One Setting, Two Stories Essay

1550 words - 7 pages

Many literary critics agree that Cormac McCarthy is one of the premier contemporary fiction writers. He is known for his bleak, stripped-down writing style, evading punctuation and disregarding convention of spelling. His view of the world is perceptibly dark, as seen through his novels, and the violence and lawlessness that permeates his writing reflects a troubled yet caring understanding of his world. In two of his greatest works, Blood Meridian and The Road, McCarthy stages his tales in a bleak, post-apocalyptic world to tell two stories which, while sharing many atmospheric elements take two different approaches to essentially the same setting. Both in character and use of language, McCarthy deftly weaves two stories that dance around their shared, bleak, apocalyptic settings with a stunning dissimilarity.
The Road tells the story of a man and his son traversing a vastly abandoned road with no purpose other than that basest need—survival. Throughout the novel it becomes clear that this survival, at least until the very end, is motivated by mutual commitment between the father and son. Perseverance, driven by the code of the “fire” imbued by the father seems to be their only option. The title of the novel is no coincidence—the road represents their journey forward in a time and place in which forward action seems futile and naïve. Certainly, the cannibalistic gangs that have assumed control of the road share no such ethos. McCarthy, then, seems to be arguing that while much of humanity requires little impetus to revert to animalistic behavior, the positivistic perseverance driving the man and the boy is another possibility.
The Road is immediately striking in its toned-down language, describing a catastrophic world while maintaining horrifying concision. The work is filled with pithy yet heavily philosophical jabs-- “Where men can't live gods fare no better”, and “There is no God and we are his prophets”, giving the man and the boy an almost divine quality. The sentences are short but packed with meaning; the metaphors are rich but accessible on first read.
The lack of color and the bleakness of the wasteland thrust the reader not only into the aesthetic direness of the scenario but the haltingness of emotion as well; the words “gray” and “black” appear around a hundred times apiece in this novel. In the entire story, there is only one named party, because the specifics of the characters are unimportant. It is the universality of human nature especially in crisis that McCarthy is so brilliantly grappling with. Yet every word is essential and powerful, and the book becomes impossible to abandon along with its imperfect and weary cast who nevertheless persevere with phenomenal strength. Even the nature of the presumed apocalypse itself is ambiguous, supporting the idea that McCarthy wants his readers to face head on the darkness he sees in the beautiful, if torrid world.
Blood Meridian, like The Road, follows travelers in a...

Find Another Essay On One setting, two stories

Romeo and Juliet, west side story, compare and contrast

514 words - 2 pages love of the two lovers brings the two families together. But the two families learn their lesson a little bit too late. Their hatred already claimed the life of two innocent people. In "West Side Story" something similar happens. There are also two lovers in this story. The lovers were separated because of gang related violence. In this story, the violence between two gangs also caused death.The setting of the two stories is one of the few

The Yellow Wallpaper and The Cask Of Amontillado

766 words - 3 pages fool. While the settings in the two stories are very different, the different settings create the elements to the stories. The narrator in "The Yellow Wallpaper" becomes haunted by the wallpaper in her room. The setting takes place in the room, she dislikes the room from the moment she sees it and fells suffocated by it. Her feeling of suffocation and being haunted by the wallpaper helps the reader become more aware of her motivation for

Comparative Essay on "To Earn My Living" & A "Man Told Me the Story of His Life", The similarities and differences between those two stories.

812 words - 3 pages story, it describes the place clearly as "It was a tiny little village, flat on its back, by which I mean really set flat upon the flatness, and almost entirely red in colour." (Gabrielle Roy, 2001, pg.53.) Therefore the method used to describe the setting is different between these two stories.The Last difference between the two stories is that the characters' background of choosing their job. In Vincente's situation, although he wants to become

"Love in L.A." vs. "The Red Convertible" - Compare and Contrast

556 words - 2 pages . They contrast by the lies being told in two different forms. Jake lied through being sly and persuasive and Henry lied through acting normal.The setting in both short stories compare in the time era. In the story "Love in L.A." the era was not mentioned, but Jake was driving a 1958 Buick. That being the only clue to what the time period this is taking place, one can only assume. In the "Red Convertible" Henry was drafted into Vietnam. This means

Similarities and Differences in Shirley Johnson's The Lottery and Hernando Tellez' "Just Lather, That's All"

597 words - 2 pages . The similarities and differences between these stories have been critically reviewed and will be discussed in the essay. The two stories are both centered on a particular person in the story. “The Lottery” was centered round Tessie Hutchinsen who happened to be the unlucky one to have picked the marked paper and had to be stoned to death. Tessie was at that period, the only one who saw the unfairness of the situation. She screams, “It isn't fair

Good Country People Vs A Good Man Is Hard To Find

978 words - 4 pages with Manley Pointer, the Misfit also gets away without being caught.So as you can see the two stories "Good Country People" and "A Good Man is Hard to Find" have very similar characteristics including the setting, characters and structure. So although two stories may seem very different there always seems to be something that can link them together.

Symbolism; The Underlying Message

863 words - 3 pages symbols. Death, smell and setting combine to give a myriad of deeper meaning to the stories. The symbol that means the most in both stories is death. Death is a massive symbol that is in the two stories. Alexie’s story “This is what it means to say Phoenix, Arizona" states that, “Victor hadn’t seen his father in a few years, only talked to him on the telephone once or twice, but there was still a genetic pain, which was soon to be pain as real

Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman

896 words - 4 pages Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman. The two stories we were asked to compare had one common themes which were the building of fear and suspense throughout. One clear difference between the stories was the function of fear in the stories. In the 'The Red Room' the author does not only use fear as a means of evolving the story but also places it at the centre of the story. 'The Signalman' uses fear of the supernatural as a

Connection between settings and action

907 words - 4 pages surrounded by crazy people. If she isn’t one of them then they consider her to be a patient. they’ve built a kind of mentality that the patients are all delusional and can’t be trusted so when they see someone in an asylum not of their ranking they automatically associate her with a patient. As you can see in both stories that the setting connects with the way characters in the story think and act. In both Lord of the Flies and I Only Came To Use The

Essay on the Setting in Curtain of Green

701 words - 3 pages The Setting in Curtain of Green    Place is one of the most distinctive factors in the development of Eudora Welty's writing and in her own evaluation of fiction in general. Welty considers setting to be a powerful tool for a writer of fiction. She sees setting as a way to provide roots for her characters and a realistic basis for her stories (Vande Kieft 8). In more general terms, Welty feels that place is so inherently

"Greasy Lake" by Jack London and "To Build a Fire" by T. Coraghessan Boyle.

941 words - 4 pages Short Stories: SettingThe setting of a story can allude to what kind of story it will be. There are many things that a setting is able to suggest other than simply where the story takes place. A story's setting deals with the place that the story occurs, the time it takes place in, and the atmosphere that it evokes. It can show that there will be romance, it will be funny, there will be suspense, or just that something bad will happen. Two

Similar Essays

Grapes Of Wrath (One Cover..Two Stories)

1397 words - 6 pages No simple definition can describe religion, however, with the many affiliations between Steinbeck's Grapes of Wrath and the Bible, one can easily envision what it entails. When first beginning my journey with the Grapes of Wrath, I merely embraced it for its literal meaning. I soon realized that doing so limited my ability to understand it at the intellectual level it called for. Changing my unfit ways, the story promptly took a new turn, for I

One World, One Land, Two Stories

551 words - 2 pages Two sixteenth century writers, John Smith and William Bradford, write about their experiences in North America in The General History (John Smith) and in Of Plymouth Plantation (William Bradford). Facing many struggles, both authors experience hardship physically and introspectively. Along with environmental and personal struggles came social struggles with the Indians. Landing on the same continent, William Bradford and John Smith give similar

"There Is Always A Moment In Childhood When The Door Opens To Let The Future In." Discuss With Reference To Two Stories From "Twenty One Short Stories" (Graham Greene).

517 words - 2 pages only a cause of embarrassment. This was soon to change. Blacker, a local baker, bribes him to get a consecrated host. The boy realises that his action would be sinful; 'I didn't want to play with the train any more that day', he says. However, he obeys Blacker out of fear. When the boy gets the host and inserts it between two sheets, he describes the host as a 'little damp mess of pump'. It had little value to him. Later that night, however, he

Compare The Similarities Of Short Stories, Poetry And Drama

807 words - 3 pages , story, or the poem is joyful.Allegory, myth and symbol are some another elements short stories, poetry and drama have in common. "An allegory is a story with two parallel meanings, one is figuratively and the other is literal." An allegories is often used by writers in short stories, poetry and drama to give their writing a deeper meaning and can be use to teach readers or viewers a lesson. A myth is "anonymous story reflecting the religious and