This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Organ Donation And Presumed Consent Essay

772 words - 3 pages

STEP 1) Choosing a TopicThe topic I have chosen is "organ donation and presumed consent" as opposed to "required request." As mentioned in the Unit 3 exercise, I feel that this is a very interesting topic because some countries like Belgium rely on presumed consent to help increase their organ donor pool and save more lives. It seems to be a very admirable policy, and if the United States were ever willing to implement a program such as this, we could save more lives as well.After reviewing the feedback I received from my peers, I realized that not many people are familiar with the concept of "presumed consent" so I will have to make an effort to define this for my audience. I also ran into this issue when I talked to a few friends about it. They did seem to find this a very interesting topic, however, so I feel good about choosing it. One student commented that she felt a "presumed consent" policy should be put in effect as soon as possible. After being on a donor list for several months, her aunt died of kidney failure because nothing was available.I also feel that the extra feedback helped me more clearly define the purpose of my paper-not only do I want people to be more aware of what presumed consent is, but I want to provide them with the right facts so they are not afraid of it. There are too many myths about presumed consent that need busting.STEP 2) Describe two controversies surrounding this topicThe first controversy surrounding this topic is of course the whole idea that a government or medical community automatically assumes they have the right to take a person's organs upon death and give them to whoever needs them. People might feel it is disrespectful to the deceased, or somehow believe that "Big Brother" has control in this personal matter. On the contrary, everyone will clearly have the right to "opt out" of this program. They can specify this in their will and those wishes must be granted regardless of the wishes of other family members, etc. I will need to research how Belgium and other countries handle the "opt out" option as well as how they handle wills in order to find the information needed to calm the reader's nerves about presumed consent.The second controversy...

Find Another Essay On Organ donation and presumed consent

Organ Donation and its Importance Essay

2250 words - 9 pages online line and sign up anytime of the day 24/7. People will either have a donor card or a marked space on their drivers license to give permission to donate organs after death, however many hospitals will consult with the family even if the patient has signed to become an organ donor. Such countries include Australia and Belgium, the system is called presumed consent. It increases the supply of human organs available for transplant. Medical

Heart Failure and Organ Donation Essay

1204 words - 5 pages of others, therefore organ donation is seen as a genuine act of love. Hindu: They believe in the ongoing process of rebirth and life after death. The Bhagavad Gita explains how the mortal body and a immortal soul act as like clothes and a body: "vasamsi jirnani yatha vihaya navani grhnati naro 'parani atha sarirani vihaya jirnany anyani samyati navandi dehi." "As a person puts on new garments giving up the old ones the soul similarly accepts new material bodies giving up the old and useless ones." (Vyasa, Chapter 2 Verse 22)

The process of organ and blood donation

2519 words - 11 pages ? “Absolutely. While I cannot speak with authority about organ donation (as that is a separate issue from blood donating), I can say with certainty that anyone who is giving of themselves is free to change their minds at any time.” Who can donate blood? “Anyone who is 16 years of age (with signed parental consent) or 17 and up who is healthy and well, weighs at least 110 pounds, has not given blood in the last 56 days, and has a photo ID or

The Process of Organ and Blood Donation

2624 words - 10 pages her mind after signing a donor card or their driver’s license? A. “Absolutely. While I cannot speak with authority about organ donation, as that is a separate issue from blood donating, I can say with certainty that anyone who is giving of themselves is free to change their minds at any time.” Q. Who can donate blood? A. “Anyone who is sixteen years of age, with signed parental consent, or seventeen and up who is healthy and well, weighs at least

A Comparison of Medical Transplants and Organ Donation in Canada and China

1410 words - 6 pages be removed from the body of executed criminal with the consent of criminal or permission of relatives. But in 2007, China issued new laws and regulations that banned the trading of human organs. New regulations also prohibited the responsible authorities to remove the organs form criminal’s body (Juan, 2010). Organ donation in Canada is regulated on both provincial and federal level. The main objective of regulatory bodies is to ensure that all

Organ Donation

2398 words - 10 pages in need of a transplant. The removal of the organs is carried out in accordance with The Human Tissue Act (2004) who “regulate the removal, storage, use and disposal of the human bodies, tissues and organs”, (DOH ,2004).Organ donation is a complex issue, one which involves factors such as ethics, legal, organisational and societal factors. Much of the debate surrounding organ donation is the issue of consent /autonomy and trying to find ways to

Organ Donation

767 words - 3 pages family will give consent of a deceased one?s organ in hope of easing their pain and sorrow. They feel by aiding in another life it will take some of their grief away. Organ donors compared to non-donors seem to be highly motivated and a bit more medically sophisticated. Those individuals who decide to become organ donors are those in our population who are willing to better other?s life. Organ Donation-Why People Do Not Become Donors

The Key to Solving The American Organ Allocation

2876 words - 12 pages . Web. 9 Nov. 2013. . This article explains the "opt-in" vs. "opt-out" organ donation platforms. Today in the United States people must opt-in and receive a donor card if they want their organs to be donated after they die. In other places in the world, such as Spain and Austria, their is an opt-out platform which runs on a basis of presumed consent where people must register for their organs to NOT be donated

Organ Donation

2388 words - 10 pages gift so that someone else might live. Works Cited Berry Jr., Phil H.. “Raising Awareness about Organ Donation is Better than Presumed Consent or Mandated Choice.” At Issue: Organ Transplants. Ed. James D. Torr. Farmington Hills, MI: Greenhaven Press, 2003. Print. Burdick, James. "Organ Donation: Utilizing Public Policy and Technology to Strengthen Organ Donor Programs." U.S.Department of Health & Human Services. 25 Sep. 2007


2932 words - 12 pages donated are by improving the consent of donated and recovered organs in the future, a way for that to occur is through presumed consent and compensation. On the same note, another article that argued about organ donations was “Producing Organ Donors” by David H. Howard. While the article by Nathan and Conrad was more about the system of organ donation and the statistics that surround it, this article talked more about the way to produce more

The Growing Need for Organ Donors

1982 words - 8 pages maintained. The selling and buying of organs is not a resolution to this problem. It would lead to the abuse of organ donation and degrading the life of human persons, especially the poor. One paired organ can be donated while the donor is alive, except ovaries and eyes. Eyes can be donated once the donor has died. Presumed consent is not an approved way to fix the lack of organ donation, because it destroys human dignity and suggests that the

Similar Essays

Organ Donation And Transplantation Essay

1380 words - 6 pages Organ and tissue donation is life-saving and life transforming medical process wherein organs and tissues were removed from a donor and transplant them to a recipient who is very ill from organ failure. It is said that one organ can save up to 10 people and may improve the lives of thousands more (Australian Red Cross Blood Service, 2011). Most of the donated organs and tissues came from people who already died but in some cases, a living person

Organ Donation And Placement Essay

1177 words - 5 pages Organ Donation has saved many lives. Whether the donor is alive or has passed away they are a hero. Deciding to be a donor is a big decision to make and is the best blessing that you could do for someone. Whether you do it, it is up to you and you should not expect anything in return. People should not be compensated for organ donations and the organs should go to people who desperately need them and also children and young adults. Donations

Organ Transplant And Donation Essay

1897 words - 8 pages brain voltage, and a cerebral blood flow (CBF) examination, which uses mildly radioactive isotopes in the blood stream to track the blood flow into the brain, or a computerized axial tomography (CAT) scan. Only one out of every 800 neurological deaths results in the donation of organs (Olson, 2002). Once the donation of organs has occurred, the process of matching the organ to a recipient begins. The factors that determine a patients eligibility

Facts About Organ Donation And Organ Transplantation

2466 words - 10 pages policy? A Policy with an “opt-out systems is when citizens are presumed organ donors unless they formally opt not to donate their organs when they die” (Lupkin, Organ Donation Rates). Many countries such as Spain, Portugal, Belgium and Austria adopted an opt-out system. Spain has set the standard with an average 35 donations per every million people to the United States 26 donations per every million. OPTN formed a subcommittee to evaluate whether