This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

On Plato’s Critique Of The Arts

912 words - 4 pages

Catherine Dicus, On Plato's Critique of the Arts, Phil 270, Essay 3Plato calls for the expulsion of mimetic art in the Republic and the Apology. For example, in the Republic, Plato discredits "any kind of poetry that is imitative" (Book x) and in the Apology, he states, "The poets say many fine things, but know nothing of that of which they speak" (21d). Critiques of Plato's argument suggest that Plato's use of myths and images in his dialogues is problematic. I will argue the opposite: that Plato's use of myths and images in his dialogues are acceptable because 1) his arguments function as the basis for his works and the style functions as decorations to his arguments and 2) Plato meets his own criterion to allow art because his decorations are of the right kind.Before explaining Plato's argument that imitative poetry is invalid, I must first explain the mimetic theory that Plato bases his findings on and define certain words. When Plato uses mimesis, he applies the following idea: mimesis is a third step removed from the truth. In addition, Plato's definition of art is simply an artistic object/work that signifies both events and things in nature, such as battles and weddings. [1: Mimesis is a Greek word that means "imitation", but Plato applies a slightly modified meaning to the word.]I will now explain Plato's argument in detail. Throughout the Republic, Plato's condemnation of poetry is based on two branches of thought: one branch is epistemological, where the mimetic poet generally lacks knowledge, (595c-602b) and one branch is ethical, where poets who do not realize their lack of truthful knowledge, instruct others as if they knew real knowledge (602c-607a). Thus, poetry is created from an agent who lacks knowledge on moral matters. However, such poets, when creating mimetic art, teach poetry as if they knew knowledge. Sharing not-knowledge as if it were knowledge is problematic because those that do not know that poets are creating imitations of art/knowledge, accept these imitations as the real thing. Plato then describes mimetic poetry is based on false pretenses and is therefore immorally wrong.My view is that Plato's use of myths and images in his dialogue is not problematic in light of his criticisms of the arts in the Republic and the Apology. I will now defend this claim through two reasons. My first reason is, rather than using mimetic art to convince the audience, Plato uses mimetic art as a decoration to his argument. If Plato had stated point blank that mimetic artists/poets are ignorant, then his use of stylized writing would have made his own argument invalid. However, Plato does not sate that all mimetic poets are ignorant; rather, Plato asserts that when...

Find Another Essay On On Plato’s Critique of the Arts

The Impact of the Great Depression on the Arts

663 words - 3 pages international trading, failed on several accounts. Within the United States, Hoover, the most lacking meteorologist of the intensity and length of the Great Depression, was widely blamed after his statement,” a passing incident in our national lives,” was soon proved extremely incorrect when the crisis lasted 61 days. The Great Depression not only affected the people masking the storm, but their methods of preserving the hardship. The arts: photography

The Effect of WWII on the Visual Arts

930 words - 4 pages The global trauma of World War II, particularly the events that took place at Auschwitz and Hiroshima, caused dramatic changes in the visual arts. New ideas and criticisms of culture and society had come about, and artists were responding--consciously and unconsciously--to the war.New ideas about the arts had emerged shortly after the war. The long-standing notion that the arts make society more civilized and raise people above their instincts

The Violent Impact of Mixed Martial Arts on Society

1291 words - 5 pages UFC, Pride, Strike Force, and all other Mixed Martial Arts programs should be banned from the Media. These programs feature men and women exchanging harsh words followed by, violent, 15 minute fights. The vigorous fighting displayed can cause severe injuries, and or death. Contenders of UFC and Strike Force are not the only ones participating in fight clubs; children and teens are starting their own fight clubs in their local schools. As a

Plato’s Theory of The Soul in The Republic

2176 words - 9 pages proceeding moral philosophy, as Plato’s definition has been used ever since as a standard since then. Plato’s confabulation on the soul contains three main portions: defining each of the three parts and explanation of their functions, description of the interaction of the parts, and then how the the parts and their interaction motivate action. This essay will investigate each segment, and seek to explain their importance. For Plato, the soul is

Plato’s Allegory of the Cave and The Matrix

2873 words - 11 pages knowledge. By his use of philosophical themes, Plato is able to further his points on enlightenment, knowledge, and education. In this allegory, the depictions of humans as they are chained, their only knowledge of the world is what is seen inside the cave. Plato considers what would happen to people should they embrace the concepts of philosophy, to become enlightened by it, to see things as they truly are. As we have mentioned in class, Plato’s

Censorship of the arts

942 words - 4 pages distributed about 20% of its funds directly to the states, all of which established their own arts funding agencies by 1974. (This comes from The Facts on File News Services, "Update: Arts Funding") NEA grants are awarded on a selective basis to artists or organizations whose projects are deemed to have artistic merit. The decisions about artistic merit is made by a series of expert panels whose staff is appointed by the president.In the late

purpose of the arts

841 words - 4 pages Our society today is a visual one that is greatly influenced by the by the arts: painting, prints, dance, photography, movies, television, and literature. Imagine lives without art, businesses would not advertise as easily, we would not be able to look back at the past, or express our inner feelings. The arts help serve many purposes for awareness of social causes, propaganda, and recreating experiences. Social causes are a widely discussed

Bullying Of The Arts

1033 words - 5 pages focused on test. In 12 of 15 school shooting cases in the 1990’s, the shooter had a history of being bullied. The arts have open there doors to bullied victims for a very long time, and have been known to help much with their emotional problems and give the victims a sense of security to be themselves without being harassed, embraced, and picked on. The arts have many branches, there is dance, theater, vocal, band, piano, orchestra, visual

Outline Plato’s Arguments For The Distinct Existence Of The Soul

1235 words - 5 pages experienced learning but rather from recollection i.e. a previous knowledge gained of ideas. This is an allusion to Plato's theory of forms, which suggests that we all recognise concepts such as equality because we all have knowledge of absolute equality or as Plato called it "the perfect form of equality". Returning to the Phaedo Socrates sums up the argument from recollection like this. Firstly knowledge [of equality] cannot be based on bodily

The Arts of Mozart

754 words - 3 pages /2012# The date occurs before January 30, 2012. Greater than >#30/1/2012# The date occurs after January 30, 2012. Between Between #1/10/2013# and #31/10/2013# The date occurs on October 2010. Greater than the current date >Date( ) The date occurs today or after. Less than the current date <Date( ) The date occurs yesterday or before. Greater than the current date (and time) >Now() The date occurs today

The Presentation of Socrates' Arguements in Plato’s Apology and Crito

967 words - 4 pages In both Plato’s Apology and Crito, Plato presents Socrates arguments clearly and precisely. Socrates is wise man with a different perspective on life, which presents us with a mass of contradictions. Socrates is an expressive man, yet he never recorded any works. He is ignorant, but wrongfully convicted who is willing to fight his unjust execution. Behind these dilemmas is an opposition not often explored. Socrates is the most patriotic of

Similar Essays

Plato’s Theories On The Immortal Soul

1810 words - 7 pages . I, however, disagree with Plato’s theory, believing that everyone should have the equal opportunity to reach his or her potential, and that there is no perfect society. Plato often argued that the soul was separated into three parts, also known as the Tripartite Theory. The first part of the soul identified by Plato is eros, also known as appetite. This is defined as the base of biological cravings for food, thirst, and sexual desire. The

Plato’s Crito: The Last Days Of Socrates

1480 words - 6 pages , his death will reflect poorly on Crito. The people will think that Crito did nothing to save his friend. If Socrates is worried about the risk or the financial cost to Crito; it’s an expense that he is willing to pay, and that he made arrangements for Socrates to live a life of exile in a pleasant manner. The next argument that Crito pleads to Socrates is that, if he stays, he would be helping his enemies in their injustices, and in turn would

Art Critique About The Work Of James Mark Salarda's "Explicit And Implicit" Arts Essay

1153 words - 5 pages + AMDG Name: __Christienne Marie M. Santiago_____________ Date: Sept 01, 2017 Section: __12- Eloquentia_________________________ Course: Core 14 Title of Artwork: __Explicit & Implicit_____________ Artist: __James Mark Salarda_____________ For Description: What colors can you see from the artwork?_ Answer/Explanation: The artwork contains a lot of colors like light blue, pink, white, black, and grey. On the left side of the artwork, it

On The Subject Of Education, How Are Plato’s “The Allegory Of The Cave” And Malcolm X’s “Learning To Read” Simil

990 words - 4 pages “If we are thinking about effect of education – or the lack of it – on our nature, there is another comparison we can make”(The Allegory of the Cave by Plato 1). Plato was a philosopher in Classical Greece; he was fighting for freedom and education. Malcolm X was an African-American Muslim who was fighting for human rights. They both had a vision of freedom and education. We have two stories; one is “The Allegory of the Cave” and “Learning to