‘Only The Type Identity Theory Can Secure The Causal Efficacy Of The Mental’ Discuss University Of Nottingham Philosophy Undergraduate First Year Essay

1513 words - 7 pages

‘Only the type-identity theory can secure the causal efficacy of the mental’ Discuss
In my essay I will argue that type-identity is the only theory that can secure the causal efficacy of the mental. I will first present the Identity theory as a theory for mental causation. I will then look to object this theory with the Functionalist position and Cartesian Dualism. However, I hope to show in what follows, that the type-identity theory provides solutions to the problems that both of these theories face using the causal exclusion argument. Throughout this essay, I will prove that type-identity theory is the only theory that can secure the causal efficacy of the mental.
The Identity Theory hold the position that all mental state types are physical types and therefore are identical to physical state types. This is to say that both mental and physical state types are one and the same thing as they are regarded as numerically identical. The Identity Theory can henceforth be used as an argument for physicalism as mental and physical states are regarded as one. One can use Princess Elizabeth’s Challenge to Cartesian Dualism argument to argue for the Identity Theory as a form of physicalism. Her argument is that mental states can cause physical effects in the same way that they physical states can. Seeing as how the physical effects of mental causes are not overdetermined, it is reasonable to say that mental states are therefore identical to physical states (Elizabeth in Shapiro, (2007) p. 62). Referring back to the example of pain, an Identity Theorist would hold the position that the state of pain is identical to the physical state of firing of C-fibers within the brain (Polger, (2009), p.822-834). In this way, the mental state type is identical to a corresponding brain state type. As a form of physicalism the identity theory can be considered as an a posteriori thesis meaning that it can be empirically supported by science. It is widely-known that there is a link between the mind and the brain which is arguably physical. The physical and chemical effects of drugs such as ecstasy have been seen to lead to changes in mental states including hallucinations. The change happening within the brain state is also occurring in the mental as they are both the same, henceforth supporting the type-identity argument.
Functionalism is also a theory which could be considered for the causal efficacy of the mental. It is the principle makes any type of mental state be defined by its functional role, rather than its “internal constitution” (Levin, (2016)). It argues for a mental state’s causal profile to show how a state can have causal outputs and inputs. Pain, for example, has the causal profile of being caused by some injury, it then causes behavioral changes such as crying or anxiety and finally leads someone to have the desire to no longer be within that state (Levin, (2016)). This state of pain is one that can be shared among many, whether they are human or...

Find Another Essay On ‘Only the type-identity theory can secure the causal efficacy of the mental’ Discuss - University of Nottingham Philosophy Undergraduate First Year - Essay

“Three-Year Efficacy of Complex Insulin Regimens in Type 2 Diabetes”

1447 words - 6 pages NTDP Cohort 7 Journal Critique Title: “Three-Year Efficacy of Complex Insulin Regimens in Type 2 Diabetes” Journal: The New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 361, no. 18, pages 1736-1747 Purpose: How do complex insulin regimens affect glycated hemoglobin, rate of hypoglycemia and weight gain in type 2 diabetic patients? Introduction Type 2 diabetes mellitus is often treated with metformin and an oral hypoglycemic

Discuss the extent to which trade theory can be used to explain the competitiveness of locations

3091 words - 12 pages ability to produce a certain good with fewer resources than the trading partner. Here is an example of how the Theory of Absolute Advantage worked. Assume labor is the only factor of production. It can be used for the production of either food or cloth.Output per labor hourFood ClothUS 12 3Mexico 6 9Suppose workers in the US produce 12 units of food or 3 yards of cloth in an hour's time; Mexican workers can produce 6 units of food or 9 yards of

VARIOUS GROUPS IN WHICH INDUSTRIAL ACTIVITIES CAN BE DIVIDED - dmi st john the baptist university second year first semester - assignment

1787 words - 8 pages types of organizations. However, the management theory of henry fayol is criticized in the following aspects; The first is Higher Level Management which is the most important criticism regarding Fayol’s concept is that he has analyzed management mainly from the view point of the top level managers. He considers that the top level managers only plan vital role in making an enterprise successful. But, practically it is not true. He has not considered

Discuss Bazin's idea that 'realism in art can only be achieved through artifice'. What are the implications for film of his approach? Make reference to films in your answers

1570 words - 6 pages the sound-track, However, he believes that the montage and décor are not the only ways of destroying the visual unity of space thus it is not sensible to single them out. Moreover, he sees Bazin's theory leads to 'no more cinema'. He sees the ' fundamental essence of film is to destroy everything that distinguishes it as film' as a paradox.In this essay, using Andre Bazin's famous argument 'reality in film can only be achieved through artifice', I have provided the analysis of application of different artifice, especially camera techniques and editing technique in two forms of realistic films in a large context of realistic theories.

Critically discuss the view that 'Universal Welfare provision can only ever be wasteful and lead to welfare dependency'. Give examples to illustrate your points

2091 words - 8 pages Key Concepts in Social PolicySXP1004Critically discuss the view that 'Universal Welfare provision can only ever be wasteful and lead to welfare dependency'. Give examples to illustrate your points.For this assignment, in the hope of covering the above statement the writer will discuss what the word welfare means and how we came about in the 1940's to implement a modern welfare system. Also, the writer will look how the effects of the thatcher

Feminist perspective on human security - La Trobe University - Major Research Essay first year

1758 words - 8 pages being talked about and dealt with in today’s political climate. The UN Security Council (SCR) recognised feminist activism with the resolution 1325 in October 2000. The resolution acknowledges the role women play in international peace and security (Hudson N 2010, p.44). This was a turning point in the UN as it was the first time they unanimously agreed on a gender issue (Hudson N 2010, p.45). The result of UNSCR 1325 can be seen around the world


507 words - 3 pages system of division of labour. The caste system can be served as Trade Guilds by regulating production and prices and helping to settle trade disputes. Caste is an endogamous group. It permits marriage only within the caste and thereby can preserve racial purity of each caste. Through performing all rights and rituals, worshipping of different kinds of gods and goddesses and celebrating of different religious festivals the caste system can provide

The Causal Theory of Action: Overpopulation

1625 words - 7 pages The problem of mental overpopulation is pretty easy to see. It is visible in situations like freezing on a test, cramping on the field, or overthrowing the first baseman. Basically, those times when you overthink or try to do too much in a situation, those thoughts actually become detrimental and stop us from performing as well as expected. Philosophers Ruben and Dreyfus do a really good job of highlighting this problem in the Causal Theory of

Academic Performance in First Year Australian University Students: Annotated Bibliography

1521 words - 6 pages Krause, K. & Coates, H. (2008). Students’ engagement in first-year university. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 33(5), 493-505. Retrieved August 13, 2010 This article was written by two authors: Kerri-lee Krause and Hamish Coates. The article is directed to the Australian students during their experience in the first year of learning. The authors have made use of data that was collected from a national study. This data represented

the inadequacies of Ricardian Theory - undergraduate - economics

1899 words - 8 pages trade depend on demand patterns, but must lie within the two autarky price ratios Ljx/LjY. Nevertheless, this fits in a world characterised by perfect competition of good, where the government must not interfere with the international trade and currency effects are negligible. Up to what extent can we test the efficacy of Ricardo?s Theory? First evidences of the Ricardian Theory were tested by MacDougall who proved that a country with a

Does the Causal Theory of Knowledge Solve the Gettier Problem?

686 words - 3 pages The purpose of this paper is to argue that Alvin Goldman's paper "A Causal Theory of Knowing" does not solve the problem in Edmund Gettier's paper "Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?" To argue the old view of knowledge, Gettier presents a case in which a Subject (S) is justified in believing that a proposition (P) and P entails another proposition (Q). S deduces Q from P and accepts Q. Then S is justified in believing Q. In the first Case that

Similar Essays

Discuss The Differences Between Romanticism And Realism University Of Nottingham Essay

1995 words - 8 pages Discuss the difference between Romanticism and Realism From the beginning of the nineteenth century, and continuing into the latter half of that century, the primary style of writing employed by American authors was that of romanticism. With a central focus on the author as the sole creator, the romantics were not concerned with accurate portrayal of events; the author has ‘a right to present that truth under circumstances, to a great extent, of

Shopping Is Not Merely The Acquisition Of Things, It Is The Buying Of Identity Nottingham Trent University Essay

2024 words - 9 pages Emily Allen, N0634051 ‘Shopping is not merely the acquisition of things, it is the buying of identity’ (Clammer qtd in Lewis and Bridger, 2001: 103). Discuss with reference to your own examples. We are regularly told that we live in a time of freedom and choice, that freedom and choice are connected, and that we are ‘free to choose’ hence why shopping has become the buying of identity, and not just simply the acquisition of things. In the early

First Year Of University Studies Essay

747 words - 3 pages . I was still the same person I had always been, only now presented with much more opportunity and room to grow. Thus, rather than continuing to flounder in grandiose thought, I began to experience what only a university can offer, by embracing the infinite potential presented to me. The first of my forays into the unique environment of a university was participating in a study abroad program. As soon as I set foot on campus, my attention

Interview Essay For First Year Writing University Of Michigan Essay

777 words - 4 pages political science. She seemed friendly and personable, ready to offer up answers to any question I might ask. “I’m sorry, I ramble a lot,” she said sheepishly at one point during the interview. I disagreed and insisted she continue. Prior to this she had told me about growing up in a small town- what she feels is one of the most important aspects of her identity. Stephanie grew up in Clawson, a suburban town outside of Detroit, with a graduating