Opposing Views Of The Effectiveness Of Monetary Policy

1486 words - 6 pages

Opposing Views of the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy

Monetary policy is a powerful governmental weapon which has historically proven that it is difficult to wield. This difficulty is one of the reasons why some economists doubt the effectiveness of monetary policy as a whole. These economists find that monetary policy is difficult to implement because of estimation problems and time lag problems, as well as cyclic effects. They also point out situations in which monetary policy may not work at all. On the other hand, some economists swear by monetary policy as one of the most influential economic tools. These economists show that controlling money supply in America is a relatively young idea, and is developing rapidly. They also attempt to show that money supply affects many variables in our economy, and that it is useful in more situations than the anti-monetary policy economists, Keynesian economists, would have us believe.

To gauge the ineffectiveness of monetary policy some economists call our attention to the great depression. How could governmental monetarists allow one quarter of the country to be unemployed[1] or for one third of commercial banks to be put out of business by “bank panics?”[2] People who took part in these bank panics were not only taking out their “own” money, but were taking out possible loans for others (the amount they took out multiplied by the money multiplier) which eventually became 31% of the total money supply.[3] The economist best fit to use monetary policy would be able to tell the future, or at least provide a pretty good estimate. These estimates are very difficult when sometimes the results of policy actions are not seen for months to over a year. Corrections of these actions could take just as long, sending the country for a roller coaster ride. “Milton Friedman, lifelong foe of the Federal Reserve System”[4] blames the “Fed” for their inaction during the great depression. Had the Fed raised the money supply during the depression perhaps more banks would be able to survive, unemployment would drop, and the U.S. would pull itself out of the depression much sooner and quicker than it had. The failure to act was probably due to the immaturity of monetary policy at the time, and perhaps learning from the past is the best we can do. There is still, however, the fact that it takes great estimation skills to use monetary policy effectively, and this provides doubt for the effectiveness of the Fed’s actions concerning money supply. There is also a time lag associated with monetary policy. The fed had raised the discount rate too late in order to slow down the stock market boom of 1929. The ill timed raise of the discount rate did contract the money supply; however, it did so during the stock market crash, making the entire situation a whole lot worse. This time lag in the policy’s effect helps to magnify the estimation problem.


Find Another Essay On Opposing Views of the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy

A Review of First Monetary Policy Overburdened

1773 words - 7 pages ; and developed his arguments using four typical economies, US, Japan, UK and Euro area. He claimed that especially after the GFC, monetary policy is compelled to achieve these goals which are beyond its traditional responsibility with the end result of compromising its independence and credibility, hence diminishing its effectiveness in achieving its primary goal of price stability. Price stability via Inflation targeting (IT) was emphasised

The Effectiveness of the Legislation and Policy Reforms in Practice

2618 words - 10 pages The Effectiveness of the Legislation and Policy Reforms in Practice In this essay I will set out to identify key legislation, which has impacted and shaped the lives of my particular client group, adults with learning disabilities. Learning disabilities can be hard to define, but it is widely accepted that impairments in the ability to read, write, spell, speak or perform any mathematical calculations can lead to a

Opposing Views of Glacial Age and History on Mt. Kilimanjaro

1347 words - 5 pages information in a concise and understandable manner which can be used by resource managers and policy makers will be the challenge of scientists. The studies presented here illustrate the uncertainties that may arise when analyzing ice core data and the importance in adequately interpreting and analyzing information obtained from glacial deposits. Works Cited Kaser, Georg, Mölg,T., Cullen, N.J., Hardy, D.R., Winkler, M. "Is the Decline of Ice

Independent Bank of England, Essay topic: Significance of the Indpendent Monetary Policy Comitee in the U.K. over the nation's economy

839 words - 3 pages that result from the decisions that it makes.In 1997, the power to set interest rates in the United Kingdom was given to a new Monetary Policy Committee (the MPC). Few decisions have as much macro-economic effects as the level of short term interest rates. Currently, the government sets the inflation level targets, and the MPC sets the interest rates to meet that target. The objectives of the independent Bank of England were explained in the 1998

The Effectiveness of Sanctions

2099 words - 8 pages the situation for which these sanctions were based upon. Although creating a new overall sanctioning body, other than the United Nations, would seem to alleviate many of the problems there are just too many governments more powerful that the entity to actually force complete and overall compliance. The best solution to ensure the overall effectiveness of sanctions would be to incorporate an equal amount of support to the civilian population

Outline and critically appraise the justifications for the current US monetary policy of very low official interest rates, and the likely consequences of that policy

1436 words - 6 pages , as well as helping maintain existing employment. In this sense, the Fed is well justified in its decision to temporarily shift its monetary policy focus in order to rescue the economy from the dominating recessionary forces.In spite of such justifications, there are underlying concerns over the effectiveness of monetary policy. While inflation targeting has been successful in the last two decades, there is concern as to whether monetary policy

Integration in the EU and Monetary Policy

2438 words - 10 pages National Information?” Banca d’Italia-CIDE. 2002 Another study done by the University of Leuven addresses the issue of different interests between countries and the decision making process when determining monetary policy at the ECB. The study argues that if an euro-wide perspective is not taken within the ECB when there are diverging monetary goals (because of asymmetric shocks) between member state, then divergent views can cause

Effects of US Monetary Policy- Provides overview of American monetary policy at home and abroad by siteing specifice examples and providing some personal opinion.

1268 words - 5 pages U.S. Monetary PolicyIn looking at the effectiveness of Monetary and Fiscal policies, it must be understood how the two relate to each other within the government structure. The Federal Open Market Committee - FOMC - is the most important monetary policy-making body of the Federal Reserve System. According to our text, Colander (2004) states, it is responsible for formulation of a policy designed to promote economic growth, full employment

The History of the European Monetary Union

3624 words - 14 pages out a plan to introduce the EMU in three stages and it included the creation of institutions like the European System of Central Banks (ESCB), which would become responsible for formulating and implementing monetary policy. (De Grauwe, 2003)All member states of the EU are expected to participate in the EMU. Sixteen members of the European Union have entered the third stage and have adopted the Euro as their currency. (European Commission) The EU

Role of the International Monetary Fund

2297 words - 9 pages I, like many people, have always heard about the International Monetary Fund in the news yet never really knew or understood its inner workings, this report over views what the International Monetary Fund is, how it works, and how it is currently involved internationally. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is a form of world credit union that has 187 countries involved, a near global involvement. The International Monetary Fund’s was

The Impact of European Monetary Union

2107 words - 8 pages colonized by different colonial masters. Under the said assumptions, the author of this paper states that an Asian attempt to build a common monetary policy with common currency will fail. The following are the reasons of such failure: • Existence of large price differentials among Asian countries will cause unprecedented increase in the price levels. Increase in the price levels (i.e., inflation) will surely decrease the welfare level of the

Similar Essays

The Opposing Views Of Reconstruction After The Civil War

790 words - 3 pages and abandoned land, even if it was now in use by freedmen. Again, the executive decisions for reconstruction left the newly freedmen with no opportunities to survive on their own.Congress had completely different views on how reconstruction should occur. Congress felt that Lincoln's proposition did not protect the freed slaves enough, and was too lax and too quick with its punishment of the rebels. In 1864 congress passed the Wade-Davis Bill. It

The Effectiveness Of Napoleon Iii's Foreign Policy

1526 words - 6 pages The Effectiveness of Napoleon III's Foreign Policy In general terms, Napoleon's foreign policy was much less successful than his domestic policy was. Generally speaking, the aims of his foreign policy were to present France as the champion of oppressed people throughout Europe, to create new countries, which would be grateful to France, to maintain good relation with Britain and to maintain a balance of power between

Degrees Of Transcendence: Opposing Views By Mc Kay And Hughes On The Consumption Of Art

1944 words - 8 pages Writing during the emergence of the “New Negro” movement, Claude McKay and Langston Hughes work to reconcile black life in white America. The trope used by the two poets within “The Harlem Dancer” and “The Weary Blues” is that of a performance and a single speaker’s recollection of it. While both depict an African-American performer presumably consumed by the isolation and oppression of their condition, the intensity of the performances prove to

Monetary Policy Of A Central Banking System

1594 words - 6 pages countries with the focus being on the empirical analysis of monetary policy shock on output and prices. Econometric models have been used to determine the effects of different policy options. With time, econometric analysis techniques have improved and most recent literatures have estimated the effects of monetary policy using VAR and SVAR techniques, this has allowed the evaluation of the effectiveness of monetary policy in several countries