This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

On Being A Theist Essay

1973 words - 8 pages

Atheism is certainly one of the adversaries of theism. However, atheism provides an important role to theism by acting as a “devil’s advocate” which, in turn, ultimately strengthens theism. In the journal article “On Being an Atheist” written by H.J. McCloskey, McCloskey is both critical of the classical arguments for God’s existence and offers the problem of evil as a reason why one should not believe in God. McCloskey progresses through, in his opinion, the weakest arguments for theism, such as the cosmological argument, teleological argument, and the problem of evil. In the end, McCloskey asserts that atheism is more comforting than theism. Through the course of the article, McCloskey brings up constructive points of theism, however at the same time shows his misunderstanding of theism. Therefore, McCloskey acts as a “devil’s advocate” of theism, ultimately helping to strengthen the arguments for theism.
McCloskey refers to the arguments for God’s existence as “proofs” and often implies that they cannot definitively establish the case for God, so therefore they should be abandoned. However, the foremost problem with viewing the arguments for God’s existence as “proofs” is that they are not proofs. These are arguments and thus are not like the proofs found in Mathematics which are one-hundred percent certain (Foreman). Since these are arguments, not “proofs”, there is no way to come to a one-hundred percent certain conclusion with such arguments. Therefore, McCloskey is viewing and trying to use the arguments for God’s existence in an unfitting manner and in a way that they were not intended to be used.
McCloskey claims that the “mere existence of the world constitutes no reason for believing in such a being,” (1968, p. 51) however, the universe must have originated from an uncaused cause. McCloskey’s claim can be disproved with the non-temporal form of the cosmological argument which states that the universe had no beginning in time, thus it is infinitely old and the cause could have created the universe in the infinite past. Nevertheless, the world around us is made up of contingent beings which rely on a cause for their existence. This is seen in the fact that a son requires the cause of a father and the father requires the cause of a father and so on. Therefore, it is essential that the contingent beings must have a first cause that is created by a necessary being: a being that is uncaused and thus does not need further explanation (Evans & Manis, 2009, p. Loc: 672).
McCloskey also claims that the cosmological argument “does not entitle us to postulate an all-powerful, all-perfect, uncaused cause” (1968, p. 51). This statement by McCloskey shows his lack of understanding of how “limited a conclusion the cosmological argument reaches” (Evans & Manis, 2009, p. Loc: 760). The cosmological argument only claims that an uncaused necessary being was the first cause of the universe. Thus, this argument is not only an argument for the Biblical God,...

Find Another Essay On On Being a Theist

Review of Mairs' Autobiography Entitled, On Being a Cripple

684 words - 3 pages “On Being a Cripple” is placed under the genre of autobiography because it focuses on a significant personal experience in Mairs’ past and draws out the meaning as she tells her story and reflects on her experiences. The key factors of an autobiographical essay include dramatic events or episodes, vivid details and narration, and an interweaving of narration with reflection on and interpretation of the essayist’s experiences (Norton

Quinceañera: A Reflection on the State, Nature and Ultimate Being

1566 words - 7 pages of the people that celebrate it influence them. In this essay I am going to elaborate on what a Quinceañera is and how they came to be. This topic makes me reflect on how it would be like to live under another government and how much nature and the idea of an ultimate being have an effect on cultural events like this one. There is a lot of history behind how Quinceañeras came about just like there is for several other cultural inspired events

A paper on "She Being Brand" by E.E. Cummings

845 words - 3 pages it. E.E. Cummings snares the feelings perfectly. He sets the experience by reminding the reader of the importance of the poem; it is a first time. He says clearly and seemingly with so much emotion, "she being Brand-new". The sweat is just starting to form on his forehead as he and his readers truly grasp the fact that this is not only one of those exciting moments but it's a first; it's a new experience. He then goes for the heart of the

My thoughts on being hit by a Car

1671 words - 7 pages into the hard, black tarmac in the centre of the road, I had a very important decision to make. Should I remain still on the ground, or should I try and stand up. I took my chances and stood up. Although disorientated, I stayed on my feet and I turned around. My heart fell. There was a web of enormous cracks running across the Volvo's windscreen. I felt more upset that I had damaged the car than me being damaged! I thought about what implications

Lessons on Being a Good Leader Described in John Maxwell's Book, Be a People Person

520 words - 2 pages others, it is important to make every effort possible to accept others for who they are, but without being judgmental of them. Maxwell’s first lesson involves “understanding the qualities you enjoy in others” (11). In order for anyone to become a person that is well liked and admired by others, it is crucial to develop the qualities that you personally are attracted to in others. This means for example, if you really like when everyone around you

Its a campiagn for president in the US. The campiagn is based on being a democrat

792 words - 3 pages leadership. Diplomatic pressure on nations can work to flush out terrorism wherever it flourishes. Military technology should be tightly controlled. The democrats have strong ideas that have nearly devised the way to make America a better nation.Another stronghold, in terms of issues, is that of crime. With gun control legislation being debated in the congress and rising rate of drug use among teenagers, the nation as a whole is acutely aware of this

Outsiders creative writing - A depressed teenager who is being picked on by a group of people

1061 words - 4 pages The day resumed with platitudinous sentences being repeatedly mumbled to himself. "What am I doing here? What am I living for? Who cares for me...?" "Is that freak staring at me again? What is his problem?" Russell whispered to his pals. Even though David was off in his own little world on the other side of the room, he had overheard that rude comment. He wasn't looking at Russell; he was merely staring at a blank space that was in

Analysis of Allison Joseph´s On Being Told I Don´t Speak Like a Black Person

838 words - 4 pages An accent, according to www.dictionary.com, is defined as “Vocal prominence or emphasis given to a particular syllable, word, or phrase.” Around the world, different cultures have different accents because of their language and the way they say words. In Allison Joseph’s “On Being Told I Don’t Speak Like a Black Person”, this description is shown. Joseph uses her mother as an example of having an accent and her mother was from Jamaica. In World

My Take on "Top 6 Keys to Being a Successful Teacher"

804 words - 4 pages An article on About.com called "Top 6 Keys to Being a Successful Teacher" lists six important traits all teachers should possess. These "keys" are sense of humor, a positive attitude, high expectations, consistency, fairness, and last but not least flexibility. While all these traits are equally important one must remember teachers are human and at times will exhibit one trait more or less than the others. It does not make her or him a bad

The methods of research a sociologist uses depends above all on the topic being studied

968 words - 4 pages The methods of research a sociologist uses depends above all on the topic being studied.The purpose of this paper is to explore some of the possible research methods a sociologist might use to study various different topics, each method used depends greatly on the topic studied and will determine the type of results that are achieved. I will investigate a few of these methods and provide an example to show how this method was used and give

Peter Abelard's Heloise: On being a woman in Europe's Middle Ages

1592 words - 6 pages This essay will evaluate the text to illustrate the lives of women in European society during the Middle Ages by giving a synopsis of this couple's life, the setting in this period of history and finally what impact this world had on women as well as the role women made in shaping their social status.Peter Abelard (1079-1142), a French philosopher and theologian, was an early exponent of scholasticism. After studying in Paris he soon became a

Similar Essays

On Being A Theist Essay

2073 words - 8 pages Several years ago notable atheist H. J. McCloskey wrote an article titled “On Being an Atheist.” In that article, McCloskey attempts to refute some traditional arguments for the existence of God. Furthermore, in an attempt to create a positive case for atheism, he presents the problem of evil and proposes the comfort of atheism. Does McCloskey’s attempt to undermine theistic belief succeed? Is it still possible to be an intellectually fulfilled

On Being A Cripple Essay

727 words - 3 pages essay “On Being A Cripple,” Mair uses her personal stories, diction, and syntactical structures to create an optimistic tone throughout the essay, so that the audience can better connect story. Mair utilizes her personal stories to create a more relaxed and optimistic tone. She opens the story with humor saying “ … I fell over backward, landing fully clothed on the toilet seat with my legs splayed in front of me: the old beetle-on-its-back

My Philosphy On Being A Successful Leader

1451 words - 6 pages expectations are, and to clarify anything that is not understood. Although a leadership task is challenging, keeping the lines of communication open by sharing with your followers what the expectations are of you and of them, are the first steps of being a responsible leader (Daft, 2011). Leadership must develop an open door policy with your team so that they know you are available to them and having one-on-one conversations individually, will

An Being An Theist Essay

1572 words - 7 pages the cosmological argument which states that the universe had no beginning in time, thus it is infinitely old. Nevertheless, the world around us is made up of contingent beings which rely on a cause for their existence. This is seen that a son requires the cause of a father and the father requires the cause of a father and so on. Therefore, it is essential that the contingent beings must have a first cause that is created by a necessary being: a