Ombudsman's Contribution To The Task Of Ensuring That Government Decision Making Is Conducted In A Defensible Way

973 words - 4 pages

Ombudsman's Contribution to the Task of Ensuring that Government Decision-Making is Conducted in a Defensible Way

The Parliamentary Commissioner for Adminstration (PCA) was set up
under the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 as a result of the
Crichel Down affair in 1954. It was thought that pre-existing judicial
and parliamentary remedies did not provide adequate redress for
members of the public who suffered as a result of maladministration in
central government. No action was being taken towards defective
administrative workings, either because it fell outside the
jurisdiction of the courts or because MPs did not have sufficient
powers to investigate it satisfactorily.

The Ombudsman stands as an independent body, empowered to investigate
a wide range of complaints than could be investigated by a court.
Where as a court can intervene in judicial review proceedings only
where a decision is ultra vires, the Ombudsman is required to consider
‘maladministration’ (under s 10(3) of the Act), which causes
injustice, as opposed to illegality.

Many as an advantage to the system see the informal and flexible rules
underlying the procedure. The flexibility is reflected in the fact
that the Ombudsman is not barred by time limits and therefore may
provide a remedy in instances that cannot be considered by a court. On
the other hand, the informality in investigation may be more effective
at times in discovering the truth than the adversarial system in the
courts. The Ombudsman being independent and impartial where as an MP
may become biased due to political allegiance.

However, there are a number of limitations on the powers of the PCA,
which may not seem inherent but are thought to weaken his efficacy.
Certain matters, set out in Schedule 3 to the Act, are excluded from
investigation. These include extradition and fugitive offenders, the
investigation of crime by or on behalf of the Home Office, security of
the States, action in matters relating to contractual or commercial
activities, court proceedings and personnal matters of armed forces,
teachers, the Civil Service or police. The government has always
resisted the extension of the Ombudsman system into these areas.
Furthermore, Schedule 2 does not include public corporations,
tribunals, the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board or, crucially, the
police.

A further important limitation, the system of making the complaint
through a Member of Parliament, has been much criticised: it is
thought that this ‘screening’ of complaints does not serve the best
interests of complainant. This is where...

Find Another Essay On Ombudsman's Contribution to the Task of Ensuring that Government Decision-Making is Conducted in a Defensible Way

DECISION MAKING--Identify and describe a minimum of 3 problems, relating to decision making that occur when managers complete performance reviews

877 words - 4 pages and supervisors also need to document throughout the year their findings. They need to communicate to employees on a regular basis their findings, good and bad in order to allow employees the opportunity for improvement and to recognize their achievements. I also found that many managers and supervisors are affected by Contrast effect where as if an employee's previous performance was of superior quality and the present performance is of average

Applying Ethical Decision-Making Models to Guerrilla Government

1455 words - 6 pages Russell and the guerillas received the attention of the White House. Though public policy was not changed, EPA employees did reinforce policies and future EPA administrators would be advised to follow them or employees would not hesitate to stand against them. Alternative Actions According to the ethical decision-making model, alternative actions should have been examined. In this case, the ethical issues lead to a lack of communication between

Discuss how information systems might be used to support decision making in business and government organizations. Provide examples from real life cases

2255 words - 9 pages restaurants with out-of-line portions and notifies their management so that corrective action can be taken.DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS (DSSs)An extension of management reports and dealing with exceptions is decision support systems (DSSs). The goal of a DSS (Clifton, Ince & Sutcliffe 2000) is to support the decision-making process although not necessarily to provide sufficient information to make the decision a fait accompli. In fact, by the nature of

Examine the principal institutions of the European Union outlining the functions that each partakes and analyse the community decision making process across the institutions

2087 words - 8 pages and the qualified majority is used for every other decision (Mc Mornach J, 199, p100). According to the procedure of qualified majority voting, each member state has a fixed number of votes. The number allocated to each country is roughly determined by its population, but progressively weighted in favour of smaller countries (Qualified Majority Voting, Online, 2006). In order for a vote to be successful. 72.3% of the votes must be unanimus that is

the vital importance of establishing ‘a system ensuring that competition in the internal market is not distorted

2609 words - 10 pages Article 3(1)(g) of the EC Treaty recognised the vital importance of establishing 'a system ensuring that competition in the internal market is not distorted.' To facilitate this, competition policy must, as has been established, 'enforce competition law whenever there are harmful effects on Europe's citizens or businesses [and] also ensure that the regulatory market fosters competitive markets.' The focus, ultimately, has been to achieve a wide

Perfoemance Reviews/Decision Making: Describe at least 4-6 problems that occur when managers complete performance reviews

1341 words - 5 pages employees year round and elevate the stress of the employee performance views.Problems with Performance ReviewsPerformance reviews are commonly approached with a high anxiety levels by both employees and managers. However, performance reviews are intended to motivate employees or team members to a work efficiently and effectively. They are also intended to improve the relationships between the employees and the managers. It is still a fact that the

Innovation is the key to product progress. How does a consumer make his or her decision? Model of consumer decision making? What is innovation? What is product progres?

1312 words - 5 pages learned person depends upon the innovative features of the product.Whereas, in a market where the consumer is less learned the importance of innovation is lesser due to the fact that the consumers in this market have less knowledge.To further understand the mind of our consumers, lets take a look at a Simple Model of Consumer Decision Making.Table 1. A Simple Model of Consumer Decision Making.The above table shows us the entire consumer decision

To What extent is Noldeke's chronology of the Qur'anic text still defensible?

1717 words - 7 pages Islam holds a unique claim in comparative religion that its sacred scripture, the Qur'an, is not the fallible work of men writing their personal accounts of a long dead teacher but the infallible dictated word of God. This essay will give an overview of modern scholars thoughts on the origin, collection and development of the text. We shall begin with Noldeke's account of the chronology of the text and move to look at Bell's and Wansbrough's

The Role of Government in Policy Making

750 words - 3 pages the legislative process is to create solutions for the social problemof concern, that is, a public policy, program design, or provision (benefit) that will plausiblycorrect the problem. That is not a simple task to do well; actual legislative proposalsvary from excellent to simplistic and all the way to unbelievably simpleminded. (Social Policy and Social Programs) Task four: is to organize public support for their issue. In order to

Evidence is always the Primary Basis for Making a Decision

3006 words - 12 pages analysis and concrete facts are likely to produce improved outcomes than decisions made instinctually or from untested theories. The purpose of this essay is to investigate whether evidence is the primary basis for making a decision and by doing so, evaluating the strengths of EBDM and in what situations this model is not the primary basis by offering alternate hypotheses.The simplest way of demonstrating how evidence is the primary basis of making

Is Ethical Hacking the Answer to Ensuring the Safety of Company’s Computer Systems?

1445 words - 6 pages it by trying to say you were helping (Spafford 1992). An extreme example of this is if a criminal attacks someone on the street and then trying to validate their actions by saying they were making others aware that the street was unsafe. Advantages and disadvantages to ethical hacking and in particular to using ethical hacking as a means to identify computer weaknesses have been explained above. One of the most important considerations to

Similar Essays

Ethically Defensible Decision Making By Danaa Ross This Paper Defines Ethically Defensible Decisions, Elements Of Ethnically Defensible Decision, And Gives Examples

1236 words - 5 pages , and give examples of ethically defensible decisions you might encounter in your workplace. After this is understood, I will describe to you a situation that occurred where the lines were blurred in my workplace, and I chose to use critical thinking to overcome the potential disaster. After the situation is clear, I will spend some time discussing ground rules, which are a part of ethical decision making, whether written or implied. Finally, I

It Has Been Claimed That "Decision Making Is Important To Every Aspect Of A Manager's Job."

3073 words - 12 pages decisions that are stronger" (De Janasz, et al., p.311). There are many people to contribute to the discussion, meaning more ideas. Consequently a decision could be made more accurate, and such a decision would generally be of better quality. The more decisions a team can make for the method/procedure while completing the task, the more the team will feel responsible for achieving success in something they "own". "Because it is then the property of team

Law And Morality. Speaks Of The Dilemma Of Making A Decision That Someone Must Die In Order For The Others To Survive. Explains And Justifies The Decision By Using Legal Tools Such As Law And Moralit

2117 words - 8 pages It is not an everyday occurrence that someone must decide the fate of another's life. The dilemma of making a decision that someone must die in order for the others to survive, can obviously be troubling. The process in which the termination of one's life may be easy to make, but to justify that decision is the most difficult one. This paper is given a situation in which a decision of taking one's life is essential. The situation is that a

Aspects Of The Practice Of Science That May Prove Useful, Especially In Decision Making

684 words - 3 pages and what biologist J. Bronowski calls "the habit of truth." It is also about courage and boldness to challenge the status quo and work for a better even though different finding. These values are actually manifested in scientific situations, in the course of experiments and discoveries but they can also be applied in daily decision-making. Aside from this, we only have to look back at our definition of science as a rational inquiry into nature