Original Position Essay

902 words - 4 pages

Flavia Neyra
Original Position

John Rawls discusses the original position in his book A Theory of Justice. “The Original Position and Justification” is a chapter where Rawls persuades his readers into taking the original position seriously. The original position is a position where people are equal and are rational in order to make principles that they live by fair. However, there is a problem with rational decisions being biased, where people will choose principles to benefit themselves. Therefore, the veil of ignorance will restrict a person’s knowledge about social status, intelligence, gender, race, ethnicity, and temperament. This will then define principles of justice that will not ...view middle of the document...

, but it would be based on the interests people have together. This is how Rawls influences his readers, by creating non-biased people to not effect any principles and having them create principles equally.
Rawls believes that people’s own interests can’t be ignored. Once, a society agreed on certain principles, which seem fair, an individual’s own interest about society is still present and must come to some agreement with the initial principle. Rawls refers to this state as equilibrium. Equilibrium is a state where people’s own interest is being taken into consideration and the principles made with the limitation of people’s knowledge are also considered. People will go back and fourth, changing the conditions of principles they have made until they have reached an agreement that expresses both reasonable conditions and yields principles that match people’s own judgments. However, the equilibrium might not be stable, so either the initial principle must be changed or people’s own judgments must be reconsidered. Either way, Rawls focuses on people’s own interest as well as a non-biased interest to determine that the original position is fair and reasonable so that everyone can agree.
I believe that the original position should not be taken seriously. My first opposing reason is that experiences in a person’s life make up their judgments and the principles they obtain. The veil of ignorance is unattainable so, having that the only option to make principles fair is unrealistic. A person cannot simply erase their judgments about certain principles. People are taught to believe certain principles or have had a...

Find Another Essay On original position

Reflection and Objection on John Rawls

549 words - 2 pages state of mind called the original position. It is a position in which humans think rationally and try their best to meet the needs of the people. In the original position, people are basically thinking like computers. They have no selfishness at all. They are simply coming up with terms that are best for the group as a whole. This is, of course, purely hypothetical.John Rawls' ethical ideas center primarily on what is fair to each person. He puts

Waves Essay

1837 words - 7 pages , forwards or backwards; but once moved, it is returned to its original equilibrium or rest position. The act of moving the first coil of the slinky in a given direction and then returning it to its equilibrium position creates a disturbance in the slinky. We can then observe this disturbance moving through the slinky from one end to the other. If the first coil of the slinky is given a single back-and-forth vibration, then

Alternative Dispute Resolution

953 words - 4 pages IntroductionAn original equipment manufacturing company built an automated piece of assembly equipment. This equipment was slated for installation during a one week when General Motors plant shutdown. Scheduling was a priority with little room for error. To maintain schedule the equipment was air freighted to the customer's location. The field installation crew uncrated the system and upon inspection the installation team noted the crated had

Vanderbilt v. Gerry DiNardo

642 words - 3 pages University contacted Vanderbilt in hopes of speaking with DiNardo about becoming the head football coach for L.S.U. Hoolahan gave DiNardo permission to speak to L.S.U. about the position. On December 12, 1994, DiNardo announced that he was accepting the L.S.U. position. Vanderbilt sent a demand letter to DiNardo seeking payment of liquidated damages under section eight of the contract. Vanderbilt believed that DiNardo was liable for three years of

Separable reversible data hiding

1853 words - 8 pages only byte-length manipulations so it is suitable for embedded systems. Assume each pixel with gray value of the original image is falling into [0, 255] represented by 8 bits. Denote the gray value as p i,j ,where ( i , j) indicates the pixel position, and bits of a pixel as b i,j,0 , b i,j,1 ,…, bi,j,7 Three cases received by making the process Non-Separable exclusive-or results of the original bits and pseudo-random

Sandel Procedural Republic

753 words - 4 pages applies Germanic obscurities to Kant’s teachings in the role of the original position. Rawls writes “to develop a Kantian conception of justice the force and content of Kant’s doctrine must be detached from its background in the transcendental idealism” (p. 17, ¶4). The purpose of the original position is to try and prove what the Kantian transcendental position cannot. In Rawls’ original position, conceptions of the good consequently have no

Marbury V. Madison Case Brief

500 words - 2 pages Marbury v. Madison5 U.S. 137 (S.Ct. 1803)Facts: President Adams appointed William Marbury to the position of justice of the peace in 1801. However, Marbury failed to receive his commission before the end of the Adams Administration. The new Jefferson administration had ordered the secretary of state (James Madison) not to deliver Marbury's commission. By the Judiciary Act of 1789, Marbury sued Madison in the Supreme Court seeking a writ of

The Ford Mustang

1211 words - 5 pages system of distribution, and discusses its pricing and promotion policies. The analysis concludes with an evaluation of The Gap's current position and makes recommendations for future developments. 12p. 40f. 27b. 08461. MARKETING PROFILE OF COCA-COLA COMPANY. Analysis of the company's marketing program of its main product, original formula Coke. The investigation includes a detailed analysis of the company's marketing strategy: segmentation

The Decisive Battle: Aftermarket versus Original Equipment Manufacturer Car Parts

1348 words - 6 pages their position in the market, aftermarket hardware car parts is a big business as do the manufacturing and selling of the cars themselves by its manufacturers but not equally. Given the idea between an aftermarket and an original equipment manufacturer car part, which is which and for which reason? Price Point The more known and valued a particular brand is, it is safe to assume it to be of more “value” to the consumers it serves and provides

Cinderella

939 words - 4 pages Family circumstances and dilemmas have become an increasingly significant part of modern society, especially in the Western nations. The fairy tale of 'Cinderella' raised the concept of a wicked stepmother who treated the first daughter of her husband harshly and with extreme dislike. These days, the situation could not possibly be any more contradictory to the original circumstances. Divorces and remarriages are common in today's day and age

The Design of Imperfection

788 words - 4 pages smaller things in life? The answer is debatable, and through vivid imagery, Frost puts readers in a position of thought. He wants the audience to question the design of life and by rewriting his original poem and making it better, Frost leads readers to another more in-depth question: If God does indeed design the smaller things in life, then does He also design the mutations and imperfections of the world, as shown with the heal-all?

Similar Essays

The Original Position And The Veil Of Ignorance

1564 words - 7 pages The Original Position and the Veil of Ignorance Political philosopher John Rawls believed that in order for society to function properly, there needs to be a social contract, which defines ‘justice as fairness’. Rawls believed that the social contract be created from an original position in which everyone decides on the rules for society behind a veil of ignorance. In this essay, it will be argued that the veil of ignorance is an important

Does Rawls Succeed In Showing That The Difference Principle Would Be Chosen In The Original Position?

2004 words - 8 pages In order to understand Rawls' justifications for choosing the Difference Principle in the Original Position and to establish his relative success we must first have a general understanding of what the Original Position and the Difference Principle comprise of, as well as the conditions he applies.In this section I will be providing a basic outline of the features of the Original position and the Difference Principle and the pertinent constraints

Regarding Rawls 'original Position' And 'veil Of Ignorance' As Well As Critiques Of His Theory From Iris Marion Young

1944 words - 8 pages Q.2How does Rawls use ‘the original position’ and ‘the veil of ignorance’ to establish a conception of social justice? Your answer should define these terms and specify how Rawls characterizes them. You might also make reference to Rawls’ use of a contractarian methodology and the hypothetical contract.While society is a form of social cooperation which exists for the ‘mutual benefit of all its members;’ there

Orginial Postion Essay

1411 words - 6 pages The Original Position thought experiment devised by John Rawls, requires one to argue for a client behind a veil of ignorance. Not knowing anything about the advantageous or disadvantageous position of said client within society, one has to resolve the issue presented in a way that does not discount the interests of any member of society. The Original Position invokes the social contract in which all members of society are seen as rational