This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Organ Harvesting In China Essay

1625 words - 7 pages

“No one has come out of there alive – Witnessed at Sujiatun Concentration Camp”. A photographer working for The Epoch Times in 2006 laid this caption under a photo he had taken to support his article. It was reported in the article how executed prisoners had become the primary source of body organ transplants. Still to this day in China, organs are being removed from the bodies of Falun prisoners without consent from anyone, to be used as donor organs for patients in need. The moment they find someone in need, the prisoners are immediately made victims. The process works something like this:
In China, the hospital notifies you in advance that they have located a donor. On average you will receive one or two weeks’ notice. The hospital finds a living donor, arranges for your surgery, and once the surgery is scheduled, then arrange for the prisoner's execution at the time that your surgery is scheduled.
No one knows who or where the organs are coming from, and it is typically not on their mind if they are n desperate need of the organ. Discussion about the curiousness of the situation emerged though in March 2006 when the religious organization, Falun Gong, reported claims (The Weekly Standard...). They stated spot-on what had been going on: that the Republic of China was harvesting the organs of executed criminals. They also noted the correlation of the rate in which one could get an organ for transplant and the high rate of prison executions. Although, the attention to China’s organ harvesting became prominent in 2006 as a result of Falun Gong allegations, the practice of using prisoners for organ harvesting actually began in the 1980s. In the 1990’s, the business of organ harvesting had progressed with the use of medical drugs developed by China. At one point it had gotten so bad that there were allegations that China’s armed services would routinely park outside the prison camps to ensure that the military hospitals got first pick of the organs of the prisoners that were just killed. (The Weekly Standard…)
The act of killing prisoners, to fulfill the demand for organs creates situations where the donor is no longer viewed as a human being but as a commodity. The attention that China has received as a result of the charges raised by the Falun Gong organization has many people talking about the moral/ethical implications that are associated with this situation. The moral/ethical dilemma is that because there is a shortage of people who are volunteering for organ donations, that it is ok for prisoners who are locked away and labeled a menace to society, to be killed and have their organs removed for less fortunate. Logic being that these prisoners will spend the rest of their lives behind bars anyway, so why not use them to save the lives of people who have been given the injustice of a fail organ. (Human Rights Watch 6:9)
The problem with China's using its prisoners' organs for transplant operations is that China is not giving their...

Find Another Essay On Organ Harvesting in China

Your Money or Your Life? (Laws & Ethical issues Surrounding Organ Donation)

2619 words - 10 pages after having received organ transplantation surgery with undocumented organs. In China, where 68 offences carry the death penalty the executed prisoners provide a rich supply for the human organs that are needed (Kates, 2002).Dr. Thiruventhiran, the director of the National Kidney Foundation of Malaysia, located in the capital city of Kuala Lumpur stated in an interview:As many as 60 to 70 kidney patients who have returned from China this last year

Richard A. Epstein’s Thinking the Unthinkable: Organ Sales

1892 words - 8 pages the immoral consequences of allowing organ sales by law. Compensating people for a good deed that is supposed to be selfless will completely change the nature of the action and the motivation behind it. Using money as motivation can be dangerous because of the manner in which harvesting the organ may occur and because of who may be reaping the benefit of the organ sale. Someone could use violence or could misuse their judgment to obtain the

Organ transplant - general facts

1408 words - 6 pages , such as kidney and blood. This kind of phenomenon is extremely common in part of Pakistan, India, and China, where the income of people are extremely low. For them, they only think that selling organ is profitable, and so they didn't concern much about the fines that is to be paid if the trade is discovered. For average, a kidney surgery is cost for Rs 400,000 to Rs 500,000 and only Rs 50,000 to Rs 70,000 goes to the organ seller, the rest all

Developing an Organ Transplant Market

811 words - 3 pages , that prohibits payment to organ donors. Reliance on voluntary donations, has been an abject policy failure. It's noteworthy that everyone else involved in the organ transplant business is rewarded handsomely - that includes surgeons, nurses and organ procurement workers. How might an organ transplant market work? Lloyd Cohen, a law professor at George Mason University, envisions letting people contract in advance to permit the harvesting of

Give A Heart, Save A Life

951 words - 4 pages compared to the amount of donors is terribly unbalanced. Although there is a misconception that a doctor may not try as hard to save someones life if they are an organ donor, organ donation is a noble cause because it not only saves and improves lives, but it can also ease the mourning process for the family members of the deceased. Being an organ donor saves lives. When someone passes away, their organs and tissues can be given to others in

The International Organ Trading System

1001 words - 5 pages Organ trafficking has been a hot topic of debate for decades. The controversy over whether or not the organ market should be legalized stays in play, but it is currently illegal under the H.R.6573 - Trafficking in Organs Victims Protection Act by the 112th Congress. This act states “that it shall be U.S. policy to: (1) end the offensive practice of exploiting the poor and vulnerable for the purpose of harvesting and trafficking their organs, and

Never Let Me Go & Innovations to Organ Regeneration

1014 words - 5 pages enlarging. “How can you ask such a world that has come to regard cancer as curable, how can you ask such a world to put away such a cure, to back to the dark days?” (Ishiguro, 263). The dystopian society exemplified in the novel has come to accept harvesting organs from clones as it solves many of the outstanding issues of organ transplantation. The society has become so accustomed to the many benefits that these clones provide that they are

Test of Faith

769 words - 4 pages countries force people to “donate” their belongings, created many ethical issues. A famous example of this is the organ harvesting of criminals that has taken place in China. Because of this, in order to be deemed ethical and acceptable, it is necessary that investors invest freely, without any type of external force, while understanding the risks. Because of this, the first idea that comes up in order to increase donations is to provide some sort


1122 words - 5 pages with scientific advancements if tissue engineering is to receive continuing public approval. In spite of potential issues, the widespread adoption of TE will eliminate at least one market for the better. In China, a massive criminal market exists for organ trade. The demand is so great that even prisoners are secretly forced to undergo organ extraction by the government (Campbell & Davison, 2012). TE is advantageous in two ways. The methods can

Let People Sell Themselves

1659 words - 7 pages organs that will help to pay for their funeral. In India a healthy organ goes for around twenty thousand dollars, in china forty thousand dollars, and in Israel one can go for around one-hundred and sixty-thousand dollars ("Which Organ Can..."). America doesn't have the organs that people need, so Americans are going to foreign counties in order to buy organs. All a patient from another country needs to do is go in saying they wish to sell their

Why does the Chinese government at the start of the 21st century refuse to give its people rights despite encouraging private enterprise in industry commerce?

1670 words - 7 pages systematic effort to implement the 1993 State Security Law, which, among other things, sought to sever ties between dissidents and their international supporters. Human Rights Watch/Asia, a human rights organization with excellent sources of information on China, reported that Chinese physicians were "harvesting" kidneys and other organs from condemned prisoners, sometimes under anaesthesia before their actual execution, to use in organ transplants

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of Medical Transplants And Organ Donation In Canada And China

1410 words - 6 pages . In addition, the transplant that is performed within same body is called auto graft. Medical transplant that is performed in between to different bodies of same species is called allografts (Hewitt, 2008). The main reason of medical transplantation and organ donation is any injury and disease which prohibit the organ to work in proper condition. Medical Transplant and Organ Donation; China and Canada There is an excessive level of organ

Organ Trafficking Essay

2212 words - 9 pages -Hughes 2013, Jafar 2009). Perhaps the most blatant of human rights violations is the nonconsensual procurement of organs. In 1999, guerillas from Kosovo reportedly harvested organs from 300 captive Serbians at a secret prison site in Albania (The Economist 2008). China, too, has been accused of nonconsensual organ harvesting. China today is one of the most attractive destinations for international buyers to travel for transplants, and with nearly

Organ Donation Essay

2119 words - 8 pages will continue to cultivate a growing legion of impoverished organ sellers who end up with an immense wad of cash,” says Glovin (Budiani-Saberi 39-40). As a result, suspicions of organ trades between Hong Kong and China in 1989 caused the Tiananmen Square massacre arose. The Amnesty International noted an increase in China’s submissions for the death penalty, and reported on the use of executed prisoners’ organs without their consent. Dr

A Solution For Organ Transplants Essay

2093 words - 9 pages A Solution for Organs Transplantation None of countries in the world allow selling human organs because it is against humane to put human bodily parts on the market. Patients with failure organs will have their name on the waiting list of donated organ three to five year, or wish their luck. In addition, candidates have to suffer pain and many side effects that causes by organs failure; they cannot wait five years for a new organ, such as