom. She heard her Mom talking to Jenny’s Mom on the phone. It didn’t sound too great. There was a lot of screaming. Emily couldn’t take it anymore. “SCREEEEEEECHHH.” “Emily? EMILY?” her mom yelled. “Where are you? Emily?” “Ahhhh.” Emily wailed. “Oh my god.” Her mom said crying. “911, what’s your emergency?” said the operator.