This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

On Experts And Global Warming Essay

884 words - 4 pages

Global warming is an increasingly common subject in our political realm, and the opposing sides seem to be farther apart and more contentious than ever. In his article at NYTimes.com, “On Experts and Global Warming”, Gary Gutting argues that given the nature of the arguments this should no longer be the case. The use of experts as evidence for each side’s belief, he suggests, takes the argument out of the hands of “nonexperts” and places it within the climate scientists’ domain. While this is the example he uses, Gutting, a professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, makes it clear that this isn’t the only forum where his idea applies.
Gutting’s idea is simple, if the two sides agree that a certain topic falls into the area of expertise of a given group, then they must accept the consensus on the subject of that group. He uses Global Warming as an example of a current issue that exemplifies his idea. Gutting points out that both sides have recognized “climate scientists” as the experts on this subject since both use studies and statements from this field to support their beliefs. Since the opposing parties have agreed on a field of expertise, Gutting argues that the consensus of that field on the topic should be accepted by each. “As long as they accept the expert authority of the discipline of climate science, they have no basis for supporting the minority position” (Gutting, 2011). Being “nonexperts” themselves, opponents are in no position to reject the conclusions of the majority, leaving only one other option. “It follows that a nonexpert who wants to reject [anthropogenic global warming] can do so only by arguing that climate science lacks the scientific status needed be taken seriously in our debates about public policy” (Gutting, 2011).
This question of the purpose of experts in a democracy, as Gutting points out, has been around since the beginning of democracy itself. More recently this idea has been grabbing headlines again, specifically around the idea of Global Warming. As the first Republican primaries approach, the differing views on the reliability of experts between the potential presidential candidates are becoming clear. One Candidate, Rick Perry, as an example was recently quoted in a CBSNews.com article as having the following to say about climate scientists, “There are a substantial number of scientists who have manipulated data so that they will have dollars rolling into their projects" (Montopoli, 2011). These recent events along with the general election itself are the clear exigencies for Gutting’s argument.
Most of the arguments and debates around the topic of Global Warming are occurring primarily in the political sphere. Gutting even suggests that it is the voters who inevitably decide who should be listened to by our government,...

Find Another Essay On On Experts and Global Warming

Penguins and Global Warming Essay

1516 words - 7 pages , global climate change is also having important impacts. In the Atlantic part of the southern ocean, ocean warming and the melting of sea ice are associated to the decline of the penguin’s major food supply. Krill in this region have declined by as much as eighty percent since the 1970s. Since krill are on algae that grow on the bottom of the sea ice, the loss of ice leads to the loss of krill. Researchers project that a 1 degree rise in sea

Global Warming and Its’ Economic Effects on Businesses and Consumers

1006 words - 5 pages Have you ever wondered why each year there seems to be more of major natural disasters than previous years? How about the increase in prices on things such as, foods, clothes, and materials made with rubber? Ironically, un-enounced to most of the world, natural disasters, and price increases go hand in hand. However, it is global warming that is causing these natural disasters that affect businesses and the ending result is it affects their

Economics and Global Warming

1821 words - 7 pages global warming. While it may not be entirely possible to reverse the harmful effects of global warming on the Earth, scientists and economists agree that there is the possibility to slow the trend. Human activity has shown to be a root contributor to the rise in greenhouse gas emission, and, as a solution, the amount of gases must be lowered significantly. This means that there must be limits on the amount of emissions a firm or industry can produce

Population and Global Warming

982 words - 4 pages Population and Global Warming In recent years, people have begun to realize the adverse affects of the technologies we use. The tools that humans use to harness energy change the face of the environment around us. When the industrial revolution began, I am sure that no one thought that the innovation taking place could potentially be the cause of a huge change in our surroundings. People were just doing what they thought was the best

1309 Words Essay on Global Warming: Causes, Effects and Remedies

1316 words - 5 pages 1309 Words Essay on Global Warming: Causes, Effects and RemediesGlobal warming is the greatest challenge facing our planet. It is, in fact, the increase in the temperature of the earth's neon- surface air. It is one of the most current and widely discussed factors. It has far-reaching impact on biodiversity and climatic conditions of the planet. Several current trends clearly demonstrate that global warming is directly impacting on rising sea

Comparison of 2 Articles on Global Warming and Climate Changes

1000 words - 4 pages in the atmosphere and level of global warming is overestimated by the new models. The heating is located in the depth of oceans, and the amount of measured carbon uptake is larger than what it actually is. Lastly, ocean uptake of heat and carbon has been slowing over the past eight years. Article .2: Panel Says Global Warming Carries Risk of Deep Changes Summary: Global warming is on a rise possessing a risk of swift, radical changes on the

This a cause and effect essay on Global Warming

1334 words - 5 pages though it simply stabilizes gases at a recent level" (Times A27). Bill Clinton, who ran for election in 1992 as an environmental advocate, seems to be back peddling on his proclaimed commitment to the environment and world ecology. Environmentalists see his watered-down proposals, as well as his traffic with American industrialists, as an environmental sellout. They feel that global warming is directly related to industrialization and consumption of

Research on the Effects and Causes of Global Warming

2318 words - 9 pages are people in the world that believe that there is another reason why this is happening; earth is experiencing a natural cycle of evolution. Global warming is a very serious part of the world and a solution needs to be found immediately. The greenhouse effect is the cause of global warming in the world. The greenhouse effect is a topic of discussion throughout the world; it needs to be contained immediately. “Our effect on the environment, and

Humans Effect on Global Warming

1424 words - 6 pages the fossil fuels come from burning in automobiles, factories and electric power plants which provide energy for houses and office buildings (McClure n. pag.). Continued global warming can cause harm to plants and animals that live in the sea and force plants and animals on land to move to new habitats. It could also change weather patterns that cause flooding, drought and an increase in damaging storms. Global warming could melt the polar ice

Class Journal on Global Warming

713 words - 3 pages warming's effects, if in different ways. It will hit us all where we live." 1Global warming is "a rise in the average temperature of the earth's climate due to a build-up of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere." Our society is mostly powered by fossil fuels which contribute to global warming.After reading a bit of information on global warming, several questions came to my mind. Why don't people know the urgency of this situation and why hasn't the

Discuss what is global warming. And the effects that global warming gives and how to prevent it. And a little history on global warming

1109 words - 4 pages What is global warming, and how is it affecting the Earth and its inhabitants? Global Warming is sometimes referred to as the greenhouse effect. The greenhouse effect is the absorption of energy radiated from the Earth's surface by carbon dioxide and other gases in the atmosphere, causing the atmosphere to become warmer. The greenhouse effect is what is causing the temperature on the Earth to rise, and creating many problems that will begin to

Similar Essays

Speech On Global Warming

494 words - 2 pages 1. Global warming was once an uncommon term used by a few scientists who were concerned about the decades of pollution affecting long-term weather patterns. 2. Good morning/afternoon whatever your teachers name is and fellow classmates. Today the idea of global warming is well known, but not many people understand it. 3. It is not unusual to hear someone complaining about a hot day or a freak storm and remark, “its global warming”. Well, is it

Critique On Global Warming Essay

1149 words - 5 pages films “An inconvenient truth” by Davis Guggenheim and “The great global warming swindle” by Martin Durkin state contradicting opinions on this topic. In the documentary “An inconvenient truth” Al Gore, the ex-vice president of the USA discusses the present and future effects of global warming and the consequences that we will incur if the amount of the greenhouse gases generated is not reduced in the future. The documentary “The great global

Essay On Global Warming:

1547 words - 6 pages Age to the present day, focusing particularly on the Younger Dryas period, situated between two major periods of warming. What happened during the Younger Dryas, which was a period of sudden but brief cold, is one indication of what might happen as a result of continued global warming. However, another scenario was offered by Peter Gent's Climate System Model which indicated that instead of a sudden (and brief) cooling -as happened during the

Canada And Global Warming Essay

887 words - 4 pages unemployment rate and taxes.Therefore, global warming is negatively affecting Canada and the rest of the world. In order to slow it down, certain countries have formed an agreement/law on how to protect the environment. The Kyoto Protocol will act as a guideline as how the world is evolving technologically, economically, and environmentally. Many consequences will result because of global warming, but the protocol will aid in removing some disadvantages and providing some benefits. Consequently, the Kyoto Protocol is a good way to help Canada control global warming.