This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Organizational Theories And Their Applicability In Other Cultures

1766 words - 7 pages

Up until the 21 century, the majority of the published literature scrutinizing and modeling organizational theories and their use in the workplace to maximize performance, were developed exclusively in the United States. However, greater awareness of international workplace culture has made it clear that these theories, which were modeled after American companies, are not as universally applicable as researchers assumed. As American management and leadership theories, these philosophies reflect an inherent bias, incorporating American values, motivations, and expectations. As such, variations across cultures and their impact on organizations can make implementation of these concepts completely inappropriate in another culture, while fully viable within the American workplace.
An example of such a concept is the motivational theory proposed by the American psychologist Abraham Maslow, called Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. This theory suggests that human beings’ five basic needs form a hierarchy – from the most basic physiological needs, followed by safety, social, esteem, and finally self-actualization. Higher-order needs such as esteem and self-actualization (the desire to fulfill one’s potential) only become dominant and thus motivate behavior, after lower-order needs have been substantially satisfied. Originally, Maslow’s hierarchy of needs theory was meant to help managers understand what motivates an employee. By understanding what needs must be met in order for an employee to achieve the highest-level of motivation, managers are then able to get the most out of production.
For instance, an American manager of an American company can reliably assume that promoting one of his hard-working employees to a higher level position would encourage similar work performance in the future. In accordance to Maslow’s theory, the promotion would contribute to the high-order self-actualization and esteem needs of an American employee and be effective motivation. However, inherent in this theory is the assumption that the “highest order” need is self-actualization. Maslow created his hierarchy of needs from a highly individualistic perspective – as the United States is a highly individualistic nation. The needs and drives of those in individualistic societies tend to be more self-centered than those in collectivist societies, focusing on improvement of the self, epitomized as self actualization.
In collectivist societies, the social needs of acceptance, harmony, and community outweigh the needs for freedom and individuality. If the same manager were an expatriate in Japan, and decided to promote one of his employees, it is likely the promotion would in fact diminish the employee’s performance. Nancy Adler, author of International Dimensions of Organizational Behavior, explains why: “Japanese have a high need for harmony – to fit in with their work colleagues. The promotion, an individualistic reward, separated the [employee] from his colleagues,...

Find Another Essay On Organizational Theories and their Applicability in Other Cultures

Death and its Personofication in Greek Mythology and Other Cultures

2039 words - 9 pages them and bring them to Hades after filling their thirst for blood. Thanatos is dependent to the Moerae, who are three sisters that decided human fate “everybody has a portion in life, the individual fate (moira) is usually present when Thanatos comes to fetch a mortal." (GreekGuide 2). Thanatos can come at any time he wants, but in one case of a wife named Alcestis deiced to die instead of him taking her husband. Apollo and the Moerae decided that

The Importance of Understanding Cultures in America and Other Countries

1454 words - 6 pages that it includes material things that different cultures have in common for example material culture is something like a lawn mower, a car, or an ipod. These are things that other cultures other than the american culture have or consider part of their norm. The book states that this is a way for people to understand others and relate to them. Non-Material culture includes things like peoples values, values are what people think is important to

Doing Business in other cultures

842 words - 3 pages in a reckonable approach. On the other hand, there was a theory of conflict that highlighted the way humans interact and divergence in opposition to predictable insight. All the cultures know a way out in order to resolve problems working for them grounded on their principles and the past. Coming to the third and final pillar of sociology i.e. symbolic interactionism, it focuses on the effort put forth by the people in order to understand

Creation: Biblical and Other Theories

2108 words - 9 pages amino acids give rise to proteins and other compounds that are the foundation for all life, at least on this planet. Scientists have yet to produce a concoction that creates proteins from amino acids. Evidence of microbial life in stromatolites suggests that primitive life forms first appeared on Earth about 3.7 billion years ago. Atoms began to merge to form molecules. RNA was one of the first to form, which not only carried genetic information

Capitalism Theories and Their Role in US Government

1274 words - 6 pages (Locke), Utilitarianism(Mills), “Justice as Fairness”(Rawls), and Marxism(Marx). Personally, I think that the only theory that is true to capitalism is Libertarianism, and I believe this resembles the Republican party in the US. Liberalism comes close, but I see it as a strong sense of the Democratic party in the US. All of the other theories I don't see being used in the US, simply because they are not close to any capitalism background. These other theories are used in the way other countries have built their governments. The distribution of property and wealth in america is minimal when looking at help from the upper-class to the lower-class.

Shopenhauer's theories and their significance in the film Memento

894 words - 4 pages through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident." Arthur SchopenhauerSchopenhauer states that in some aspects, the world is will, in other aspects, it is idea. These two parts of his philosophy are what the film is trying to overcome. Both are fairly obvious. Firstly, I would like to discuss will.Will is of great significance- in the film and in Schopenhauer's philosophy

A discussion of brand loyalty approaches and their applicability for different markets

801 words - 3 pages for the competingbrands should that customer be considered brand loyal to that brand. This way oflooking at brand loyalty¡ªthat is , a greater liking for the brand¡ªcan betermed attitudinal brand loyalty.Brand loyalty has been largely defined and measured in either behavioral orattitudinal terms (Mellens et al., 1996). Brand loyalty is the biased behavioralresponse, expressed over time by some decision-making unit, with

"Ahimsa" and the Differences Between Jainism and Other World Cultures

1173 words - 5 pages "Ahimsa" and the Differences Between Jainism and Other World Cultures A dog is being chased by 12 other dogs through the crowded streets of India. He is being chased because he had just found a bone and being as hungry as the rest of the dogs, he wants the bone for himself. Gazing upon this, a Jain monk was reminded of Aparigraha, the Jain principle of non-attachment. In the religion of Jainism, one must not be attached to material

Memory, Motivation and Other Learning Theories

1519 words - 6 pages , incentives, inhibitors and prior training. (Hull, 1940, 1943). Reinforcement was the main determinant of learning. In Hull's theory, the habit strength hierarchy for a given stimulus creates different responses from an organism. The probability of change in a specific response becomes likely because of rewards. This is also affected by other variables such as inhibition. Intended as a general theory of learning, Hull's theory involves a number of

Leadership Paper: Styles, Organizational Culture, and Theories

1919 words - 8 pages organizations has a different and more meaningful definition. A leader is interpreted as someone who sets direction in an effort and influences people to follow that direction. How they set that direction and influence people depends on a variety of factors. To really comprehend the "territory" of leadership, we will discuss various styles of leadership, provide some of the major theories and review some of the suggested traits and

Organizational Culture: Diverse Types of Cultures and Employees Viewpoints

1052 words - 4 pages % Support 6.46% 21.04% 72.50% It is evident from this table that there are some variances in opinion, but there are also similarities where the majority of employees agree and disagree on what they believe the organizational culture should be. The author surveyed over 350 employees in manufacturing firms on their current and preferred cultures (Ledimo, 2013). This large sample adequately meets the qualifications for a quantitative report

Similar Essays

How Poets Reveal Their Ideas And Feelings About Other Cultures

989 words - 4 pages Culture. What is culture? People think of culture in different ways but it is the culture inside them which makes them unique. Culture is what gives a person their very own identity. This diversity is what makes everybody different. There are two sides to culture. On one side it unites and unifies people but on the other it separates and deviates people. Many poets have explored these issues. Poets like John Agard in Half-Caste explore on how

"The Disappearance Of The Anasazi" An "A" Grade Paper Which Discusses The Logical Theories Of Their Disappearance And Other Suggested Alternatives

2565 words - 10 pages varying degrees in different areas and magnified the problem until most of the Western Anasazi area was empty. Climatic change is one of two theories that show the strongest evidence. As the canyons grew drier, crops, wild plants and game grew scarcer. Eventually, the Anasazi were forced to abandon their homeland in search of a more hospitable place. Another assumption made on their disappearance is that of sporadic raids in the scattered

Britain Has Become A Multicultural Society. How Can Schools/Teachers Develop Their Pupils' Awareness Of The Values Of Other Cultures?

2702 words - 11 pages Multicultural Education can be defined in terms of preparing pupils to exist in a multiracial society by providing them with an understanding of the culture and history of different ethnic groups. Multicultural education should therefore allow both minority and majority pupils to be acquainted with and investigate the multifaceted interconnections and gaps that transpire between their own and other cultural and social identities. This essay will

National Cultures And Organizational Cultures Essay

2204 words - 9 pages . (1983). The cultural relativity of organizational practices & theories. Journal of International Business Studies ,14 (2), 75-89. Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture’s Consequences : Comparing Values, Behaviours, Institutions & Organizations across Nations (2nd ed.). USA, Sage. Lecture Notes given by the lecturer Dr. Robert Khan. Saini,D.S, & Budhwar,P.S. (2004). Managing Human Resources in Asia – Pacific. New Delhi, Routledge. Swaminathan, V, & Kashyap , M. (2012). User Experience across cultures : A study. Infosys Opinions, 1 (1). Trompenaars,F, & Wooliams,P. (2004). Business Across Culture.Wiley.